Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prívate vs state Primary education

109 replies

ClumpyMascara · 12/12/2021 19:29

DH wants to send twin boys to private Primary school - he was privately educated and I wasn’t, he feels very passionately about it.

While I have no quibble with them going to private secondary, where I do believe you can see the benefits, I don’t see the point in private primary? We have great state primaries near us and the education they will get won’t be that different?

It just seems like a waste of money - we aren’t super well off but his parents are going to help (and agree with him)

Most of our friends have done state primary, private secondary with their children

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 13/12/2021 10:29

My DD went to private primary and I believe it set her up for a successful and happy time at school.
15 in a class, in infants they had a teacher and a ta. High standards of behaviour - they noticeably stood out in a good way at events with other schools. There was a lot of emphasis on basics, not the endless topic projects and dress up days. Lots of opportunity for public speaking and extras like poetry vanguard and English speaking board. Very working parent friendly - wrap around without pre booking, longer hours, only school in town open on a snow day etc. Grammar school area so included prep for 11 plus. School was more diverse than state primaries and lots with some additional needs - it was popular with parents with children who needed a bit of extra attention but wouldn’t qualify for support in state.
My DD is yr 11 now and talks fondly about primary school and can see how it benefited her.
All you can do is compare the schools and see what feels best fit.

CruCru · 13/12/2021 10:21

I don't have a view on whether your state or private school are better (depends where you live and what you are looking for). What jumps out at me is that we aren’t super well off but his parents are going to help (and agree with him).

How much are his parents going to help? Does this mean that they will effectively pick your children's schools? If something should happen that means they won't be able to help any more (retiring on a lower income, running out of savings, having more grandchildren to help, God forbid - dying), how much of a hole will you be in? Fourteen years is a long time to be dependant on financial help.

GratS · 13/12/2021 10:08

@ClumpyMascara
SEN care is often much better in state schools, think your DH might have outdated info in this.

boltz · 13/12/2021 09:46

and watch them develop into people who then cruise through senior school (of any type) with astounding success.

That's nonsense & not a guarantee at all.

TooMuchPaper · 13/12/2021 09:45

I wouldn't be happy that his parents would have a say. If you need their money to help pay the fees I would think twice.

boltz · 13/12/2021 09:43

Depends on the options & sometimes the dc. I would chose an excellent state primary over private but a child may need to be prepped to get into secondary schools.

Usernamehell · 13/12/2021 09:35

@GonzoFlyingProducts you phrased it better than I could. Exactly the reasons we invested in private from 4 and the pandemic highlighted it all.

DD's school had a full online timetable from first day of first lockdown with all specialist teachers. The children did not miss out at all from the academic perspective. The local states had a story or 2 in morning online and then worksheets throughout the day which were not marked or viewed by the teachers. I don't for a second blame state teachers - I know they are phenomenal but they have so much to do and a fraction of the resources they should have to do it with.

We have paid for private to give them the solid base and grounding and enforce a love for learning and education. We have only just started our journey but I can see exactly what I am paying for and am very happy with the school for her.

You will get some ridiculous perceptions on here about people paying because they don't want children to mix with 'undesirables' or that those from private think the world owes them something but in reality, the overwhelming majority who go down that road do it because of the education and opportunities it provides. Other things don't feature in the decision. We are extremely fortunate that we have things we can sacrifice in order to pay the fees. That does not mean my children are better than those in the state sector or deserve better jobs when they grow up. They will need to work hard and prove themselves to get that.

Changechangychange · 12/12/2021 23:53

I think there are usually two reasons for sending kids to private primary - first one is that prep schools “prep” kids for the entrance exams, or offer straight-through places - all of the kids at the private schools near us are guaranteed a place at the secondary school regardless of academic ability.

The second reason is that you don’t have to mix with undesirables. This can be as innocent as wanting to avoid disruptive kids/knife crime, or as malignant as wanting to social-climb/avoid the poors.

Kids with SEN are usually better cater for in the state sector. My friend has recently pulled her daughter out of her super-selective primary because, while she is incredibly bright and was coasting with the work, they could not cope with her ODD. The state school love her and she is thriving (the state school is also giving her more stretch work to avoid boredom triggering a meltdown, something the private school apparently couldn’t manage).

PercyThick · 12/12/2021 23:42

I'd take a very good state primary and secondary any time.

I know many families whose kids attend private schools. There is one things that all of them have in common: a huge sense of the world owes them and their kids. I wouldn't want my dc to adopt an air of super confidence, which is one of the top selling points of private school. I also don't want my children to only interact with a narrow strata of society. Many private schools have a huge intake area and local friends are hard to come by. A great local schools wins hands down for me.

GonzoFlyingProducts · 12/12/2021 23:37

The thing is that "they education they will get" WILL actually be that different.

People imagine that the difference is: State School says "1+1 is 2" and Prep school says "1+1 is 2 and that will be fifty quid" but it's just not that simple.

My three all went to prep school then on to state Grammars and it was the early years that made the difference - learning good French and Latin, a grounding in the classics, a huge emphasis on an absolute proficiency in maths and English (and provision for LOTS of extra help if needed that only a private school can offer). By the time they got to eleven and were ready for secondary school they were confident, independent, scholarly and in love with learning - that is what prep school can give kids in a way that state primary school simply never can. Plus of course the school had amazing facilities, a pool, loads of inter-school competitions in gymnastics and netball and cricket not to mention in chess and maths - state schools just can't afford to do the "extras" that you get from prep school. Their French teacher will be French, their music teacher will be a jazz pianist, the cricket coach will have played for England - prep school kids get the BEST of everything and once it's in them it's in them for good - it's not fair - but it's real.

My advice would be to spend the money EARLY and get them into prep school (although you had better have had their names down from birth for any of the good ones in any major UK city) and watch them develop into people who then cruise through senior school (of any type) with astounding success.

But in the end remember - the kids who do best in education are those who are supported best AT HOME. Don't order them to do the homework - take a real interest in the homework. Don't just praise their drawing of the Tower of London - take them to the tower of London.

Thirtytimesround · 12/12/2021 23:33

I, like you, did not see the point in state primary.

Half way through, we switched to private. I'm shocked by how far behind her privately-educated peers DD already was - not so much at academics (which were fairly similar, as DD had a weekend tutor), but in fitness levels, confidence, public speaking, knowledge of sports/art/music, and happiness...

The teachers at our local state school were overworked, under resourced, and perhaps as a result were often bad tempered and rude to very young children. Bullying went unchecked, teaching materials often contained basic spelling errors, and there was never a plan. The experience crushed DD and she was miserable, often crying on the way there. At private, she comes out every day saying she's had a wonderful time. She's sad when weekend/holiday arrives because she'd rather be at school.

Perhaps we just had a bad state primary and a great private prep near us. But I wish we'd done prep school from the beginning. It's sad seeing her so far behind the others and more importantly she had several years of being miserable during the day when she could have been having a fab time.

Look at the schools local to you, talk to as many parents as you can and be very careful about your choice. In particular look for where your child will fit in and somewhere that bullying is dealt with firmly.

AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 12/12/2021 23:25

I'm sorry but just re-read your sentence again and tell me you aren't a crashing snob:

"They are more confident, have wider interests and, in my experience, are usually more accomplished due to the huge amount of experiences they are exposed to."

Perhaps you don't mean to, but you come across as hugely offensive and exactly the type of private school cliché that puts so many state parents off private education.

Badabingbadabum · 12/12/2021 23:17

I think it depends on what primary schools are in your area. The right state primary can be as good as a private one. Private schools have the advantages of smaller classes, more opportunities etc. If you have the means to pay, I would consider it.

explodingeyes · 12/12/2021 23:17

@Fomofo

Banana - I guess it depends what you mean by a wide range of interests, I know plenty of privately educated people with very narrow interests
I'd second that actually. I sports coach both state & private DC in large numbers. I actually notice zero difference. There are entitled / confident / shy / nervous / outspoken / naughty / polite / rude / confident / quiet children in both camps. I know state school kids with loads of interests & private with none.
explodingeyes · 12/12/2021 22:56

@PoshWatchShitShoes sounds fab. The preps near us aren't that good. They are just about getting entrance exams passed. That's what people are paying £12k a year per child for. Many still tutor on top and kids are still at all the local clubs on top, same as the state kids

Fomofo · 12/12/2021 22:51

Banana - I guess it depends what you mean by a wide range of interests, I know plenty of privately educated people with very narrow interests

PoshWatchShitShoes · 12/12/2021 22:27

After doing Reception at the Outstanding infant school next to our house, we moved DC1 to a nearby prep school for year 1. It's night and day. Much smaller groups for lessons. High-touch, individual approach to learning with a strong focus on pastoral care. The curriculum is varied and the facilities are outstanding too. Lessons are taught by subject specialist teachers. In just 1 term, I'm impressed with the leaps and bounds made from an academic perspective. Many of the extra-curricula activities we did on the weekends are now covered as part of the school day. I love that my 6 year old can chat in French and Spanish, adores drama, enjoys Art, is a much stronger swimmer, looks forward to forest school etc.

explodingeyes · 12/12/2021 21:55

@ClumpyMascara you really need to both go and visit both options.
I can honestly say that all 10 primaries within a mile of us are very very good. They don't have massive sports fields or swimming pools etc but they do have choirs / music provision / drama / forest school and basic sports etc. Non could be described as poor or woeful.
Our 2 nearest preps on the other hand has no exciting playground equipment and have playgrounds that are concrete squares. They get tons of worksheet homework which isn't actually effective but parents like it.
I'd invest my money in uni & houses instead

jacks11 · 12/12/2021 21:39

Depends on the school and your children- there is no single right option.

We went private prep, now private secondary. I can say, without a single doubt that private prep provided a far, far better education than our local state options in every way I can think of. I can see that from the experience of friends/colleagues with one notable exception where the state school coped ad it’s my with a child with SEN and some difficult behaviours resulting from that. I also compare the truly woeful education my niece and nephew received at their state school and am really glad we had the choice to go private.

Perhaps if we had very good state school locally, or a reason to think the state school was a better option, we might have chosen differently. For us it was absolutely worth it.

explodingeyes · 12/12/2021 21:34

@BananaDrama25 that's as much to do with what parents spend money on and disposable income.
Maybe your state schools parents spent it on tutors to get in and not other stuff whereas those who were at your private primary have more money and the preps do it all for them.
Maybe you are attracting a certain type of applicant; maybe it's the ones parents don't think will cope at state schools as they aren't confident etc
All the (state) DC we know in our relatively affluent area use great state schools and do tons of extra curricular; sports, music, drama,scouts etc.
My own DC do loads clubs at state school and stuff every night to a good level. They couldn't fit any more into their days.
They are all bright, articulate & streetwise.
Academically our state school does as well as private's when adjusted for intake.
(But it all costs money).
There's a lot of misconceptions about state high schools in particular.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 12/12/2021 21:28

What can you afford. If you can afford both just do it, he's right most private school will have better provisions for lots of things.

If you will be stretched then don't do it and save like mad.

SmallProvincial · 12/12/2021 21:27

*its racial diversity (sorry for typo).

SmallProvincial · 12/12/2021 21:26

DD5 attends a prep school, we chose the independent route almost entirely based on class sizes (her class has 11 children).

We chose her specific school based on their ethos (they prize creativity, sport, learning through play, and encourage confidence), it's racial diversity, and the fact it's not a hot house environment like some of our local independent schools are.

reluctantbrit · 12/12/2021 21:21

Depends how you think long-term. Do you plan private secondary as well?A 4-18 private one? Do you take all fee increases into account?

We are in a London borough with good private and good state schools. Most parents try state first unless they are underlying issues as some of the state ones are par with most of the public ones and grammar. Some private only go until Y11 so you don't have the advantage of priority admission to 6th form lots of secondary have for their own pupils.

We moved to make sure we had a decent choice for state as we think it's nuturing which is important in early years, not a hothouse.

explodingeyes · 12/12/2021 21:17

@BananaDrama25

I'm SLT in a private senior school and I can assure your there is a massive difference between state and prep educated children. You can spot them a mile off at interview and they settle much better into school life
Which ones settle better?