Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prívate vs state Primary education

109 replies

ClumpyMascara · 12/12/2021 19:29

DH wants to send twin boys to private Primary school - he was privately educated and I wasn’t, he feels very passionately about it.

While I have no quibble with them going to private secondary, where I do believe you can see the benefits, I don’t see the point in private primary? We have great state primaries near us and the education they will get won’t be that different?

It just seems like a waste of money - we aren’t super well off but his parents are going to help (and agree with him)

Most of our friends have done state primary, private secondary with their children

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
littlepeas · 20/12/2021 09:25

Hmmm. Well I haven't read the full thread, but in my experience private primary is better and just as valuable as private secondary. I have experience of both private and state, as we moved our dc when they were in years 2, 1 and R (yes, 3 in consecutive school years).

My youngest went from a class of 30 to a class of 11, he read with a teacher every day instead of once a week - he went from being lost in a big class to getting a huge amount of individual attention and it made a big difference (he is an August baby). My dd had speech and language therapy within school and came on leaps and bounds (one of the reasons we moved them is that the state school did nothing to help her).

There are significantly better opportunities for extracurricular activities from the early years too - music and sport in particular, but also things like LAMDA - it will of course depend on the school. You also have easy and direct contact with the teaching staff.

We chose schools with strong pastoral care (2/3 are now at secondary) and the sense of looking after each child as an individual makes an enormous difference to their school experience. I have never for one second regretted our decision - not even when our mortgage statement arrives!

yourestandingonmyneck · 20/12/2021 09:06

@GonzoFlyingProducts

The thing is that "they education they will get" WILL actually be that different.

People imagine that the difference is: State School says "1+1 is 2" and Prep school says "1+1 is 2 and that will be fifty quid" but it's just not that simple.

My three all went to prep school then on to state Grammars and it was the early years that made the difference - learning good French and Latin, a grounding in the classics, a huge emphasis on an absolute proficiency in maths and English (and provision for LOTS of extra help if needed that only a private school can offer). By the time they got to eleven and were ready for secondary school they were confident, independent, scholarly and in love with learning - that is what prep school can give kids in a way that state primary school simply never can. Plus of course the school had amazing facilities, a pool, loads of inter-school competitions in gymnastics and netball and cricket not to mention in chess and maths - state schools just can't afford to do the "extras" that you get from prep school. Their French teacher will be French, their music teacher will be a jazz pianist, the cricket coach will have played for England - prep school kids get the BEST of everything and once it's in them it's in them for good - it's not fair - but it's real.

My advice would be to spend the money EARLY and get them into prep school (although you had better have had their names down from birth for any of the good ones in any major UK city) and watch them develop into people who then cruise through senior school (of any type) with astounding success.

But in the end remember - the kids who do best in education are those who are supported best AT HOME. Don't order them to do the homework - take a real interest in the homework. Don't just praise their drawing of the Tower of London - take them to the tower of London.

@GonzoFlyingProducts

I agree with all this.

Sadly, I wouldn't be able to afford this from age 4-18 for both my kids. I am disappointed but that's life.

Our local state schools are good so I think we will send them there and spend money on extra curricular activities, experiences and tutors rather than do state primary and then private secondary.

But at the end of the day, we, like anyone else, can only do what we think best.

FedupAnon2 · 14/12/2021 10:41

Thank you @Dixiechickonhols

GratS · 14/12/2021 10:31

@Motheroftigers
Where did she ask for experiences of people with kids in private schools? The original post which people are responding to without necessarily going through each individual comments does not ask for this. The title of the thread very much sets up a private v's state debate, that is what the OP wanted, that was what people gave her.
Might need to bring you to the front of the class where you will listen better.

Dixiechickonhols · 14/12/2021 10:25

FedupAnon2 state grammar

Dixiechickonhols · 14/12/2021 10:19

FedupAnon2 She passed 11+ and went to Grammar. She’ll go on to Grammar 6th form. We are in Lancashire so it’s a pass in catchment and you have a place not super selective.

ClumpyMascara · 14/12/2021 09:11

For clarity the boys and their younger sibling will definitely go to private secondary from 11. Most of our friends have had their children at our local (very good) Primary where there’s been no trouble getting the children into private for year 7. We live in a small but expensive city where there are many private schools and places generally aren’t too difficult to get if you’ve been organised and they pass their entrance exam/interview. We don’t seem to have the same set up as some on our area but now I’m thinking that Primary is the way to go or potentially moving them over from KS2.

OP posts:
FedupAnon2 · 14/12/2021 08:27

Dixiechickonhols

Hi Dixie I really like what you wrote snd I agree. What did you do with your kids for secondary school? Did you choose grammar, state or private?

onemouseplace · 14/12/2021 07:39

My experience has been academic teaching has been on a par between state and prep. DC go to a good with aspirations of being outstanding state primary and the extra curricular is shockingly awful, and has got significantly worse since covid (ie pretty much non existent).

yourestandingonmyneck · 14/12/2021 07:34

I looked into this quite a lot a few years ago when my eldest nephew was starting school and I was wondering about it for my kids when they were school age.

It's actually the other way around - primary is where it makes all the difference.

The difference in confidence between the kids who started private school / prep school very young and those who started as young teens is vast.

But obviously a lot of other factors come into play, such as the actual schools involved and how it will impact on your finances. It's not a "better at all costs" option.

Ilovechocolatetoomuch · 14/12/2021 07:34

My child is in state, my friends child in private both hfa my child receives better care and support hands down.
It depends what you want and also how good your local primary is.

MsTSwift · 14/12/2021 07:05

Agree Angelica - Banana sounds like the worst sort of dreadful snob and a good reason to avoid private school. We are state educated as are our children and there is no discernible difference between us and our many privately educated friends! Knowing many teens as my two are teens and they all hang out together private and state - anecdotally the state schools ones have better social skills!

Motheroftigers · 14/12/2021 06:58

This always happens to these threads.

OP asked for positive experiences from proper who have kids in private school.

Yet like moths to a flame posters can not help coming in to say how much their DC would hate private school. Every. single.Time.

Grin
Motheroftigers · 14/12/2021 06:53

[quote explodingeyes]@PurplePeculiar but how do they field a sports team or perform a nativity play etc. What if the kids fall out.
How do they run a jazz band etc ?[/quote]
They put classes together eg kindergarten and reception, year 1&2, 3&4 ect or all lower junior, all upper junior.

dd2 tiny Indi did a whole junior nativity where each class had a theme with in the navity. Out little reception kids were stars and had their own lines. Its not that much of a hardship Grin

What if the kids fall out It gets squished very quickly plus there is always more kids to play with at break.

whiteroseredrose · 14/12/2021 01:34

As others have said, it is very area specific.

Where we are DC generally only go to private secondary if they don't pass the 11+.

The Prep schools start 'prepping' from Y3 whereas our state primary only did weekly prep before school in Y5. Some got in with that alone, others (including us) paid a tutor for a year.

If you're set on a private secondary in a competitive area then private primary might be a must. I have friends in London and it sounded like an absolute rat race getting into the really top schools.

For local Grammar Schools like here the preps aren't really necessary.

The state primaries are good. Possibly not as glossy as the prep schools but I don't think my DC have missed out on much.

DS learned piano at primary school and continued up to Grade 8 with the same teacher. All DC got to learn to play an instrument for free for a year. They had an orchestra and played at various local events. He did rugby at primary school and continued into secondary - and played against the private schools from further afield. There were lots of cheap after school sports clubs (some free). The primary school took them to the theatre termly and had regular music groups in. The preps probably did more, but our state primary did more than enough.

PurplePeculiar · 14/12/2021 01:14

@explodingeyes

Sports teams are 2 year groups so 1 & 2, 3 &4 and 5 & 6

Orchestra and ensemble - we managed a choir, a brass ensemble, strings, woodwind, piano, guitar, drums and ukelele! So not bad.

The school was very small so friendships were school-wide, not class-based.

The nativity was whole school and delightful. Performances were usually lower school together and upper school together.

As DS's class could fit in the school mini-bus - whenever opportunity arose, they'd pop out for extended learning. The library, museums, beach, park etc - not a massive project - just in the minibus and drive.

It's always about what's best for the child and depends on the school. But this was the most brilliant thing I could ever have done for DS. I just wish I'd done it sooner.

We've now relocated so he could go to an independent secondary with a similar ethos. Again - a fantastic opportunity. But without his stint at the independent primary, he wouldn't be the confident, happy little boy he is.

explodingeyes · 14/12/2021 00:24

@PurplePeculiar but how do they field a sports team or perform a nativity play etc. What if the kids fall out.
How do they run a jazz band etc ?

explodingeyes · 14/12/2021 00:22

A class on 7 would be my DC worse nightmare. It's very limiting friendship wise. Cute at age 4. Hideous by Yr3

PurplePeculiar · 13/12/2021 23:48

Yes to private if you can. Small classes (7 for my DS) chatting to staff every day, lots of enrichment and opportunities that simply wouldn't exist in the state sector. No stress about hot-housing for SATs. Just an absolutely lovely experience. Don't hesitate for a moment.

UndertheCedartree · 13/12/2021 23:38

Purely going on my DD's State Primary the only benefit to a Private school would be smaller class sizes as far as I can tell. She is in a class of 28 with one teacher and one TA (Y5) - there were 2 TAs in Infants.

They have fantastic facilities. All proper gymnastics equipment. They get taught all sorts of different sport by specialist teachers. They have an allotment for gardening and a woodland area for outdoor learning. There is an outdoor pool that they swim in Autumn 1 and all Summer term. Large grounds with lots of play equipment. They have specialist Music and French teachers and Musical instrument tuition offered. Good wrap around care and Holiday club. The lessons are interesting and engaging and prior to Covid lots of opportunities for parents to come into the classroom/class plays to watch etc. They do lots of Art, Science and History. The school meals are reasonably healthy. The pastoral care is outstanding. There is a whole range of before and after school clubs all free of charge.

So much better than when I was at school.

explodingeyes · 13/12/2021 23:24

I too love the M&S ready meal analogy. You get it. It's good. It's quality. But if you are in it from age 4-18 maybe you don't get the eclectic variety that state offer. There are some really good points on here about quality of extra curricular if all done via school.
Is it a bit samey. Can you swop and change as DC grow and change?
Can they mix and meet other players.
Can they try lots of different ones with different teachers and kids and levels. Can they try an advanced class or different style of dance / drama / sport.
My DC have tried loads, progressed to very high level in some etc
But yes, two very active kids and two busy parents facilitating it all.
(state schools in our area all have full wrap round and there's tons of holiday clubs for every interest within a mile so that's not an issue in citys)

Herhereherhere · 13/12/2021 22:49

This is so area/child/school dependent. My area has a number of outstanding state and private primaries. The intention was state primary follows by with state or private secondary.

We have just moved the eldest from state to private as they entered year 3. We are really pleased that we did, despite agonising over it. But my child has had gaps because of COVID and is the type of child that loves all the extra curricular/broad curriculum that they now have access to. We couldn’t fit all that in around a state education. All very well saying you can get tutors/take them to clubs but there are only so many hours in the day - they understandably only wants to do a small amount when home from school.

Having said that, we were happy with the state Infant that they attended but it has become clearer as time has gone on that the gap gets bigger between sectors once you hit junior school, then senior again. At least that is the case round here.

The advantage of the state Infant they attended, which we were happy with is that they met lots of different children from a range of backgrounds and could find out who they really got on with. She also learnt about how to handle bad behaviour in others. They also gave them a good basic academic grounding. Her current school definitely feels like a bubble which is lovely, and increasing their confidence, but it also isn’t the real world.

Fomofo · 13/12/2021 22:27

State all the way, all successful, level headed and happy

whattodo2019 · 13/12/2021 22:05

Private all the way.
More opportunities and breadth

Mamajunebugjones · 13/12/2021 22:04

Three of my kids went private primary. We then moved into the catchment area of a excellent primary in an expensive suburbanised village. The local secondary school gets at least a quarter of it’s A level students into Russell group universities.

Private primary will help with wrap around care, it will provide all the extra curricular activities on tap, (although not necessarily at highest level without extra support and opportunities), music and dance lessons and vast opportunities to gain confidence. You will need to pay for that if you go state, as well as have time for. However I think few activities done well due to interest is far superior to lots done just because it’s available. My older kids main progress in a sport was due to attending national lottery funded countywide sports club.

With kids doing uni applications - I know universities want to know if you did private at ANY stage- it potentially acts against you.

I think the main thing is how much education is valued at home and what opportunities you can provide.

I will start my 4th in the local primary- hopefully DC will get a place. I know what I think would be good enough and we will see how it goes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread