Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to give up and switch?

31 replies

FutureDriver · 12/12/2021 14:21

Been having manual car lessons for close to a year. Gear changes aren’t quite smooth when changing down quickly e.g for turning.
Got my second test coming up but not quite confident I’ll pass.
AIBU to switch to automatic lessons if I fail? It’s one less thing to think about.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Theoldcuriosityshop · 12/12/2021 15:56

I've been driving for over 40 years, passed my test in an automatic and obviously have only ever driven automatic cars. They are increasingly popular.

TamzinGrey · 12/12/2021 15:40

Definitely switch. I was in exactly the same position as you, and as soon as I switched to an automatic I sailed through my test. I always intended to retake it in a manual car, but never bothered as I enjoy driving automatics, and don't see the point of manual gear changes to be honest.
DH, who is a very competent driver and passed his test in a manual, now has an automatic because he much prefers the driving experience.

ThinWomansBrain · 12/12/2021 15:33

I qualified in a geared car, very first temporary car was automatic (no one told me, 2 minute explanation in an underground car park when I stopped a passing director and asked why there was a pedal missing, then lauched into rush hour traffic in central London) - 5-6 years of a geared car, then didn't drive for 10+ years when I moved to central London.
I then needed to buy a car, and went for an automatic as I was a bit rusty after a 10 year gap - that and then fairly newish sat nav & I was away, never looked back, no real disadvantages.
As PP has said, electric cars don't have a clutch, if you're fiding it hard, why bother?

Justcashnosweets · 12/12/2021 15:29

Definitely go with Automatic. I passed in a manual but hated it. Never looked back since driving automatic cars, so much easier!

VitalsStable · 12/12/2021 15:25

We've 2 cars, a big one for the family which is automatic and a mini which I drive mostly which is automatic. We've never had any problems with them.

Electric cars are the future and they're all automatic.

Just go for a lesson in one and see what you think, not having to worry about changing gear whilst manoeuvring makes a huge difference to learners.

FutureDriver · 12/12/2021 15:18

Also thanks to everyone who replied either way ; may not be able to reply to all but reassuring to see so many people agreeing.

@exexpat I was thinking the same thing, I think what put me off was people in IRL being very negative about automatics. But then again maybe it's just my circle who judge people by their driving ability.

Who cares though - all i need is to pass and be on my merry way in a car...

OP posts:
Sugarplumfairy65 · 12/12/2021 15:16

I e been driving automatics since 1984. I've never had a problem getting a vehicle I want, never paid over the odds and modern automatics use no more fuel than a manual of the same model.
Once we are all driving electric and hybrids, manual cars will be obsolete anyway

myparentswerealiens · 12/12/2021 15:15

It's always good to have the choice just in case but my last 2 cars have been automatic and I'll never willingly go back to a manual.

I'd say do your automatic test now and then once you've been driving a while you may feel confident enough to do your manual test (you'll probably never feel the need to though)

Stellaris22 · 12/12/2021 15:12

Considering the future is electric cars I would just switch to automatic lessons. It's not worth the stress if you would find it easier.

If I were to have lessons it would 100% be automatic.

FutureDriver · 12/12/2021 15:10

@ColdTattyWaitingForSummer

I’m considering automatic lessons for ds2 when he turns 17. I think his dyslexia plus dyspraxic tendencies might mean he struggles with a manual. If you switch now and it gets you through the test, you can always try manual again in the future.
Thanks - that's what I was thinking too. It doesn't really matter that automatics are expensive etc etc I;'ll probably spend more than it's wroth in lessons anyway if I have to keep retaking
OP posts:
exexpat · 12/12/2021 15:09

All hybrids and electric cars are automatic, so gear changes are going to be a thing of the past soon - people who have spent their lives driving standard manual shift cars may not realise this yet.

Only being able to drive automatics may slightly limit your choice of cars for the next five years or so (and they are a bit more expensive for now) but if it's a choice between spending ages and lots of money on more driving lessons and tests, and getting an automatic licence pretty quickly, I would go for that.

Xiaoxiong · 12/12/2021 15:00

Don't waste your time learning manual unless you're planning on driving classic cars or something. Automatic is going to be universal very soon as hybrid and electric cars are virtually all automatic. Add to that that it's so much easier to learn, and IMO safer as you can give more of your attention to awareness around you rather than your gears, no chance of stalling, etc.

I learned automatic only in the USA, DH scoffed at me (fuel economy! Lack of control! Not as much fun!) until he drove an automatic for a while and now he says he was completely wrong about all of it and he'll never go back.

EishetChayil · 12/12/2021 14:53

Automatic! So much easier. I've never loved driving as much as since I switched.

FutureDriver · 12/12/2021 14:47

@OnlyonemoresleeptilChristmas

Have you had the same teacher all this time? Why are the gear changes quick when turning? Do they not give you advance instructions that you will be turning eg the next road on the left or whatever? Would a change of instructor help?

Automatic cars tend to be more expensive to buy.

Same teacher; I think he is ok but sometimes I feel that he gives directions last minute and says that I’m not quick enough to react. Like he’ll say ‘turn left here’, I’m going at 30 mph and the turning is literally in front of me so by the time I lower speed, change gear etc.

I have had a couple of cover lessons with other instructors though and they all have instructions similarly so I don’t think it’s just him

OP posts:
XelaM · 12/12/2021 14:46

Absolutely no reason to drive a manual car ever

sparklefarts · 12/12/2021 14:45

(I have a 2009 Nissan note which is is fab condition)

sparklefarts · 12/12/2021 14:44

I drive automatic!

Best decision I made.

MartyHart · 12/12/2021 14:44

We've had 3 automatics in a row. They're brilliant and I would never go back to a manual car again. Switch to auto and enjoy driving.

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 12/12/2021 14:44

I’m considering automatic lessons for ds2 when he turns 17. I think his dyslexia plus dyspraxic tendencies might mean he struggles with a manual.
If you switch now and it gets you through the test, you can always try manual again in the future.

XelaM · 12/12/2021 14:43

Automatic is soooooooo much easier! I have passed on manual many years ago, but have only ever driven automatic since. It's infinitely easier

FutureDriver · 12/12/2021 14:42

@VitalsStable

God yes change to a manual, they're like driving a bumper car, so much less to think about.
Hi thanks - do you drive an automatic? What sort of car do you have
OP posts:
FutureDriver · 12/12/2021 14:42

@bonfireheart

Woah, escalated quickly. If you want to drive manual, do it. If you want to drive automatic, do it. Simple.
Well everyone around me keeps telling me to stick to manual and judging people who drive an automatic - but I just want to pass and get on with my life.

Maybe I should have reworded the question ; does anyone with an automatic face any issue.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 12/12/2021 14:41

@FutureDriver

Been having manual car lessons for close to a year. Gear changes aren’t quite smooth when changing down quickly e.g for turning. Got my second test coming up but not quite confident I’ll pass. AIBU to switch to automatic lessons if I fail? It’s one less thing to think about.
I'd stick with the gears personally, so much more choice of car when you're driving
ComtesseDeSpair · 12/12/2021 14:38

Yes, switch. Automatic cars are just as reliable as manual cars nowadays; and honestly, considering electrical vehicles are the future I’m unsure why anyone learning to drive over the next few years would bother to learn what will soon be a redundant piece of technology.

bonfireheart · 12/12/2021 14:34

Woah, escalated quickly.
If you want to drive manual, do it.
If you want to drive automatic, do it.
Simple.