Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to give presents away?

82 replies

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 12/12/2021 13:42

So for various reasons my inlaws have turned up today with presents for christmas.

In October I gave them a list of present ideas for DD (18 months) to ensure she'd get toys she'd use and no duplicated. Including things in a mix of prices that they could easily get. So no online retailers. They bought 3 items off it and told us about these. Great. She has too many toys anyway and the 3 they got were more than enough. In late November i asked if they were done with the list and they said yes they were and I could buy anything else off it they hadn't bought.

Today they have turned up with a sack of presents and i mean a sack. Quick look there's about 12 reasonable size gifts in there.

Now here comes the crunch. WIBU to go through it when they've gone and donate at least some to our local baby bank who are collecting christmas gifts? We do not need loads of presents and I'll probably end up giving some away after christmas anyway.

They won't be here on christmas day itself. But may come over new year instead. But I don't think they'll actually notice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhatATimeToBeAlive · 13/12/2021 12:15

@Capricopia

YANBU. At 1& months she will be overwhelmed by too many gifts. It would be kind for you to share some of them with kids who are less fortunate.
Yup, agree with this 100% but just be sure your husband is on board with it too.
aSofaNearYou · 13/12/2021 12:06

Personally, unless you live in a one bed flat, I think YABU.

You could always ask them to keep some of them at their house, or as some other posters said, you could put them in a cupboard and slowly hand them out over the coming months.

Odoreida · 13/12/2021 12:02

Definitely give them away, a while before Christmas if possible.

skkyelark · 13/12/2021 11:56

I think whatever you do, DH has to be happy with it and happy to explain it to his parents.

My ILs ask for a list and then buy additional items –that's fine, it's nice to choose some presents yourself. However, the additional items inevitably include half a dozen cuddly toys, which quickly adds up (and DD is not even that into most cuddly toys).

We've always gone for letting her open them all and seeing what she fancies, and then culling a bit later. We always keep something (at least for the first cull; I don't keep track after that), and I'll sometimes put away a particularly nice or unusual one in hopes she might like it when she's older – which also means they can be pulled out for visits, even if DD still ignores them.

MoreAloneTime · 13/12/2021 10:00

@immersivereader

I did this last year. The same magic set 3 times. Gave 2 away
Some people see themselves as these generous givers and they don't even give a shit do they?
UnsuitableHat · 13/12/2021 02:43

Not unreasonable to give stuff away (and annoying that they’ve bought so much more than requested) but I’d wait until after new year.

immersivereader · 13/12/2021 02:37

Giving away your child's gifts before she has even seen them is disgusting quite frankly

^

LOL.

She's 18 months. Hardly at an optimal decision making age

immersivereader · 13/12/2021 02:37

I did this last year. The same magic set 3 times. Gave 2 away

Rodion · 13/12/2021 02:35

Maybe you could say that they've clearly gone to a lot of effort which is lovely and v much appreciated. But that given how many gifts there are you are concerned that DD might end up overlooking some of them and they'll go unplaced with, and perhaps it would be sensible to put half away for her birthday?

Fleemeister · 13/12/2021 02:25

It's a bit grim to grub through your DD's gifts beforehand. I think you should open them all at Christmas. If some then find their way to a charity box without quite making it out of the packaging, so be it. There will be another Christmas toy appeal next year and plenty of charity shops are open all year.

PinkSyCo · 13/12/2021 02:25

Giving away your child's gifts before she has even seen them is disgusting quite frankly.

Don’t be so bloody dramatic. OP’s child sounds to be the very opposite of deprived, she is not going to miss a few toys that she’s never had, but a needy child would really really appreciate them. What on earth is disgusting about that?

Pixiedust1234 · 13/12/2021 00:50

I am assuming nothing. If you haven't bought anything then problem solved for this year. If you have bought then either return or gift yours. Giving away your child's gifts before she has even seen them is disgusting quite frankly. As others have suggested clear out her old unplayed with toys first and then see what she likes after she has unwrapped them.

MenoMom · 13/12/2021 00:05

i think it's a lovely idea to give some to charity now so that other families can have new unused gifts at Xmas.

PinkSyCo · 13/12/2021 00:01

I think it’s a lovely idea to donate your surplus of toys to children less fortunate than your DD. Do it 0P.

justasking111 · 12/12/2021 23:48

Well you will have to unwrap them to check they're actually safe to pass on also write down each present so you can tell in-laws thanks for xyz.

But you should discuss with partner also

ChampagneLassie · 12/12/2021 23:42

You remind me of my mother. My granny, her MIL would bring outlandish and unnecessary gifts and food. And I loved it! Whereas my puritan mother saw it all as wasteful. 2-3 times a year for 48 hrs sounds a fair amount to me, but hey if you want them around more perhaps making them feel welcome.

Mylittlepotofjoy · 12/12/2021 23:22

Could you peek in the parcels and see if anything is doubled up . If so one of them could be donated and no one would be any wiser ?

Hadtocomment · 12/12/2021 19:26

I do share the frustration. It can be difficult when people think huge amounts of wasteful gifts are the thing. Maybe the people they are giving to don't have loads of room and just gives them a headache. Or maybe they feel a bit queasy just being given far too much that can't become special due to sheer amount. It sounds just slightly controling maybe about them having to give something on a specific list and nothing else. But if it's really a huge amount I can see your point. It's a tough one about donating. I think it's a lovely idea particularly now with the pandemic making things so hard for so many. There could be kids that would really get a lift from getting presents your baby will not really understand yet. But if they are coming in the new year and will immediately ask where this or that is what will they say and will they get offended? Will it seem as though you thought their presents were expendable as not on your list and under total control? If you do do this I'd ask your partner maybe and also not make it just their presents and I'd also highlight some specific ones they gave that you do like to take pride of place or something. I am sympathetic to you though. It is sad that some people are inundated with stuff they don't want if it could be really appreciated elsewhere.

Dishwashersaurous · 12/12/2021 18:20

Just keep them in a cupboard and give her one a week or so for the first half of the year.

Cold rainy January day, slightly grumpy child, new toy happiness for a day

StoneofDestiny · 12/12/2021 17:52

If you want to donate elsewhere - do so after their NY visit - children have birthdays throughout the year and people are less generous donating outwith Christmas. That way they won't be 'hurt'.

AlwaysLatte · 12/12/2021 17:41

I wouldn't. Grandparents are important. Can you video them opening them (assuming they're unable to get there on the day given they've already delivered them) and then after the novelty has worn off either rotate or donate.

Redarrow2017 · 12/12/2021 17:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

shreddies · 12/12/2021 17:22

I would give them away now as new toys that another child can enjoy.

Lushplease · 12/12/2021 17:14

They are gifts for your dd - let her play with them.
Store some away after Christmas and rotate throughout the year.

It's not very nice giving the ils gifts away.

Fl0w3ry · 12/12/2021 17:06

I think you should give them to your child. Also if your in-laws did ask after specific presents that you have given away it could be awkward.