Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to tell 44 weeks and breech friend she's risking her baby?

738 replies

scottishlass43 · 12/12/2021 11:16

My friend is 44 weeks pregnant with a footling breech. She's determined to have a natural birth at home with another friend of ours who's a midwife. She's been declining all intervention till now and has no cut off point - she wants to let the baby come naturally and doesn't want scans or any monitoring. She refuses to consider a c-section.

She's older (late thirties) and has been waiting for several years for this baby. I have no idea why she'd risk it now.

AIBU wanting to tell her what I think? Am I (and other worried friends) overreacting? Does anyone know of anyone who's done this, and how it went?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 09:03

the lack of advocacy over my own body and the sense that I have no choice or control over what will happen

I'm very sorry to say it, but there isn't a lot of control you can exert over birth. If there were, we wouldn't ever have terrible tragedies. Hopefully you will be lucky and get the birth you want, but it is a simple fact that there are all sorts of things that could happen that you can't control. It's the same for all of us.

chiatta · 13/12/2021 09:00

Any news @scottishlass43

Saoirse82 · 13/12/2021 08:56

What the fuck? Both those situations individually would be extremely high risk for a home birth but together it's a recipe for disaster. She's a fucking idiot to put her baby at risk like that and I'd have to say something. At what point will she accept medical intervention?

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 13/12/2021 08:56

@DropYourSword

Prefacing this comment by making it clear that I think this woman is making a terrible decision. BUT - all of the approaches on this thread about showing her this thread, telling her her baby WILL die etc isn’t the approach.

She is obviously making this decision for whatever reason she has, which we don’t know. She is allowed to make this decision. But it needs to be an INFORMED decision.

In my experience women in these situations get frustrated because they aren’t being heard. And the medical experts get frustrated because they feel they aren’t being heard.
What’s worked MUCH better in my previous experience is to approach this conversation as “Ok as your caregiver I t’s my job to ensure you get the care YOU choose. I can provide you with your options and the benefits and drawbacks of both and then you decide what the right decision is for YOU. I want you to make an informed decision so I need to provide you with all the information to be able to do that” and then discuss risks / benefits etc.

Simply going into that conversation saying “if you don’t do what I say your baby will probably die” does NOT open up that dialogue.
I’ve seen so many women shut down a conversation before it’s even begun because they feel they are just being railroaded into doing what the doctor wants them to do rather than both parties listening and being heard.

This is exactly my experience. I am currently pregnant with twins (20 weeks). I see a consultant every fortnight and they have talked about stillbirth every time. I am told when and how my babies are delivered by policy. I'm going to do as I'm told, but it has left me sobbing on multiple occasions at the lack of advocacy over my own body and the sense that I have no choice or control over what will happen. I'm dreading an induction and being told so glibly that my choice will be that or stillbirth does not make a great environment for collaborative decisions around my care.

This lady has driven it to the extreme, but I can empathise with how people get there.

DropYourSword · 13/12/2021 08:47

Prefacing this comment by making it clear that I think this woman is making a terrible decision.
BUT - all of the approaches on this thread about showing her this thread, telling her her baby WILL die etc isn’t the approach.

She is obviously making this decision for whatever reason she has, which we don’t know. She is allowed to make this decision. But it needs to be an INFORMED decision.

In my experience women in these situations get frustrated because they aren’t being heard. And the medical experts get frustrated because they feel they aren’t being heard.
What’s worked MUCH better in my previous experience is to approach this conversation as “Ok as your caregiver I t’s my job to ensure you get the care YOU choose. I can provide you with your options and the benefits and drawbacks of both and then you decide what the right decision is for YOU. I want you to make an informed decision so I need to provide you with all the information to be able to do that” and then discuss risks / benefits etc.

Simply going into that conversation saying “if you don’t do what I say your baby will probably die” does NOT open up that dialogue.
I’ve seen so many women shut down a conversation before it’s even begun because they feel they are just being railroaded into doing what the doctor wants them to do rather than both parties listening and being heard.

dumdedumpop · 13/12/2021 08:45

@scottishlass43 what is your mutual friend / her midwife doing to her through this situation? She must realise she's risking fitness to practise by supporting this?

dumdedumpop · 13/12/2021 08:37

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

My 3am reading (non sleeping toddler) unearthed a fucking irresponsible article in the Guardian of all places essentially supporting free birth! Wtf
What article was that? I've read a few over the years in the Guardian but I wouldn't have classed any as supportive of that choice.
Comedycook · 13/12/2021 08:34

@DrSbaitso

Obsession with it all being "natural" is very much a first world privilege.
I agree and I think many people forget that if we left childbirth entirely to nature many women and babies die.
DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 08:29

Obsession with it all being "natural" is very much a first world privilege.

Comedycook · 13/12/2021 08:04

I never understood the obsession with waiting for labour to start naturally. I was terrified when I was overdue with my DD and they wouldn't do anything until I was late by a certain number of days...

Rainartist · 13/12/2021 08:00

@HairyFanjoBanjo

Women in my NCT group refused to be induced into labour and insisted on a ‘natural birth, - after 42 weeks she was finally rushed into hospital as home-birth didn’t work out and she had a stillbirth.

There is an appalling ‘culture’ of woowoo birthing bullshit amongst a really wide cross-section of middle class women who are almost competing to have the most ‘natural’ birth. It’s delusional and has horrific outcomes for a minority of them.

I don’t mind a bit of woo now and again, but why on earth would you risk your unborn child’s life - it’s utterly tragic and completely unnecessary.

I remember being pregnant with my first and my good friend was too but a few months ahead, sent me a "wonderful book" (her words) about natural birth, it's a while ago so I forget all the details but remember reading the male doctors opinions about how women can labour without pain relief how it's all in the mind and how's years ago women gave birth and an hour later they were up and out working again in the fields, factories etc as the had no choice I stopped reading it, though it was a load of rubbish and gave it back but said nothing to her as I thought it was none of my business.

Fast forward, she was blue lighted across the city when everything went wrong at the natural birth centre. Luckily with a healthy baby at the end. This friend is very like the relative I have who left her birth 43 weeks. Highly educated, middle class and a bit "alternative" in views but essentially arrogant as they believe they know better than the healthcare professionals who are highly trained. I love them both but they're also ignorant (and wouldn't appreciate me saying it).

I work in healthcare and have sadly seen the other side of all the success stories, I understand the wanting to limit medical intervention and "naturalise" birth, but I really don't think people like this realise that death is another outcome of a natural birth with no interventions. It's playing russian roulette with their and their baby's life and the consequences as sadly displayed in this thread show are tragic and ripple out to more people than that mother Sad

There's nothing to lose by laying it on thick to your friend op, how would you feel about supporting her if the worst happened? It's harsh but I'm not sure I could have forgiven my relative for her opinions if the worst had happened, in that sense I "got lucky" too as I didn't have to deal with the consequences and neither did my family, I suspect I wouldn't have been alone in my feelings either....

Jacaranda75 · 13/12/2021 07:31

@scottishlass43 I would send her a screenshot of @aurynne 's post below. Yeah, she might not ever speak to you again, but I think you need to do something. She might just see sense.

Fetchthevet · 13/12/2021 07:22

@Lilyargin

My friend declined induction at 42 weeks. Then the baby stopped moving. She had to give birth knowing the baby had died. She wishes she hadn't declined the induction with all her heart.
Your poor friend. That sort of regret is incredibly hard to live with.
Fetchthevet · 13/12/2021 07:19

I can't believe any mother would do this. Poor baby.

aurynne · 13/12/2021 07:05

Midwife here.

"She wants to let the baby come naturally" --> I would remind her that the birth of a dead baby and death of a mother due to sepsis is a very normal birth in her specific circumstances. I hate it when people equate "natural" with "lovely and beautiful". In nature, newborn babies are eaten alive shortly after birth by predators. Mothers die of infections. A broken limb results in pain and suffering for days, if you're not torn to pieces by predators before you heal. THAT is nature. Nature won't give a shit if her baby lives or dies.

She is being utterly stupid and blindsided by her wish for a "natural birth".

In the country I practice I would not have any obligation to give her care. If she contacted me in labour, I would call an ambulance to pick her up and take her to hospital. I would have stopped offering her care long before she got to 44 weeks on personal principle. There is no way I would put my career and my mental health at risk in such an extremely risky environment, by a woman who would also probably refuse any monitoring during labour. And I don't know any other midwife, no mater how "natural", that would.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 13/12/2021 07:04

My 3am reading (non sleeping toddler) unearthed a fucking irresponsible article in the Guardian of all places essentially supporting free birth! Wtf

Fridafever · 13/12/2021 06:19

How do you/ she know it’s footling breech if she’s not having scans?

ShippingNews · 13/12/2021 06:14

Footling breech is one of the most dangerous presentations. The feet slide easily into the birth canal, and the head can then get stuck in the uterus, since the cervix doesn't dilate sufficiently to allow it to pass. The cord can become trapped between the skull and the cervix, leading to a still birth. I can't believe that this woman is even considering this plan. The midwife is asking to be prosecuted for malpractice if she is going along with it.

oohmamama · 13/12/2021 06:01

I had a footling breech birth. The lack of pressure on my cervix prevented proper dilation and there was a very high risk of cord prolapse. I went into labour before my scheduled Csection and it was terrifying. Ended up with a hugely traumatic emergency csection with the baby’s feet in my birth canal. Footling breeches have a very, very high risk of death if birth is natural.

liveforsummer · 13/12/2021 05:51

Have you spoken to your mutual midwife friend about it? That seems the most sensible thing to do. Why is she supporting this?

SuPerDoPer · 13/12/2021 05:29

It's very likely that she has been told the risks in very graphic detail by all the relevant medical professionals. I refused an induction initially as I wanted to wait a bit longer and give baby a chance to come naturally and the consultant did not hold back in telling me the risks of serious complications and still birth. They know they will risk having their practice criticised if they don't spell it out very clearly. My SIL had the same experience. Induction is a scary process - handing yourself over to increasing amounts of interventions which themselves aren't without serious risk. But the risk of not acting is also scary. It's hard to know what is best, at least initially.

I would consider that your friend has likely been given all the medical information about risks already so you wouldn't be telling her anything new. I'm concerned that a registered midwife is involved in this as she must know that the chances of a good result are seriously limited by this stage.

daretodenim · 13/12/2021 05:01

OP do you know the reason why she wants a home birth? Does she simply have a romanticised view of what birth will be and she's aiming for that (and it can be a great experience, but that's usually down to luck - not that those mothers often admit that, it's usually presented like they did something right)? Or does she have a history of medical or sexual trauma? I'm asking because her thinking is irrational to us all, but in her mind it makes sense. Knowing what her reasons are could help discuss birthing alternatives.

However, you're the poster and you are, as a friend, also going to be impacted by what happens next. There's an increasing likelihood that your friend is about to go through something traumatic. Is this something you can support her in, or do you think not (either would be completely understandable by the way!!).

If you think you simply can't be there for her if things go wrong in any way, because you'll be lacking in sympathy for someone who you feel thought it on themselves (sounds harsh but I think it would be a normal reaction), then you have little to lose by talking to her about the situation.

If you think that you can be there for her, no matter what she chooses and no matter the outcome, then your choice re the discussion is different.

At the end of the day, this is what "her body, her choice" means. It's not always comfortable and we don't always agree. But the alternative is not ok.

DuckPancake · 13/12/2021 01:07

This is tragically selfish, all for a few hours of her's/baby's life? What about the rest of it? Poor dad too!

TallulahsCurse · 13/12/2021 00:01

Not insensitive no, don't worry.

I only ever post on threads like this to educate, if only the tiniest amount - even if it's just to say be that person to mention SB to a pregnant woman, or to point out that sadly it is more common than people think.

DrSbaitso · 12/12/2021 23:59

@TallulahsCurse

^No, you idiot, a dead mother and/or baby is the worst possible outcome. Thankfully it is rare these days, but only because we've got interventions that we didn't always have^

No it's not that rare, sadly... Once you become a member of that group no one wants to ever even knows exists, let alone be a part of, which is the stillbirth and neonatal deaths.... You realise it isn't that rare.

But for all the people I know who have lost children, I know that we would have done anything we possibly could have done to save them.

This woman needs help. Quickly.

I'm sorry if that was insensitive. It wasn't my intention.

All the more reason not to take terrible and completely unnecessary risks.