Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to tell 44 weeks and breech friend she's risking her baby?

738 replies

scottishlass43 · 12/12/2021 11:16

My friend is 44 weeks pregnant with a footling breech. She's determined to have a natural birth at home with another friend of ours who's a midwife. She's been declining all intervention till now and has no cut off point - she wants to let the baby come naturally and doesn't want scans or any monitoring. She refuses to consider a c-section.

She's older (late thirties) and has been waiting for several years for this baby. I have no idea why she'd risk it now.

AIBU wanting to tell her what I think? Am I (and other worried friends) overreacting? Does anyone know of anyone who's done this, and how it went?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 10:13

I'm sorry, @RainbowCrayons, I think I might have misread your point. Didn't get much sleep last night!

Beenheresincethebook · 13/12/2021 10:13

Surprised but glad they are both fine

DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 10:11

Well I'm very glad they're both OK.

DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 10:10

To be honest this thread has got rid of the last of that guilt as many people have pointed out here perhaps 'nature intended' me and DS to die.

I don't think anyone has said that? What they've said, in essence, is that "natural" doesn't mean safe or good. In fact it's often the exact opposite, and therefore we shouldn't place too much value in what's "natural" over what's actually a good outcome.

scottishlass43 · 13/12/2021 10:09

I just found out that she went into labour early yesterday morning, but kept it very quiet as she didn't progress and was transferred for a c-section in the afternoon. Mum and baby both fine.

Very relieved they're fine. A little worried the overall positive experience means she'll continue telling people to trust their bodies and wait as long as possible. By the anecdotal evidence of lots of the stories in this thread it sounds like it could have ended very differently.

OP posts:
RainbowCrayons · 13/12/2021 10:04

I agree with almost everything PPs have said. The only issue I have is people saying this decision is selfish. Not because it isn't a really terrible decision but because I'm sure the friend is being told by the natural birth community that it's selfish to do anything that isn't natural and because 'selfish' has become an overused term using guilt to force (especially women's) behaviour.

I had planned a perfect waterbirth after avoiding all alcohol, caffeine and even paracetamol for the whole pregnancy in order to do everything 'right'. I then had to be induced by drip at 37 weeks due to reduced/no movement with epidural and only narrowly avoided forceps/section. I had so much guilt that eventually manifested as PNA/PND for being so 'selfish' for putting a 'comfortable', 'medical' birth for me above doing things 'as nature inteded'. To be honest this thread has got rid of the last of that guilt as many people have pointed out here perhaps 'nature intended' me and DS to die.

I'm really just hoping for a positive update from OP or that her friend somehow got her dates wrong.

Chely · 13/12/2021 10:02

I don't know how she can not be totally fed up by now.

I wouldn't risk a natural birth with a known breech, c-sections are not great (had 2) but if it's safer for baby it's worth doing.

CloudPop · 13/12/2021 09:44

@EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall

My oldest is nearly 27. By the time induction worked I was 43 + weeks, not something I'd have chosen! He wasn't breech though and he weighed 11lb 2. It wasn't pleasant
11lb 2!!!! 😮
Teaandcakeordeath83 · 13/12/2021 09:43

[quote Glassofshloer]**@Teaandcakeordeath83* I didn’t mean to be condescending but home vbacs are discouraged. After 2 caesarians one would think the risk would be even higher. So how did you know it would be safer than any* hospital?[/quote]
"A multivariate analysis of the NICHD study showed that there was no significant difference
in the rates of uterine rupture in VBAC with two or more previous caesarean births (9/975,
92/10000) compared with a single previous caesarean birth (115/16 915, 68/10000).46 These
findings concur with other observational studies, which, overall, have shown similar rates of
VBAC success with two previous caesarean births (VBAC success rates of 62–75%) and single
prior caesarean birth.47–50 It is notable that more than half of the women with two previous
caesarean deliveries had also had a previous vaginal birth and 40% had a previous VBAC.
Hence, caution should be applied when extrapolating these data to women with no previous
vaginal delivery."- RCOG GTG45 birth after previous caesarean birth guidelines.

The evidence level for this is considered a 2+ which is pretty decent for maternal research seeing as it's chronically under-researched and people would rather make assumptions than actually determine the best course of treatment.

I can see why others wouldn't be happy taking the decisions I made- however they weren't made with "woo" or a desire to have a "perfect insta birth" like some of the comments on here are judging the woman in the original OP to have made. They were made after reading absolutely every research paper about vbacs/ systematic reviews/ guidelines etc that I could lay my mitts on. After conversations with doctors who refused to acknowledge the data and risks in the guidelines they should be working to. Hardly trust building.

How do you know I live within a safe distance of any other hospital? Or that if I did if that hospital wouldn't be "worse"/ failing/ under special measures/ had a report against its maternity department? If you're repeatedly lied to by doctors, coerced into treatments you don't want and are generally subjected to poor outcomes surely the question is why would you opt for that again? You only have to read through this thread and see that there's a substantial group of posters who think that home birth shouldn't be an option anyway regardless of "risk".

Fwiw I'm a scientist and work in the NHS. I've had extensive experience as a patient and worker in many areas of the NHS. I've never been spoken to or treated so poorly as my experiences in maternity- you can see it in the responses of posters on here "I didn't think they'd let you" as though women are supposed to be compliant and just do whatever the doctor says with no personal choice allowed. I can fully see why the current maternity set up has some women running for the hills.

timeisnotaline · 13/12/2021 09:42

@Comedycook

I never understood the obsession with waiting for labour to start naturally. I was terrified when I was overdue with my DD and they wouldn't do anything until I was late by a certain number of days...
It’s not an obsession, it’s the simplest way to give birth for many/most. My obstetrician will induce at 10 days over. But going longer than two weeks over is madness really, why the hell take that risk?
Incognito22333 · 13/12/2021 09:37

Your friend needs a C-section immediately.
A hospital won’t induce for footling breech (far too risky).

I reckon she has anxiety around the C-Section/hospitals. Plus pregnancy hormones can make people a lot more anxious. People can get very fixated on birth plans and often irrationally and illogically so. I remember after my C section I regretted it for ages as I was so fixated on natural birth. I think it was just a mild phobia in my case. An elective C section can be a nice calming thing - can have your music on etc. Ideally for your friend she could have your midwife friend present as birthing partner during the C section to calm her down.

McOrange · 13/12/2021 09:37

@Comedycook

I never understood the obsession with waiting for labour to start naturally. I was terrified when I was overdue with my DD and they wouldn't do anything until I was late by a certain number of days...
Many women want labour to start naturally. Being induced is frankly an awful experience. I declined induction for as long as possible (within the time limit approved by the midwives) because I did not want to go through that. As it was, I ended up with a 72 hour labour in which the baby’s heart rate ended up dropping and I had an EMCS.

It’s well known that with inductions you often end up with an epidural as the drip is so painful, so end up down the chain of intervention with an instrumental delivery or EMCS a very real possibility.

Of course that’s a real fear of many women and why so many want to wait to bring labour on naturally

DropYourSword · 13/12/2021 09:33

@Glassofshloer

But what is an ‘informed choice’?

To be honest if you think you can weigh up risk better than a medical professional then you’re very unlikely to listen to them anyway.

Doctors can provide information on the risks of something. People receiving care are the ones that are able to weigh up those risks as they apply to their specific situation. It should be a partnership.
EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 13/12/2021 09:31

My oldest is nearly 27. By the time induction worked I was 43 + weeks, not something I'd have chosen! He wasn't breech though and he weighed 11lb 2. It wasn't pleasant

SacramentoQueen · 13/12/2021 09:25

One of the reasons there isn’t a huge amount of info out there on the effects of such an overdue baby is because it is completely unethical to do a study like that which risks babies and mothers lives. Sweden tried it a few years ago and cancelled the study after 6 of the babies died. If your friend is interested in doing research on it maybe this would be something she’d read? Reported in lots of places if the guardian isn’t her thing but this is the first one that came up when I searched for it

amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/oct/28/post-term-pregnancy-research-cancelled-babies-die-sweden

candlelightsatdawn · 13/12/2021 09:22

I think that part of the free birthing movement it due to doctors and sometimes midwives (not all please don't shoot me) for not really allowing mum to have a voice and women feeling completely uninpowered, often not being asked to consent to medical checks and treated less a human and more a oven. It's not right btw but there should be some type of balance. I mostly found the worst was the consultants, I wish I had been completely in MW care with my DD but with my history I couldn't be.

I really hope your friend changes her mind. Burying my baby was one of the worst days of my life. I wouldn't wish it on anyone. The statics maybe "low" but that's sometimes not how life works, now what I go by is if there's a chance of the worse happening, could I live with myself.

Please update us OP.

DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 09:19

[quote GrealishHairband]@DrSbaitso you can’t control birth but you can control how involved a mother feels in her own pregnancy and provide her with options and information so she feels as though she as much control as possible rather than just being a passenger in her own pregnancy.[/quote]
Yes, I'd certainly agree with that.

But I don't relate at all to the idea that birth is something you can control as such (I'm not saying PP said that, but I know some women feel that way). Hopefully you can have the water birth or whatever you want. But I never saw it as an "experience"....for me, it was always a means to an end. I didn't even write a birth plan because I was aware that so many things could happen that I simply couldn't control. Just as well, as it happens.

Birth trauma is very real. I don't know what the solution is. I don't want mums to be to be terrorised, but I also don't think it's a good idea to get too invested in the idea that you can control everything, and you've somehow failed or missed out on the "experience" if it doesn't go as you wanted.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/12/2021 09:19

There was once a heartbreaking post on here, from someone who’d insisted on a home birth for a first baby - which was brain damaged as a result. She was consumed with guilt about that decision.

Whether it’d be any use telling your friend about that I don’t know, though. Some people seem so fixated on the birth itself, rather than on the hoped-for outcome - which is a healthy baby, with a healthy mother to care for it.

OliviaBean · 13/12/2021 09:18

OP, maybe talk to the so called midwife who is involved with your friend.

In this instance I would 100% make my feelings known and damn the consequences.

Please do let us know how things go, this thread has made a lot of us quite anxious about the welfare of the baby.

Saoirse82 · 13/12/2021 09:18

@Blondeshavemorefun

44w and not given birth

Are you sure ?

Seems very weird no scans since 20w

Why not a 28w one

You don't have to agree to any scans. And routinely no scans are given after the 20 week one any more if you're considered a low risk pregnancy.
Glassofshloer · 13/12/2021 09:18

[quote GrealishHairband]@DrSbaitso you can’t control birth but you can control how involved a mother feels in her own pregnancy and provide her with options and information so she feels as though she as much control as possible rather than just being a passenger in her own pregnancy.[/quote]
I strongly suspect that some (not all of even most) women who say they felt ‘bullied’ by the medical profession in pregnancy merely mean that the medics didn’t tell them what they wanted to hear in order to justify an unsafe birthing preference.

GrealishHairband · 13/12/2021 09:13

@DrSbaitso you can’t control birth but you can control how involved a mother feels in her own pregnancy and provide her with options and information so she feels as though she as much control as possible rather than just being a passenger in her own pregnancy.

Glassofshloer · 13/12/2021 09:12

But what is an ‘informed choice’?

To be honest if you think you can weigh up risk better than a medical professional then you’re very unlikely to listen to them anyway.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 13/12/2021 09:08

@dumdedumpop

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/jun/29/free-birth-janet-fraser-system

This is absurdly positive given the context IMO. I say that as someone who had a homebirth (second baby, textbook pregnancy and with two midwives there, 10 mins from a hospital).

user14943608381 · 13/12/2021 09:05

I’m nervously check the thread to see if OP updates with news on the baby, I don’t think this story has a happy ending unfortunately.