Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to tell 44 weeks and breech friend she's risking her baby?

738 replies

scottishlass43 · 12/12/2021 11:16

My friend is 44 weeks pregnant with a footling breech. She's determined to have a natural birth at home with another friend of ours who's a midwife. She's been declining all intervention till now and has no cut off point - she wants to let the baby come naturally and doesn't want scans or any monitoring. She refuses to consider a c-section.

She's older (late thirties) and has been waiting for several years for this baby. I have no idea why she'd risk it now.

AIBU wanting to tell her what I think? Am I (and other worried friends) overreacting? Does anyone know of anyone who's done this, and how it went?

OP posts:
user14943608381 · 13/12/2021 21:50

@Mamette so I’m going to speak from my own personal experience… I was lied to during my birth of both kids (more so on delivery suite with an IoL), not a conspiracy but because they have a conveyor belt sort of process in delivery suite and it was easier to come up with some BS rather than try and cater to my birth preferences. I’ll list the examples below to illustrate my point.

  1. asked to use birth pool- told it was broken and had been for weeks, but another woman had given birth in the pool earlier in the day shift- so not true and a lie to make life easier
  2. can’t have delayed cord clamping baby and skin to skin has to be weighed… baby had apgars of 9 so that was bollox
  3. most recently on the MLU when I asked to see the infant feeding team as breastfeeding was painful, the team are based on the same corridor, i was told no, as they only see patients who have faltering growth. Luckily I had the number saved and text them to come, midwife got really snitty and they affirmed that any one can see them and the referral criteria the midwife said was not true.

Coercive language is routinely used in maternity care, you can see it on this thread with people commenting saying ‘I didn’t think they’d let you go over 42 weeks’- like there is 0 choice to be had in the matter. I was coerced Into an induction with an sga baby based on out of date guidelines and was told ‘we won’t let you get to 40 weeks’. Coercion is used to get women to follow clinical guidelines it’s as simple as that

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 13/12/2021 21:50

@Glassofshloer

Why would doctors/midwives/healthcare professionals bother to actively lie/coerce you? It’s quite paranoid if you ask me. General neglect or a poor bedside manner I can understand, but some of these posts almost suggest there is a sinister plot afoot Confused
It's not a sinister plot, it's a matter of priorities. Obstetrics is a highly litigious area of medicine and ultimately they want as many babies born safely as possible. Policies and procedures are based on mitigating the risks for those that have the worst outcomes. So if the 1/1000 tragic event can be avoided by treating the whole 1000 as if they are potentially that 1 they successfully avoid it. The unintended outcomes are seen as tolerable, to justify the benefit. The doctors want the best outcomes for as many women as possible, even if that means there is (for want of a better phrase) collateral damage. The problem with treating whole populations like this is that it doesn't take into consideration individual circumstances.
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 13/12/2021 21:49

@Teaandcakeordeath83

I agree with you re language used by medical staff but I hve to say I think it has evolved that way from a standpoint of just wanting to deliver live babies. My experience from my first, totally unnecessary induction was the same. They see a risk, however minimal, and they want to remove it. Yes it makes for an unpleasant experience. But does it save babies and mothers? Yes. I suspect they have also had to adjust their language and mannerisms to deal with all the women who put themselves and their babies in danger. Must be tiresome. Like the subject of this thread - 44 weeks and footling and avoiding monitoring. Imagine being the doctors and midwives dealing with this shitshow. I get what you’re saying But birth is just so bloody risky. I don’t even really feel comfortable advocating for homebirth although mine was amazing; i do not know everyone's circumstances and would not want to be responsible for that!

Glassofshloer · 13/12/2021 21:18

The right course of action is what a mentally competent and fully informed woman thinks is the right course of action. Period.

I think this thread proves otherwise.

CrotchetyQuaver · 13/12/2021 21:17

That's great news they are both out the other side @scottishlass43 many thanks for the update

snowdropsandcrocuses · 13/12/2021 21:06

@Awwlookatmybabyspider

I didn't think the Hospital let you go that far over your due date. Confused
The hospital have no say whatsoever when it comes to that. They do not like it and will encourage you to be induced or have c-section but that is all they can do. I guess they could intervene if your own life was at imminent risk but a foetus, even fully developed does not have any 'rights' until it takes its first breath.

I normally would be pretty supportive of someone delaying medical intervention and I went to 42 weeks when I was expecting. However, it was my second pregnancy, I was planning on having a hospital birth and I went to the hospital daily for scans to keep an eye on the baby. When a baby is breech it is my understanding that sometimes labour will not come at all. I would be incredibly worried about your friend if she is refusing all checks and balances too. There is no harm to at least have the baby's heart rate checked and a scan to check for amniotic fluid. It's a very risky decision (which I suspect is not based on accurate knowledge/research) to blindly carry on without at least checks and supports. There are very good reasons that so many women used to die in childbirth and your friend is risking both her own life and that of her unborn child.

BiscuitLover3679 · 13/12/2021 20:38

I understand wanting to wait, even potentially as long as she is but no way would I be refusing constant scans and monitoring!

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 13/12/2021 20:36

@Glassofshloer

Why would doctors/midwives/healthcare professionals bother to actively lie/coerce you? It’s quite paranoid if you ask me. General neglect or a poor bedside manner I can understand, but some of these posts almost suggest there is a sinister plot afoot Confused
I don't think there's a plot at all. I think there's a patriarchal mentality to maternity care that's basically "do as you're told little woman" and that's it. You only have to read any of the maternity care failings reports to see that echoed time and time again. I was told ridiculous things by consultants who wanted me to just agree to their lies (because that's what they were) and book a third section. "You can't physically give birth". "You will die in labour or kill your baby". "The risk of you dying in a home birth is 50%". Actual plucked out of their arse bs which when challenged was ignored and more lies brought up. If you were in a relationship and someone was treating you that way you'd be right to think it was coercive and abusive. I've watched midwives say to other women in the waiting room after growth scans that "the doctor won't let you go past 39 weeks with this scan measurement". Won't let you. Language matters. Facts matter for women to make informed choices- not just have over egged figures, meaningless risk statistics and random bs thrown at them to make them comply with whatever a HCP thinks is the correct course of action. The right course of action is what a mentally competent and fully informed woman thinks is the right course of action. Period.
Teaandcakeordeath83 · 13/12/2021 20:36

@Glassofshloer

Why would doctors/midwives/healthcare professionals bother to actively lie/coerce you? It’s quite paranoid if you ask me. General neglect or a poor bedside manner I can understand, but some of these posts almost suggest there is a sinister plot afoot Confused
I don't think there's a plot at all. I think there's a patriarchal mentality to maternity care that's basically "do as you're told little woman" and that's it. You only have to read any of the maternity care failings reports to see that echoed time and time again. I was told ridiculous things by consultants who wanted me to just agree to their lies (because that's what they were) and book a third section. "You can't physically give birth". "You will die in labour or kill your baby". "The risk of you dying in a home birth is 50%". Actual plucked out of their arse bs which when challenged was ignored and more lies brought up. If you were in a relationship and someone was treating you that way you'd be right to think it was coercive and abusive. I've watched midwives say to other women in the waiting room after growth scans that "the doctor won't let you go past 39 weeks with this scan measurement". Won't let you. Language matters. Facts matter for women to make informed choices- not just have over egged figures, meaningless risk statistics and random bs thrown at them to make them comply with whatever a HCP thinks is the correct course of action. The right course of action is what a mentally competent and fully informed woman thinks is the right course of action. Period.
Teaandcakeordeath83 · 13/12/2021 20:36

@Glassofshloer

Why would doctors/midwives/healthcare professionals bother to actively lie/coerce you? It’s quite paranoid if you ask me. General neglect or a poor bedside manner I can understand, but some of these posts almost suggest there is a sinister plot afoot Confused
I don't think there's a plot at all. I think there's a patriarchal mentality to maternity care that's basically "do as you're told little woman" and that's it. You only have to read any of the maternity care failings reports to see that echoed time and time again. I was told ridiculous things by consultants who wanted me to just agree to their lies (because that's what they were) and book a third section. "You can't physically give birth". "You will die in labour or kill your baby". "The risk of you dying in a home birth is 50%". Actual plucked out of their arse bs which when challenged was ignored and more lies brought up. If you were in a relationship and someone was treating you that way you'd be right to think it was coercive and abusive. I've watched midwives say to other women in the waiting room after growth scans that "the doctor won't let you go past 39 weeks with this scan measurement". Won't let you. Language matters. Facts matter for women to make informed choices- not just have over egged figures, meaningless risk statistics and random bs thrown at them to make them comply with whatever a HCP thinks is the correct course of action. The right course of action is what a mentally competent and fully informed woman thinks is the right course of action. Period.
siestasiesta · 13/12/2021 20:34

I'm so glad they are both OK, it's a miracle and I hope she comes to realise the risk she has taken. It isn't worth it.

@Teaandcakeordeath83 I knew someone who went into labour whilst waiting for an ELCS and her scar ruptured, luckily she was already in hospital and it wasn't a problem. I was put off a VBAC due to that, and I had previously had an induction where I overcontracted from the first stage with first baby and I didn't want an EMCS due to scar rupture/fetal distress due to overcontraction with the third. I knew that I would end up with an induction as I'd had issues with fetal growth previously and they wouldn't have let me go past 40 weeks (and I wouldn't have wanted to). I wouldn't have picked a homebirth because my baby very nearly died, it leads you to make a different choice. I'm not dismissing birth trauma, I have been there and there are few things more scary than waking up after an EMCS and asking if your baby is alive, as you think they had probably died.

With women feeling lied to/coerced, I think the understaffing does not help as they don't have time to explain. They also work on probability, they pick the option which is statistically safest to keep the mother and baby alive and this doesn't always correlate with the mother's wishes. Postnatal care is even worse.

Mamette · 13/12/2021 20:09

Why would doctors/midwives/healthcare professionals bother to actively lie/coerce you?

I always think this too. Talk about making work for themselves.

Really glad to see your update OP.

Glassofshloer · 13/12/2021 19:43

Why would doctors/midwives/healthcare professionals bother to actively lie/coerce you? It’s quite paranoid if you ask me. General neglect or a poor bedside manner I can understand, but some of these posts almost suggest there is a sinister plot afoot Confused

Chocolatewheatos · 13/12/2021 19:30

@Namechangetimes100

I completely agree with you *@Teaandcakeordeath83* and I’ve had an induction and whilst I didn’t feel traumatised after, I was routinely lied to about the most innocuous things and made to feel like I was ridiculous for even asking, and it was things like basic decency I was denied and it was out of ease of life for the staff. Lied and told the birth pool was broke even though on the earlier shift they’d said someone else was using it, not allowed skin to skin because she needed to be weighed then and there, no delayed cord clamping because i had an induction, OB who did an internal didn’t ask for consent and was so rough he had me in tears and when I asked him to be more gentle i was told to grow up. I can’t think of another field of medicine where the patient is so routinely disrespected. I was terrified at the thought of another induction as id gone past my due date and induction has been brought up since 37 weeks. Luckily baby was born at 41 weeks.

Fact is birth is overly medicalised, midwives and consultants do use coercive language (generally midwives are better) and there is a vast difference between a midwife on a MLU/ home birth midwife and a delivery suite midwife. The care in post natal wards is often atrocious and leaves women traumatised and women are so often not given the opportunity of informed consent options are routinely presented as if they have no choice and if they voice concern or question the decisions they are immediately shut down.

However in the case of this friend they’re taking things to the extreme in the other sense, it’s a shame but its an extreme (free birth woo) reaction I bet to the birth industry

Absolutely agree with this. I had a consultant tell me that my (non existent) diabetes would make labour dangerous. When I said I didn't have gestational diabetes she said "well we don't know that." OK then.

I felt so under attack that it was genuinely hard to stay level headed and make sensible decisions because it felt like I had to fight back and that they weren't to be trusted. I even got criticism for having researched the things they were telling me wrongly. Always with an eye roll and reference to "Dr Google" yeah i have a degree in biology pal, I'm not a child and I won't be doing as I'm told. I found that actually just agreeing to what the consultant wanted then going in and telling the midwife what we were doing instead worked well. "Yeah I'm here for an induction but I'm actually only having a sweep."

I can see how when you really believe, like I did, that birth is over medicalised and our bodies are meant to do this and when you're being lied and coerced by those medical practitioners you go into the total opposite, "stay away from me I don't trust you" mindset.

I'm glad mum and baby are both safe.

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 13/12/2021 19:24

Just one of many journal articles about how placentas don't tend to have an off switch. You can't be wary of a growing and massive baby post dates and at the same time be worried about a placenta that's calcified and not working properly... if it's not working then the baby doesn't continue to get bigger.

fn.bmj.com/content/77/3/F171

I'll reiterate the OPs friends choices would not have been mine (certainly not with a footling breech and no monitoring...) but there isn't an element of madness/ selfishness/ neglect or any of the other insults thrown around by wanting to let your body go into labour by itself. There is a lot of coercive language used around maternal healthcare and understandably an element of an increased risk being unacceptable to some people, equally there are others who will take a different view of risk and plan their healthcare accordingly.

FlamingoDust · 13/12/2021 19:15

Thank you for the update and I am so glad there was a good outcome. I really hope she doesn't transfer her ideas to others and that if she has another child someone gets some sense into her

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 13/12/2021 19:09

This article references the mbrace studies on birth outcomes and dates. www.aims.org.uk/journal/item/induction-at-term

Straighttalking1 · 13/12/2021 19:01

My daughter is a midwife. And just to say there are increasing numbers of women wanting births that are not advised. It's not that we want to support these women, but morally we would rather be close than to hear a mum or baby die.

nocoolnamesleft · 13/12/2021 18:01

Oh, that's a relief. Glad this has had a positive outcome. Thanks in part to obstetrics!

Shoobydooer · 13/12/2021 17:48

So relieved. Was upset thinking about this all day.

Camii · 13/12/2021 17:24

I'm glad it turned out OK. But the risk she took was horrible -just my opinion. But I wouldn't want to risk any harm to the baby or myself to be honest.

notquiteruralbliss · 13/12/2021 15:52

I think risks depend on safeguards in place. One of mine was born naturally at 44 weeks + 3. Midwives were experienced independent midwives. Backup was with a very good surgeon. I chose not to have an induction but did opt for daily monitoring after 43 weeks and would have elected to have a c-section if the placenta had started to fail.

Saoirse82 · 13/12/2021 15:45

Just saw the update, it's wonderful that the baby is ok.

Saoirse82 · 13/12/2021 15:43

@RedRobyn2021

OP you are doing the right thing to keep your opinions to yourself, she doesn't need negativity from you

She is not risking her baby, what utter bs some of these comments are ridiculous. How have we survived as a human race??? Do you people realise due dates are meaningless, they are just guessing

So why do you think trusts recommend inducing women who go beyond 42 weeks, there's huge risks due to the calcification of the placenta so it could fail leaving the baby without oxygen. Due dates are meaningless by the sense that a full term pregnancy is considered between 37 and 42 weeks, not 44. And a vaginal footlong birth (the riskiest breech position) is massively risky on its own, never mind at home with just one midwife when you're 44 weeks (or potentially later) pregnant. You'd have to be an idiot not to see that there's a good chance the baby will die. There have been midwives on this thread pretty horrified at the risks this woman is prepared to take with her baby. The majority of midwives have never even attended a vaginal breech nowadays. And yes, the human race has survived but women and their babies frequently died in childbirth up until fairly recent times and for these exact reasons. 🙄
Fetchthevet · 13/12/2021 14:38

Very glad they are both OK.

Swipe left for the next trending thread