Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to tell 44 weeks and breech friend she's risking her baby?

738 replies

scottishlass43 · 12/12/2021 11:16

My friend is 44 weeks pregnant with a footling breech. She's determined to have a natural birth at home with another friend of ours who's a midwife. She's been declining all intervention till now and has no cut off point - she wants to let the baby come naturally and doesn't want scans or any monitoring. She refuses to consider a c-section.

She's older (late thirties) and has been waiting for several years for this baby. I have no idea why she'd risk it now.

AIBU wanting to tell her what I think? Am I (and other worried friends) overreacting? Does anyone know of anyone who's done this, and how it went?

OP posts:
Fridafever · 15/12/2021 17:37

At six months I wouldn’t bother introducing formula I don’t think. They’re eating then anyway

DrSbaitso · 15/12/2021 17:18

@Glassofshloer

I saw a post on here from a poster who refused to give up breastfeeding and her 6 MONTH old baby weighed 9lbs!!!!!!!! Medical staff were begging her to give formula but she was adamant & posters on here egged her on!!!!!!!!
She wouldn't even consider mixed feeding? At six months baby will be starting on solids anyway.
Glassofshloer · 15/12/2021 16:33

I saw a post on here from a poster who refused to give up breastfeeding and her 6 MONTH old baby weighed 9lbs!!!!!!!! Medical staff were begging her to give formula but she was adamant & posters on here egged her on!!!!!!!!

siestasiesta · 15/12/2021 11:22

Sometimes milk will not come. Last month a woman in the ward almost let her newborn baby starve to death by insisting, and insisting, and insisting, that she "had enough milk" (she didn't) and that "she only wanted to feed her baby naturally" (baby would have, very naturally, died... he lost 20% of his birthweight in the first week; he was severely hypoglycemic by the time this woman saw sense).

Some breastfeeding advisors will tell women that they will always have enough milk, even if they don't as the baby is failing to thrive and losing too much weight. I had the same advice, from an advisor who hadn't actually seen the baby and had no medical training. It's important to support breastfeeding, it's also important to know when outside intervention is necessary for the health of the baby and some need a little help in the first few days or weeks.

Regarding always seeing the natural way as the best, that is the narrative pushed by hypnobirthing and natural birth advocates. You are told that your body knows best. They forget that nature doesn't need every mother and baby to survive childbirth, just most.

The best approach would be a blend of the two where you could use hypnobirthing in a safe environment (hospital, next to a delivery suite, theatre and NICU just in case it was needed) for straightforward labours with no complications, and use the interventations when they are required - i.e. having an elective section for a footling breech birth or having an induction if there is a higher risk of stillbirth due to gestation over 42 weeks.

I don't really understand it going for a "natural" birth at all costs. I did hypnobirthing and ended up with a c-section, I'm happy to go with the more natural way where it is safe but not as the expense of risking the baby or myself. I'd much rather have a c-section if there was a risk to the baby than push for a natural birth and risk losing them.

Rocket1982 · 15/12/2021 08:58

@BiscuitLover3679 both France and the UK induce 20% of labours. And in France 80% women have an epidural/spinal (30 in UK), 44% are injected with oxytocin to speed up labour (don't think this happens much in the UK outside of induction), and only 0.3% of births are over 42 weeks (so they must induce women before that).

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 15/12/2021 07:00

I wonder if it's because people try to explore that 'grey' but are met with such rigidity from health services that they pull even further away from the recommendations in an attempt to get an agreement in the middle ground. If their medical team don't budge, they move further apart.
Like a tug of war, except the medics don't move at all and the patient ends up moving back along the rope until there isn't any left and they let go (where they disengage completely, in obstetrics this would be where they opt for freebirthing).

aurynne · 15/12/2021 00:19

You know, it is not a black and white decision between being told what to do by a health professional who tells you if you don't do X, your baby will die; and refusing 100% of intervention even when things are so far from normal that you would be deluded to ignore them. there are a huge range of greys in between, and within those shades of grey there lie a reasonable number of options.

It is natural to wait till you're hungry before you eat anything. But if suddenly you found yourself not being hungry for 7 days in a row... wouldn't that be giving you a clue that something is wrong with your body? Wouldn't you be consulting with someone who knows more than you about how the digestive system works to find out why you are not feeling hungry? Or would you let yourself starve to death because "I know my body, and I want to feel hungry the natural way".

Getting sick is natural. Cancer is natural. Placentas malfunctioning is natural. Now we have options to NOT let nature making us very sick or killing us if we can prevent it. It is perfectly reasonable to refuse treatment for any reason you want. What is not only NOT reasonable, but actually bonkers, is expecting that each and every one of our bodies are always going to work perfectly and never malfunction. Our bodies are not perfect. We get sick. Despite how healthy we eat, and how much we take care of ourselves, some of us will still develop hypothyroidism, allergies, cancer, asthma. Despite having the perfect body and the perfect nutrition during pregnancy, some women will still develop gestational diabetes, and pre-eclampsia, and some of our placentas will fail. Sometimes milk will not come. Last month a woman in the ward almost let her newborn baby starve to death by insisting, and insisting, and insisting, that she "had enough milk" (she didn't) and that "she only wanted to feed her baby naturally" (baby would have, very naturally, died... he lost 20% of his birthweight in the first week; he was severely hypoglycemic by the time this woman saw sense).

What is with this strange denial from some people that their bodies cannot, under any possibility, do things wrong ever, and that "everything should happen the natural way". If your toddler chokes with a piece of food, will they not help her get it out? Or will they let her die, because it happened "naturally"?

Please someone explain this to me.

nocoolnamesleft · 14/12/2021 18:56

@vivariumvivariumsvivaria

I have gone down a google warren of post maturity syndrome.

Seems these babies can have issues with maintaining their blood sugar and temperature, have dry cracked skin and can lose body fat before birth - presumably they use that if the placenta is failing. I hadn't realised the over due babies could have issues after birth. Dry cracked skin alone sounds painful.

So, it's possible your friend's baby is having a hard start to life and needs some support.

I hope they are ok.

I worry more that because the placenta is failing not only is the stillbirth rate rising, but so is the likelihood of fetal distress, and the baby being born in poor condition, needing resuscitation. If they do become distressed, a post term baby is much more likely to pass meconium. Into the liquor. That they're breathing in. Meconium aspiration syndrome can be very nasty, and cause pneumothoraxes, lung inflammation, turn off the surfactant that normally keeps the alveoli (air sacs) open... This can need ventilation, chest drains, transfer to a bigger hospital away from mum...all sorts of deep unpleasantness. Best avoided if possible.
Frazzledmummy123 · 14/12/2021 17:47

I am glad to see the most recent update and things are ok.
OP, is the baby ok? Did he/she weigh in heavy?

Salome61 · 14/12/2021 17:43

I had my son when I was 37, and it was touch and go as he was facing downwards but upwards, I needed forceps in the end and had to have a transfusion. I do hope your friend decides to be induced in hospital.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 14/12/2021 17:31

@Namechangetimes100

Absolutely shocking. Wow. And people wonder why breastfeeding rates are so low! I was made to shower alone with my numb leg (due to failed epidural) and given a baby cloth to dry with. Nothing in comparison to what you went through but I was lucky enough to leave hospital 5 hours after birth.

Southtrainer · 14/12/2021 15:21

Gosh I hope your friend and her baby are ok OP. I would definitely encourage my friend to seek medical advice at this stage. Is her GP aware of this? X

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 14/12/2021 13:40

I have gone down a google warren of post maturity syndrome.

Seems these babies can have issues with maintaining their blood sugar and temperature, have dry cracked skin and can lose body fat before birth - presumably they use that if the placenta is failing. I hadn't realised the over due babies could have issues after birth. Dry cracked skin alone sounds painful.

So, it's possible your friend's baby is having a hard start to life and needs some support.

I hope they are ok.

BiscuitLover3679 · 14/12/2021 13:38

[quote RedRobyn2021]@Theregoesmyhomebirth you explained this really well

There feels like there is an attitude that as long as mum and baby are alive when they leave the hospital that's all that matters

Of course this matters, but it's not all that matters in my opinion

If a woman leaves traumatised because of a cascade intervention then this matters

I had heard that the recent statistics are now saying you are now more likely to be induced or have a c section than give birth "naturally" and this isn't even including all the sweeps. Yet still birth rates are not changing.

Men in suits who known nothing about pregnancy or women are making these decisions because of liability, because of money.

It is possible for all women to be cared for on an individual basis so why isn't that happening? Women should be offered these life saving interventions because they are needed, not as a matter of routine and liability. [/quote]
Completely agree. And the NHS is great in many ways but it no way perfect. France has a very good health system, for example, and they don't have the horrible processes the UK does. They also don't induce as quickly or start offering sweeps (which have hardly any medical benefit!) or other forms of induction for barely being over the due date.

NandorTheRelentless · 14/12/2021 13:32

@RedRobyn2021

The comments in this thread make me sick to my stomach.

If I was her and you spouted some of this to me, I would never ever forgive you.

Please don't say anything. It's not your place, she has looked at the risks and chosen to birth her baby the way she wants.

Honestly, I don't know if I'm even going to stay on this site after reading through these comments, I'm absolutely disgusted. Some women have actually talked about forcing her to have her baby against her will.

My best friends brother was born naturally footling breach. It's people like the women in this thread which make me frightened to have anymore children, not birth itself.

Please don't say anything. It's not your place, she has looked at the risks and chosen to birth her baby the way she wants

Even if she is being a fucking idiot? And possibly killing her child???

RobinPenguins · 14/12/2021 13:26

[quote RedRobyn2021]@Theregoesmyhomebirth you explained this really well

There feels like there is an attitude that as long as mum and baby are alive when they leave the hospital that's all that matters

Of course this matters, but it's not all that matters in my opinion

If a woman leaves traumatised because of a cascade intervention then this matters

I had heard that the recent statistics are now saying you are now more likely to be induced or have a c section than give birth "naturally" and this isn't even including all the sweeps. Yet still birth rates are not changing.

Men in suits who known nothing about pregnancy or women are making these decisions because of liability, because of money.

It is possible for all women to be cared for on an individual basis so why isn't that happening? Women should be offered these life saving interventions because they are needed, not as a matter of routine and liability. [/quote]
Induced births and c sections are more expensive than “natural” labours. This is not about money. Unless it’s limiting liability to have to pay out settlements to parents of babies who have been stillborn or suffered catastrophic birth injuries because they should have been induced or delivered via c section earlier? Which I’m on board with, tbh.

And still birth rates are, thankfully, reducing.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 14/12/2021 12:05

So relieved to hear baby safely delivered by C-section!

siestasiesta · 14/12/2021 10:24

@Namechangetimes100 I'm very risk averse because my baby nearly died, she was under the 0.4th centile.

@aurynne Thank you.

For me, preventing stillbirth has to be the most important thing. I know how bad birth trauma is, I was very traumatised by the birth and it took a long time to get over it. I still panic if I hear the crash alarms going off in hospital, it takes me back.

user14943608381 · 14/12/2021 10:21

@RedRobyn2021 excellently put! The experience of each women does matter, how they are treated in birth does matter. Yes mum and baby being alive and well is the most important thing but it’s not the only important thing.

@Justheretoaskaquestion91 honestly that’s like 5% of it, I’d consider my birth a serene and calm experience that I’d gladly repeat compared to my horrific stay on the maternity ward, that was horrendous. Laughed in my face when I said I had anxiety, baby was 2nd centile so needed blood sugar checks before and after feeds they were forgotten, feeding help was actively refused and I was told breastfeeding is meant to hurt and what do I expect she has small mouth, begged for help and then was thrown a colostrum collector syringe from the door of my room (no cup to collect it in) and told to figure it out. Second birth I refused to stay in.

Inthesameboatatmo · 14/12/2021 09:30

Absolutely the most stupid and irresponsible thing I've read in ages.
The friend does not deserve to be a parent at all if she's this cavalier in her attitude towards the health of her unborn baby. It will be a miracle if they both come out of this alive to be honest .

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 14/12/2021 09:28

@RedRobyn2021

I think people (myself included) are lied to about the need for intervention. With DS1 he was “measuring 10lbs plus” at 39 weeks so he was induced (my father had been 13lbs and my brother 11lbs). If I had had any idea of the fucking horror show of induction and the fact that a large baby would be fine to deliver naturally I would have just declined! I was also told all the way along my cervix was “favourable”. They were “sure”
The sweep would work. They were “sure” the second time pessary would work. They promised to come back at 11pm to check on me and guess what? They didn’t! I was vomiting as they had “forgotten” (OOPS) the antiemetics drug alongside the pethedine and I was in active labour and alone like a wild fucking animal as no one as around. I can never forget the panic. Absolutely agree re the word trauma.

As it was, DS1 was 9lbs. Popped out easily. What was the fucking point.

@Namechangetimes100

Your after care makes me so fucking angry. Bastards

RedRobyn2021 · 14/12/2021 09:21

@Glassofshloer I used to think this as well. Not anymore though.

RedRobyn2021 · 14/12/2021 09:19

@Theregoesmyhomebirth you explained this really well

There feels like there is an attitude that as long as mum and baby are alive when they leave the hospital that's all that matters

Of course this matters, but it's not all that matters in my opinion

If a woman leaves traumatised because of a cascade intervention then this matters

I had heard that the recent statistics are now saying you are now more likely to be induced or have a c section than give birth "naturally" and this isn't even including all the sweeps. Yet still birth rates are not changing.

Men in suits who known nothing about pregnancy or women are making these decisions because of liability, because of money.

It is possible for all women to be cared for on an individual basis so why isn't that happening? Women should be offered these life saving interventions because they are needed, not as a matter of routine and liability.

DropYourSword · 14/12/2021 08:47

@Glassofshloer
@DropYourSword I’m not misunderstanding

Yeah, you are

Glassofshloer · 14/12/2021 08:38

@DropYourSword I’m not misunderstanding.

An anti vaxxer’s risk of dying from covid is not dissimilar to the risk you state above. Yet the general consensus on here is that you are ridiculous not to have the vaccine. Nobody says ‘oh it depends on your perception of risk’, they just tell them they’re an idiot to take the chance.

However in maternity care, it seems perfectly acceptable for women to turn down medical advice based on the opinion of strangers on Internet forums, and it’s all ‘your body your choice’.

I’m just saying the difference in attitude is stark & illogical.

Swipe left for the next trending thread