Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to tell 44 weeks and breech friend she's risking her baby?

738 replies

scottishlass43 · 12/12/2021 11:16

My friend is 44 weeks pregnant with a footling breech. She's determined to have a natural birth at home with another friend of ours who's a midwife. She's been declining all intervention till now and has no cut off point - she wants to let the baby come naturally and doesn't want scans or any monitoring. She refuses to consider a c-section.

She's older (late thirties) and has been waiting for several years for this baby. I have no idea why she'd risk it now.

AIBU wanting to tell her what I think? Am I (and other worried friends) overreacting? Does anyone know of anyone who's done this, and how it went?

OP posts:
honeylulu · 12/12/2021 14:21

I posted upthread but wanted to comment on the queries about how she knows its a footling breech if she hasn't had a scan since 20 weeks. She may have had another scan. For various reasons I had 6 scans during my last pregnancy, one very late, I think only 6 days before I gave birth.
Also at my final Midwife check she was able to tell by palpation that baby had her arm up above her head so the part immediately against the cervix was a hand rather than head. I was then sent for a growth scan (small for dates) and the sonographer confirmed the position of arm/hand. Few days later she was indeed born arm first. Luckily because she was so small her shoulders did not get stuck. So midwives can tell quite a lot by palpation.

bondbaby · 12/12/2021 14:21

I dealt with a case which sounds very similar to this at work. Sadly, it didn't end well. I don't understand surely mum is aware of the massive risks to them both in this situation?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 12/12/2021 14:20

My suggestion to contact SS wasnt about forcing the delivery.

It was because she is clearly demonstrating a lack of consideration for her own childs wellbeing. Someone who can be so cavalier with their childs life has real potential to follow in the same vein during their life too.

DrSbaitso · 12/12/2021 14:20

@endofthelinefinally

Back in the 80s when I was working as a hospital midwife we had a lady on the ward for daily CTG monitoring because she was 40weeks plus 10 days and had refused induction. There were signs that the fetus was getting tired and the placenta was starting to fail. Every single person on the ward spoke to her and her husband. From the Professor of obstetrics, the Senior registrar, the midwives, GP trainees. Everyone begged her to agree to induction. She refused. Every conversation was clearly documented in her notes. She went home because she refused any further monitoring. Eventually at 33 weeks the fetus died in utero. It was absolutely awful and everyone was devastated. Legally nobody could do anything because the fetus has no rights. The worst thing was that the couple tried to take legal action against the hospital. It didn't go anywhere because the records were so clear and witnessed. There is no way I would be able to go along with risking the life of my friend, her baby and my registration. But maybe the friend feels she can't just walk away.
That's horrifying.

What was the basis of the legal complaint? What were they claiming the hospital should have done?

rainydogday · 12/12/2021 14:18

@shouldistop

Midwives also can't refuse care. We are legally obliged to attend home births even if they're against medical advice, regardless of how traumatic the situation may end up for us as well.

@littlemissalwaystired

I understand why it's got to be that way but can I just say that it's really awful that midwives are expected just to walk into what they know could be an awful situation, deliver a dead baby or one that dies in their arms when the mother has been given advice and chosen to ignore it. How would you not be absolutely furious.

And this is exactly a small Part of why lots of midwives leave or have ptsd.
ForbiddentoForbid · 12/12/2021 14:17

@endofthelinefinally

Back in the 80s when I was working as a hospital midwife we had a lady on the ward for daily CTG monitoring because she was 40weeks plus 10 days and had refused induction. There were signs that the fetus was getting tired and the placenta was starting to fail. Every single person on the ward spoke to her and her husband. From the Professor of obstetrics, the Senior registrar, the midwives, GP trainees. Everyone begged her to agree to induction. She refused. Every conversation was clearly documented in her notes. She went home because she refused any further monitoring. Eventually at 33 weeks the fetus died in utero. It was absolutely awful and everyone was devastated. Legally nobody could do anything because the fetus has no rights. The worst thing was that the couple tried to take legal action against the hospital. It didn't go anywhere because the records were so clear and witnessed. There is no way I would be able to go along with risking the life of my friend, her baby and my registration. But maybe the friend feels she can't just walk away.
That's awful.

On what basis was the legal action? What did they suggest the hospital should have done?

VestaTilley · 12/12/2021 14:16

Definitely tell her.

I’d go further than that, I’d actually inform the local NHS trust/maternity unit.

endofthelinefinally · 12/12/2021 14:15

Unless the law has changed recently, even social services cannot order an invasive medical or surgical procedure to be done without consent. It is assault.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 12/12/2021 14:13

Tbh I'd ring social services.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 12/12/2021 14:12

@DropYourSword

I think people need to stop recommended contacting social services! This woman is absolutely within her rights to make this decision. SS can’t do anything!
No she isn't! Not once she reaches the threshold of putting the child at risk! Ffs
endofthelinefinally · 12/12/2021 14:11

Typo in my earlier post. Should have read 43 weeks, not 33.

Branleuse · 12/12/2021 14:11

I remember someone in some hippy parenting group i was in decided to homebirth a footling breech. Quite a few years ago. They enlisted some Mary Cronk type midwife who was quite confident in breech births, which the vast majority of midwives now are absolutely not. Thankfully i think it went ok in the end, but i remember feeling quite upset about the risk she was taking. I read a bit about it. Risk of accidental decapitation just because woman may push when told not too etc. I dont know how anyone can consider risking their child like that.

LaBellina · 12/12/2021 14:10

44 weeks? That’s a very scary situation. You can tell her but I doubt she will listen if she refuses any interventions at this point. My God.

reesewithoutaspoon · 12/12/2021 14:08

Honestly please try everything to get her to at least get monitored. My sister went to 44 weeks in 1988 ( I think it was a phase were they were allowing people to go naturally) but she was being monitored daily in the last week. and her placenta was going white, was gritty and barely functional when my nephew was born, also his skin was so dry because all the vernix had gone, that it cracked and bled for weeks.

timeisnotaline · 12/12/2021 14:08

endoftheline that’s desperately sad, it was a baby at that point, and really it was just left to die- by its mother of all people.
This is terrifying. Is the midwife not registered at a community centre or hospital and you can contact them there and ask isn’t there anything that can be done?

Winnietherose · 12/12/2021 14:06

I think this should be referred to social care (I work on a duty Child protection team) as this needs a multi agency intervention for both her and the babies sake, I would be worried about the views of the midwife friend who is not giving the right advice. I would also be worried about any further views on caring for the baby, and also how her mental health might cope if (when) something goes wrong.

Mermaidwaves · 12/12/2021 14:05

If this woman is happy to take such awful risks with her unborn child for her own selfish reasons then its worrying how she would be as a mother with a live baby, being blunt if she has a live baby Angry

This poor defenceless baby with no legal right to life, completely at the whim of its mother, it makes me want to weep to be honest Sad

CoastalWave · 12/12/2021 14:03

Sod the friendship. She needs telling straight.

What a ridiculously selfish woman. Doesn't bode well for being a great mother does it (putting her own selfish 'natural' desires' above getting out a healthy baby)

THE BABY WILL PROBABLY DIE/ Just god damn tell her. And I would be furious with her.

Maray1967 · 12/12/2021 13:59

I went 14 days over with DS2. Placenta was gritty and he had lost weight over the last 2 or 3 weeks. If I’d had another I would not have gone that far over.
Who told her that the placenta can’t degrade? That is nonsense.
I would risk the friendship and try to get intervention. This sounds very dangerous for both mother and baby.

OhWhyNot · 12/12/2021 13:59

I was 42 weeks and I finally had emergency c section
I desperately wanted to be induced earlier (as my midwife had advised the consultant)
Hearing you baby’s heartbeat drop and professionals panic stays with you it’s an awful experience

I think honesty it best with your friend she is putting her baby at risk

CityCommuter · 12/12/2021 13:57

@scottishlass43 is that length of gestation even possible? Surely the amniotic fluid would have dried up considerably by now? I was only 1 week over with DC1 and DC was extremely crinkled when born - obstetrician said it was because the amniotic fluid starts to decrease naturally at just before 40 weeks gestation...

Piglet89 · 12/12/2021 13:57

My advice to you OP is that you must put the woman and baby's lives ahead of your friendship. Be as clear talking as you can, and yes say you are risking your baby's life.

PLEASE, please do this. How would you feel @scottishlass43 if something awful does happen and you didn’t speak up?

MrsJamin · 12/12/2021 13:55

@endofthelinefinally

Back in the 80s when I was working as a hospital midwife we had a lady on the ward for daily CTG monitoring because she was 40weeks plus 10 days and had refused induction. There were signs that the fetus was getting tired and the placenta was starting to fail. Every single person on the ward spoke to her and her husband. From the Professor of obstetrics, the Senior registrar, the midwives, GP trainees. Everyone begged her to agree to induction. She refused. Every conversation was clearly documented in her notes. She went home because she refused any further monitoring. Eventually at 33 weeks the fetus died in utero. It was absolutely awful and everyone was devastated. Legally nobody could do anything because the fetus has no rights. The worst thing was that the couple tried to take legal action against the hospital. It didn't go anywhere because the records were so clear and witnessed. There is no way I would be able to go along with risking the life of my friend, her baby and my registration. But maybe the friend feels she can't just walk away.
Do you mean 44 weeks, not 33?

Reading this thread agog. DS1 was breech, nearly 14 years ago. Even then I was told that midwives don't have the experience necessary to be confident to support a vaginal breech birth, and I opted for a planned CS. I ended up going into labour before that and I was petrified that I wouldn't get to surgery in time. I was labouring very quickly.

My advice to you OP is that you must put the woman and baby's lives ahead of your friendship. Be as clear talking as you can, and yes say you are risking your baby's life. Nature can be very cruel and is not always a good rule of thumb to always take the natural option. Death is natural, unfortunately.

scrivette · 12/12/2021 13:54

Absolutely crazy. I had a footling breech and I was initially disappointed when I was told I had to have a C Section within the next few days but when they explained the risks (head getting stuck as cervix may not dilate fully) I completely understood.

I went into natural labour the next day and ended up with an emergency section and as I give birth very very fast the midwife looking after me was very concerned we wouldn't make theater in time. (We did).

Chasingaftermidnight · 12/12/2021 13:54

Assuming she’s receiving NHS antenatal care she’ll have been warned of the risks in no uncertain terms won’t she? I can’t see why she’ll listen to you if she won’t listen to her midwives and consultant.

Although the person I’m really amazed at in this scenario is your midwife friend. Is she an NHS midwife? Surely she isn’t happy to attend a 44 week footling breech homebirth on her own?