Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable about meeting SILs new partner on Xmas day

158 replies

Day2night · 12/12/2021 07:52

My SIL wants to bring her new partner to meet everyone on Christmas morning at my MILs house. He left his wife and young kids in the summer, and they’ve been together for two months. I’m not sure how to feel about it. Myself and husband and my two sons aged 6 and 12 always go to MILs to open their presents, but having this new man there will make me slightly uncomfortable. My SIL 40, wants kids and marriage, he is already saying he wants this all again too which rings huge alarm bells for me…but she’s so loved up I don’t want to shatter her happiness. He won’t be there in the afternoon, so I’m debating leaving our visit until then this year. Am not sure if I’m being too sensitive about it though, and should just go and put up with him being there.

OP posts:
Fomofo · 12/12/2021 12:34

It's not about new or random folk, it's about not wanting to hang out with a man who's left one young family to hook up with someone new so soon

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 12/12/2021 11:57

I have always had random folk at Christmas and I don’t get why it’s such a big deal.

I wonder if this depends on your experience of Christmas. If, like some of the people on the 'worst behaviour' thread, Christmas is an opportunity for all of your dysfunctional family to come together and act out their own various dramas and resentments then there may be a tendency not to want to involve random people in the mix because many people don't spontaneously behave better.

For people who had less traumatising Christmas events in their history, perhaps it feels very different.

AnFiaRuaNua · 12/12/2021 11:47

Id be super nice, let him lower his guard and then you can see what his real level of awareness his. If you go right in there and ask him what he learn from the marriage breakdown, he'll be defensive, especially if he's interrogated (on xmas day, with an audience).

If your sil thinks you like him, she'll be more receptive to you maybe pointing out that he believes his marriage broke down because his xw expected him to give up his free time to help......

Babyvenusplant · 12/12/2021 11:46

I'll add too, I don't find it weird they are talking about kids so soon given your sil's age. I assume if he wasn't keen on kids your sil wouldn't be interested in him so maybe that's why he is going with it

Babyvenusplant · 12/12/2021 11:42

@Day2night

It’s not that I don’t approve of the relationship, it’s just that I’m worried she’s going to get hurt again. I can’t imagine leaving my children and moving on so quickly…talking about remarrying and having more kids within months. I don’t know the exact circumstances fully though, so perhaps I’m wrong.
I think this is the point, you don't know the full circumstances. For all you know his wife may have been the reasons for the break up, just go along and be civil. Its a good opportunity to suss him out anyway 😉
RitaFires · 12/12/2021 11:40

I get disapproving of SIL's partner and choices and Christmas Day would not be my choice of day for first meeting but it's her mother's house and she is really keen on her new man. It's not for you to dictate what she can and cannot do.

I find it easier with people who get really invested in relationships really quickly to just smile and nod and wish them well. You genuinely want your SIL to be happy, anything negative you say could well cause issues between you that will outlast this relationship. Also it's not sounding likely but this could actually work out and you could be seeing this man for many years to come.

Theremoresefulday · 12/12/2021 11:37

@rubbishatballet

Why are so many people so anti meeting new people on Christmas Day? What are they worried about?

We've often had random extras at our extended family christmases - new partners, antipodean friends/house mates who aren't going home, someone's colleague with nowhere else to go etc etc. Surely it's exactly the time we should be welcoming of others (and I'm not even religious..), plus in my experience it only adds to the day and generally freshens up the dynamic!

Me too. I have always had random folk at Christmas and I don’t get why it’s such a big deal.
Numbertime · 12/12/2021 11:36

@rubbishatballet

Why are so many people so anti meeting new people on Christmas Day? What are they worried about?

We've often had random extras at our extended family christmases - new partners, antipodean friends/house mates who aren't going home, someone's colleague with nowhere else to go etc etc. Surely it's exactly the time we should be welcoming of others (and I'm not even religious..), plus in my experience it only adds to the day and generally freshens up the dynamic!

I absolutely agree, people seem to be very precious about it being for ‘one of us’ only.
rubbishatballet · 12/12/2021 11:32

Why are so many people so anti meeting new people on Christmas Day? What are they worried about?

We've often had random extras at our extended family christmases - new partners, antipodean friends/house mates who aren't going home, someone's colleague with nowhere else to go etc etc. Surely it's exactly the time we should be welcoming of others (and I'm not even religious..), plus in my experience it only adds to the day and generally freshens up the dynamic!

Faevern · 12/12/2021 11:31

I'm with you OP, why would she want to choose Christmas morning to introduce him and why does she need to introduce him so soon? Plenty time to introduce him if he's in it for the long haul, if he's not it will be the elephant in the room next Christmas morning.

She wants you all to play happy families on Christmas day with a stranger while his children spend their first Christmas without him? I doubt they've come to terms with it if it's only been since summer. I don't think I would feel too comfortable doing that and if that makes me judgemental so what? I would question his judgement too.

I want to spend my Christmas with people I know and love. I would go in the afternoon.

Bubblecap · 12/12/2021 11:31

I love meeting new people but on Christmaday is a bit odd.

My SIL relationships have caused huge amounts of drama over the years and her behaviour always escalated at Christmas. She also took things too fast always, asking about babies and marriage after about three weeks. She came across as deranged and any ok bloke was scared off immediately. This was a pattern from 30 to 45 . A siblings choice of partner and how they run their relationship shouldn’t be any of our business but when it becomes dominant at any get together especially over many years it’s really difficult to watch the slow car crash multiple times.

StormyTeacups · 12/12/2021 11:12

Yanbu. I'd go, as the rest of the family is important too,but I'd be very suss of someone who leaves a 3 and 1 year old, gets it on with someone else withing months, starts taking marriage and babies and then pitches up to their family Christmas. Wrong diddly wrong wrong

FilthyforFirth · 12/12/2021 11:04

I would hate this and totally see where you are coming from OP.

It is weird, certainly in my circles.

Gonnagetgoing · 12/12/2021 11:03

@Watapalava

I can’t believe more arent commenting on the xmas day meet!

Xmas day is not an appropriate day to have a stranger around

That’s just shitty as everyone will likely be more on edge etc

@Watapalava - 100% agreed. It does only take a seemingly innocent comment from the family involved re his situation to potentially upset new partner, add in copious amounts of alcohol and recipe for disaster.

I’d speak to SIL and say would love to meet her and new partner but as it’s a lot of pressure for all could we meet new partner eg one evening next week for casual drinks/posh hot chocolate instead? And then he can also come Xmas day if all goes well.

Gonnagetgoing · 12/12/2021 11:00

If it were me as the SIL bringing a new partner over on Christmas Day but also if I were OP I’d advise against doing this. Puts a lot of pressure on all involved including new partner.

I can be the judgiest woman on earth (have toned this down a lot over the years) but I think most people would be a bit Hmm about this man and circumstances despite all the MN cool girls accepting this without a backwards glance.

Watapalava · 12/12/2021 10:54

I can’t believe more arent commenting on the xmas day meet!

Xmas day is not an appropriate day to have a stranger around

That’s just shitty as everyone will likely be more on edge etc

JumparooSavedMyLife · 12/12/2021 10:50

You sound very judgemental and invested. If you don't want to meet him christmas day just go round later, I'm not sure why you feel in a position to comment on his circumstances having never actually met him? He might have really young children but who knows what happened in his marriage? It's none of your business and not your judgement to make. If your sil is 40 she isn't going to be meeting someone who hasn't got baggage (I hate referring to children and an ex wife as that but you get what I mean), I'd be more suss if she met a man in his 40s who had never had a serious relationship, by 40 most people will already have had a life and a family so whoever she gets with this will be a theme.

HunterGatherer · 12/12/2021 10:47

I get your concern but shes 40 and wants kids, they are under a bit of time pressure. I'd invite them both round for a drink prior to xmas then you won't be so anxious on the day. (Or if he turns out to be awful, you can change your plans).

Laufeythejust · 12/12/2021 10:41

We had to introduce a rule that someone can only come round for Christmas dinner if we have met them at least once before and they have been dating at least 3 months. I got so sick of cooking for some random bloke that changed the whole vibe of our Christmas to then never see him again.

WonderfulYou · 12/12/2021 10:36

YANBU 2 months is way too soon to be spending Christmas with someone.
It sounds like she’s rushing into things which usually ends up in disaster.

However, she probably thinks she’s in love and will be together forever so all you can do is be supportive.

SpindlesAdventWhirl · 12/12/2021 10:34

@Grayskelly

How can you be properly judge and be indignant if you haven't even met him? I look forward to meeting unsuitable partners for this reason, but I am a right bitch. If I could get away with it I'd bring all my sisters for additional judgement and disapproval. You can always bore your DH later with detailed analysis of all his behaviours. If you are going to be judgemental you need to learn how to enjoy it.
Ah yes, the sorority approach Grin

You could be wanting to know all about his children, what he's got them for Christmas, is the elder one all excited this year for the first time?

That'll be genuinely illuminating, whether he gives a shit or not.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 12/12/2021 10:25

@00100001

Taking the speed of the relationshipand tour feelings about that out.

It's fucking weird to meet someone/family for the first time on Christmas morning.

Especially such a family event with young children there when he is not with his own DC (perhaps he will see them in the afternoon?).
ChiefStockingStuffer · 12/12/2021 10:23

I get it, OP.

If you and your husband split up, I imagine that you would prefer it if you both agreed that new boy/girl friends were not being introduced willy nilly until you were positive they were going to be around for a long time. So not wanting to have a constant parade of strange men introduced to your children, after only a couple of months of dating (and cheating involved) with your SIL isn't an unreasonable desire.

Unfortunately, I suspect your MIL will be crushed if you don't go, so your husband probably should make the final call on this. Maybe a good compromise is to go for the afternoon, after the new guy has left (presumably to see his own children).

Day2night · 12/12/2021 10:19

His history wouldn’t bother me at all if he’d been split up from his wife for a while, if he wasn’t already talking about having more kids with someone he’s just met etc etc But anyway, I will go and be polite.

OP posts:
SimpsonsXmasBoogie · 12/12/2021 10:17

I think your feelings are natural, but it really isn't your place to be judgemental and your sister doesn't need your approval.

Keep these feelings to yourself and be friendly on the day. Fake smile.