Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if our children would be the ‘poor’ ones at private school

658 replies

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 19:56

DH and I have a good joint income of over £100,000 and I’m seriously considering private school for our children.

A worry for me is if they are surrounded by children from much wealthier backgrounds if they would feel ‘poor’. I’m just posting for thoughts from people who know a bit more about the independent system than me.

OP posts:
gunnersgold · 12/12/2021 06:54

Yes they will be , that is a stretch on that income ! There will be kids with enormous houses / second homes etc . How will you afford 2 x private school and all the extra activities money and your mortgage on £100k?

felulageller · 12/12/2021 06:50

We do it. I've just always prioritised my DC's education over everything else. We don't buy things other people take for granted.
Low mortgage by living in smaller house in non gentrified area
Only one car, no PCP.
No non mortgage debts at all.
Grandparents pay for uniforms
Trips are that year's birthday/Christmas present
Clothes from charity shops
Cheap phones, no big TV packages
No pets
No insurance other than house/ car
Very rare holiday abroad
Buy food in discount aisle/ semi vegi
House doesn't get done up even though kitchen/ bathroom 30 years old
Never go to hairdressers/ salons
Don't go out for meals often and if we do only in wetherspoons
Very rare nights out drinking/ socialising

I'm happy with the choices I've made and believe DC will benefit from it for decades to come.

Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday · 12/12/2021 06:33

I think you’ll find that they’ll have peers who have an income about the same as yours, and peers who come from incredibly wealthy backgrounds. Like fly first class multiple times a year, have homes in multiple countries with staff kind of wealth. And everything in between. They won’t ALL be filthy rich. Wealth will be noted. “Mum did you know Xxxx has a nanny for every kid??.” My kids have been at two international schools in 2 countries and it’s not really been an issue. In fact boasting about wealth is seen as kind of try hard. Granted I’ve not been in the UK.

tangyandsalty · 12/12/2021 06:22

@PoppityInThe

YABU x 1000

They will definitely not be the 'poor ones' at private school with that income.

Why would you say that? £100k a year isn't a high income amongst private school parents by a long way.
TheBlessedCheesemaker · 12/12/2021 06:17

My DC have between them attended a few of the ‘well known’ senior schools. In all honesty, at those schools then yes, you may be one of the poorest. But no-one gives a flying fuck. One of my DC was besties with a girl whose extended family lived in a small terrace where sleepovers meant a blow-up in the living room. And another DC was invited to go via private jet to a mate’s family chalet in the US. They didn’t differentiate, and I was way more impressed with the family sacrificing everything for education than the rich families that didn’t really care.
It’s is possibly no coincidence that none of my DC measure people by their wealth, and none of them value material things. And that’s fine by me.

supperlover · 12/12/2021 05:41

@ShanghaiDiva

My dd attends a private school in the south west and fees are circa 15k per year. Clearly there are some very wealthy families: holidays in Barbados last Xmas, ponies, holiday homes etc, but equally plenty of pupils from families where they holiday in Cornwall, live in a semi etc. Dd doesn’t seem bothered by the disparity in incomes. Dd and her friends spend time together going to pizza express for birthday parties, rummaging in charity shops, going to the cinema etc
That's interesting. My earlier post about the public school my husband taught in and where two of our children went, on reduced fees and were unaware of other's backgrounds wealth. That was in South West. Wonder if it depends on geographical area? Maybe less attention paid to this in rural areas. I would say that, wen our youngest was at the local comp, possibly there was more awareness of backgrounds as kids seem to form friendships with children from similar backgrounds so pretty obvious who were the middle class kids, the children from council estate etc.
HappyDays40 · 12/12/2021 04:46

Just imagine the poor children whose parents earn over 100kConfused . Just send them to a state school with us common folks if you are that worried.

Nowayoutonlydown · 12/12/2021 03:47

Really depends who you're talking to,
Private school is much the same as state, there will be some families who are not spectacularly well off who have made a lot of cut backs to ensure that their children's school fees are attainable, there will be children there on bursaries who live in council properties and have a very different life out of school, there will also be families who have huge, huge incomes. There will be families who might view you as poor, and don't be fooled- there's always going to be a few kids who have better than everyone and will go out of their way to make that known (regardless of which school!)

mathanxiety · 12/12/2021 02:37

Whether your family income stacks up against the income of other families is one question, and whether your child will feel at home in the school are two separate questions.

The answer to your question really depends on your own child's personality.

Pinksloth · 12/12/2021 02:08

@Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas

Children, even those ones influenced by snotty parents really don't make friends based on money. We all make friends on what the other person is about.
Yep, this is very true. We're nowhere near as rich as some of my son's friends' parents. I mean by this, own big companies, have helicopters, hired a butler for their child for a month rich. There are also parents who are less financially well off than us. None of them care.

However, this is at a private school, not a public school. I'm not sure whether the class factor would make things operate differently at somewhere like Eton or Harrow, for instance.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 12/12/2021 02:07

@Corcory

You are being ridiculous to think that. A very high proportion of children at any private school are on bursaries as were mine. A certainly didn't feel inferior neither did my children they made great friend and so did I with many of the mums. Yes some of the children lived in castles and mansions but we just made fun of it. all the children were invited to everyone's parties etc. Even the titled parents who are near enough to the royal family to be invited to all their weddings were more than welcoming and always very friendly.
I agree with all of this - it's been my experience too.
RiverSkater · 12/12/2021 01:46

Relatively speaking, we can all be richer or poorer.

It's your job to teach them that and how to handle it. And teach yourself.

Derbee · 12/12/2021 01:30

@paimio

I was that kid. My parents couldn’t afford private school fees but my grandparents wanted me to go to a private school so they paid. I felt it a little but overall it didn’t bother me.

It is all relative though. Our household income is £500k+ and DP is concerned we can’t afford it and DC will be ‘poor’ in comparison to his peers.

Your DP sounds like an idiot. £500k is an income that can certainly support private education.
Derbee · 12/12/2021 01:28

@NoAprilFool

Jeeeesh

I said this in a much wordier post but here in brief: school fees vary MASSIVELY across the country and across different schools.

So posters saying they couldn’t afford private school on £100K is worthless unless we know where they - and OP - are

Unless you read the thread and see that the OP stated the fees would be £28k/year for both DC. But thanks for your opinion Hmm
Corcory · 12/12/2021 01:12

You are being ridiculous to think that. A very high proportion of children at any private school are on bursaries as were mine. A certainly didn't feel inferior neither did my children they made great friend and so did I with many of the mums. Yes some of the children lived in castles and mansions but we just made fun of it. all the children were invited to everyone's parties etc. Even the titled parents who are near enough to the royal family to be invited to all their weddings were more than welcoming and always very friendly.

PegasusReturns · 12/12/2021 00:58

OP you also talk about fees costing £28k, leaving you with £80k but you don’t seem to have accounted for the fact you’re paying for those out of taxed income so you must have to earn, what £45k to pay them, leaving you with nearer £65k gross.

PegasusReturns · 12/12/2021 00:49

When people say there’s a “broad range” of incomes they mean a handful at most might be in the £80-150k bracket. Most families are earning £500k plus. And some families are earning/have millions.

But it’s not the flashy things that are difficult: it’s easy to have your DCs birthday at the local climbing wall when classmates hire out amusement parks; or dress your DC in Nike when classmates are in kenzo.

The stretch comes when everyone is flying to Antibes for the weekend or they get invited skiing or or there’s a rugby match they want to go to with mates or simply everyone’s come back to yours after a day out and they want £150 of sushi for dinner and you’re just reciprocating what happens in every other house.

Not being able to do the things that 95% of their peers are doing is tough from a social perspective.

No one’s being mean or a bitch but i think it’s tough in those that don’t have means.

Frazzled50yrold · 12/12/2021 00:49

You don't have to publicly declare your income so I can't see why it would a problem. Presumably private school children are going to have good shoes, not be the ones in the hand me down uniforms etc so they won't look any different to the others in the way that some poor children in state schools do. My children mingled with some very wealthy children at their grammar school but they were from very old money and there was never anything showy about them. Surely every parent, whether they choose private or state education, just want the best for their children and aren't going to judge to this extent.

Furries · 12/12/2021 00:48

Flipping Nora - this site sometimes does my head in. Firstly, I’m not rich. Secondly, I don’t have children. Thirdly, I have skimmed the OP’s posts only - but am getting a vague idea of what else has been posted.

To me, it is fairly obvious, even from the very first post, that the OP is not claiming poverty with regards to joint income - I think they realise (without bragging) that they are in a fortunate position to be considering this. Secondly, from reading further posts from the OP, they are not questioning whether or not they could afford the fees in relation to managing their annual budget - the suns have been done and they can manage/adjust accordingly. And again, no bragging about being in a position to do this.

Finally, there is nothing wrong with the question they have asked. OP - I would honestly say that they MAY feel poor in relation to others. As a few people have pointed out, it depends on the school/area etc. There could very well be children from families whose wealth would be unfathomable to many.

There is nothing wrong with the question you have asked. And, TBF, it shows that you are thinking about the impact of your decisions on your children. Just because you are fortunate enough to be in a position that this COULD be an option for your kids, you are weighing up how it could impact on them in the long run.

As I said, I’m not rich and I don’t have kids. But I really dislike the mentality on here sometimes to immediately bash someone with a salary over a certain threshold - and to make them feel shit about trying to figure out what is best for their kids. Because, in today’s SM-driven society, sadly her children might be looked down on even if fortunate enough to attend a private school. Peer pressure can often seem really subtle, but can have quite a big impact/effect.

Sorry OP - no actual real advice, but I just thought you’ve been bashed a bit for asking a question about what is best for your children with regards to your own circumstances and means.

paimio · 12/12/2021 00:47

@youvegottenminuteslynn DP’s family really struggled for money when he was growing up. He has worked really hard to get where he is but is always worried he doesn’t have enough money. It’s emotional, not rational.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 12/12/2021 00:47

@paimio thanks for replying! Mmm professional services. Like the sound of that. Smile Does he have a colleague/brother recently divorced? Asking for a friend.

NoAprilFool · 12/12/2021 00:43

Jeeeesh

I said this in a much wordier post but here in brief: school fees vary MASSIVELY across the country and across different schools.

So posters saying they couldn’t afford private school on £100K is worthless unless we know where they - and OP - are

paimio · 12/12/2021 00:43

@CherryBlossomAutumn It is almost entirely down to DP. He has a senior position in professional services, but is a lot older than me and will probably retire in ten years (which is when DC will enter secondary). I earn twice the UK average wage but not anywhere near the crazy money he does.

jeaux90 · 12/12/2021 00:40

OP I am a single mum. I earn 125k a year and send my DD12 to an all girls private school.

There is also another single mum in her year and plenty of parents who are divorced.

Majority of parents are in tech, surgeons etc.

There are no super wealthy parents, privileged yes of course, anyone who can send their kids to private school is.

It really comes down to what kind of private school it is. Send them. If you can afford it, do it.

Cordeliathecat · 12/12/2021 00:39

I haven’t read the full thread but stop deducting school fees from gross salary. You pay school fees from net salary. That makes a huge difference to most school fee payers as they are nearly always in the higher tax bracket so have to earn double the fees just to clear them.

Don’t underestimate extras. Uniform costs £1,000, overseas trips cost £2,000. Almost every week there is another email about another cost that is going to be added to the bill. If in prep, your child will want to do ballet with her friends, or Lamda with his friends, or learn the trumpet, that’s another £1,000 per activity, per year . It goes on and on.

From saying you still pay for childcare, it sounds like you’re a long way from paying for senior schools. Please be aware that annual school fee increases drastically outstrip any inflationary pay rises you might get. If you think you might be able to afford it now, you won’t by the time they’re in senior school unless you are due some hefty pay jumps.

You will likely be on your own in using such a high percentage of your income on school fees. To my mind, you’ve not done the maths properly and it would be insanity to commit to an independent school on your income. In my experience nearly all those at independent schools are either eligible for bursaries, wealthy (earning at least double your incomes) or super wealthy. Middle earners can’t afford independent education any more. It’s not like when our parents were our age.

You mention TPS. Teaching at an independent school could give you 50% fee reduction or more. I’d look at that if you’re determined to go private.

Swipe left for the next trending thread