Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if our children would be the ‘poor’ ones at private school

658 replies

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 19:56

DH and I have a good joint income of over £100,000 and I’m seriously considering private school for our children.

A worry for me is if they are surrounded by children from much wealthier backgrounds if they would feel ‘poor’. I’m just posting for thoughts from people who know a bit more about the independent system than me.

OP posts:
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 12/12/2021 08:31

find the people in my postcode who send their kids to end excellent local state school appear richer than some of them

🤨 well yes, of course they appear richer, they aren’t burning through money on school fees, that’s pretty basic/obvious.

@felulageller
We had years like that immediately after my parents divorced. I think it’s amazing what you’re doing and, speaking from experience, your children will thank you one day.

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 12/12/2021 08:28

Mine most definitely was the poor kid and it really affected him. He got in on a bursary and my ex husband paid his fees. Just for instance when he passed his exams we gave him a bit of money but all his mates got brand new cars with personalised number plates.

Mind you, we don't earn anywhere near 100k

KittyKattyFosterMummy · 12/12/2021 08:28

[quote NatriumChloride]@KittyKattyFosterMummyYou only have one child you’re putting through private school. OP has two.[/quote]
I thought I'd put it one of my other posts, but I didn't so have missed probably the most important part of my point, sorry, my fault entirely Blush my daughter is a boarder because until recently we lived overseas. So the fees are more than the 2 OP's.

SwumMum · 12/12/2021 08:27

I was a child at independent school with fees subsidised by grandparents and parents who sacrificed loads.

I hated it and I wish they'd made different decisions.

We never went abroad, ours cars always broken-down, any new clothes had to be my birthday or Christmas presents. Any invites to friends' houses caused mass anxiety, as did things like speech/prize giving day.

It's all very well saying the richer kids didn't care. I doubt they did. But I did. I hated it. They all went on multiple holidays a year, went skiing, went on planes, went abroad. I did none of those things. They all rode, had horses, or played tennis with their parents or swam in their pool at home etc. The gulf in cultural capital was massive.

I had to have a job through uni as there was no spare money from home. And I got next to no help with my wedding or house deposit.

None of my siblings were particularly happy at private school and all would have massively benefitted from help with housing.

It's not a decision I would dream of making unless I was so well off I didn't have to budget for it. If I could still save loads for their future, work part time and have the holidays off, take them on weekends away and interesting holidays the whole family enjoy and remember, have memberships to interesting places, support their education with extras...

On your salary (and the pp who said they're in half yours!!) there is no way I'd consider it.

Hormonehelp · 12/12/2021 08:26

I think your question is very valid. My parents didn’t send me for this exact reason when grandparents offered to pay the fees. They were concerned they couldn’t afford all the extras etc etc.

In short I stayed in a local comp where I was bullied and miserable. It has affected my adult personality and confidence.

I would send them if I could, just be realistic in realising some kids might have the latest gadget, the latest water bottle, a cooler new car and holidays non stop - but usually this is at the sacrifice of their parents time; Usually said parents are working endless hours and it doesn’t make the child a happier person.

You can explain to your child if they ever complain or feel inferior the importance of working hard, making friends and that having all the latest stuff isn’t what will make them happy in life.

I speak from experience now that your child might also get opportunities to go on holiday with their peers, enjoy fun days at their homes with pools and cinema rooms- but that the other children might also have just as much fun coming to your home which is full of love (and freshly baked cookies)!

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 12/12/2021 08:19

Also I’ve been wondering why everyone is going on about the “south east”, thinking that I lived in a place that’s notoriously fancy that I’ve believed my whole life to be the south west due to “south western rail”. Nope. South east. Don’t I feel silly 😬

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 12/12/2021 08:17

Actually I want to add to my original statement:

My secondary school was boarding and it really was for the obscenely rich in the main. Oligarch’s children, foreign royalty, counts etc. I did feel very left out in lots of ways (and actually we were by that point pretty well off by most standards) BUT I do actually have to say 100% of my hang ups can be traced back to my mother absolutely freaking out/fixating on our change of financial circumstance after my parent’s divorce snd focusing on money SO much. If her attitude had been a lot more relaxed about it I really don’t think I would have minded - so many other people didn't. DH was one of the richest at his public school (no mean feat) and I think there was potentially ribbing of some children with less but also not, depending on whether or not they liked them.

As a PP said, it really does depend on the school as well.

alh26 · 12/12/2021 08:17

Hi - I'm 27 and went to a private boarding school age 11 onwards. My dad was a high earner and my mum didn't have an income. My dad for sure was over £100k but honestly couldn't tell you how much but he certainly wasn't ridiculously high. We lived in a nice 5 bedroom big countryside home in the heart of a village but by no means a mansion. Private school the whole of our childhood, at least 2 family holidays a year and enjoyed nice things but we still didn't have majority of things others had.

A lot of the girls at my school had another property, either a holiday home or a flat in London, or both! Large houses, horses, given a car at 18, christmas in Mauritius or verbier etc. I did notice some differences like when we left uni I went to live and work in London and I was earning my first salary and paying rent! A lot of them didn't have to pay rent because they lived in their parents flats (some still do 6 years later Shock). But I had a fab life, we were by no means poor and had what others would describe as a luxury lifestyle but a lot of my friends had more but that was fine. I prefer to have mine, it made me appreciate how hard my dad worked to give us that as children and how I probably took it for granted at the time. My own money has never meant so much to me and I hope one day I can give my children the same.

My advice would be if you want to send them to private, then do. If you can afford it they won't feel poor. But be prepared for them to be invited on lavish holidays with friends families and be taken out to very nice restaurants with their friends parents. They will be exposed to a different lifestyle. I saw many things on holidays and at parties with friends families (drugs, hookers, copious amounts of alcohol, really derogatory language). It was eye opening and they're not afraid to show off.

My partner and I currently have a good joint income of over 120k, we are 27 and 29 and I already know that I won't be sending our children to boarding school.

Motheroftigers · 12/12/2021 08:16

@paimio

I was that kid. My parents couldn’t afford private school fees but my grandparents wanted me to go to a private school so they paid. I felt it a little but overall it didn’t bother me.

It is all relative though. Our household income is £500k+ and DP is concerned we can’t afford it and DC will be ‘poor’ in comparison to his peers.

Grin
dalrympy · 12/12/2021 08:08

We are in south east and no way would they feel like the poor kids.

DC goes to private school and her friends range from family of 5 in small rented 2 bed flat, to kid having own suite with dressing room etc.

Categorically at NO point have we been made to feel poor.

There will always be someone with more than you - whatever school you go to. (And probably someone with less).

Go for it. It's worked really well for us.

Switch82 · 12/12/2021 08:03

Also we come from an ethnic background and we want to put the kids in the best position possible not to derail the thread but due to the work DH and I do we see the true value of private education. I can’t see social mobility equalising / race related work issues not occurring in their lifetimes sadly so want to get them in the best position.

Switch82 · 12/12/2021 08:00

The state was excellent to a point but there has been some issues around the academic kids just being left to stagnate. Now we’ve moved the eldest to the prep we can see the big difference between the standard of education (DC is catching up now and is very bright so always would). The Senior School is academically selective private school so we believe putting in prep for last two years will get them to the right level for the secondary school.

desperate4spring · 12/12/2021 07:57

Well we are in the process of applying for a bursary for DD to attend a private school and we earn less than half of what you do. I wouldn't worry about it if I were you. You're loaded in my eyes.

Solasum · 12/12/2021 07:57

In my experience the only person who will have an issue with how much you earn is you, as the children don’t care much. I would say this with the caveat I would not want to be the only family that does not have any holidays, or to be able to do activities. School uniform is a great leveller. I also think you do not to make friends with other parents to feel comfortable. I think atmosphere does massively depend on the school. At ours the vast majority are both-working professional parents, and they work Hard. Which has actually triggered a high level of awareness in my DC of what they could achieve professionally themselves. We have had interesting conversations about wealth, and the decisions most people have made in their lives to get there. In our case it helps that we live in a very mixed area, so DC are not in a gilded bubble, and can see for themselves that some people have more money and some people have less.

crazycrochetlady · 12/12/2021 07:53

@Switch82

I think it’s hard. Just started my eldest at prep. DH on about 120k gross - I’m self employed so take home net £50k is that about £70k gross?! Fees just over £1k a month will be sending the second so it’ll be about 2.5k net a month!! It’s a huge amount of money and I’m shitting it! We live in an expensive area (In comparison to a lot of the parents at the private school) so have a modest house but the value of our house is high cos of postcode and we drive a 6 year old car. So far I’ve found it ‘ok’ definitely a lot of people I don’t relate to but actually find the people in my postcode who send their kids to end excellent local state school appear richer than some of them. Lots business owners but also some lawyers and medics not on so much.

What I am shocked at is single income households and single children - so people with multiple children generally not sending their kids to prep school.

If there's such an excellent state in your postcode then why on Earth are you paying and bricking it?
Switch82 · 12/12/2021 07:51

I think it’s hard. Just started my eldest at prep. DH on about 120k gross - I’m self employed so take home net £50k is that about £70k gross?! Fees just over £1k a month will be sending the second so it’ll be about 2.5k net a month!! It’s a huge amount of money and I’m shitting it!
We live in an expensive area (In comparison to a lot of the parents at the private school) so have a modest house but the value of our house is high cos of postcode and we drive a 6 year old car. So far I’ve found it ‘ok’ definitely a lot of people I don’t relate to but actually find the people in my postcode who send their kids to end excellent local state school appear richer than some of them. Lots business owners but also some lawyers and medics not on so much.

What I am shocked at is single income households and single children - so people with multiple children generally not sending their kids to prep school.

user68901 · 12/12/2021 07:51

Given that it’s currently £28k for 2 kids in the most expensive year I think you’ll find there are plenty of other families in your income bracket. Would suspect the mega bucks families in your area probably send their kids to big name boarding schools.
On the question of affordability, please don’t ignore the importance of saving for pension in your monthly budget.

titanic25 · 12/12/2021 07:47

@Changethefloorthroughout

For either of us, being made redundant or not being able to work is really highly unlikely. I mean I don’t want to tempt fate and never say never but you could make the same argument against a mortgage and people don’t not buy houses because they might not be able to work.
OP its good decision to invest in children's education. One of my friend s children attend very elite school and she pays around 35k each term for her two children.But whole family is so down to earth and live in big mansion.They are so welcoming. It will be fine.i think its general perception about wealthy people but not all of them make you feel poor. We can't afford private schools even we are earning £90k but are paying for private tutions for our children. we have three children so its hard on our salary.
Bunnycat101 · 12/12/2021 07:42

I’m not 100% sure if you’re talking prep or secondary as I think there is a difference re demographics. In our area, the state primaries are very good so there are lots of professional couples who go state and then private for secondary at the day schools. The demographics for the boarding schools are much more ‘monied’ and that is the difference of paying fees of 18k versus 40k a year.

I would feel anxious paying fees on £115k but your mortgage is comparatively low for your income which is probably why your day to day costs aren’t worrying you. Mine is triple yours. We have decided we’d like to do private secondary but want to save during the primary years so we’re only ever doing one set of fees out of income. I wouldn’t go into it unless I could reach a good level of savings before as I don’t want the stress of having such large fixed costs coming from income alone.

mobear · 12/12/2021 07:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Hope478 · 12/12/2021 07:33

@Changethefloorthroughout

But it is relative *@LagunaBubbles*, which is the whole point of the thread. £100000 is untold wealth in some quarters and absolute poverty if you are best mates with Bill Gates and Elton John.
Hmm
malificent7 · 12/12/2021 07:15

Club

malificent7 · 12/12/2021 07:15

Stealth boast! I was the poor kid at private school...it was awful. The"in" kids had money. Its an exclusive cklub. However, on that amount of cash they will be ok.

Cieloazzurro · 12/12/2021 07:14

I teach in an independent school with similar fees. Your kids will be fine. You aren’t looking at Eton type boarding and, whilst there will be some very wealthy families, there will be many on incomes similar to yours, some on much less who receive bursaries or who have generous grandparents. At our school, many teachers’ children are students so definitely not the super rich. This is possible due to staff getting a 50% discount. If you teach, can you keep an eye out for jobs at your preferred school? I’ve been teaching for over 20 years and made the move from state education a few years ago. Life changing

Chasingaftermidnight · 12/12/2021 07:12

I don’t think it’s a stupid question.

I was one of the ‘poor’ kids at a private school (I got a scholarship). Honestly, it was pretty miserable for a number of reasons:

  1. It made money tight at home. Which meant that in my parents’ minds my educational achievements and their finances were intertwined, which led to a huge amount of pressure and guilt on me. Our home life was so tense. To be fair they weren’t as well off as you and your husband. And as a parent I think it’s important to recognise that it’s your choice to use a private school, not your kid’s choice.
  2. It wasn’t nice being the kid in charity shop clothes while everyone else was in branded stuff. I used to pull sickies on non-uniform days.
  3. I never wanted to have friends round to our house because it was so different to their houses.

I think a lot depends on the school. It sounds like it’s a pretty ‘minor private school’ so it might be that your income would be fairly normal amongst the other parents. Obviously at one of the major public schools it might be different.