Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if our children would be the ‘poor’ ones at private school

658 replies

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 19:56

DH and I have a good joint income of over £100,000 and I’m seriously considering private school for our children.

A worry for me is if they are surrounded by children from much wealthier backgrounds if they would feel ‘poor’. I’m just posting for thoughts from people who know a bit more about the independent system than me.

OP posts:
Bubblecap · 12/12/2021 10:54

DH and both his parents went to public school. MIL family were very wealthy, staff, overseas holidays in the 1950’s a tennis court plus a second home. FIL was a scholarship boy from a very modest background, his Mum worked in a shop and his Dad worked as a clerk. DH lived in a beautiful house on a private road in Surrey they had a housekeeper and second home, horses and the house sold about a 15 years ago for 2 million. They moved out 25 years ago when in laws divorced.

MIL and DH are two of the nicest people you could ever meet, have time for everyone and lovely manners. , FIL was a very insecure man that was obsessed with status. I am convinced being the poor kid at his very expensive boarding school messed him up. But this was just post war and honestly the class system was alive and kicking then.

I am but a humble state school kid who was clever and ended up at a leading University where I met DH. The percentage of public school kids was really high there and an eye opener. We chose to send DS to a state school. The polish and confidence people talk about that private school influences. DS has that regardless. It’s shallow but I think being one of the well off kids at state school helps make them popular. There was a group of six boys including DS who were all very popular and all bar one lived on the very expensive roads in our locality.

FrancescaContini · 12/12/2021 10:44

So many Hyacinths on this thread, it’s amusing.

So glad we never got on the “keeping up with the Joneses” hamster wheel.

Hoppinggreen · 12/12/2021 10:43

@Spaceman1

I think you need c. £300k pa to send two children to a good public school and afford new school clothes, all the extras, clubs, school trips and for them to fit in. This is because fees go up every year by way more than inflation. By the time you get to the final year you will find they are much higher than the first year.
It will have cost us around £150k by the time both have left. Private rather than Public school though. It’s an excellent non selective school that achieves results similar to those of the local Grammar.
Lanique · 12/12/2021 10:41

My friend has chosen to send her one dc to a 25k independent. Her dc seemed perfectly happy in state school and didn't want to leave it, but, (fond as I am of her), my friend is an unabashed snob and admits that she and her husband have made the decision because she basically thinks the local state school is beneath them.

I don't know what they earn. Her Dh is a professional, and she works, so I'd imagine 100k plus, but I do know that they have to make an awful lot of sacrifices. Her dc is currently having a lot of mental health issues, has made a decision not to go to university, and seems happier hanging out with old state school friends.

Why they have chosen this route is beyond me.

Spaceman1 · 12/12/2021 10:34

I think you need c. £300k pa to send two children to a good public school and afford new school clothes, all the extras, clubs, school trips and for them to fit in. This is because fees go up every year by way more than inflation. By the time you get to the final year you will find they are much higher than the first year.

Scrunchies · 12/12/2021 10:30

Christ how boring that we are only allowed to post now if we are ‘properly poor’ …. @Changethefloorthroughout this is a very valid question.

I went to state school, and was bullied for being ‘the rich one’

My ex went to a private school on scholarship as his dad was a teacher, and was ‘the poor one’. He definitely had a huge chip on his shoulder about it and gave him loads of insecurity issues. Plus his other friends did look down on him and he didn’t seem to really fit in there, no matter how hard he tried.

So it is an actual issue to be concerned about,I think you have a valid question and nobody else needs to give ‘permission’ on this board for you to post it, PP are being ridiculous

Merryoldgoat · 12/12/2021 10:29

@Changethefloorthroughout

That’s no guarantee of strong finances. I’m not saying it doesn’t have a great foundation, but download their last annual report and read the Head’s and Chair’s report in detail and see what their debtor book is like and how full they are.

Plenty of well established schools have left the arena recently.

It’s not a criticism - I do this for a living. I’m just advising you of some of the pitfalls many don’t consider.

June2008 · 12/12/2021 10:27

It sounds like you can afford it on paper. Do think about the extras though. Uniform is expensive, £130 for a blazer for us, approx £1000 for a full set of winter and summer uniform and pe kits. About £400 for uniform top ups per year thereafter.

Compulsory lunches in lower school.

It would be difficult to keep saying no to everything if you'd had to tighten your purse strings; singing lessons, two night residential here, three nights in London there, two theatre trips - thats just been for one child this term.

To come back to your original question realistically it will depend on the type of school you choose and the friends / cohort they end up with.

Doubledoorsontogarden · 12/12/2021 10:23

I’m in a similar boat OP. DH and I combined salary would easily afford a private school for our one DC. I’m thinking about it for secondary. If one of us lost our jobs we should be able to get another quickly due to the sectors that we work in, both in short supply.

I’m concerned that we would stick out a bit. Other families would have holiday homes in the Caribbean and probably the DC have been skiing every year etc, we haven’t. Also both DH and I went to state schools, I’m sure some/a lot of the cohort will have multi generational history at the school.

I think you need a good slush fund for school uniform and kit etc. Also if you have savings some schools offer a discount to pre pay years in advance.

The fees for private school seem to be on par with what we paid for nursery fees tbh, also what we will likely pay in accommodation costs if they go to Uni.

VitalsStable · 12/12/2021 10:18

Both kids have a huge range of other kids at their private schools, the eldest went to stay at his friends who live in a mansion in St John's wood last weekend, he mentioned their house being amazing, bigger and more luxurious than ours and ours would be amazing to those on a lower income but it means nothing to the kids, they're just friends.

The youngest has a kid at their school who arrives by helicopter and a fair few are house hold name celebrities but they're all just school kids to each other who seem to get on and don't think about the disparities in their parents income. DC doesn't think about how much a helicopter must cost just that it's a helicopter and is v cool.

Of course their just 2 kids out of thousands but it hasn't been an issue for us.

Changethefloorthroughout · 12/12/2021 10:11

Well, yes, but the schools been up and running for some 150 years. Never say never but it’s fairly well established.

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 12/12/2021 10:09

OP - one thing I’d say is do a thorough check on the school’s finances.

Lots of smaller standalone schools are often in financial difficulties and you will see the effect if that trickle down to education.

Class sizes and ratios will be pushed, lots of staff on temp contracts, people withdrawing children etc.

We are a small standalone (with an exceptional Balance Sheet) and other local well thought of preps have really suffered, especially lately.

We were approached by one to discuss merging. It wasn’t for us but we’re seeing lots of kids on our waiting list who are currently there.

Just a practical note.

littleowls83 · 12/12/2021 10:04

It is incredibly shit to be the poor one in any school. For private secondary, if you can't afford the lifestyle that goes with it, don't put your kids in that position.

logsonlogsoff · 12/12/2021 10:01

Depends on the school. 2 in our city are full of billionaires kids, and kids of Russian Oligarchs and ‘famous’ world wide. The other 2/3 are full of kids from MC/upper MC families and less elitist though it’s still all ski-ing at Easter
Etc
We chosen not to send or kids to private school - we want them to know they’re privileged and learn how to get on in the world with all
Sorts of people. Both brought up WC with little money.
But that being said because of our income oir kids already have advantages of sports clubs, private music lessons, and if they struggle
in a subject at school when older we could afford tutors.

pilar3 · 12/12/2021 10:00

OP, fair enough, but I would say really look at the outcomes and the management before you choose a school. A lot of smaller independent schools are run by “governors” who feel they answer to nobody.

Really look at whether you are getting value for money here. Smaller class sizes mean nothing if the teaching is crap. Also, a non-selective school will not produce better outcomes than a non-selective state. Finally, some independents are brilliant with SEN, but others offer nothing and they can get away with offering nothing in a way that state schools would not be able to.

Is it a selective school and how selective?

ShanghaiDiva · 12/12/2021 09:57

@pilar3

My apologies, I missed that it was £28,000 per year for two. I assume this is a quite rural location?

Just be careful OP. Some independent schools are money for old rope frankly, especially at the less expensive end of the scale.

I’m sure you have looked into it, but what are the results at GCSE, A-level? Are they actually better than the local state school?

Is this school selective at all?

Location is key with regard to fees imo. My dd attends a selective school in the south west and fees are circa 15k per year. School has excellent results. We are not in a rural location.
Keke94LND · 12/12/2021 09:56

@Changethefloorthroughout

I didn’t ask if we could afford it, *@Keke94LND*
Fair enough you're right you didn't, but I don't really understand why you care if your kids are going to be the 'poor' ones at a private school? What are you worried about? Are you worried they're going to feel hard done by? Because if so then just teach them how privileged they are to have parents that can afford to send them to private school? Are you worried they're gonna be bullied? What is it you're actually concerned about?
ShanghaiDiva · 12/12/2021 09:53

@Ijustreallywantacat

You have completely misunderstood the op’s post. She knows she is not poor.

It says the word in the title. OP then goes on to use the word 'poverty'. I don't care if its in quotes or not, I think a lot of people here could gain some perspective. I work with people who are actually, properly 'poor' every day. I've had mums faint on me because they haven't eaten for a week to ensure that the kids do. OP, watch your language. Go volunteer somewhere.

No need to be so aggressive in your post. Op uses the word poor, but has stated numerous times she know an income of over £100k is not poor. She is asking about comparative wealth levels. Instead of criticising the op’s language, why not read through the thread?
Whammyyammy · 12/12/2021 09:53

Similar income to us, our daughter went through private school, which was 90% funded from government as oh in the military.
Yes, she mixed with friends a lot lot wealthier than us, didnt make a blind bit of difference though. She was judged because she was lot from a wealthy family.

Changethefloorthroughout · 12/12/2021 09:52

I don’t think it’s particularly rural. I mean, Not London, but still a smallish city. We live fairly rurally, which is one reason I’m giving serious consideration to private schools, as the private schools are actually close to the (state) school I work in which would help with pick ups and drop offs. That’s a fairly minor reason but is still a reason.

OP posts:
pilar3 · 12/12/2021 09:50

My apologies, I missed that it was £28,000 per year for two. I assume this is a quite rural location?

Just be careful OP. Some independent schools are money for old rope frankly, especially at the less expensive end of the scale.

I’m sure you have looked into it, but what are the results at GCSE, A-level? Are they actually better than the local state school?

Is this school selective at all?

Ijustreallywantacat · 12/12/2021 09:49

You have completely misunderstood the op’s post. She knows she is not poor.

It says the word in the title. OP then goes on to use the word 'poverty'. I don't care if its in quotes or not, I think a lot of people here could gain some perspective. I work with people who are actually, properly 'poor' every day. I've had mums faint on me because they haven't eaten for a week to ensure that the kids do. OP, watch your language. Go volunteer somewhere.

ShanghaiDiva · 12/12/2021 09:46

@pilar3

OP, rather than inciting all the inevitable speculation and sweeping statements, why not just state how much the fees are and roughly where you live? Why all the mystery?

There’s a massive difference between eg. the London Day Schools wharf the fees will be £9k per term, and a sleepy little private school in the countryside where it might be £4k per term.

It totally depends in the school and location. This is obvious Confused

I believe Op already stated fees were circa £28k for two children and she does not live in south east.
LactoseTheIntolerant · 12/12/2021 09:46

In my experience this doesn't happen. I have 2 dc at 2 different private schools and neither have had experience of this, although our financial situation is different to yours.
That being said I hate materialism and will not enter into a 'keeping up with the jonses' type behaviour, and I think I've brought my dcs to be similar. All their friends are lovely, down to earth with perfectly normal parents. Dc1 school has a few billionaires children (particularly the Chinese borders) but also many boys on burseries. Those boys that try and boast about money get laughed at, it just isn't a thing, but who knows maybe in some schools it is?
When I was at private school (centuries ago) it was actually 'cool' to put on a cockney accent and pretend you werent an over privileged idiot, we sounded like wannabe eastenders actors!

Changethefloorthroughout · 12/12/2021 09:45

I have, pilar Grin I’ve said exactly how much the fees are!

OP posts: