Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if our children would be the ‘poor’ ones at private school

658 replies

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 19:56

DH and I have a good joint income of over £100,000 and I’m seriously considering private school for our children.

A worry for me is if they are surrounded by children from much wealthier backgrounds if they would feel ‘poor’. I’m just posting for thoughts from people who know a bit more about the independent system than me.

OP posts:
gattey · 11/12/2021 20:31

Because it’s too high a percentage to make the risk worth it. For example, what happens if one of you can no longer work? What happens if one of you is made redundant?

Presumably the OP has savings & insurance & can get another job.

Grumpycatsmum · 11/12/2021 20:30

*if we could we would have...

Grumpycatsmum · 11/12/2021 20:28

@HalfTermHalfTerm I know this question was directed at the OP but I'm going to answer for us. We moved from a "good" state to small private because DD was miserable, stressed and depressed. Behaviour was awful, especially in her class, most of her friends were unhappy (especially the academic ones), lockdown learning was patchy at best and, above all, she was getting almost no support for her dyslexia and falling behind - even though teachers liked her and thought she was doing well. She's now in a small class, with much better behaviour and can actually concentrate. Not only has she caught up academically she is much happier. If we could have moved to another state school and achieved the same outcome but even the best state schools I spoke to in or near us said they wouldn't be able to provide her with much additional support. So although we didn't want to send her private it was the best choice for her at the time.

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 20:28

For either of us, being made redundant or not being able to work is really highly unlikely. I mean I don’t want to tempt fate and never say never but you could make the same argument against a mortgage and people don’t not buy houses because they might not be able to work.

OP posts:
gattey · 11/12/2021 20:27

These threads always go the same way

"OP you are so rich & out of touch"

"OP you are too poor for private school*

It's location & school dependent.

NettleTea · 11/12/2021 20:27

@kitty1993

I went to a lovely private school, some people in my class were very poor but they were at the school on scholarships. None of the pupils cared about who had the most money we just wanted to be kids and have fun. Money or no money, I had a much better education at private school compared to my experience of state school.
this is the experience of my son, currently in yr 11 He is on a bursary and Im a single parent, living in a council estate. He has lots of good friends. As opposed to when he was at the local comprehensive which seemed far more focused on who had what and wore what, and he had barely any friends
LuaDipa · 11/12/2021 20:27

Can’t speak for all but there is a huge mix at my kids school. There are some super wealthy and some not so much. It genuinely makes no difference whatsoever to the kids.

gattey · 11/12/2021 20:26

This was blow some posters minds, but you can get a discount if you earn 90k in some schools

Pumperthepumper · 11/12/2021 20:25

@Changethefloorthroughout

I guess this is what I’m asking though *@Pumperthepumper*, why, when it still leaves us with a high annual income? The income levels in independent schools must be pretty high and I clearly have different (low! Grin) standards.
Because it’s too high a percentage to make the risk worth it. For example, what happens if one of you can no longer work? What happens if one of you is made redundant?
Megan2018 · 11/12/2021 20:25

DH went on a bursary and scholarship to a very expensive “elite” school. He was definitely marked out as “poor”. He didn’t mind overly but he lived in a modest 4 bed cottage and didn’t spend holidays on a yacht like his peers.
My 2 close friends teach at a good but not elite independent, average parental income exceeds £250k so £100k would definitely be bottom tier. Whether it matters depends on so many factors.

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 20:23

I guess this is what I’m asking though @Pumperthepumper, why, when it still leaves us with a high annual income? The income levels in independent schools must be pretty high and I clearly have different (low! Grin) standards.

OP posts:
Halloweenbiscuits · 11/12/2021 20:23

I think it completely depends which school. We are in similar position and kids at private prep (south Manchester) and we are in the middle I would say.. lots richer lots less well off but really makes no difference in the way the kids or the parents interact x

Remmy123 · 11/12/2021 20:23

That income isn't enough for secondary school private .. not where I live anyway!

whereisthekey · 11/12/2021 20:21

@lastqueenofscotland has a great point. 30k a year towards house deposit, travelling the world, extra curricular activities, endless tutoring if needed etc would be wonderful.

gattey · 11/12/2021 20:21

£100 k income and you're worried about your kids feeling poor? Jesus

Post tax it wouldn't be enough to pay he fees for one dc at certain schools.

gattey · 11/12/2021 20:20

& the fees obviously

Pumperthepumper · 11/12/2021 20:20

@Changethefloorthroughout

Of course you’re not being a knob, that’s why I’m asking.

However, two at private senior is less than £30,000 (I know this will go up, but so will our salaries) and that still leaves us with over £80,000 gross.

30% of your joint salaries is a lot to pay for school fees. What are the state schools like around you?
Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 20:19

I think some people were bored on a Saturday night and delighted to find a thread that could be ‘offended’ at.

But it does go to show as even after paying school fees we would be left with around £80,000 gross, yet that is at the lower end of the wealth spectrum. So in many ways it’s a very different world to the one I’m familiar with.

OP posts:
HalfTermHalfTerm · 11/12/2021 20:19

@AutumnLeaves21

They will be surrounded by much wealthier children and they will notice. They’ll also notice different treatment from the teachers Speaking from bitter experience. It’s not a mistake I’d make again.
I’ve worked in private schools and I’ve not noticed this. There were a few students who were very wealthy and a few on some sort of full bursary but as for the rest of them I couldn’t have told you whose family was earning £1m+, whose was earning £100k, who had grandparents paying the fees, etc.

It might be different at some of the very big, well established schools but I don’t think you would be able to send multiple children to one of those on £100k a year.

gattey · 11/12/2021 20:19

Well not all private schools are the same so it depends on the actual school.

lastqueenofscotland · 11/12/2021 20:18

Personally if your local states are good I would send them there and use the money for trips/activities/money toward helpigg nhs them at uni/with a deposit

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 11/12/2021 20:18

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Nobody is saying £100K a year is ‘poor’. Not one soul.

Read the thread title

ChocolateHelps · 11/12/2021 20:18

...but what are you actually buying? My kids go to the local state secondary, have excellent accdemic results and local friends who think we live in a lovely house (mid terrace).

You could work less, be at home with kids, or go skiing every Feb half term and Bahamas in December and your children go to the local school and still receive an education.

You could put all your salary into your pension or save for university fees. You are not rolling in it and there is a huge opportunity cost to spending your whole salary on something that is available for free in the state sector...

So, what are you actually buying?

DickMabutt73962 · 11/12/2021 20:18

@OnceuponaRainbow18

Quite an insensitive thread.

Try being the poor one in a state school…!

You are not obliged to open the thread or read it
FreedomFaith · 11/12/2021 20:17

BINGO!

Knew 'girls' and 'bitchy' would come up

I hope you don't mean teenage girls aren't bitchy and it's just a stereotype. They are all bitchy, we all were at that age. Grin