Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if our children would be the ‘poor’ ones at private school

658 replies

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 19:56

DH and I have a good joint income of over £100,000 and I’m seriously considering private school for our children.

A worry for me is if they are surrounded by children from much wealthier backgrounds if they would feel ‘poor’. I’m just posting for thoughts from people who know a bit more about the independent system than me.

OP posts:
BlueShirtGirl · 11/12/2021 21:48

I think some are giving you an unnecessary hard time OP!
I’ve limited experience of private myself but round here it’s about £1k a month which is a lot considering we’re in a low wage area but friends who’s DC’s attend the only private school say there’s a huge mix of local children and international and that’s where the wealth divide is tbh. Most kids are nice but you always get the odd one or two and they say it’s more about teaching your children to choose friends wisely.
And I think that’s true if you attend state or private! Good luck.

gattey · 11/12/2021 21:47

Well I'm not going to out myself but you can list your employment history....

I never said the majority had an income of 110k as thats dependent on the location & fees but many parents are not rolling in it.

DeepaBeesKit · 11/12/2021 21:47

Your monthly income doesnt only need to cover the mortgage.

It needs to cover rising costs of food, transport, council tax, a phone/internet connection, gas, water and electricity. Having savings for home repairs, emergencies, buying clothes for you all, gifts.

Remember that salaries tend not to rise so meteorically in the second half of your career as the first.

Look at your bank balance. How much do you have spare every month now. Will it cover it, comfortably? Or are you relying on major lifestyle cut backs?

No one is saying you can't afford it, on paper. They are saying the impact it would have on your family budget would be much more significant than most families that afford private.

dollbaby868 · 11/12/2021 21:46

Why are people saying this post is insensitive?? Is it the OPs fault that so many of us are poor? Obviously not.

This is an open forum for everyone to use, not just poor people so the majority of posters are able to relate. If you don't have anything to add why comment just to take the piss. It's so childish

Pumperthepumper · 11/12/2021 21:46

@Changethefloorthroughout

How do you KNOW parental income just from working there though Pumper?

Actually don’t tell me … I don’t think I want to know! I’m smelling something goady.

Because I worked there. What’s the goady answer?
TheGarbageManCan · 11/12/2021 21:46

We are similar income and one child at a small independent, fees around £10k/year and recently paid off mortgage. I am v much working class. DH was privately educated but this was sought out for a number of reasons, it wasn’t a given for them or in the family.

We are definitely at the lower and of the scale in terms of wealth within our class, but as with any school setting it’s the luck of the draw in most senses. In just over 4 terms (through covid) I’ve realised that we have a great bunch of kids and they play with who they like. A couple of the mums are arses/cliquey, but you’d get that in any setting. A couple are snooty/aloof, but I don’t let it get to me. One of the most wealthy mums is the most lovely and I adore her, she’s a really nice person. Many families have planned skiing holidays this Christmas, but for many reasons (and money not being one) it’s not our bag. I very much try not to “conform”, we just do us and that’s all I expect of others. But I know there’s at least some “keeping up with the Jones’s” going on.

I know we’re not the poorest. But equally I know that our finances are solid, and I wonder sometimes if some of these families are building a house of cards. But at the same time I try not to think about it too often, mostly because it’s none of my business.

I am aware that at some point DD may ask why our house is smaller than some of her friends. But equally we have a lot of friends out of the independant school setting and I think it’s really important for us to continue to have that diversity, plus the parents of all her non school friends are my mates!

I think if you know you can afford it, then it’s a fabulous opportunity. However, in my limited experience (DD is young) the biggest differences are resources; like arts and crafts and iPads/technology and books, and the staff ratios are exceptional.

If we had 2 DC there would be no way we could afford it without sacrifices (and two hypothetical kids would really have been the “poor” ones), so I would have gone down the state route but supplemented more with tutors and clubs as that would have been more feasible.

sparklytriceratops · 11/12/2021 21:46

@igglepigglegingin

OP this is entirely dependent on where you are. If the state secondary schools are poor in your area you will find families of all walks of life in the classroom with your children - if the private school is nearby to an excellent school state system, potentially not so much.

My children attend private school in an area of fantastic primary and shocking state provision. The result is a huge intake at secondary.

Your salary, in the north for a good independent is fine. And your kids will be fine.

This is the most accurate post on this thread.
Toastfiendish · 11/12/2021 21:45

**This couldn't be further from the truth. The vast majority of the mums at my DDs school are professional women with busy careers who 'share' parenting - the school facilitates working parents with flexibility and amazing extra curricular programmes.

This is also completely the case where I work. Actually, I worked in a state school where a lot less of the mums worked and there was an amazingly active parents' association as it was just a very different sort of area. Private schools often have great wrap around care in primary (I'm not sure what age OP's children are) which I think is probably is a factor in parents choosing those schools.

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 21:45

How do you KNOW parental income just from working there though Pumper?

Actually don’t tell me … I don’t think I want to know! I’m smelling something goady.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 11/12/2021 21:44

@gattey

That was in response to a pp saying loads of people on that income send their kids private. They don’t.

Don't they, based on what? The private schools I've worked in have had a real mix, the majority imo aren't multi millionaires.

Which private schools have you worked in? I doubt you’ve worked in many with a majority of parents having an income of 110k combined.
gagababy · 11/12/2021 21:44

@Girlmum2020

Depends a lot on where in Uk you are, and what the school is like. There is a lot of variety!! We have similar income level to you and our dd goes to local independent in the north. We don’t live in a mansion and she does visit some amazing houses which doesn’t bother us. I think it’s not bad for her to understand that everybody has different backgrounds. We always emphasise to her that we are much better off than a lot of people so it’s all relative. A lot of the families at the school are hard working professionals who are not from wealthy backgrounds originally (often offspring of immigrant parents) so actually she sees a lot of inspirational people which I think is healthy. We are not alone, there are others in similar houses/ jobs to us and we haven’t found anybody looking down at us.
Love this
janet8 · 11/12/2021 21:44

Honestly, this forum is ridiculous.

gattey · 11/12/2021 21:43

That was in response to a pp saying loads of people on that income send their kids private. They don’t.

Don't they, based on what? The private schools I've worked in have had a real mix, the majority imo aren't multi millionaires.

gattey · 11/12/2021 21:42

@icedcoffees I can't keep up!

Fomofo · 11/12/2021 21:42

'Silly and distracting', sorry ma'am

Pumperthepumper · 11/12/2021 21:42

@gattey

But you asked if they’d be amongst the less wealthy, and with 30% of your combined salaries going on school fees, they would be.

It depends on the school & location imo.

"Because it’s too high a percentage to make the risk worth it. For example, what happens if one of you can no longer work? What happens if one of you is made redundant?"

This certainly implies that you don't think the OP can afford it.

That was in response to a pp saying loads of people on that income send their kids private. They don’t.
Botsicle · 11/12/2021 21:42

Gross salaries are helpful as a ballpark, but don't deduct fees from them to give your remaining income; you won't be paying fees from gross pay (exception below!)
Fwiw my DH worked at a fab indie school near us with similar fees; we also have a similar income to you (135k ish) and we'd look at sending ours there. Would be a squeeze paying both sets for five years when they overlap but our mortgage is quite low so it's doable. If I could get him to go back and teach there, the fees would be paid from his gross pay!

Girlmum2020 · 11/12/2021 21:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request due to concerns.

gattey · 11/12/2021 21:41

But you asked if they’d be amongst the less wealthy, and with 30% of your combined salaries going on school fees, they would be.

It depends on the school & location imo.

"Because it’s too high a percentage to make the risk worth it. For example, what happens if one of you can no longer work? What happens if one of you is made redundant?"

This certainly implies that you don't think the OP can afford it.

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 21:40

No I know what you mean Sleepy. I’ve experienced similar. It’s a feeling of being out of sync or out of place, I think. I’m sorry you went through that Flowers

OP posts:
igglepigglegingin · 11/12/2021 21:39

@time2tork

In my experience, barely any private school mums work, they are hugely involved with the school, always volunteering and making things amazing for the children.

If your the parent who is busy with life or working then in my experience I was made to feel like I didn't care about my kids!!

All the other Mums LIVED at the school.

Just thought I'd mention if your having to work to pay for the school.

This couldn't be further from the truth. The vast majority of the mums at my DDs school are professional women with busy careers who 'share' parenting - the school facilitates working parents with flexibility and amazing extra curricular programmes.
CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 11/12/2021 21:39

[quote Changethefloorthroughout]@Pumperthepumper yes, I remember.

In this hypothetical world, I am dead and my £40k salary is no more and all DH has his his - 75000.

and he has no life insurance

or pension payout

or death in service benefit for me

all he has is his own salary, of £75000 or £54,000 in real terms.

54 minus 28 is 26.

then the mortgage which is £10000

so £16,000 left.

so even though I have died so thoroughly that he hasn’t been able to access any of the hundreds of thousands of pounds he’d actually get if I died, he could actually still manage to afford it, pay the mortgage, and have £1300 for other bills and so on, and you’re still adamant this is unaffordable.

It’s getting really daft now and it’s distracting me from other helpful posts.[/quote]
Your hypothetical sadly widowed DH who inexplicably hasn't been able to access your death in service payout etc has more money left after he's paid the school fees and mortgage than I have before I've paid any bills! So I think you'll be fine.

I've got friends who were the "poor ones" at private school. They were fine. Maybe because being friends with even less well off people outside of school (ie me) let them see their relative privilege.

Sleepyquest · 11/12/2021 21:39

I have been the poor one at private school and it was horrible. Not because the pupils were mean or anything. It's hard to explain.
However you are far better off than my family were

Changethefloorthroughout · 11/12/2021 21:38

I’m not trying to do that @Fomofo, but I don’t think there’s anything to be gained by endlessly posting facts and figures over and over and then ‘yes but what if …’ - it gets silly. And distracting.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 11/12/2021 21:38

@Changethefloorthroughout and again, I’m not saying you can’t afford it. Hang on, I’ll write it out properly:

YOU CAN AFFORD PRIVATE SCHOOL FOR YOUR TWO CHILDREN

But you asked if they’d be amongst the less wealthy, and with 30% of your combined salaries going on school fees, they would be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread