Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that I might lose my British citizenship one day because of the new law going through parliament?

438 replies

flashbac · 11/12/2021 14:03

I was born here and so was one parent.

There is a Bill that has just been passed, while we were all distracted with shenanigans with parties and what not, that will allow citizenship to be revoked without notice.

I know the power to remove citizenship already exists but the without notice bit is quite scary. I assume that means someone could happily go about their business until they need to show right to be in the UK e.g new job or new rental and then poof, they can't access things and possibly get detained and then deported when they enquire about it and it's probably too late to contest it through the courts.

I know the responses will indicate how so many don't care, "don't do anything naughty then and they won't put you in the naughty bin ready to be turfed off to another land" but remember the right to protest, to give an example of how easy it will be to get on the wrong side of the authorities, will also be outlawed soon so anyone could be arrested, if the circumstances meant a person was driven to it, e.g you do a sit down protest outside a hospital because they covered up malpractice or, it's decided that a huge Amazon warehouse is built in the field behind your garden and you wanted to protest with your neighbours.

Lots of people will think this only affects 'foriners' so probably won't care. I think it's awful.

OP posts:
wasthataburp · 12/12/2021 12:19

I did know about this and also the law re protesting etc. It's terrible that important things thing like this can happen without anyone even noticing. All anyone cares about is what is on the bbc news or whatever.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:14

@RandomLondoner

You don't have to have citizenship somewhere, you just need to be eligible for it.

I have two genuine questions: is there always, in law, a distinction between being eligible for a citizenship and having it? And if so, can you not renounce your right to citizenship, in the same way you can renounce the citizenship?

(I was born abroad, and grew up thinking of myself as citizen of that country who could claim British Citizenship due to a British father, but when the time came, I discovered that being entitled to British citizenship by ancestry meant I had always been British, in law, and "applying" just meant proving this so I could get a passport.)

I think you are probably right that there will be cases where you cannot renounce another citizenship. But there will be cases where you can, so my post will still help some of those people. (I never thought it would be helpful to everyone, as of course some people genuinely won't want to lose their other citizenship.)

(I guess I know that there is sometimes a distinction in law between a right to apply and having citizenship, as I know from threads on here that you can have the right to a citizenship at birth which you lose if nothing has been done to cement your claim by the time you are an adult.)

I don't know how other countries view it but I know someone who married someone from another country and applied for citizenship when they moved to that country. The problem was she needed to renounced British citizenship as the country did not allow dual nationality. She talked to the British Embassy and they told her not to worry about it, she could renounced her British Citizenship but if she changed her mind and applied for a new passport she'd get one as they wouldn't enforce it.

I have no idea if the advice she got was correct but that was what she was told and when her marriage ended in divorce she did indeed get a new British passport.

Don't know how other countries would apply it.

PAFMO · 12/12/2021 12:13

@ancientgran

Not everything that happened in WWII is about the Jews and I've been to Auschwitz too, doesn't give me or Starcup any special powers. What happened to them is truly awful but they weren't the only ones they came for, they also came for the disabled, the socialists, the Jehovah's Witnesses, homosexuals, gypsies and anyone who just happened to disagree with them. The Holocaust is generally used as a term to refer to the murder of six million Jews but the issue is bigger than that and Niemoller's word are appropriate to other horrors e.g. the Soviet regime that also killed millions.

However the International Jewish community feel the horror and tragedy of WWII is not their's alone.

Niemoller, who wrote First they came for, was not a Jew but he spent 7 years in a concentration camp. In his quoted speech he does not just speak of the Holocaust, he is speaking of the danger of ignoring things because they don't directly affect you which is what some of us are emphasising.

The point of "First they came for" is not that any step will automatically affect Jews (although as has been pointed out Jews will be one of the ethnic groups at risk from this proposed law change) or that it will lead to Auschwitz, the point is that if we ignore these steps they can lead to a totalitarian regime.

Stripping people of their nationality is nothing like covid rules.

I didn't say it was. I said the international Jewish community is currently begging people to stop comparing everything to the Holocaust.

Are you saying they shouldn't?

ldontWanna · 12/12/2021 12:12

@Starcup what's ignorant is not acknowledging how vulnerable people are and how reliant they are on the government of the day to do the right thing.

Have you ever lived through a change of regime so radical that doing the right and moral thing became illegal? That a respected career and intellectuals were viewed with suspicion and were cause for concern? That you had to spy on your brother and telling him could mean losing your job,home or worse your life? That having a cousin in a certain country meant being looked at under a microscope or your job at risk, even if you never met them? That marrying a man with a certain job meant your life scrutinised to every single detail, including interviews with neighbours in your home town and your primary teachers? That a malicious accusation was enough to be carted off in the middle of the night and the best case scenario is JUST a beating? I could go on.

That's where the true ignorance lies. The refusal to accept that it has happened all over the world and it could happen here too. Not one of those countries thought it could happen to them, they didn't even realise it was happening in the beginning. It still did and it will happen again. Whether it'll be in the UK too no one knows. It is extremely ignorant though to claim it never will based simply on wishful thinking.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:10

Not everything that happened in WWII is about the Jews and I've been to Auschwitz too, doesn't give me or Starcup any special powers. What happened to them is truly awful but they weren't the only ones they came for, they also came for the disabled, the socialists, the Jehovah's Witnesses, homosexuals, gypsies and anyone who just happened to disagree with them. The Holocaust is generally used as a term to refer to the murder of six million Jews but the issue is bigger than that and Niemoller's word are appropriate to other horrors e.g. the Soviet regime that also killed millions.

However the International Jewish community feel the horror and tragedy of WWII is not their's alone.

Niemoller, who wrote First they came for, was not a Jew but he spent 7 years in a concentration camp. In his quoted speech he does not just speak of the Holocaust, he is speaking of the danger of ignoring things because they don't directly affect you which is what some of us are emphasising.

The point of "First they came for" is not that any step will automatically affect Jews (although as has been pointed out Jews will be one of the ethnic groups at risk from this proposed law change) or that it will lead to Auschwitz, the point is that if we ignore these steps they can lead to a totalitarian regime.

Stripping people of their nationality is nothing like covid rules.

RandomLondoner · 12/12/2021 12:09

You don't have to have citizenship somewhere, you just need to be eligible for it.

I have two genuine questions: is there always, in law, a distinction between being eligible for a citizenship and having it? And if so, can you not renounce your right to citizenship, in the same way you can renounce the citizenship?

(I was born abroad, and grew up thinking of myself as citizen of that country who could claim British Citizenship due to a British father, but when the time came, I discovered that being entitled to British citizenship by ancestry meant I had always been British, in law, and "applying" just meant proving this so I could get a passport.)

I think you are probably right that there will be cases where you cannot renounce another citizenship. But there will be cases where you can, so my post will still help some of those people. (I never thought it would be helpful to everyone, as of course some people genuinely won't want to lose their other citizenship.)

(I guess I know that there is sometimes a distinction in law between a right to apply and having citizenship, as I know from threads on here that you can have the right to a citizenship at birth which you lose if nothing has been done to cement your claim by the time you are an adult.)

Meadowbreeze · 12/12/2021 12:03

I'm starting to Think starcup is Pritis Mumsnet name 🙈

I just hope all of the posters who are so sure the government won't abuse it have no family members who this could effect. Yup, this has been a law for a long time, however it's never been the case that you're not informed of this happening.
Also, together with the new policing bill, the definition of a terrorist is completely different to what these posters are going on about.
And EVEN if it wasn't. The whole point is, the citizenship is now two class, the second being so low that you don't even get to know when you've been stripped of it.

Its really quite worrying that some of these posters seem to think that people who hold dual citizenship want terrorists? Are you really that short sighted.
Renouncing your other citizenship makes zero difference. Please read the post before commenting, there's actually some very informative posters on here.

LostForIdeas · 12/12/2021 11:55

@RandomLondoner

I may have a solution for people worried about this, though it won't suit everyone. Renounce your foreign citizenship first. It's true that they can't deprive you of citizenship if you don't have another to fall back on.

(Shamima Begum is a controversial case that is atypical. I think what happened is that she potentially had two citizenships, but had to actively claim one by a certain age, and they cancelled her British citizenship just in time to beat the cut-off. So she may have ended up stateless, but she wasn't made stateless at the price moment her British citizenship was removed, therefore it wasn't unlawful. I think it was effectively Bangladesh's age cut-off for claiming citizenship that ultimately rendered her stateless, in a scenario that the law-makers had not anticipated.)

It doesn’t matter.

My dcs are on paper eligible for the French citizenship and therefore the law would apply. Whether they could get ut is a different matter (esp if they had renounced it).

The case of S Begum is actually a case in point. The government had no idea at the time of whether she would or not be able to claim that citizenship. Or whether sh was going to be successful. Whether she has been or not is a different issue (Google doesn’t seem to be able to answer that question so I’m surprised you know for sure she is now a citizen of Bangladesh).

Basically the British government was and is happy to take the risk of someone ending up stateless even though it’s illegal for the British government to do so….

Plus of course, this was a different law altogether and the really big issue here is that people are stripped of their citizenship WITHOUT BEING TOLD ABOUT IT.
Cue discovering that when you want to go back into the country or if you want to prove you can get healthcare on the NHS (remember Windrush and people who died because they couldn’t get access the healthcare?) etc etc

PAFMO · 12/12/2021 11:55

My second paragraph not to the OP but to the followers of Godwin.

PAFMO · 12/12/2021 11:54

@flashbac

Did you protest about it on 1/1/1983 when the BNA 81 came into force containing exactly the same legislation?

No, as I was a child and, circumstances were different then. In any case, there was always the right to appeal. This won't apply going forward as no information or even notice will be given before they take away your citizenship.

That's not true. You have no idea of the hoops the Home Office has to go through before deprivation would ever be considered. Look at how long Begum managed to hang on to hers.

The international Jewish community is already begging people to stop comparing everything to the Holocaust. Anti-Semitism is on the rise and being fed still further by these lazy comparisons. Principally with regard to Covid and mandatory measures but it doesn't take a huge leap to extrapolate the ludicrous comparison here too. It really needs to stop. Please read what the international Jewish community leaders are saying about this.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2021 11:43

Your clearly not aware of the history of how Auschwitz concentration camp came into being @Starcup. It started with a wee law that disproportionately affected some people, including Jews. And sure nobody had to worry as long as they didn't do anything wrong.Xmas Hmm

RuggerHug · 12/12/2021 11:39

@RandomLondoner

I may have a solution for people worried about this, though it won't suit everyone. Renounce your foreign citizenship first. It's true that they can't deprive you of citizenship if you don't have another to fall back on.

(Shamima Begum is a controversial case that is atypical. I think what happened is that she potentially had two citizenships, but had to actively claim one by a certain age, and they cancelled her British citizenship just in time to beat the cut-off. So she may have ended up stateless, but she wasn't made stateless at the price moment her British citizenship was removed, therefore it wasn't unlawful. I think it was effectively Bangladesh's age cut-off for claiming citizenship that ultimately rendered her stateless, in a scenario that the law-makers had not anticipated.)

RandomLondoner You've missed the point. You don't have to have citizenship somewhere, you just need to be eligible for it.
Starcup · 12/12/2021 11:29

@TooBigForMyBoots

Oh please, the same old argument. It really is getting boring now.

And I think it’s beyond disgusting when people suggest it’s similar to the Holocaust. That’s absolutely atrocious and shouldn’t ever be brought up in the same sentence for god sake. Disgusting.*

You should have a wee look at history and how the Holocaust came about @Starcup.

Believe me, I know. I’ve been to Auschwitz and to compare what went on there to the new bill coming in to prevent terrorism is beyond ignorant.
RandomLondoner · 12/12/2021 11:18

I may have a solution for people worried about this, though it won't suit everyone. Renounce your foreign citizenship first. It's true that they can't deprive you of citizenship if you don't have another to fall back on.

(Shamima Begum is a controversial case that is atypical. I think what happened is that she potentially had two citizenships, but had to actively claim one by a certain age, and they cancelled her British citizenship just in time to beat the cut-off. So she may have ended up stateless, but she wasn't made stateless at the price moment her British citizenship was removed, therefore it wasn't unlawful. I think it was effectively Bangladesh's age cut-off for claiming citizenship that ultimately rendered her stateless, in a scenario that the law-makers had not anticipated.)

flashbac · 12/12/2021 11:17

Did you protest about it on 1/1/1983 when the BNA 81 came into force containing exactly the same legislation?

No, as I was a child and, circumstances were different then. In any case, there was always the right to appeal. This won't apply going forward as no information or even notice will be given before they take away your citizenship.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2021 11:15

Oh please, the same old argument. It really is getting boring now.

And I think it’s beyond disgusting when people suggest it’s similar to the Holocaust. That’s absolutely atrocious and shouldn’t ever be brought up in the same sentence for god sake. Disgusting.*

You should have a wee look at history and how the Holocaust came about @Starcup.

Starcup · 12/12/2021 11:03

@Graphista

It seems daily we are edging towards becoming a fascist state!

Wtf!

As for the yabu voters not commenting I'm guessing not wanting to admit they're xenophobes/racists!

Which also applies to the govt! If they're so sure such a bill is right and fair then WHY ARE THEY HIDING IT AWAY?!

Same applies to the police and crime etc bill - it's an APPALLING bill clearly specifically designed to stifle ANY dissent at all!

I'm a Glaswegian and in the city centre are street preachers and protesters most days certainly weekends and they are part of our culture! This bill would criminalise those people who are basically harmless and often mentally ill.

Indeed it will criminalise ANYONE who publicly voiced dissent.

Quite honestly I don't think it will be long until there's a similar bill applying to electronic protests - like this forum!

It would give this obviously xenophobic govt the perfect EXCUSE to remove certain dissenters!

This is honestly getting more like a nazi or ussr type state we're living in! Terrifying!

I say all this as someone unlikely to be personally affected by the bill but who considers such laws outrageous and unacceptable and not what Britain stands for!

@gogohm but they're ALSO basically making it a crime to say anything negative about the govt or other "authorities" in public spaces!

On a separate bill they're also trying to keep as quiet as possible!

Though frankly whenever something like this comes up (and it's happening more and more frequently!) I keep finding myself thinking "what the actual fuck are our supposed journalists playing at?!" There seem to be only a few who are willingly sticking their necks out to alert us to the horror that is this govt! And none of the major media players have the balls to say anything!

Anyone notice the change in the petition responses? Over 100,000 will CONSIDER for a debate? I'm pretty sure it used to be it was definitely debated at that point ? Or a higher number? It's got over 200,000 signatures

People who say it won't apply to ordinary folk, they're all small steps to the same destination.

Exactly!

Just behave yourself and you’ll be fine!

Well "behave yourself" is rapidly becoming "never DARE to say anything critical about the uk or it's govt" do you seriously think that's acceptable in a supposed democracy!?!

Personally I think "it only matters if you have dual citizenship" is a callous, ignorant and xenophobic response!

Calls to mind (and I really don't care that I'm invoking Godwin's law TWICE in one post!) niemöllers poem.

I'm alright jack responses - shame on those if you that have said this!

The more they do this crap the more ashamed I am to be British! Bigoted arseholes!

@oatmilk4breakfast who are the best ones to write to in the lords on this? I have found this difficult to assess as lords don't have constituency areas like mps but it's best writing to the ones most likely to speak out and make a difference hopefully persuade others to reject awful bills like this

Don’t see the issue. You aren’t going to have your citizenship revoked for a parking fine are you?

Well aren't you LUCKY not to have a reason to be worried by this. I'm guessing you are white, at least 4th gen British and relatively well off?

I really wouldn't put that past this govt! Honestly. Esp if the person with the parking fine is also not white and especially if they're an outspoken activist

This is designed to silence dissenters!

We are allowing this govt to tell us how to THINK certainly how to express our thoughts!

Fuck me 1984 coming to life!

but this new law specifically relates to those who break the law particularly in relation to terrorism

They're REDEFINING terrorism with another bill too hardly a coincidence!

@Wannakisstheteacher do you SERIOUSLY think the holocaust happened out of the clear blue yonder?!

Of course it didn't!

The German govt GRADUALLY enacted various laws that were biased against certain groups esp Jews this was designed to make the population think they were "law breakers" "anti German" etc which over time made it easier and easier to demonise, vilify... and then massacre them!

Deeply insulting and offensive post to Jews and others massacred in the holocaust that you can't or rather won't understand that

How far on the road to fascism and dictatorship do we need to be before calling it out for what it is?

Exactly!

Discrimination by the state doesn't happen overnight! It's a boiling frog situation

Anti terrorism laws have been being abused since they came in! And I'm not just talking post 9/11 they've been used against those of Irish descent, those campaigning for nuclear disarmament, those campaigning for animal rights... the history of this happening in the uk goes WAY back

"You've nothing to worry about if you've done nothing wrong"

Guildford 4
Judith ward
Winston silcott
Birmingham 6...

And that's just fairly recent history!

Yea the British have a GREAT history of unbiased justice system and terrorism and how they treat dissenters NOT!

Not everything you dislike can be compared to the Holocaust.

No but in this case it is ABSOLUTELY appropriate!

This is a way of othering and denigrating people who aren't at least 4th gen British! How is that ok?! How is that not a fascist attitude?!

Nobody is saying the conclusion (the holocaust) will be the same but the dehumanisation of people ('cockroaches', let them drown' etc) has already started happening so it's only right to learn lessons from the past and feel concerned about it. Nobody is making light of the holocaust here.

Exactly

The power for them to revoke citizenship has already been enshrined in law but now they want to do it WITHOUT NOTICE which begs the question: why? So you can't contest it that's why.

No truly democratic legal system should ever have such a law

The right of reply is KEY in a democracy

@LiterallyKnowsBest I honestly wouldn't blame any of you! Why should you remain and work and contribute and pay taxes when you are treated like this!

Wondering if you could all organise a strike? That could prove interesting say the first main day back to work after the Christmas and Hogmanay break the first Monday perhaps drive home how valuable you are to this country! All the 1st to 3rd gens who are healthcare workers, teachers, transport workers, retail workers etc I think it would be quite something!

Did you watch the original Shameless? Frank says a version of what you said about how if every immigrant downed tools for 1 day, the entire system and country would fall apart. Your both absolutely right.

I've not seen this show as didn't think it was my sense of humour I may try it now!

Frank is bloody right! Britain is BUILT on immigrants and their descendants.

I'm 4th generation 3 of my great grandparents being Irish. The 4th of Nordic descent we believe

I'm old so I remember Adrian mole and in one of those books I remember he was talking to a Tory Mp who was standing for "send them all back home" crap and Adrian apparently or it might have been his dad calculated that if everyone in Britain who wasn't pure Anglo Saxon blood left there'd be one person left!!

Well I’m pretty sure you could go to the European courts of human rights not any more!

or British courts of humans rights….

No such thing

Sarcasm? Can't tell

*As for the yabu voters not commenting I'm guessing not wanting to admit they're xenophobes/racists*

Oh please, the same old argument. It really is getting boring now.

And I think it’s beyond disgusting when people suggest it’s similar to the Holocaust. That’s absolutely atrocious and shouldn’t ever be brought up in the same sentence for god sake. Disgusting.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2021 10:49

Did you protest about it on 1/1/1983 when the BNA 81 came into force containing exactly the same legislation?

In 1983 I was 10 years old and already aware that my government considered me and my completely law abiding family troublemakers. I wasn't allowed to go to protests in 1983 in case I was detained or killed by the government.

flashbac · 12/12/2021 10:18

@Kendodd

People who think this (and all the other baby steps) is nothing should read a bit of history.

The Nazi's were voted into power and had mass support, their actions were a series of small steps. The people who supported them were just like us, they weren't monsters, they were probably very nice and made lovely, do anything for you, neighbours . They just wanted a better life for their children and to feel safer and the (as they saw it) unfairness in life, corrected.

Yes. This.
OP posts:
ancientgran · 12/12/2021 09:41

@TooBigForMyBoots

Don’t be so OTT dramatic. Do you think it’s about you? And the average law abiding citizen? Don’t be ridiculous.

Any average law abiding citizen can find itself under suspicion, this bill is broad enough to cover that. Also, the government don't have to tell you!🤯 You could go on holiday and come back to find your citizenship stripped from you and barred from entering your own country.😲😲😲

This is so true. I worked for a large police force in the 70s/80s. I happened to work in an office that was on the same corridor as the Anti Terrorist Squad. I have dual nationality, British/Irish, I had a name that was easily identified as Irish. I have ginger hair and freckles and many people will say I look Irish.

So one of the women I worked with took me aside one day to tell me that an officer from ATS had been asking questions about me. He thought it was "suspicious" that I'd applied for a job on that corridor and he'd seen me in certain Irish clubs known for IRA affiliations.

I was horrified, when I applied for an admin job I had no idea where it would be in a multi storey building, I was a young mum and rarely went out as I couldn't afford it and didn't have childcare and finally I'd never been in an Irish club. I married as a teenager, my husband was English, I am teetotal and going to a drinking club didn't appeal to me. I've never been in a nightclub and generally the only pubs I've been in area steak houses where I've had a meal but the point was he told people he'd seen me in those clubs which was not true.

I applied for a transfer and went to work in a police station local to me but I have no idea what that officer did, he might have been watching me, he might have investigated my background but whatever he suspected me of was based on nothing.

For all I know there is a file on me somewhere containing his "evidence" and his suspicions.

ldontWanna · 12/12/2021 09:38

@Nyz9213

Suppose it depends if you’re intending to commit serious crimes or not.
Can you guarantee 100% what will be considered a serious crime in 5 years? 10? 20? 50? Can you guarantee 100% that no mistakes or fuckups will be made? That no government or Secretary of State or whatever paper stamper will use this to further their own agenda?
Kendodd · 12/12/2021 09:27

Suppose it depends if you’re intending to commit serious crimes or not

And if you're not deemed foreign.

boogiewithasuitcase · 12/12/2021 09:23

@Nyz9213

Suppose it depends if you’re intending to commit serious crimes or not.
Well it will partly depend on what the Government classes as a serious crime. I wouldn't be surprised if that there are some who think that demonstrating peacefully against the Government is serious enough to warrant a loss of citizenship.
FlowerArranger · 12/12/2021 09:21

@Nyz9213

Suppose it depends if you’re intending to commit serious crimes or not.
I am truly appalled by the above and other comments made on this thread who cannot see the problem with this proposed bill.

Are 3 out of 10 British citizens really okay with the idea of 2-tier citizenship?

Having First Class and Second Class citizenship for different kinds of Brits?

Being treated differently under the law, depending on your families origins?

Knowing that most of the Second Class Brits will be non-whites?

I am hoping that most of those who clicked on YABU did not really think this through. Because if they did and still approve of this bill, it is truly frightening.

Kendodd · 12/12/2021 09:03

People who think this (and all the other baby steps) is nothing should read a bit of history.

The Nazi's were voted into power and had mass support, their actions were a series of small steps. The people who supported them were just like us, they weren't monsters, they were probably very nice and made lovely, do anything for you, neighbours . They just wanted a better life for their children and to feel safer and the (as they saw it) unfairness in life, corrected.

Swipe left for the next trending thread