Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that I might lose my British citizenship one day because of the new law going through parliament?

438 replies

flashbac · 11/12/2021 14:03

I was born here and so was one parent.

There is a Bill that has just been passed, while we were all distracted with shenanigans with parties and what not, that will allow citizenship to be revoked without notice.

I know the power to remove citizenship already exists but the without notice bit is quite scary. I assume that means someone could happily go about their business until they need to show right to be in the UK e.g new job or new rental and then poof, they can't access things and possibly get detained and then deported when they enquire about it and it's probably too late to contest it through the courts.

I know the responses will indicate how so many don't care, "don't do anything naughty then and they won't put you in the naughty bin ready to be turfed off to another land" but remember the right to protest, to give an example of how easy it will be to get on the wrong side of the authorities, will also be outlawed soon so anyone could be arrested, if the circumstances meant a person was driven to it, e.g you do a sit down protest outside a hospital because they covered up malpractice or, it's decided that a huge Amazon warehouse is built in the field behind your garden and you wanted to protest with your neighbours.

Lots of people will think this only affects 'foriners' so probably won't care. I think it's awful.

OP posts:
Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:55

@ancientgran

Starcup are you entitled to Irish citizenship? You will also have 2nd class citizenship if you are.
Yes exactly and guess what….. I’m not stressing about it like so many on here, that’s the point!!
Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:54

@RuggerHug

Starcup Why are you deliberately ignoring everyone giving examples of what has happened before? You might be of "Irish descent" but you clearly never listened to anyone in your family that dealt with the shit in the last century from government bodies.
I don’t create a drama about something that is out of my control. What you going to gain from moaning in here? Do you think it will change anything?
ancientgran · 12/12/2021 13:52

Starcup are you entitled to Irish citizenship? You will also have 2nd class citizenship if you are.

Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:52

The people who are bringing up the holocaust are the people moaning about bringing up the holocaust

Wrong. To compare it to suffering of millions of people is just so wrong on so many levels.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 13:51

[quote PAFMO]@RandomLondoner

"I have two genuine questions: is there always, in law, a distinction between being eligible for a citizenship and having it? And if so, can you not renounce your right to citizenship, in the same way you can renounce the citizenship?"

The two often overlap but are not totally the same. For example, there are several clauses in BNA81 which (as you said) allow the children of British Citizens born abroad and who are not automatically British themselves, to apply to be registered as BCs. They have an entitlement to citizenship, and if an application is received and all the criteria are met, then the citizenship is given. As far as I know there would be nothing in law necessary for anyone to renounce the right to apply to have that entitlement (iyswim) you just wouldn't apply to obtain it. Similarly, you can't renounce your citizenship without providing proof that you have another one. If anyone applied for British Citizenship and is found to have already been British (happens quite a lot, especially with children born abroad) then they are informed- and there's no possibility to "upgrade" as it were by obtaining a "better" citizenship (otherwise than by descent as opposed to "by descent" for example)

@ancientgran- the person you know was very definitely misinformed unless what she meant was that she could un-renounce at a later date. Once you've renounced, any passport is voided and should you try and travel on it it would be picked up the minute it was checked. All passports contain within them what's known as "status check" information, which is basically how the holder is a British national. She may have been misinformed, as an anomaly of the civil service is that it's the Home Office responsible for immigration and nationality law but consulates are staffed by the FO who don't have the same in-depth legislation training (for obvious reasons)[/quote]
I think reapplying for a passport was the unrenouncing. She definitely couldn't use her old passport. I might not have explained it well but I get your point about the consulate staff as she had more than one piece of bad advice as have her adult children.

RuggerHug · 12/12/2021 13:50

Starcup Why are you deliberately ignoring everyone giving examples of what has happened before? You might be of "Irish descent" but you clearly never listened to anyone in your family that dealt with the shit in the last century from government bodies.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 13:47

@Starcup

*The international Jewish community is already begging people to stop comparing everything to the Holocaust. Anti-Semitism is on the rise and being fed still further by these lazy comparisons. Principally with regard to Covid and mandatory measures but it doesn't take a huge leap to extrapolate the ludicrous comparison here too. It really needs to stop. Please read what the international Jewish community leaders are saying about this*

Absolutely this. Is disgusting that people continue to make the comparison. It’s an embarrassment and they should be ashamed of themselves for being so disrespectful.

The people who are bringing up the holocaust are the people moaning about bringing up the holocaust.
Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:45

[quote TooBigForMyBoots]@Starcup, the international Jewish community know all to well what can happen when they are appointed 2nd tier citizens. As am I.

Why do you think it's ok?[/quote]
I think you’re OTT about a government decision that will not impact you, ever. So what’s the point in stressing about it?

To add, I’m of Irish descent….

Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:43

@MaxNormal

Starcup the point is that isn't how it started. It's how it ended.
You’ll need to provide more that that
TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2021 13:43

@Starcup, the international Jewish community know all to well what can happen when they are appointed 2nd tier citizens. As am I.

Why do you think it's ok?

PAFMO · 12/12/2021 13:35

@RandomLondoner

"I have two genuine questions: is there always, in law, a distinction between being eligible for a citizenship and having it? And if so, can you not renounce your right to citizenship, in the same way you can renounce the citizenship?"

The two often overlap but are not totally the same. For example, there are several clauses in BNA81 which (as you said) allow the children of British Citizens born abroad and who are not automatically British themselves, to apply to be registered as BCs. They have an entitlement to citizenship, and if an application is received and all the criteria are met, then the citizenship is given. As far as I know there would be nothing in law necessary for anyone to renounce the right to apply to have that entitlement (iyswim) you just wouldn't apply to obtain it. Similarly, you can't renounce your citizenship without providing proof that you have another one. If anyone applied for British Citizenship and is found to have already been British (happens quite a lot, especially with children born abroad) then they are informed- and there's no possibility to "upgrade" as it were by obtaining a "better" citizenship (otherwise than by descent as opposed to "by descent" for example)

@ancientgran- the person you know was very definitely misinformed unless what she meant was that she could un-renounce at a later date. Once you've renounced, any passport is voided and should you try and travel on it it would be picked up the minute it was checked. All passports contain within them what's known as "status check" information, which is basically how the holder is a British national. She may have been misinformed, as an anomaly of the civil service is that it's the Home Office responsible for immigration and nationality law but consulates are staffed by the FO who don't have the same in-depth legislation training (for obvious reasons)

Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:35

@Meadowbreeze

I'm starting to Think starcup is Pritis Mumsnet name 🙈

I just hope all of the posters who are so sure the government won't abuse it have no family members who this could effect. Yup, this has been a law for a long time, however it's never been the case that you're not informed of this happening.
Also, together with the new policing bill, the definition of a terrorist is completely different to what these posters are going on about.
And EVEN if it wasn't. The whole point is, the citizenship is now two class, the second being so low that you don't even get to know when you've been stripped of it.

Its really quite worrying that some of these posters seem to think that people who hold dual citizenship want terrorists? Are you really that short sighted.
Renouncing your other citizenship makes zero difference. Please read the post before commenting, there's actually some very informative posters on here.

Talk about over dramatic….
MaxNormal · 12/12/2021 13:33

Starcup the point is that isn't how it started. It's how it ended.

Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:32

The international Jewish community is already begging people to stop comparing everything to the Holocaust. Anti-Semitism is on the rise and being fed still further by these lazy comparisons. Principally with regard to Covid and mandatory measures but it doesn't take a huge leap to extrapolate the ludicrous comparison here too. It really needs to stop. Please read what the international Jewish community leaders are saying about this

Absolutely this. Is disgusting that people continue to make the comparison. It’s an embarrassment and they should be ashamed of themselves for being so disrespectful.

Starcup · 12/12/2021 13:29

@TooBigForMyBoots

Your clearly not aware of the history of how Auschwitz concentration camp came into being *@Starcup*. It started with a wee law that disproportionately affected some people, including Jews. And sure nobody had to worry as long as they didn't do anything wrong.Xmas Hmm
Stop being so disrespectful by comparing it to one of the worst atrocities in history!
TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2021 13:20

My father was imprisoned and tortured by my government.Shock

As a young child, I would have to get my sister's coats on and go my grandmother's house after government forces had wrecked my home and taken my parents away.Sad

I was constantly harassed by government forces in my teens. But I didn't get it as bad as my male contemporaries who were subjected to violence and fitted up by my government.

30 years on and I still can't fly to mainland Britain without intrusive, time consuming, distressing for my children, security checks.

We are a law abiding family, I am a law abiding British citizen, all my grandparents and great grandparents were British, but our British government did this to us.

Meadowbreeze · 12/12/2021 12:27

@PAFMO I lost not only members of my family but also masses amounts of family memorabilia and priceless heirlooms in the Holocaust. My family were not Jews but another group the Gestapo went after. I feel I am able to bring this up thank you.

Anywho, the general problem with bringing up the Holocaust everywhere is the constant victimisation of Jews and other minorities. People make this comparison in day to day troubles and it is very disrespectful. That's what they'd like to stop, as would I.
This however is something the Jewish community is also worried about! It effects everyone and together with the new policing bill, is very very frightening when you or your family have lived through these sorts of things before. It always always starts small. Neither of these bills are small.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:26

@RandomLondoner

The Niemoller quote is valid. He is making the point that you have to defend the rights of other people, including groups you don't agree with, if you want to protect those rights for yourself.

That you don't believe the UK government and their intentions are in the any way comparable with Nazi Germany is irrelevant, that wasn't the point.

Much more succinct explanation. Thank you.
ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:25

I wonder how the British govt will react if other countries start doing the same? How many criminals in countries like Australia, New Zealand, Canada etc have a British gran or granddad? Will we be welcoming them back?

RandomLondoner · 12/12/2021 12:25

The Niemoller quote is valid. He is making the point that you have to defend the rights of other people, including groups you don't agree with, if you want to protect those rights for yourself.

That you don't believe the UK government and their intentions are in the any way comparable with Nazi Germany is irrelevant, that wasn't the point.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:23

@RandomLondoner

Lots of people have posted that you don't have to worry about this if you don't commit a serious crime. I don't think you have to commit any crime though, the government just has to want you gone.

I may be wrong, but I don't think Shamima Begum has been convicted of anything in the UK? I know she's not a good example, as everyone sees her as guilty, but the point is, you don't need to be guilty of a crime to have citizenship revoked.

I don't think she's been convicted of anything anywhere so your point is definitely correct.
sashh · 12/12/2021 12:23

As a person with disabilities I've been saying over the last few years that it is like living in 1930s Germany.

I see they are now going for other 'undesirables'.

As for, "It's only if you are a terrorist" I recommend Tom Sharpe's book set in South Africa.

Yes they are spoofs but based on the actual political situation.

It's a while since I read them but I remember someone arrested for 'terrorism - attempting to poison the drinking water' - they'd peed in a reservoir.

On the other hand the woman who tries to hand herself in for murdering her cook, the police tell her it isn't murder because the cook is black.

Actually you don't need to go as far as SA, have a look at the miner's strike and google Ricky Tomlinson.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:22

@wasthataburp

I did know about this and also the law re protesting etc. It's terrible that important things thing like this can happen without anyone even noticing. All anyone cares about is what is on the bbc news or whatever.
Or what affects them personally. I mean if I get deported to Ireland it won't be the end of me but if someone who is gay gets deported to Iran it might be the end of them, or if someone with one Chinese grandparent gets deported to China when they have no resources, can't speak the language and know nobody there it could be very disastrous for them. Let alone people who don't even get accepted by the relevant country. Where do they go? Are we going to have refugee camps somewhere for them?
RandomLondoner · 12/12/2021 12:22

Lots of people have posted that you don't have to worry about this if you don't commit a serious crime. I don't think you have to commit any crime though, the government just has to want you gone.

I may be wrong, but I don't think Shamima Begum has been convicted of anything in the UK? I know she's not a good example, as everyone sees her as guilty, but the point is, you don't need to be guilty of a crime to have citizenship revoked.

ancientgran · 12/12/2021 12:19

Are you saying they shouldn't? No the Holocaust is generally used to refer to the murder of six million Jews so they can say what they want about it as far as I'm concerned.

I'm saying what the Nazis did wasn't just the Holocaust of the Jews and therefore what a Christian minister wrote/said is not their's to control.

It is people objecting to references to the Niemoller who are saying I and others were referring to the Holocaust but I don't think anyone did, they linked it to a quote referencing the dangers of ignoring something that doesn't, at the moment, affect them because step one can lead to step two and maybe step three.

Swipe left for the next trending thread