Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that I might lose my British citizenship one day because of the new law going through parliament?

438 replies

flashbac · 11/12/2021 14:03

I was born here and so was one parent.

There is a Bill that has just been passed, while we were all distracted with shenanigans with parties and what not, that will allow citizenship to be revoked without notice.

I know the power to remove citizenship already exists but the without notice bit is quite scary. I assume that means someone could happily go about their business until they need to show right to be in the UK e.g new job or new rental and then poof, they can't access things and possibly get detained and then deported when they enquire about it and it's probably too late to contest it through the courts.

I know the responses will indicate how so many don't care, "don't do anything naughty then and they won't put you in the naughty bin ready to be turfed off to another land" but remember the right to protest, to give an example of how easy it will be to get on the wrong side of the authorities, will also be outlawed soon so anyone could be arrested, if the circumstances meant a person was driven to it, e.g you do a sit down protest outside a hospital because they covered up malpractice or, it's decided that a huge Amazon warehouse is built in the field behind your garden and you wanted to protest with your neighbours.

Lots of people will think this only affects 'foriners' so probably won't care. I think it's awful.

OP posts:
LostForIdeas · 11/12/2021 17:00

@Ace56, I disagree because

1- you have no idea how that law is going to be used. At the moment, it’s terrorism (and any other reason they might come up with, they dint have to tell you after all) and in 5 years time? What will it be?

2- comparaison with windrush is helpful. Because windrush is the prime example of incompetence and how little the British government cares about its own citizens. If they are able to make mistakes in that scale, what is telling you that they will not do it again? What’s preventing them? As I can see nothing for the simple reason that Windrush might have been forgotten now. But the attitude? Nope still the same. Second class citizen so not valuable and expandable.
As far as I am concerned, the lack of reaction for a big part of the British population has told me all I needed to know about how they see ‘immigrants’

Kendodd · 11/12/2021 16:59

Unfortunately, this will be hugely popular with the Brexit loving Tory supporters and they are the ones with all the power in this country now.
I'm truly ashamed to be British.

Meadowbreeze · 11/12/2021 16:57

@beatrixpotterspencil You are of course correct. I am just so sad. I feel like I'm living in the Truman show watching these bills get passed. It is not just about this immigration one.
It is scary how much trust and freedom people have handed to the state. I hope they all know we will not get this back.

Wannakisstheteacher · 11/12/2021 16:55

ancientgran

For all the people who think it will never be a problem for them.

First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

Yawn. Was waiting for one of these posts. Nope, not really anything like the Holocaust and the comparison makes you look deeply uneducated, ignorant and horribly offensive.

RedWingBoots · 11/12/2021 16:55

@Wannakisstheteacher

Don’t see the issue. You aren’t going to have your citizenship revoked for a parking fine are you? The crime that would preceded revocation would be serious enough that you couldn’t accidentally do it, you’d have willing committed an incredibly serious offence.
You have so much faith in this British government.
LostForIdeas · 11/12/2021 16:54

@Wannakisstheteacher

Don’t see the issue. You aren’t going to have your citizenship revoked for a parking fine are you? The crime that would preceded revocation would be serious enough that you couldn’t accidentally do it, you’d have willing committed an incredibly serious offence.
Once again…

Windrush?

Meadowbreeze · 11/12/2021 16:54

@BritWifeInUSA do you honestly believe that? The UK is breaking UN laws today! This is nothing new.
Are you implying the windrush generation were all massively dangerous criminals?
This country has a track record of being incredibly irresponsible and complacent when it comes to immigration law. I think it is wishful thinking that they wouldn't abuse this.

Ace56 · 11/12/2021 16:53

@LostForIdeas I am one of the people it can affect. I’m a dual national UK and EU citizen, born and bred in the UK Smile

The comparisons to Windrush are unhelpful. That was a terrible scandal, yes, but this new law specifically relates to those who break the law particularly in relation to terrorism. I’m not necessarily agreeing with it, I’m just Hmm at the number of posters who seem to think they or their children are in imminent danger of being booted out the country. What nonsense.

ancientgran · 11/12/2021 16:51

For all the people who think it will never be a problem for them.

First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

beatrixpotterspencil · 11/12/2021 16:50

@Meadowbreeze

I'm honestly envious of the blissful ignorance and blind trust of some of these posters.
Sadly ignorance is rarely bliss, it sows the seeds of prejudice and fear. It seems to be at the root of so many historical atrocities and paves the way for manipulation, social division and war. :(

I know what you mean though...

BritWifeInUSA · 11/12/2021 16:48

@LiterallyKnowsBest

Yes, I’m fully aware of all of that, BritWifeInUSA (both personally and otherwise), but I have absolutely no reason not to believe that this government would happily twist things for their own pleasure.
Then it would be a matter for UNHCR. The Tory government might be inept, but I seriously don’t think they would be getting involved with breaking the UN laws on stateless was over petty criminals, protesters, etc.

The UK has always had a provision in law to remove citizenship from people who break certain laws. The number of times it’s actually happened is very few and those were cases of highly organized terror and espionage, not people protesting at a new motorway being built behind their house.

So the situations being discussed here (going to Spain on a package holiday and not being able to return) are just not going to happen to average Joe. You’d know if you were involved in the stuff that caused you to lose citizenship.

And this is nothing that other other countries don’t have. I’m a naturalized US citizen and can lose my citizenship through two ways - if I obtained my citizenship through fraud or I commit a crime that threatens the security of the United States.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/12/2021 16:48

@TipseyTorvey

Mummyoflittledrafon hi, I was born in Britain, I have a British passport and grew up here so am 'naturally' British. As was shamima begum. Didn't help her because her parents were born in Pakistan. The bill makes it possible to revoke my British citizenship because another country offers me citizenship. As pp have said I'm a very dull law abiding officer worker, but what if I decide to join a protest and get arrested and they deem me a threat? Off I go. I wouldn't mind a nice holiday in South Africa but have children and a job here and nothing in South Africa.
Thank you for responding to me. It doesn’t seem likely, does it? But you never know. As per my family. I mean we’d be fine. But dd has only ever known the place we live right now in England.

So many people saying Shamima should stay and rot. I’ve never agreed with this. She was born and bred here. For us to deal with what she did. I think neither parent was originally British, whereas you have heritage here. Not that this should make any difference. She is British born.

HerbertChops · 11/12/2021 16:48

I’d imagine this affects more than 5.5m people in the UK if your looking at those with one grandparent born outside of the UK. We’re in SW London and the majority of kids at my sons school have at least one parent born abroad.

My DH is British by naturalisation, born in Albania so this affects him and our dc, they’re British by descent as am I but they have claim to Albanian citizenship.

Wannakisstheteacher · 11/12/2021 16:45

Don’t see the issue. You aren’t going to have your citizenship revoked for a parking fine are you? The crime that would preceded revocation would be serious enough that you couldn’t accidentally do it, you’d have willing committed an incredibly serious offence.

Musmerian · 11/12/2021 16:37

Totally agree. I’ve been here since I was 6 and was naturalised sometime after. It’s outrageous. People should be furious and challenging but the circus distracts them and behind the scenes terrible things are happening .

LiterallyKnowsBest · 11/12/2021 16:34

@Lockdowninfinity

Lots of talk about Irish heritage here. Let’s keep it real…..We all know this will only affect brown peopleHmm. No change for the majority of brown people born here - almost all of my friends born here to immigrant parents in the 60s and 70s are already despairing about their retirement. They were raised by parents who dreamt of returning ‘home’. Many did; most didn’t. That generation are dying out now. The dream of ‘going back home’ offered some comfort during their years of trauma here. The racism their babies and grandbabies have endured as British born non-whites has resulted in a sense of not belonging in their own home (UK). It’s now dawning in many of these (now middle aged) babies that they don’t have a ‘home’ to dream about for retirement. British - but not accepted as such - however their parents birth countries are alien to them. Anyway. This bill just serves to remind them of this status…..but it’s not a surprise.
Bears repeating.

Astonishing the number of people, even on one so far small thread, who preface their remarks with:

“It’s only if …”

or

“It’s only those who …”

As if it’s nothing. As if the millions of people, like me, who now discover their citizenship has a different hue, just Do Not Matter.

Meadowbreeze · 11/12/2021 16:32

I think this thread has reminded me just how little the average Brit knows about their own immigration system. Eligibility for citizenship at birth, how dual citizenship works etc etc. Maybe they slide these crazy laws through knowing the average Joe won't bat an eye lid because it looks like a good thing when you add the word terrorism here and there 🤔

oatmilk4breakfast · 11/12/2021 16:32

I wrote to members of the House of Lords and at least one has written back so far. Email them now! Their addresses are on the House of Lords website. Email Tory Lords - they’ve no constituencies. Write to newspapers. Make some noise. Govt will bow to three things - Public pressure, parliamentary pressure and press paper. Write to the Tory Press. Individually we can’t fight this. But if we all do little things we can show them we care.

Cam77 · 11/12/2021 16:31

No government should have the right to revoke anyone’s citizenship. Much less our FPTP government’s which usually only have the backing of about 1/3 of the electorate.

flashbac · 11/12/2021 16:30

Some posters keep saying this will apply only to dual nationals (as if that isn't bad enough) but Shamima Begum wasn't a dual national as far as I recall. They said her mum was born in Bangladesh hence she could apply for citizenship there. Bangladesh said they won't accept her.

OP posts:
Kotatsu · 11/12/2021 16:30

Where would they deport someone born in the U.K.? They wouldn't have citizenship anywhere else either...

But they might have the ability to have citizenship elsewhere.

For example, how many people have Irish Grandparents?

LostForIdeas · 11/12/2021 16:27

@Lockdowninfinity

Lots of talk about Irish heritage here. Let’s keep it real…..We all know this will only affect brown peopleHmm. No change for the majority of brown people born here - almost all of my friends born here to immigrant parents in the 60s and 70s are already despairing about their retirement. They were raised by parents who dreamt of returning ‘home’. Many did; most didn’t. That generation are dying out now. The dream of ‘going back home’ offered some comfort during their years of trauma here. The racism their babies and grandbabies have endured as British born non-whites has resulted in a sense of not belonging in their own home (UK). It’s now dawning in many of these (now middle aged) babies that they don’t have a ‘home’ to dream about for retirement. British - but not accepted as such - however their parents birth countries are alien to them. Anyway. This bill just serves to remind them of this status…..but it’s not a surprise.
Yep.

It reinforced the idea that unless you have several generations of British ancestors, you are not really British.
And you dint have to be ‘brown’ for that. My own dcs were feeling like this before that law and they are white.

LostForIdeas · 11/12/2021 16:24

@Ace56

Oh for goodness sake. This is being blown out of proportion. As PP have said, you’d need to commit a pretty serious crime in order for this to even be remotely considered, and even then it is heavily debated/brought to court/fought against etc (e.g. Shamima Begum). You’re not just going to be walking around Tesco, living a normal life, and have your citizenship stripped away from you.
@Ace56, honestly I think that unless you are one of those 5.5 millions people affected by that law, you have no idea.

Just like if you are not an EU citizen, you have no idea the effect Brexit has had on us and how we feel about living in the U.K.

You are looking at things from the confort of your own privilege. One where you know this will never happen to you. It’s easy to dismiss it saying it’s an over reaction, it will never happen etc…

We are looking at Windrush and how those people who had been in the U.K., working etc.. for 50+ years and they were treated like pariahs.people who were told to leave everything behind, all their family, children, grand children to ‘go back home’.

I look at that law and think that, in 5, 10 or whatever years time, one of my dcs will be stuck at the border unable to enter THEIR country without even knowing WHY (because they don’t need to tell you). Because they will caught in the middle of another Windrush.

It might look improbable to you. But you know what, I’m sure it looked improbable to all of those affected by Windrush too.

TipseyTorvey · 11/12/2021 16:22

Mummyoflittledrafon hi, I was born in Britain, I have a British passport and grew up here so am 'naturally' British. As was shamima begum. Didn't help her because her parents were born in Pakistan. The bill makes it possible to revoke my British citizenship because another country offers me citizenship. As pp have said I'm a very dull law abiding officer worker, but what if I decide to join a protest and get arrested and they deem me a threat? Off I go. I wouldn't mind a nice holiday in South Africa but have children and a job here and nothing in South Africa.

Meadowbreeze · 11/12/2021 16:21

@Lockdowninfinity The second most effected are the polish nationals, I'm sure they also feel like they don't belong and the great majority are white.
Whilst I don't for one second dismiss the struggles you've described, this bill will effect everyone who has or potentially has dual citizenship.

Swipe left for the next trending thread