Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that I might lose my British citizenship one day because of the new law going through parliament?

438 replies

flashbac · 11/12/2021 14:03

I was born here and so was one parent.

There is a Bill that has just been passed, while we were all distracted with shenanigans with parties and what not, that will allow citizenship to be revoked without notice.

I know the power to remove citizenship already exists but the without notice bit is quite scary. I assume that means someone could happily go about their business until they need to show right to be in the UK e.g new job or new rental and then poof, they can't access things and possibly get detained and then deported when they enquire about it and it's probably too late to contest it through the courts.

I know the responses will indicate how so many don't care, "don't do anything naughty then and they won't put you in the naughty bin ready to be turfed off to another land" but remember the right to protest, to give an example of how easy it will be to get on the wrong side of the authorities, will also be outlawed soon so anyone could be arrested, if the circumstances meant a person was driven to it, e.g you do a sit down protest outside a hospital because they covered up malpractice or, it's decided that a huge Amazon warehouse is built in the field behind your garden and you wanted to protest with your neighbours.

Lots of people will think this only affects 'foriners' so probably won't care. I think it's awful.

OP posts:
daretodenim · 11/12/2021 23:08

This thread reflects what was said on many Brexit threads. We think we're equal. We say we're equal. And then we hear all the voices saying that purely because of who we were born to - like we chose those people - some people are not as British.

Windrush was something the entire country should have been protesting about.

The country should have been up in arms about the treatment of Brits in many EU countries during the drawn-out Brexit negotiations, because they had moved abroad under freedom of movement and had zero reason to believe they were disconnecting from the U.K. by doing so.

The country should have been up in arms about the Brits who cannot return to the U.K. with their EU spouses and their children, because the visa rules changed.

But our society is set up in such a way that there is a hierarchy, there has always been, and through that lens, British society accepts that some people are simply more deserving than others, for no reason other than birth. And people want to have a higher position in that hierarchy. So, rather than protest, there is a subconscious smugness that there's another layer below them, making them feel just a little more important.

The country is built on the inequality of the population. There will never be a critical mass - ever - of Brits to prevent another layer bring added to the bottom.

Starcup · 11/12/2021 23:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Kyliealwayshadthebestdisco · 11/12/2021 22:53

Yes, this is worrying. I guess what’s most important is how this law is going to be used and if used proportionately (although I’m not actually sure I agree with it ever being used, I agree it creates two tiers of citizenship overnight, and even with Shamima Begum I think we ought to have taken responsibility for her and brought her back and tried her and imprisoned her most likely for life in the UK, rather than strip her of citizenship). I hope it’s going to be a rarely used arcane law on the future, but I do not trust the current government and it does worry me that they seem to be putting all the machinery in place so that if a truly evil dictator type came along (rather than an incompetent narcissist who just doesn’t really care enough about his responsibilities or us little people like now), we could very quickly become an authoritarian state. It’s not dissimilar to how Hitler ultimately gained power, he did it through legal means, and I’m shocked that not more people seem alive to what’s going on. I’m not a COVID denier but I think the government have certainly used aspects of the pandemic to huge advantage.

Kendodd · 11/12/2021 22:45

Not surprised at all by all the posters celebrating this bill.
Booting out 'foreigners' is always going to be popular sadly.

LiterallyKnowsBest · 11/12/2021 22:33

We should all leave. Tomorrow. Every single person in the UK with any heritage outwith. (Going back how many generations???)

Then read about the result come Monday morning. Would be hilarious … (Obvs wouldn’t be reading English newspapers - because they’d have shut down overnight. Along with Westminster, roads, laboratories, hospitals, courts, the entire arts industry, the BBC, all the restaurants still standing after Brexit, Wi-Fi probably, and a million other things I can’t be bothered to list.)

Oh, how we’d laugh.

willstarttomorrow · 11/12/2021 22:16

OP you are very right to be concerned. A few of my friends who are second generation UK citizens drew this to my attention. All are professionals who contribute a lot to society, as have their parents. A very close friend's father has always maintained as a family they must not assume they will always have a home in the UK and has kept a home in Bangladesh no one has lived in since 1970. She has always humoured him but this law has really made her think about her and her family's place in UK society.

RuggerHug · 11/12/2021 21:50

[quote LostForIdeas]@StrongerThanA90sTrend it depends on the country.

Eg in the USA, if you are born there, you are automatically an American citizen. Other countries do not work like this and you wouldn’t get that citizenship just because you are born there.[/quote]
This is true, but I seriously doubt those wanting this give a shit. You're not our problem anymore, it's not up to us to find somewhere else to take you.

LostForIdeas · 11/12/2021 21:21

@StrongerThanA90sTrend it depends on the country.

Eg in the USA, if you are born there, you are automatically an American citizen. Other countries do not work like this and you wouldn’t get that citizenship just because you are born there.

flashbac · 11/12/2021 21:13

@StrongerThanA90sTrend

I'm so confused by this.

So, I was born in a different country. My mother was born here. So I could just randomly be deported even though I have been a citizen of the uk for decades? Seems mental.

But what seems even more mental, because I was born in a different country, my children, who were born here could also potentially be deported?! Because that seems to be the OPs position. They were born here, but one parent was not?

I just don't see how that is what they are meaning with this bill. It makes zero sense. Am I missing something?

(Disclaimer: I haven't read the bill in question. I am purely going by I have understood from the OP. Which, I am fully accepting of the fact that I have misunderstood)

If you were born somewhere else, or your parents or grandparents were, it could be said you have access to citizenship elsewhere so, if you were to become an 'undesirable' person, you could lose your British passport. This wouldn't apply to Mr Bloggs down the road who doesn't have any foreign grandparents so basically you and I are not as British as a white 'indigenous' Brit.

If Mr Bloggs and I were tried for the same crime e.g we both protested against a road being built over our gardens and this was deemed to be in support of XR because they were at the protest too, Mr Bloggs can resume his life after his sentence but I would be turfed out and have to apply to another country I have no experience of, just because my grandparents were born there.

The power for them to revoke citizenship has already been enshrined in law but now they want to do it WITHOUT NOTICE which begs the question: why? So you can't contest it that's why.

OP posts:
StrongerThanA90sTrend · 11/12/2021 20:52

I'm so confused by this.

So, I was born in a different country. My mother was born here. So I could just randomly be deported even though I have been a citizen of the uk for decades? Seems mental.

But what seems even more mental, because I was born in a different country, my children, who were born here could also potentially be deported?! Because that seems to be the OPs position. They were born here, but one parent was not?

I just don't see how that is what they are meaning with this bill. It makes zero sense. Am I missing something?

(Disclaimer: I haven't read the bill in question. I am purely going by I have understood from the OP. Which, I am fully accepting of the fact that I have misunderstood)

Echobelly · 11/12/2021 20:29

I think the symbolism of it is the worst thing - as people said it creates a second tier of citizenship. I doubt it will be employed hugely often, but that hardly matters, even a few cases would be an utter outrage, and I can see how scary it is for people.

My mum and both my in-laws are not British born - I'm not worried for any of them, but then we're white and affluent, and you know it's not going to be targeted at us.

llanfairfechan · 11/12/2021 20:26

I'd start by removing citizenship from a man born in New York who spent part of his childhood in Brussels- Boris Johnson.

This Bill is awful and I hope the next government repeals it.

ancientgran · 11/12/2021 20:24

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@ancientgran umm no, I’m not. Comparing the Holocaust to something so minor would make me an idiot. Almost like comparing it to every law you don’t like.[/quote]
People who need to be rude really don't have much of an argument do they.

There are lots of laws I don't agree with but they are not as dangerous as this bill. Perhaps you can't see the dangers, perhaps you don't want to but it doesn't mean other people can't see it.

MummyJasmin · 11/12/2021 20:21

@TooBigForMyBoots

This law disproportionately discriminates against British minority groups. It is being passed by a untrustworthy government.

How can anyone think it is OK?Xmas Shock

Racism. Can't see any other reason...
ancientgran · 11/12/2021 20:21

I used to have a neighbour who was born abroad as her father was posted abroad in the army, he had also been born abroad for the same reason. Her mother also came from a military family and was in the same situation. Her husband was born in South Africa but his family returned to Britain when he was a child. Not sure where the other grandmother came from.

They were very shocked when they found out that one of their children wasn't British. He had been born on a trip to South Africa when he arrived a little earlier than expected. They were very upset and it took some months for them to sort it out. They were particularly upset as the grandfather was posted abroad by the British Army so they felt they should be a special case. They weren't though.

As soon as the son was 18 he emigrated as he felt he had been unfairly treated by Britain. Last I heard before we moved away he loved his new life and wasn't interested in being British.

Wannakisstheteacher · 11/12/2021 20:19

@ancientgran umm no, I’m not. Comparing the Holocaust to something so minor would make me an idiot. Almost like comparing it to every law you don’t like.

RuggerHug · 11/12/2021 20:14

@Viviennemary

In any case Shamina Begum hasn't been deported. She left. And wasn't allowed back.
viviennemary When little Tarquin and Candidia make a stupid mistake on their gap yah and end up banged up in another country do you think it's ok the British embassy ignores them because of a grandparent they never met being born somewhere else? Because they left Britain! Or is it different if they're white?
onlychildhamster · 11/12/2021 20:12

My future child would be affected due to having a foreign mother and my British DH is also affected as he too has a foreign mother.

But supporters of the Palestinian cause could have their citizenship stripped as supporting Hamas is now a crime. I am Jewish but I think making British citizens stateless cos of supporting Hamas is wrong....

ancientgran · 11/12/2021 20:12

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@ancientgran It is literally nothing at all like the massacre of the Jewish people. Dragging the Holocaust in to try and make your point is both crass and embarrassing. Do you start chanting “first they came for” when your DC’s school enforces the uniform policy? Not everything you dislike can be compared to the Holocaust.

Seriously, educate yourself www.google.co.uk/amp/s/pittnews.com/article/167838/opinions/opinion-stop-comparing-everything-to-the-holocaust/amp/[/quote]
The nazis didn't start with annihilating the Jews you know. Dictatorships don't start like that, they start with small steps and then bigger steps and some people complain and others say it's OK and then one day you wake up and it is full on and too late to do anything.

It doesn't have to mean we end up with concentration camps, it doesn't mean any particular group will be targeted but when people say, "It doesn't apply to me" about any political steps like the new Nationality and Borders Bill they are doing the thing that allows dictatorships to take hold.

Are you seriously comparing enforcing school uniform to depriving people of their citizenship? Maybe you need to educate yourself before you try to educate others.

Saskatcha · 11/12/2021 20:08

Quick google of what is happening to Jehovah’s Witnesses in Russia is quite eye opening as to how different groups can be identified as extremist organisations on a very arbitrary whim. They are being jailed for worshipping and yet are completely anti violence.

flashbac · 11/12/2021 20:08

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@ancientgran It is literally nothing at all like the massacre of the Jewish people. Dragging the Holocaust in to try and make your point is both crass and embarrassing. Do you start chanting “first they came for” when your DC’s school enforces the uniform policy? Not everything you dislike can be compared to the Holocaust.

Seriously, educate yourself www.google.co.uk/amp/s/pittnews.com/article/167838/opinions/opinion-stop-comparing-everything-to-the-holocaust/amp/[/quote]
Stop putting words in her mouth. She didn't say its 'literally' like the massacre of Jewish people, she's drawing a likeness to the lead up to it, in response to the attitude of some who don't care about these horrible new laws because they think it won't affect them. Nobody is saying the conclusion (the holocaust) will be the same but the dehumanisation of people ('cockroaches', let them drown' etc) has already started happening so it's only right to learn lessons from the past and feel concerned about it. Nobody is making light of the holocaust here.

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 11/12/2021 20:06

@BeepBoopBoob to be fair the people who say if you are law abiding the government and their representatives never come after you or harasses you, have lived a very sheltered life.

And also wonder why protest groups like extinction rebellion are completely white.

RedWingBoots · 11/12/2021 20:02

@fournonblondes

It seems nothing to worry about unless you are a terrorist.
"One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter."

I grew up around children whose parents had left South Africa as their parents or close family members were active members of the ANC. The ANC was considered a terrorist organisation by the UK government at the time. All the people in the UK had British citizenship and the children tended not to have South African citizenship.

This law means if anything similar ever occurs the UK government can chuck these children out if they decide to follow their parents/family members in protesting for their group to have a say in the running of their family's country.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 11/12/2021 19:52

It’s really scared me for my children, born here, know nothing else.