Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Generational inequality- seedy effects

62 replies

EmilyisLivingItUp · 11/12/2021 11:53

We all know this generation are financially way worse off than us with tuition fees, house prices etc. I was speaking to some of the women in my office and they revealed that three of their daughters have only fan accounts, one of their poses nude to be drawn at hen dos .
Is this the disgusting side of generational inequality? I can’t help feel a bit sick at men and women in their 40s/50s leering at half naked 20 year olds because of their financial state. AIBU

OP posts:
MintJulia · 11/12/2021 14:03

@etinoxaurus 'there were grants, you are correct, but my grant covered my room and half my bus pass. Nothing left for food, books, clothes, and no possibility of a loan.

So earning money between lectures was the ONLY way to survive if parents were unwilling to help.

We weren't able to get into debt and there were plenty who worked in night clubs or on smutty phone lines.

People always forget that bit when berating the boomers

sst1234 · 11/12/2021 13:59

Why are so many people going to university to do Mickey Mouse degrees that they have to respite to this type of thing? What about those don’t come from money and am don’t get into type of thing? Sorry OP, you’re argument is weak. This is just a quick way of making money for people who are too lazy to do normal work like the rest of the population.

fournonblondes · 11/12/2021 13:57

@Ozanj

OnlyFans is the equivalent of Classifieds / flyers put in bathrooms or phone booths. A certain type of person will always be attracted to sex work. That doesn’t mean it’s more or less acceptable for this generation than previous ones!!
Exactly! However, somehow these jobs are getting normalised by some in society. There are plenty of jobs but younger generations are after quick ways of getting big money quickly.
MintJulia · 11/12/2021 13:56

@sarahsonnet But no-one buys an 'average house' to start with. They do the same as we did, buy a one bed flat at a third of the cost and work their way up.

MurielSpriggs · 11/12/2021 13:43

@Choirgirl2021

Correct me if I’m wrong but when Osborne was chancellor didn’t he include this work as part of the gdp? There have been pushes to bring this employment into taxable income with ssp, etc across Europe.
Sightly missing the point of the thread, but it's always been taxable in the UK.
Etinoxaurus · 11/12/2021 13:39

@MintJulia

Not unreasonable but perhaps naive . I'm in my late 50s. As a student I posed for an art class to make some money. Plus worked in a pub most evenings, and in a toy factory in the summer.

At that point there were no student loans so if a student's parents didn't help, it was very difficult to survive.
I wouldn't have done it at hen nights though. There are plenty of other jobs available..

Key point about generational inequality is that when you were a student there were grants!
SeaAndSnow · 11/12/2021 13:37

I'm 49 and can recall uni friends in sex work at that time to assist financially. So i am not sure this is a recent thing. Doesn't make it right though.

Gumboots29 · 11/12/2021 13:35

@DeniseCrease

Not at all, I was at a hen party pre covid and cringed at having a 20 year old ‘buff butler’ serve women old enough to be his mother to try and pay his way through uni. We need to do away with these ‘services’
Oh god the same. We asked them to put their clothes on and help us in the kitchen instead as about 80% of the hen party were mortified!
hygtt · 11/12/2021 13:31

I also think stigma had been removed

hygtt · 11/12/2021 13:30

I don't think it helps they can earn so much doing this work & because of inequality the only way for most to afford a house, decent pension etc is to earn a lot.

LethargicActress · 11/12/2021 13:10

Yabu because men finding ways to look at women is nothing new. Women using their bodies to make money from men who find them attractive has been going on for centuries. This is nothing to do with generational inequality.

If anything, the fact that we have this technology today makes it much easier and safer for women to use their bodies for money than it was previously.

Mulhollandmagoo · 11/12/2021 13:06

*knew 🤦🏻‍♀️

Mulhollandmagoo · 11/12/2021 13:06

@uneffingbelievable

Sorry it has been going on for years - I went to uni in the 90s and can name at least 4 girls and 3 guys who did "escort" work on the side.
Same, I finished uni 17 yrs ago and new quite a few people who would 'escort' mainly it was just dates for functions but a fair few did more for extra money. Its not new but I agree its really sad that young people are doing this just to get through uni or get on the property ladder
Ozanj · 11/12/2021 12:59

OnlyFans is the equivalent of Classifieds / flyers put in bathrooms or phone booths. A certain type of person will always be attracted to sex work. That doesn’t mean it’s more or less acceptable for this generation than previous ones!!

MatildaIThink · 11/12/2021 12:54

@Sparklfairy

Is it because they're "desperate" for money as PP suggests, or is it because they think its "easy" money? I have a younger sister of "that" generation and am at the older end of it myself, and there seems to be a belief that you can easily become an influencer or tiktok sensation or sell pics of your feet and get rich quick. Grafting in low end jobs is sneered at rather than hard work being respected.

Not being goady, its a disgusting industry, but I saw many articles in lockdown saying "I lost my job in lockdown and now make ££££ a week on onlyfans". Its not pitched as something only desperate young people do.

I can see why some people do it, the younger sister of a friend does only fans, it is a foot fetish thing, she has never posted any videos or pictures which show anything higher than her knees. From what I have been told stuff from taking her socks off, to standing on various fruits, feet in a bowl of beans, in the bath, getting a pedicure etc.

I initially thought "why would anyone do that for a few quid", only it is not, it takes her around ten hours a day and makes her £2-8k a month depending on how much content she uploads and how creative she is being. She has a decent job, earns around £60k a year from her day job, but earns roughly the same from onlyfans. I can understand why she does it, even if it is not for me.

Elleherd · 11/12/2021 12:52

Prostitution and the sidelines and edges of it has always been a real possibility. What's newer is that it's seen as more socially acceptable and even empowering according to some.

SarahSonnet · 11/12/2021 12:45

@DorothyZbornakIsAQueen

You say this as if it is a fait accompli OP.

Utter tosh. It's not if your a student you need to get your tits out, or you're poor.

They aren't the only options available.

I would be heartbroken if 3 of my daughters thought that prostituting their bodies was a viable option to get by in life and I would honestly be questioning my parenting skills.

I think the point is how much harder it is for young people now. If the average house price in your area is 15 times the average salary and you come from a poor family these situations become a real possibility.
Kendodd · 11/12/2021 12:42

Yanbu OP. I hate what we've done to our young people and the world we've left for them. It's so wrong.
And the latest, upping NI on them so they can pay my care home bill for me.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 11/12/2021 12:40

You say this as if it is a fait accompli OP.

Utter tosh. It's not if your a student you need to get your tits out, or you're poor.

They aren't the only options available.

I would be heartbroken if 3 of my daughters thought that prostituting their bodies was a viable option to get by in life and I would honestly be questioning my parenting skills.

SarahSonnet · 11/12/2021 12:38

Upon reflection of all the ethical debate around employment and inequality this is not a profound one.

Yes there is a seedy aspect to it and I would hate my son to work in that business but is there really a fundamental issue with it?
I thoroughly enjoyed having a stripper at my hen do and I obviously wanted a fit, muscular man which happens to be a man in his twenties as opposed to someone twice his age.
And

Elleherd · 11/12/2021 12:36

Sparklfairy is spot on! It isn't generational inequality, it''s a belief that work is for fools, and smart people shouldn't have to. I'm surrounded by this in uni, and whenever I query the wisdom of it I get the same responses.

senua · 11/12/2021 12:31

People may end up falling into that sort of work thinking they'll make a quick buck, but then be unable to get out when reality bites.
This is so true. Do they not realise that something on the internet is there FOREVER. It is also not "for your eyes only"; it can potentially be seen by any future partner, employer, FIL, blackmailer, etc, etc.

It's not generational inequality. It's youthful stupidity.

Sparklfairy · 11/12/2021 12:22

I'm not sure, which is why I tried to carefully word my post! I do think that my sister's peers in particular see a level of lifestyle as attainable for everyone through these means. The realists among us know that the insta lifestyle is heavily filtered of course, but attitudes are starting to lean dangerously towards "shrug, I don't need to study in school, I'll just make a living on social media and I'll have xyz stuff" the kind of aspirations that my parents would have associated with winning the lottery iyswim.

Its unrealistic, and a bit of a vicious cycle. People may end up falling into that sort of work thinking they'll make a quick buck, but then be unable to get out when reality bites.

MintJulia · 11/12/2021 12:19

Not unreasonable but perhaps naive . I'm in my late 50s. As a student I posed for an art class to make some money. Plus worked in a pub most evenings, and in a toy factory in the summer.

At that point there were no student loans so if a student's parents didn't help, it was very difficult to survive.
I wouldn't have done it at hen nights though. There are plenty of other jobs available..

EmilyisLivingItUp · 11/12/2021 12:16

@Sparklfairy

Is it because they're "desperate" for money as PP suggests, or is it because they think its "easy" money? I have a younger sister of "that" generation and am at the older end of it myself, and there seems to be a belief that you can easily become an influencer or tiktok sensation or sell pics of your feet and get rich quick. Grafting in low end jobs is sneered at rather than hard work being respected.

Not being goady, its a disgusting industry, but I saw many articles in lockdown saying "I lost my job in lockdown and now make ££££ a week on onlyfans". Its not pitched as something only desperate young people do.

That’s interesting, my colleague did imply their daughter made a lot of money from it but given the increase in house prices and tuition fees does the level of money simply level the playing field?
OP posts: