Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Generational inequality- seedy effects

62 replies

EmilyisLivingItUp · 11/12/2021 11:53

We all know this generation are financially way worse off than us with tuition fees, house prices etc. I was speaking to some of the women in my office and they revealed that three of their daughters have only fan accounts, one of their poses nude to be drawn at hen dos .
Is this the disgusting side of generational inequality? I can’t help feel a bit sick at men and women in their 40s/50s leering at half naked 20 year olds because of their financial state. AIBU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hellokittyninja · 13/12/2021 18:08

It’s not new, I also went to uni in the 90’s and there were girls and boys ‘escorting’. This was in London and they were mostly privately educated. They just saw it as easy money, plenty were also selling drugs for extra income. I worked in the West End clubs and saw all sorts. Definitely not more seedy now, just more out in the open cos of the internet and phones. I’d wager there are less people doing that sort of thing now at my uni, than there were then.

CatsArePeople · 13/12/2021 17:52

Whereas now as pp's have posted it's completely normal for a lot of young, middle class, people and nothing to be ashamed of.

Nothing new for middle classes to be involved in sex trade.

CatsArePeople · 13/12/2021 15:55

Social media.
Older generations exchanged sexual favours without internet.

CatJumperTwat · 13/12/2021 11:35

An attractive man took his clothes off and let’s me rub oil on his body and everyone involved had fun.

He didn't have fun. He probably felt equal disgust and pity at how pathetic you are.

Contactmap · 13/12/2021 11:25

Whereas now as pp's have posted it's completely normal for a lot of young, middle class, people and nothing to be ashamed of.
How very Mumsnet to specify middle class.

Lightbulbmoments12 · 12/12/2021 16:49

There is at least some demand from all social classes. I’m my opinion this post highlights how our views change with having children

When I was at University some of the students groups raised funds through naked calendars which I had no problem with and I even purchased some for the fun of it.

Now that i have been a mother for some time had my son posed for something similar for his University club I’d be very upset thinking about who would be buying it, what age they would be, if I knew them and other connotations.

I think a lot of this posts responses depends on the audience.

EightWheelGirl · 12/12/2021 15:38

Doh, meant to quote the buff butler post.

EightWheelGirl · 12/12/2021 15:36

I know a guy who did this. Plenty of business from the middle aged, middle class women in a posh market town. He had to be fully naked.

EllaVaNight · 12/12/2021 07:17

An attractive man took his clothes off and let’s me rub oil on his body and everyone involved had fun. I doubt he enjoyed you touching him. And how do you know he had fun? He consented because he was paid. I could never touch someone like that without genuine enthusiastic consent.

IsItReallySeedy · 11/12/2021 20:25

Whilst I am not on OF, I do have a pretty high degree of control. I don't show my face, I decide exactly what I do show. If someone is rude or unpleasant to me they are blocked. In a grotty nightclub I'd have to tolerate unpleasant remarks my whole shift as the manager would be reluctant to remove them as long as they were spending.
I don't exactly wake up excited to "go to work", but then the normal jobs I've had havnt always been the sort of thing I wake up excited to do.
On the odd occasion I tell people what I do, I liken it to when I was self employed as a cleaner. I don't love it, but I don't dread it and I work just enough to pay for what I want and I leave it at that. Except its far better paid than cleaning so I have to work far fewer hours to achieve the same aim.

The only down sides to what I do is the stigma and of it could ever hinder my career when I graduate.

onceandneveragain · 11/12/2021 20:18

@Ozanj

OnlyFans is the equivalent of Classifieds / flyers put in bathrooms or phone booths. A certain type of person will always be attracted to sex work. That doesn’t mean it’s more or less acceptable for this generation than previous ones!!
I disagree with this. Before people usually did things like that out of necessity and it had a grim, dirty association. You'd rarely see lawyers/professionals doing sex work on the side and if you did have to do it you'd try to do anything you could to keep it from your parents/friends. Whereas now as pp's have posted it's completely normal for a lot of young, middle class, people and nothing to be ashamed of.

I can sort of understand it - on OF etc the woman is in control to some extent. She can decide who she speaks to, who she sends additional pics/vids to. Like a pp said she can decide if she ever shows her face or just does foot work etc. I can see the argument that taking photos of your feet for an easy £5k a month, or serving a few drinks with your bum out and people admiring you and showering you with compliments could feel less degrading than earning pennies wiping someone else's bum as a nursery nurse or adult carer, or being looked down on and spoken to like shit working in a shop or as a waiter/ress.

Ss1970 · 11/12/2021 17:56

@IsItReallySeedy

Not surprisingly I've name changed for this....

I'll keep it a little vague as to what it is I do, as I know mumsnet will not agree with it but hey ho....!

I choose to go into this line of work because I am a single mum and uni student. Student loan and grants only cover my very basic expense where I live, and childcare grants only really cover childcare for the time I am studying (be it at home or physically in uni). There's just me (DDs dad has her sporadically when he wants to Disney dad for a day or so) so it's not like I can work in a pub on an evening, if I wanted to work during the day I have to fit it around awkward uni hours and find child care and I simply don't have anyone who can provide regular child care for me.

Pre DD I have worked "normal" jobs so it's not a case of being work shy or trying my make money doing sweet FA.
So my options are that me and DD live life on a budget that simply doesn't allow for any extras and treats or I can do this. It allows me to be "online" for an hour or so when I chose l, I have no travel or extra expenses and I earn more per hour than I can ever hope to, though I do hope to have a more acceptable job after I graduate.

I guess basically, it provides an income that has no effect what so ever on my family time, nor causes me child care issues, and massively improves my standard of living and stops the money worries.

Do I think its exploitive? The men (and occasional women) who look at me don't make me feel exploited, I chose how much I charge for the service and I am comfortable I can chose what I am prepared to do... the companies that i provide the service through however, make me feel massively exploited. They earn more than I do! However they are the only company I have found that allows me to do it as anonymously as possible...

Very interesting story. Everything isn’t black and white in life, you had to do this and it sounds like it’s benefitted you.
Ss1970 · 11/12/2021 17:54

@EllaVaNight

Yes I feel guilty to an extent as I would not like my family to be in that line of work but I hardly think it’s ‘disgusting’, an adult man took his clothes off at my hen do it really isn’t that deep. Oh it's ok for someone you don't know to do it but you wouldn't want it for your family! If you think it’s impacted the love I have for my husband then that’s very unusual. I'm not saying it has, but I wouldn't be with someone financing that industry and neither would my partner. I don't agree with buying consent, it isn't real consent.
No I would not like my son who is 22 to become a stripper but I also wouldn’t like him to join the army and be deployed overseas but it doesn’t mean I believe the army shouldn’t exist.

An attractive man took his clothes off and let’s me rub oil on his body and everyone involved had fun.

It was a one off hen party im not regularly financing anything.

DolphinFC · 11/12/2021 17:44

Sarah

If you don't want to debate are you sure that posting your opinions on a discussion forum is really your sort of thing?

IsItReallySeedy · 11/12/2021 17:43

Sorry another post whilst I am pondering it... every single pub I have worked at has almost certainly hired me because I am averagely attractive in my face, but have ridiculously large breast but otherwise petite frame. So undoubtedly hired for men to leer at me, but for minimum wage and undesirable working hours, because as one boss put it "tits sell beer". I may aswell be levered at for 10x the amount.

IsItReallySeedy · 11/12/2021 17:40

And when it comes to generational wealth, I have maybe 3k of inheritance to come, nothing will really be passed down to me. I have gone to uni to study for a specific profession which I hope will mean I have far more to pass down to my DC so that maybe they won't have to do what I do.

IsItReallySeedy · 11/12/2021 17:38

Not surprisingly I've name changed for this....

I'll keep it a little vague as to what it is I do, as I know mumsnet will not agree with it but hey ho....!

I choose to go into this line of work because I am a single mum and uni student. Student loan and grants only cover my very basic expense where I live, and childcare grants only really cover childcare for the time I am studying (be it at home or physically in uni). There's just me (DDs dad has her sporadically when he wants to Disney dad for a day or so) so it's not like I can work in a pub on an evening, if I wanted to work during the day I have to fit it around awkward uni hours and find child care and I simply don't have anyone who can provide regular child care for me.

Pre DD I have worked "normal" jobs so it's not a case of being work shy or trying my make money doing sweet FA.
So my options are that me and DD live life on a budget that simply doesn't allow for any extras and treats or I can do this. It allows me to be "online" for an hour or so when I chose l, I have no travel or extra expenses and I earn more per hour than I can ever hope to, though I do hope to have a more acceptable job after I graduate.

I guess basically, it provides an income that has no effect what so ever on my family time, nor causes me child care issues, and massively improves my standard of living and stops the money worries.

Do I think its exploitive? The men (and occasional women) who look at me don't make me feel exploited, I chose how much I charge for the service and I am comfortable I can chose what I am prepared to do... the companies that i provide the service through however, make me feel massively exploited. They earn more than I do! However they are the only company I have found that allows me to do it as anonymously as possible...

TractorAndHeadphones · 11/12/2021 17:29

The issue isn’t generational inequality it’s social acceptance. The youth of today don’t mind having sex with people they barely know. So showing their bodies to strangers for money isn’t a big deal for them.

They could do ‘proper’ work, and get by. Or do a few hours of ‘seedy’ work and have enough to go on holiday.

EllaVaNight · 11/12/2021 17:28

Yes I feel guilty to an extent as I would not like my family to be in that line of work but I hardly think it’s ‘disgusting’, an adult man took his clothes off at my hen do it really isn’t that deep. Oh it's ok for someone you don't know to do it but you wouldn't want it for your family!
If you think it’s impacted the love I have for my husband then that’s very unusual. I'm not saying it has, but I wouldn't be with someone financing that industry and neither would my partner. I don't agree with buying consent, it isn't real consent.

SarahSonnet · 11/12/2021 17:22

@DolphinFC

Cognitive dissonance.

It's OK you for to enjoy the benefits of somebodyelse's children being sex workers but you'd hate it for yours.

If a man came on here and said he loved watching strippers at his stag do but he really oves his wife he'd be torn to spreads.

I’m not having this debate on a Saturday night. At my hen party an attractive man took his clothes off and I enjoyed it, it really isn’t that deep.

The two aren’t mutually exclusive, you can love your partner and still find other people attractive.

DolphinFC · 11/12/2021 16:58

Cognitive dissonance.

It's OK you for to enjoy the benefits of somebodyelse's children being sex workers but you'd hate it for yours.

If a man came on here and said he loved watching strippers at his stag do but he really oves his wife he'd be torn to spreads.

SarahSonnet · 11/12/2021 16:36

@EllaVaNight

I thoroughly enjoyed having a stripper at my hen do and I obviously wanted a fit, muscular man which happens to be a man in his twenties as opposed to someone twice his age. That is just disgusting. Leering over a young man and believing you have the right to buy his consent to do so. I don't understand why you'd enjoy something like that, even less so when you're about to marry someone you claim to love.
I wasn’t leering and wolf whistling at a random man in the street he had clearly chosen that career.

Yes I feel guilty to an extent as I would not like my family to be in that line of work but I hardly think it’s ‘disgusting’, an adult man took his clothes off at my hen do it really isn’t that deep.
If you think it’s impacted the love I have for my husband then that’s very unusual.

EllaVaNight · 11/12/2021 15:35

I thoroughly enjoyed having a stripper at my hen do and I obviously wanted a fit, muscular man which happens to be a man in his twenties as opposed to someone twice his age. That is just disgusting. Leering over a young man and believing you have the right to buy his consent to do so. I don't understand why you'd enjoy something like that, even less so when you're about to marry someone you claim to love.

Ss1970 · 11/12/2021 14:19

I agree and disagree. If you research inequality between my generation and the younger generation the statistics show they are much worse off. And yes I do think the stigma should be removed if the younger ones coming out of uni are struggling.

However I’m reminded of a 50th birthday party attended a few years back that had these buff butlers. The guests had their hands all over this man who we found out was a 21 year old student.
Here was a young man who was half naked being felt up while he served drinks in a house he could likely never ever afford in order to fund his studies.

To make things worse at the end of the night one of the guests drunkenly offered him more money to remove his apron.

This whole event made me question the predicaments we have left for that generation.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 11/12/2021 14:16

@Choirgirl2021

Correct me if I’m wrong but when Osborne was chancellor didn’t he include this work as part of the gdp? There have been pushes to bring this employment into taxable income with ssp, etc across Europe.
It has always been taxable. Back months late 80's and 90's I used to do tax returns for a number of escorts who worked at the massage parlors in Sheffield