Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
Embracelife · 12/12/2021 22:24

www.philosophyforlife.org/blog/is-alpha-and-htb-as-bad-as-alex-preston-says

Generating ecstacy thru music and ritual

Embracelife · 12/12/2021 22:19

[quote Southtrainer]@PerfectPrepPrincess
I suppose initially their very different views that she suddenly stopped talking about in front of him, she stopped seeing her gay friends, he comes into zoom family chats and she goes quiet. She gave up a good job and life to
Move across the country to be with him (which I suppose is normal but he didn’t offer to move there).

Im still not sold on her not being converted. As another rooster said- that is part of what evangelical Christians believe is it not?[/quote]
Sounds controlling
Religion or not
Just be there when she needs support

Was,she depressed or anxious?
Vulnerable?
Ready to be sucked in?

Exp got into alpha when he was in bad place... took dc on a camp... they had to stand in circle and say they felt
Jesus in their hearts

It didn't convert them from agnostics
But was weird
But yeh exp sent me some of their books it was all about sticking with your husband no matter what (abuse or whatever)

So yeh I would be worried your sister sucked into controlling relationship
Not that she exploring religion for her own sake

paws17 · 12/12/2021 22:16

@kmblark

Yes, there's talk of wives respecting and submitting to their husbands - but the corollary of that is an expectation that husbands will love their wives as they do their own bodies.

That still seems like a red flag to me.

In my view, you should be pleased that he is taking this step before he commits to a possible longer term relationship.

And the OP's sister giving up her job, ditching her gay friends, going quiet when he comes in the room. Should she be glad of that too?

I'm definitely not sticking up for the male partner - Just putting forward the scriptural basis for Christian marriage. Christian marriage isn't for everyone - but I suspect that a "biblical-standard" marriage would, on balance, provide a more stable base for a long-term relationship (and for the well-being of children) than "civil ceremonies" or other informal arrangements where the participants make far fewer & less strong promises to one another. (Tin hat at the ready...)

I agree with you that the evidence doesn't look all that good at the moment - in which case, the sister needs to evaluate his actions & demands against the biblical standard that he should be upholding, and not enter in to a long term relationship with him if he appears unlikely to be able to live up to the biblical demand that he should, effectively, put her interests and well-being before his own in all things, and on all occasions.

Gillimac37 · 12/12/2021 21:52

@Againstmachine

Glad alpha question but do they accept there is no evidence of Jesus at all. And even if you read that lots of scholars think he did there is still none.
Not quite true! Roman historians Tacitus and Josephus both record John the Baptist and Jesus in their historical (and not Christain) writings along with the whole of the eye witness accounts from the New Testament.
CateJW · 12/12/2021 21:48

Alpha course isn't that heavy.
I went on many Christians weekends and such in my teen years as went to a church youth group and my childhood sweetheart and friendship group where all Christians, but never felt any pressure to "convert"

Violinist64 · 12/12/2021 21:47

As a practising Christian and member of the United Reformed Church, there are a lot of people here who profess no faith but sweepingly describe all Christians as belonging to a cult, being judgmental and unfeeling and completely out of touch. This is not true of most Christians and most churches. There are some very fundamental Christians, as there are in all religions, but they are very much in the minority, For me, it means accepting Jesus as my personal saviour and trying to follow His example. Christianity is for everyone who wishes to follow it, regardless of social background, ethnicity, sexuality or anything else. The Alpha course is a place to explore Christianity and ask questions about it. Christianity is not taught in many schools as much as it was when most of us were at school and many adults have only a vague idea about it. Yes, it is also a way of evangelising but it certainly does not force anyone to believe, which would be impossible in any case.

VitalSpark · 12/12/2021 21:46

All organized religion is cult like, remember this!

kmblark · 12/12/2021 21:45

Yes, there's talk of wives respecting and submitting to their husbands - but the corollary of that is an expectation that husbands will love their wives as they do their own bodies.

That still seems like a red flag to me.

In my view, you should be pleased that he is taking this step before he commits to a possible longer term relationship.

And the OP's sister giving up her job, ditching her gay friends, going quiet when he comes in the room. Should she be glad of that too?

wishforgood · 12/12/2021 21:40

Some religions are of the opinion that the path they follow is the only path.
The religions that embrace interfaith are usually more tolerant.

However with your relative you are powerless over the choices she makes and the most important thing to do is take care of yourself and focus on your life
.I was in a cult once and didn't listen to anyone my relatives were all upset,I left of my own accord.
Its true of myself when I focus on my own life I'm much happier than when I focus on someone else's life.
wishing you peace and happiness

Againstmachine · 12/12/2021 21:27

So zero evidence then

E17Stowmum · 12/12/2021 21:17

Some people find faith, others lose it. For many it comes and goes throughout life. It is not incompatible with socialism and there a lots for whom Labour and Christian values go hand in hand. The basis is love. I wouldn't worry.

paws17 · 12/12/2021 21:16

@Againstmachine

Glad alpha question but do they accept there is no evidence of Jesus at all. And even if you read that lots of scholars think he did there is still none.
Have a look at this:

www.history.com/news/was-jesus-real-historical-evidence

keffie12 · 12/12/2021 21:12

@Bunnybunny1

It definitely IS a cult no doubt. Look up John Ronson’s take on it! He spent time investigating them.
It depends what he investigated! Obviously he was looking for this and would find it.

That's like saying all medical staff for example are rubbish because a few who have messed up.

Not all Christianity is like that. If you go back a couple of pages from this you will find my posts on it.

I am as maverick as they come. You wouldn't expect me to have any Christian beliefs. The church is not like the view of one person. My beliefs aren't main stream.

Yes parts of it I expect can come across like that in some churches. That's people and they evildoers be like that in any walk of life.

The Christian Church does a hell of alot of good in this country and abroad.

Foodbanks are just one example that are run by the Trussel group which is the Chrisyian Church. Like I said go back to my other posts if you want more info

paws17 · 12/12/2021 21:00

@EnidSpyton

OP have since seen your other posts about your sister's behaviour changing since she's been with this guy.

A lot of evangelical Christian men are very controlling. They're attracted to the church because it gives them legitimised power over women.

Evangelical Christians believe men are superior to women, that they have the role of the head of the household, that they are the authority over the household, etc etc etc. They believe that a woman's job is to 'submit' to her husband.

Evangelical Christian readings of the Bible are built around perpetuating a narrative of rightful male dominance over women. There's also a HUGE and incredibly unhealthy focus on sexual purity and homophobia.

Evangelical Christianity IS a cult. It's led by a small group of men who enjoy the power it gives them over others. Honestly, unless you've been in that world, you will never truly understand how toxic it is.

I would be doing whatever I could to get her out of this relationship before you lose her altogether.

Just in case any of you are really interested in what most "evangelical Christians" believe about men, women & marriage, can I recommend that you go to the source of those beliefs, the Bible.

Genesis 2 vs 18 - 25 is a good starting point and then Ephesians 5 vs 21 - 33. You won't find anything there about men being encouraged to be "controlling" or regard themselves as "superior" to their spouse. Yes, there is some clear teaching on exactly which partner in the relationship God regards as more accountable to Him for the well-being of that relationship - The man. Yes, there's talk of wives respecting and submitting to their husbands - but the corollary of that is an expectation that husbands will love their wives as they do their own bodies. Therein lies the balance. If husbands don't show that they love their wives that much in every decision they make & every interaction that they have with their wife, they are in the wrong as far as God is concerned - PERIOD.

If the prospective partner knows his bible, he'll be aware of the instruction to Christians in 2 Corinthians 6 v 14 not to be "unequally yoked with unbelievers". God knows that a marriage is unlikely to succeed if the 2 partners do not share a like mind on matters of faith & beliefs - or of unbelief, for that matter. By encouraging your sister to attend the Alpha course, he's testing the water to see if there is any likelihood of her being of like mind with him going forward.

In my view, you should be pleased that he is taking this step before he commits to a possible longer term relationship. If your sister baulks at what she hears at Alpha, it is very likely that the outcome will be a parting of their ways, not a veiled attempt to brain-wash her into submission.

VK456 · 12/12/2021 20:58

I know people who have undertaken it and they all seemed to really enjoy the discussions.

Againstmachine · 12/12/2021 20:57

Glad alpha question but do they accept there is no evidence of Jesus at all. And even if you read that lots of scholars think he did there is still none.

Truffs2000 · 12/12/2021 20:54

It’s not always as innocent as others have said. My husband did it following encouragement from a work friend and was converted, baptised and in my opinion, brainwashed. It’s not always CofE; the one he did was apostolic which is to do what the apostles do which is go out and recruit people, very full-on, all-encompassing and intense.

It has been so unbelievably hard. He is a different person now and I am so sad.

I did the alpha course after him after he encouraged me to do it and I hated it. The teacher boasted that in all his years of teaching it, every single person had gone on to be baptised. Not me, I found it a massive hard sell, the teacher said everyone who wasn’t a believer was a “sinner” and I had to sit through it seething at the enormous wedge it had driven between me and my husband. Literally no way I am converting.

Tell your sister to be careful and keep her wits about her.

Mollymoostoo · 12/12/2021 20:42

The Alpha course is very generic and not specific to any religion. It is for people who want to explore who God is and what the Bible says. It isn't a conversion tool to a particular religion.
Be more worried if she starts studying with Mormons or JW.

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 12/12/2021 20:40

Sorry should read 'I'm a Christian...'

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 12/12/2021 20:39

I'm no a Christian and have attended an Alpha course. They absolutely shouldn't be about pressuring people to become Christian. They are literally about raising questions you have about the faith.

We encourage Christians from our church who have doubts or worries about inconsistencies to attend them and try to get more settled in their ideas. The Christian faith is so far from simple and there's no judgement of anything said on an Alpha course.

expat101 · 12/12/2021 20:24

I undertook the course with the Salvos years ago. Lovely meal and and active discussion, although because I liked the Officers attending I must say I didn't ask the harder questions. Unless they have updated the film and people, I thought the guy presenting it was pretty lame.

However on one occasion I found myself quite overwhelmed and upset. I don't know why as I'm not usually easily influenced. However in the long run I don't believe its had any influence or changed my decision making.

My MIL did the course through her local Anglican church years before me. She was someone you would say walked with her God and lived her life accordingly. She was asked to leave her Alpha course as her questions (and she would never be rude) were considered extreme. She just felt the people hosting it through her church should have been able to answer her questions!

So in summary I don't see that the course on its own is influential as far as ''converting'' to another religion.

What I would be more concerned about, is this guy's influence on your Sister's thinking, esp. if she is dropping friends solely because of their private sexual preference. That is nobody's business except their own.

Surely if this fellow is so judgemental, he needs to be called out for not following God's teachings?

riceuten · 12/12/2021 19:58

@Motheroftigers

Not evangelical church but our parish has seen an uptake in young families coming back to the church. We are a very fractured society at the moment and religion does create a safety net (sometimes)
And a way in to "St Michael of the Bleeding Heart and nice children from the posh houses and no-one from the Council Estate Primary School".
Motheroftigers · 12/12/2021 19:49

Not evangelical church but our parish has seen an uptake in young families coming back to the church. We are a very fractured society at the moment and religion does create a safety net (sometimes)

Pixxie7 · 12/12/2021 19:48

I went to one meeting on the alpha course, but I am quite analytical so being told that in gods eyes Hitler and mother Teresa were equal, I couldn’t agree.
However having said that one of my daughters did the whole course and found it very meaningful and fulfilling. Yes it did change her but in a positive way.
It certainly won’t do her any harm, because as a family you may not believe doesn’t mean you are right.

masterblaster · 12/12/2021 19:45

I have done the Alpha course. It was absolutely about converting you. There was far too quick a movement on from “this guy thinks this, what do you think?” To “yeah, I think we’ve all agreed God did it”.

Towards the end of my last session I had four church people “discussing” things with me, and everyone else was on a separate “agrees that God might exist” table.

Was a fun few nights. Thinking about doing it again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread