Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
Allsortsofroses · 13/12/2021 17:29

His family's values sound disturbing.

It's that that would make me worry for her getting into a serious relationship with him, marrying him etc.

ElectricDeChocobo · 13/12/2021 17:11

[quote silvercosmopolitian]Now I am agnostic, but have only recently been exploring faith, so I probably cannot comment on C of E policy.

However, I don't understand why you are worried.

A lot of people find faith, ( of any perspective), adds great peace, meaning and fulfillment to their lives. Certainly, I find the idea there is a higher power than us mere mortals greatly comforting. Your sister may or may not convert to christianity, but if she finds peace, meaning, hope and fulfillment within the C of E, ( which is th enational religion, hardly a fringe religous sect), then I don't see why you would be worried. The C of E are not going to tell your sister to cut off contact with family, give all her earnings to them etc.

I also don't see the issues with her boyfriend being a creationist. Whilst I, ( and tbh 99% of the flly practicing Christians I know), do not believe the creation story is literal, I don't see why it would be harmful or a "red flag," for her boyfriend to take it literally. None of us know for certain how the world was created, and so I don't understand why her boyfriend believing what is actually a rather nice part of the bible is literal would be concerning ?

As for homophobic, well many people of many faith's, ( be that Jewish, Sikh, Muslim, Hindu , Catholic), believe that gay sex/ gay msrriage is wrong. I do not share these views, ( I am adhemently in favour of gay marriage), but have friends of different religions who truly believe this.Obviously if they were going around actively harassing gay people that would be completely wrong, but I just couldn't get upset that my sister's partner has sincerely held views about gay sex being against his religion, and goes about his buissiness quietly.

Also,if christianity was that homophobic, would that many mainstream U.K churches allow gay marriage:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-40190204

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-36756387

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-57658161

www.quaker.org.uk/about-quakers/our-history/marriage-equality[/quote]
You really don't see the fact that OP's sister goes quiet when her boyfriend enters the room and has ditched her gay friends as a red flag?

ElectricDeChocobo · 13/12/2021 17:09

@ElectricDeChocobo - Now read on to verses 25 - 33 in Ephesians 5 - It's funny how people always get offended before they read the rest of that passage. Notice that there are only 3 verses in that passage addressed to wives and 9 to husbands, which is a true measure of who the passage is really intended to speak to most loudly, of course - proving that God really isn't sexist or patriarchal.

I did read the rest of the passage. It still says that husbands should submit to their wives, which is as sexist as it comes.

Your point about same-sex couples is very interesting. God doesn't say anything in the bible about how they should conduct their marriage relationships. I wonder why that is...

Could it be because the bible is homophobic?

silvercosmopolitian · 13/12/2021 17:03

But yeah, I don't get if the guy doesn't believe in gay marriage why that would mean he would be a bad partner for your sister ? Obviously if he was being violent/ smashing up gay clubs, but why having a sincerely held religous belief, ( that albeit most of us don't agree with), would make him that bad in the grand scheme of things.

Corbally · 13/12/2021 16:52

It is interesting that people demand "first-hand" accounts of thing that are already very well documented in history & literature (by contempories)

How are they 'well-documented'? And it's less that anyone is demanding 'first hand' accounts than that it's deeply frustrating pointing out to a certain kind of Bible-basher that a book written by believers many years after the events it purports to describe doesn't really have any evidentiary value of anything other than the existence of early Christians. (And that Paul had issues.)

paws17 · 13/12/2021 16:50

[quote ElectricDeChocobo]**@paws17* Genesis 2 vs 18 - 25 is a good starting point and then Ephesians 5 vs 21 - 33. *

22 Wives, submit yourselves to your own husbands as you do to the Lord. 23 For the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of the church, his body, of which he is the Savior. 24 Now as the church submits to Christ, so also wives should submit to their husbands in everything.

Well that sounds sexist as fuck.

What about same-sex couples? Who should they submit to?[/quote]
@ElectricDeChocobo - Now read on to verses 25 - 33 in Ephesians 5 - It's funny how people always get offended before they read the rest of that passage. Notice that there are only 3 verses in that passage addressed to wives and 9 to husbands, which is a true measure of who the passage is really intended to speak to most loudly, of course - proving that God really isn't sexist or patriarchal.

Your point about same-sex couples is very interesting. God doesn't say anything in the bible about how they should conduct their marriage relationships. I wonder why that is...

silvercosmopolitian · 13/12/2021 16:44

Now I am agnostic, but have only recently been exploring faith, so I probably cannot comment on C of E policy.

However, I don't understand why you are worried.

A lot of people find faith, ( of any perspective), adds great peace, meaning and fulfillment to their lives. Certainly, I find the idea there is a higher power than us mere mortals greatly comforting. Your sister may or may not convert to christianity, but if she finds peace, meaning, hope and fulfillment within the C of E, ( which is th enational religion, hardly a fringe religous sect), then I don't see why you would be worried. The C of E are not going to tell your sister to cut off contact with family, give all her earnings to them etc.

I also don't see the issues with her boyfriend being a creationist. Whilst I, ( and tbh 99% of the flly practicing Christians I know), do not believe the creation story is literal, I don't see why it would be harmful or a "red flag," for her boyfriend to take it literally. None of us know for certain how the world was created, and so I don't understand why her boyfriend believing what is actually a rather nice part of the bible is literal would be concerning ?

As for homophobic, well many people of many faith's, ( be that Jewish, Sikh, Muslim, Hindu , Catholic), believe that gay sex/ gay msrriage is wrong. I do not share these views, ( I am adhemently in favour of gay marriage), but have friends of different religions who truly believe this.Obviously if they were going around actively harassing gay people that would be completely wrong, but I just couldn't get upset that my sister's partner has sincerely held views about gay sex being against his religion, and goes about his buissiness quietly.

Also,if christianity was that homophobic, would that many mainstream U.K churches allow gay marriage:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-40190204

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-36756387

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-57658161

www.quaker.org.uk/about-quakers/our-history/marriage-equality

paws17 · 13/12/2021 16:36

@Grumpyoldpersonwithcats

Not quite true! Roman historians Tacitus and Josephus both record John the Baptist and Jesus in their historical (and not Christain) writings along with the whole of the eye witness accounts from the New Testament.

Tacitus and Josephus were both born after the assumed death of Jesus. So not exactly first hand accounts.
And to take the NT as 'gospel' proof of Jesus' existence (see what I did there?) Is rather like marking your own homework.

It is interesting that people demand "first-hand" accounts of thing that are already very well documented in history & literature (by contempories) that happened only 2000 years ago as proof of their occurrence but don't question anything that Prof Brian Cox has to say about "The Big Bang" and the origins of our universe, even though, as far as we know, he wasn't actually alive 13.8 billion years ago...
Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/12/2021 16:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ElectricDeChocobo · 13/12/2021 16:26

@paws17 Genesis 2 vs 18 - 25 is a good starting point and then Ephesians 5 vs 21 - 33.

22 Wives, submit yourselves to your own husbands as you do to the Lord. 23 For the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of the church, his body, of which he is the Savior. 24 Now as the church submits to Christ, so also wives should submit to their husbands in everything.

Well that sounds sexist as fuck.

What about same-sex couples? Who should they submit to?

Embracelife · 13/12/2021 16:22

@brokendark

I know it's really annoying and very uncomfortable but, given the things we believe to be true, we do have real concerns for your eternal futures. If it's all just a load of codswallop & mumbo jumbo then, yes, we have all been wasting our time for the last 2000 years - but if it is true, then one day you might not thank those Christian friends, colleagues & family members who failed to give you a heads-up on what is to come

Bloody hell, that sounds like the sort of threat a mobster would make to a small business owner.

Indeed, Still, with no eternal future to worry about I won't lose sleep over this
brokendark · 13/12/2021 16:20

I know it's really annoying and very uncomfortable but, given the things we believe to be true, we do have real concerns for your eternal futures. If it's all just a load of codswallop & mumbo jumbo then, yes, we have all been wasting our time for the last 2000 years - but if it is true, then one day you might not thank those Christian friends, colleagues & family members who failed to give you a heads-up on what is to come

Bloody hell, that sounds like the sort of threat a mobster would make to a small business owner.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/12/2021 16:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/12/2021 16:09

Not quite true! Roman historians Tacitus and Josephus both record John the Baptist and Jesus in their historical (and not Christain) writings along with the whole of the eye witness accounts from the New Testament.

Tacitus and Josephus were both born after the assumed death of Jesus. So not exactly first hand accounts.
And to take the NT as 'gospel' proof of Jesus' existence (see what I did there?) Is rather like marking your own homework.

TatianaBis · 13/12/2021 15:57

Participants are pressured by the final weeks of the course to engage with the concept of the Holy Spirit, to have hands laid on them in healing, to speak in tongues, to prophesy over one another, etc. Much like the psychics and faith healers Christians decry, this Holy Spirit nonsense relies on cold reading people and confirmation bias

From what I saw with my friend - they seem to elevate perfectly ordinary observations to the status of divine prophesy. It all seems very naive, credulous and confused.

Corbally · 13/12/2021 15:53

[quote paws17]@EnidSpyton

I'm really sorry to hear of your experiences. It is clear that you have seen & experienced the very worst side of "corporate Christianity" over a number of years and I can't defend those organisations which seem focussed on mass enrolment, control & financial growth rather than on what they are supposed to be doing, which is freely sharing the unadulterated & simple gospel of Jesus Christ.

Whilst you are clearly & understandably bitter about your experiences, I hope that you might still, in time, be able to filter out the unattractive noise of these large organisations and allow a "still small voice" to convince you of the spiritual truths that you are no doubt already aware of.

Speaking to the broader audience here, it would be good if you could understand & even forgive Christians for wanting to interest you in the things of God. I know it's really annoying and very uncomfortable but, given the things we believe to be true, we do have real concerns for your eternal futures.

If it's all just a load of codswallop & mumbo jumbo then, yes, we have all been wasting our time for the last 2000 years - but if it is true, then one day you might not thank those Christian friends, colleagues & family members who failed to give you a heads-up on what is to come.[/quote]
You have a serious case of spiritual arrogance, @paws17. Yet again, the idea that people who don't swallow this guff just haven't encountered it, and just need a pamphlet or a nudge to attend a service, a mini-sermon? Many of us know it all too well. We grew up in it, are thoroughly well-versed in scripture, took a long hard look at it when we became adults, and said 'This is just a man-made attempt to contend with the fear of death and the unknown, like all other religions.'

It's not 'codswallop', but neither does it deserve adherence. It's possible it's adult to live a good life without the carrot of an eternal reward, or the bit you're so arrogantly concerned by, @paws17 -- the prospect of hellfire for everyone else from your all-merciful god.

So thanks for the 'heads-up' on the damnation you confidently believe is waiting for everyone who doesn't appease your supposedly omnipotent, all-merciful deity who seems to require an awful lot of worship and maybe devote the spare energy to considering whether 'worshipping' in church is any different to a wiitchdoctor in a pre-Enlightenment society appeasing the local spirits.

TatianaBis · 13/12/2021 15:50

Speaking to the broader audience here, it would be good if you could understand & even forgive Christians for wanting to interest you in the things of God. I know it's really annoying and very uncomfortable but, given the things we believe to be true, we do have real concerns for your eternal futures.

This is the kind of thing that really pisses people off about Christians. Just keep your nose out of other peoples’ eternal futures and worry about your own.

OMG12 · 13/12/2021 15:49

Meh, I’ve done an Alpha course and firmly of the belief the Bible is entirely symbolic and Christianity as it’s been presented for the last few hundred years at least is a bastardisation of the true meaning for use as a control mechanism. I never felt anyone was trying to convert me.

Maybe meeting someone has enabled your sister to challenge her beliefs. Maybe being surrounded by left wing agnostics has not enabled your sister to fully explore this before.

Just let her get on with it. It’s not like she’s been recruited into some death cult.

Is the real problem you’re worried about your sister having fundamentally different views to yours?

EducatingArti · 13/12/2021 15:07

@LefttoherownDevizes
"Equally, please don't worry that by becoming a Christian you equally become a bigot, one does not have to follow the other."
I do so agree with this!

LefttoherownDevizes · 13/12/2021 15:05

I attend a liberal evangelical CofE course. DH and I were brought up by hard left wing anti-inflammatory religious parents (mine lapsed Catholics/Christians his Marxists).

We both did the Alpha course, for me it was part of my journey to coming to Faith, for him it was out of curiosity (hi didn't finish the curse).

Whilst I do have reservations about HTB and their particular branch of charismatic evangelism (and interpretation of the Bible on issues such as homosexuality, divorce, abortion etc) off you choose the right Church it shouldn't be an issue.

Out of every Alpha course we run I would say that less than 5 'convert' and continue attending Church, so the odds aren't great.

Equally, please don't worry that by becoming a Christian you equally become a bigot, one does not have to follow the other.

voldr · 13/12/2021 14:56

@CatsArePeople

But then gradually you'll get frozen out.

Some things ar not for everyone's taste and lifestyle.

OP's sister has stopped seeing her gay friends since meeting her boyfriend.
EnidSpyton · 13/12/2021 14:52

@ricepolo

There are numerous posts which show that this is clearly not the case. Lots of people have repeatedly explained how they know gay Christians, churches which have no issue with homosexuality and gay ministers.
BUT the Alpha course was created by a man who is homophobic and who has compared gay men to paedophiles.

The OP's sister's boyfriend is also homophobic.

So the fact that there are some churches who are accepting of gay people is irrelevant to the topic of THIS thread.

The type of church the OP's sister is attending to do the alpha course is the type of church that has produced her homophobic, creationist boyfriend.

The Christians on this thread sound like the women who bleat #NotAllMen whenever misogyny is discussed. Just because your church is welcoming doesn't mean the rest are. Your experience does not negate the experience of so many others. Your attempt to downplay the rampant homophobia in the church is shameful. You know it exists. Stop pretending it doesn't.

paws17 · 13/12/2021 14:49

@EnidSpyton

I'm really sorry to hear of your experiences. It is clear that you have seen & experienced the very worst side of "corporate Christianity" over a number of years and I can't defend those organisations which seem focussed on mass enrolment, control & financial growth rather than on what they are supposed to be doing, which is freely sharing the unadulterated & simple gospel of Jesus Christ.

Whilst you are clearly & understandably bitter about your experiences, I hope that you might still, in time, be able to filter out the unattractive noise of these large organisations and allow a "still small voice" to convince you of the spiritual truths that you are no doubt already aware of.

Speaking to the broader audience here, it would be good if you could understand & even forgive Christians for wanting to interest you in the things of God. I know it's really annoying and very uncomfortable but, given the things we believe to be true, we do have real concerns for your eternal futures.

If it's all just a load of codswallop & mumbo jumbo then, yes, we have all been wasting our time for the last 2000 years - but if it is true, then one day you might not thank those Christian friends, colleagues & family members who failed to give you a heads-up on what is to come.

ricepolo · 13/12/2021 14:46

There are numerous posts which show that this is clearly not the case. Lots of people have repeatedly explained how they know gay Christians, churches which have no issue with homosexuality and gay ministers.

voldr · 13/12/2021 14:29

@CatsArePeople

But then gradually you'll get frozen out.

Some things ar not for everyone's taste and lifestyle.

Like having gay friends...
Swipe left for the next trending thread