Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
kmblark · 13/12/2021 22:13

@paws17

I have a conscious, thanks, it just differs from yours. I think homophobia is wrong, for example.

Corbally · 13/12/2021 22:13

@logsonlogsoff

It’s homophobic, but I get that lots of straight people are prepared to overlook that in their search for the meaning of life. Pretty sexist too.
My most devoutly Christian friends are a lesbian couple who met via church, a sort of renegade Catholic congregation that used to meet in different central London churches — they actually had a Catholic priest marry them. I think that he was semi-retired and in transit back from an overseas parish, so felt that there were limits to what his hierarchy would be able to do to him if he was found out. Apparently there were/are other priests who did similar.

I do struggle to understand their investment in a faith that deems their relationship sinful, but I respect their right to feel differently.

kmblark · 13/12/2021 22:13

@paws17

I have a conscious, thanks, it just differs from yours. I think homophobia is wrong, for example.

Corbally · 13/12/2021 22:11

@logsonlogsoff

It’s homophobic, but I get that lots of straight people are prepared to overlook that in their search for the meaning of life. Pretty sexist too.
My most devoutly Christian friends are a lesbian couple who met via church, a sort of renegade Catholic congregation that used to meet in different central London churches — they actually had a Catholic priest marry them. I think that he was semi-retired and in transit back from an overseas parish, so felt that there were limits to what his hierarchy would be able to do to him if he was found out. Apparently there were/are other priests who did similar.

I do struggle to understand their investment in a faith that deems their relationship sinful, but I respect their right to feel differently.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/12/2021 22:07

Counting oneself as an atheist or non-believer would certainly seem to absolve most people of any conscience or concern in regard to that possibility
What about followers of other religions?

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 13/12/2021 22:02

Of course, it's much easier to argue that He didn't exist than face up to dealing with & responding to his numerous moral, social and relationship challenges to us all

Very odd that you seem to think this is an either/or question. Do you really think all non-believers go through life ignoring moral, social and relationship challenges? It's manifest nonsense.

paws17 · 13/12/2021 22:00

@kmblark

Dismissing the bible as entirely the work of "believers" may provide some with a get-out clause for their consciences

What is it on my conscious that I'm trying to get out of exactly?

The Bible teaches that everyone will one day have to give an account of their lives to Jesus Christ. Counting oneself as an atheist or non-believer would certainly seem to absolve most people of any conscience or concern in regard to that possibility - at least until that day arrives, if it ever does, of course...
Againstmachine · 13/12/2021 21:57

No - I'm arguing that the very proven existence of those other contemporaries from that period - whose lives actually entwined on occasions with Jesus - is further proof of his existence.

Someone historical who existed at same time as jesus is no proof at all he existed, that's total clutching at straws.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 21:50

It’s homophobic, but I get that lots of straight people are prepared to overlook that in their search for the meaning of life. Pretty sexist too.

paws17 · 13/12/2021 21:46

@Againstmachine

There is just as much reason & evidence to accept the fact that there was an historical Jesus as there is for other contemporary figures of that era (Pontius Pilate, Emperor Augustus, King Herod, etc.)

Wow you are grouping in people who clearly existed during this time so you think there is no evidence of Augustus and Herod even though there is things such as coins, records ect.

No - I'm arguing that the very proven existence of those other contemporaries from that period - whose lives actually entwined on occasions with Jesus - is further proof of his existence.
kmblark · 13/12/2021 20:15

Dismissing the bible as entirely the work of "believers" may provide some with a get-out clause for their consciences

What is it on my conscious that I'm trying to get out of exactly?

Againstmachine · 13/12/2021 19:48

There is just as much reason & evidence to accept the fact that there was an historical Jesus as there is for other contemporary figures of that era (Pontius Pilate, Emperor Augustus, King Herod, etc.)

Wow you are grouping in people who clearly existed during this time so you think there is no evidence of Augustus and Herod even though there is things such as coins, records ect.

Corbally · 13/12/2021 19:44

For heavens’ sake @paws17, I was clearly responding to your claims of things being ‘well-documented’ by contemporaries — by which I assumed you meant the life of Jesus by Mark, given that there are no other (roughly) contemporary accounts. As regards your point about the dating of the Bible texts, did you not realise that the gospels were composed precisely so as to retrofit with the long tradition of Jewish prophecies about the coming of a Messiah? So the writers of the gospels have Jesus say and do things to fit the prophecies in Isaiah, Genesis, Psalms, Deuteronomy etc. It’s not that texts written a thousand years earlier magically foresaw Jesus — the only independent testimony that he even existed by non-believers doesn’t go into detail. Hmm

Catinabeanbag · 13/12/2021 19:41

@EnidSpyton

Thank you - and well said. Grew up in that whole environment (spring harvest, new wine, soul survivor)..... Never did the Alpha course but wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. Or ever tell anyone else to.

Now go to a CofE church which accepts me as I am and where I am at home.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/12/2021 19:40

@paws17

Of course, it's much easier to argue that He didn't exist than face up to dealing with & responding to his numerous moral, social and relationship challenges to us all.

Wow. It never fails to amaze me how quickly apparently christian folk turn patronising, snarky and sarcastic when challenged about things they state as fact.

Spoiler alert - lots of us manage to navigate those challenges without god being a factor.

You seem to equate being christian with working harder at life than atheists. You say atheists take the 'much easier' road.

I would argue that if anything its 'easier' to defer to a higher power instead of taking absolute responsibility for your own path in life and decisions along the way.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/12/2021 19:40

@paws17
Of course, it's much easier to argue that He didn't exist than face up to dealing with & responding to his numerous moral, social and relationship challenges to us all.
Poor argument I'm afraid. What about Muhammad or Joseph Smith or Dr. Sun Myung Moo or Guru Nanak. (to name but a few). There is very good historic evidence that all the above existed (much stronger evidence than that of Jesus).
It doesn't mean I have to believe in the religions they founded either though.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/12/2021 19:36

@paws17

Dismissing the bible as entirely the work of "believers" may provide some with a get-out clause for their consciences

Is this really what you think the motivation is for people challenging christian scripture? That they want to alleviate their conscience? That doesn't make sense. I'm an atheist. I do not believe in god, therefore my conscience is clear when it comes to any potential consequences of me as an individual not believing in god. It's of no concern to my conscience as I do not believe in god.

The way you've written on here is as if non believers are either lapsed Christians who just need to remember the right things and see what you think is 'the truth' (but is not provable as it requires faith in the absence of proof) or are people desperately fighting off beliefs in a sort of lifelong struggle between atheism and religion.

In reality, me and many others like me, don't feel this huge internal struggle you think we do. We don't believe in god and we are more than happy with it. We love and are loved, we do nice things because we want to and not because of perceived potential reward or punishments.

So no need to worry about us or our souls. Plus I don't think it's ok to tell people their relationships with the people they love are worth less just because they are the same sex.

Considering how many people on here are saying their church doesn't distinguish between gay couples and straight couples, it's staggering how few churches in real life show genuine equality (not just 'love the sinner' / 'as long as you don't act on it' etc) isn't it? You must all go to the same few churches.

Againstmachine · 13/12/2021 19:31

There is clear historical proof a man called Jesus existed.

There really isn't even the name jesus didn't exist in that world. Everything wrote about Jesus was after his alledged death.

CatsArePeople · 13/12/2021 19:19

What about same-sex couples? Who should they submit to?

whoever identifies as a wife Grin

paws17 · 13/12/2021 18:55

@Corbally

It is interesting that people demand "first-hand" accounts of thing that are already very well documented in history & literature (by contempories)

How are they 'well-documented'? And it's less that anyone is demanding 'first hand' accounts than that it's deeply frustrating pointing out to a certain kind of Bible-basher that a book written by believers many years after the events it purports to describe doesn't really have any evidentiary value of anything other than the existence of early Christians. (And that Paul had issues.)

You are aware that the bible is actually a collection of 66 different books, written in several different languages, over a period of around 1500 years by around 40 different authors, living on 3 different continents?

Most of the authors didn't meet the person called Jesus - and yet there are prophetic references to him and his future arrival and even more future return interlaced throughout the Old Testament. Dismissing the bible as entirely the work of "believers" may provide some with a get-out clause for their consciences but constructing such a mammoth conspiracy to deceive people over the course of a 2000 year period would be a challenge for any interest-group, even in this advanced technological age.

There is just as much reason & evidence to accept the fact that there was an historical Jesus as there is for other contemporary figures of that era (Pontius Pilate, Emperor Augustus, King Herod, etc.) Of course, it's much easier to argue that He didn't exist than face up to dealing with & responding to his numerous moral, social and relationship challenges to us all.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/12/2021 18:16

There is clear historical proof a man called Jesus existed
I"m afraid there really isn't. Just a relatively small collection of documents (mostly with a definite bias) dating from years after his (alleged) death.
On the balance of probability you might say it is likely that a man called Jesus existed. But if he did, I think he's been misquoted.

ricepolo · 13/12/2021 18:00

There is clear historical proof a man called Jesus existed. Whether you believe he was the son of God is another matter but that’s no. argument whatsoever.

backtolifebacktoreality · 13/12/2021 17:43

It's a course that you go on so you can ask questions and make your own decision on Christianity!

It's not a cult!

Againstmachine · 13/12/2021 17:33

It is interesting that people demand "first-hand" accounts of thing that are already very well documented in history & literature (by contempories) that happened only 2000 years ago as proof of their occurrence but don't question anything that Prof Brian Cox has to say about "The Big Bang" and the origins of our universe, even though, as far as we know, he wasn't actually alive 13.8 billion years ago...

Much of Brian Cox has to say about the big bang are theories or based on science what we know and he will admit that.

There is no evidence of Jesus at all.

Corbally · 13/12/2021 17:31

@silvercosmopolitian

But yeah, I don't get if the guy doesn't believe in gay marriage why that would mean he would be a bad partner for your sister ? Obviously if he was being violent/ smashing up gay clubs, but why having a sincerely held religous belief, ( that albeit most of us don't agree with), would make him that bad in the grand scheme of things.
Why does its 'sincerity' make it any less morally repugnant? People 'sincerely' believe all kinds of rotten things.
Swipe left for the next trending thread