Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
mordinvasnormandy · 18/12/2021 17:00

@paws17
Jesus didn't say anything directly about a number of other issues - e.g. incest, kidnap, paedophilia, etc - Are we to infer that He must therefore now affirm/permit these things, too, or do we simply accept that he didn't have to restate those things because they are still plainly & morally wrong and censured elsewhere in the Bible?

Did you really just fucking compare homosexuality - which harms absolutely no one by the way, unlike the homophobic bile you're spewing - to incest kidnap and paedophilia?

No one wants to be called a homophobe, eh? Well if the shoe fits.

speakout · 18/12/2021 16:58

but also encourages them to live a life of faith in Jesus Christ which reconciles their sexuality with the teachings of the bible.

Yes- and what that means is vile.

So in essence that church is saying it's ok to be gay, as long as you never have a romantic or sexual relationship with somone of the same sex, never marry, them all will be fine.
What a hideous cruel doctrine that is happy to resign a homosexual person to a sexless, loveless, partnership life- but that's ok eh- god still "accepts" the "gayness".
It is a foul, putrid and inhumane way of treating people.
Both my mother and sister belong to churches with this thinking ( both different churches). Keen to show how much they accept "the gays" " not their fault poor things", one of them even has a gay conversion clinic.
So being gay in your head is ok, but the church doesn't accept how you want to live your life if that includes being fully human.

It's so fucked up, makes me want to weep.

amoosee · 18/12/2021 16:46

I don't

Thankfully, considering the vile organisations you promote.

amoosee · 18/12/2021 16:45

On a more positive note, just in case anyone is interested, there is a Christian organisation called Living Out founded by Christians who live with same-sex attractions which encourages churches to welcome all those with a same-sex attraction but also encourages them to live a life of faith in Jesus Christ which reconciles their sexuality with the teachings of the bible. This doesn't have to be an either/or issue. It can be one where truth, honesty and justice come together in a positive way.

An organisation that tells people they have to be single their whole lives, can never have a relationship and fall in love. Or worse, marry someone of the opposite sex. That's not positive that's disgusting and you should be ashamed of yourself for promoting them.

speakout · 18/12/2021 16:40

I don't but if I had, I hope I would still have been able to love them into the Kingdom of God, for their sake.

Wouldn't you rather have a child capable of free thinking so they could make up their own minds about religion?
It seems very arrogant to assume you know the "ultimate truth"

paws17 · 18/12/2021 15:55

[quote amoosee]@paws17

I hope you don't have any gay children, for their sake.[/quote]
I don't but if I had, I hope I would still have been able to love them into the Kingdom of God, for their sake.

paws17 · 18/12/2021 15:45

@allyouvegottenminuteslynn

It so often feels like Cherry picking the bits that are palatable and least likely to offend. As I said upthread, it would almost be refreshing if someone on here said 'yes as a Christian I believe it's wrong to be gay' because we have all met plenty of Christians who feel that way and surely part of them being true to their beliefs is sharing them if they are sure of them?

Thank you for your insight. It does seem sometimes that Christians can do no right in this discussion, and that's probably why so many are reluctant to speak out. We don't want to deeply offend people but how can we fulfil our commission to share the Gospel faithfully if we don't share what God says in His word about key issues like this one? And no-one wants to be described as "homophobic", whatever that means nowadays.

As you & others have hinted, since the bible is absolutely clear and unambiguous, in both Old & New Testaments, about what God thinks about same-sex acts (not inclinations or desires), there's no useful purpose in Christians with a more "liberal" theology saying that it's different in their church or that they don't believe that same-sex acts are wrong. In doing so, they are effectively denying the very God of truth and love that they claim to believe & trust in. In this context, what is someone who is genuinely searching for answers to do? My answer would always be "Go & see for yourself what the bible says about these matters."

Christian allies and apologists for same-sex activity will always come up with the same old arguments to try to get people to ignore or overlook what the bible says, but none of these hold up to serious scrutiny. e.g.

  • The suggestion that as we no longer uphold the OT prohibition in Leviticus (Chapters 11 & 19) of the eating of shellfish or wearing mixed fibres, we should tell people that God has somehow changed His mind on the matter of same-sex acts, too. In fact, the shellfish & mixed fibre laws were ceremonial signs of outward distinctiveness for God's chosen people in the OT & which are no longer re-emphasised as applicable in the NT. (Acts 10 vs 9 - 16). Same sex acts ARE specifically prohibited in both OT (Leviticus 18) & NT (Romans 1; I Corinthians 6, etc) on a moral basis, not a ceremonial basis. The OT punishment for these acts was death - There isn't such a severe penalty for infractions of the ceremonial laws.
  • The suggestion that the cities of Sodom & Gomorrah were destroyed because of their "lack of hospitality", not their sexual immorality - Check out Jude 7 in the NT, you bible scholars;
  • The fact that Jesus didn't say anything recorded in the bible about homosexuality - Christians believe that Jesus is the Living Word and that He is the inspiration for the whole Bible, including the bits that the Apostle Paul wrote & that some people seem to take particular exception to.) Jesus didn't say anything directly about a number of other issues - e.g. incest, kidnap, paedophilia, etc - Are we to infer that He must therefore now affirm/permit these things, too, or do we simply accept that he didn't have to restate those things because they are still plainly & morally wrong and censured elsewhere in the Bible?

On a more positive note, just in case anyone is interested, there is a Christian organisation called Living Out founded by Christians who live with same-sex attractions which encourages churches to welcome all those with a same-sex attraction but also encourages them to live a life of faith in Jesus Christ which reconciles their sexuality with the teachings of the bible. This doesn't have to be an either/or issue. It can be one where truth, honesty and justice come together in a positive way.

3scape · 18/12/2021 13:57

The alpha course was specifically written to persuade and cajole and is a pile of 'ignore evidenced and God is love utter tripe. They need bigger congregation s to stay in business. It's one of their strategies.

amoosee · 18/12/2021 13:52

@paws17

I hope you don't have any gay children, for their sake.

OllyBJolly · 14/12/2021 22:42

I got involved with the church only because the DCs wanted to go to Sunday School because their friends did. Surprised to find the Minister (CofS) was an old University acquaintance - openly gay, his boyfriend sat in the front pew —sometimes looking very bored—

I was converted. So much of what the sermons seemed to resonate with me. The fellowship, the intellectual stretching, the love - meant that I felt “at home” in church. I’m sure the congregation contained misogynists, racists, homophobes, hypocrites etc but probably fewer than I found as a member of the Labour Party! As the Minister used to say. “How can God be homophobic? He wanted more love in the world, not less.”

youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/12/2021 22:08

You can't accuse Christ of being a homophobe based on things he may have said that we don't know about.

We don't know anything though. That's where faith comes in.

Believers are content to take the word of the Bible as accurate representations of people they believe existed as depicted in scripture. Non believers aren't.

To say 'Jesus never said anything homophobic' therefore doesn't sound like a sensible or possible statement as we can't even know Jesus existed as depicted, let alone what he did say or didn't say.

Againstmachine · 14/12/2021 21:54

Yes, but we can only go on what we have. You can't accuse Christ of being a homophobe based on things he may have said that we don't know about.

But it was stated he never said anything 'ever' it was absolute.

But it doesn't matter he didn't exist so he won't matter.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/12/2021 20:49

@Againstmachine

Christianity is fundamentally homophobic For this to be true, Christ himself would have needed to say something condemning homosexuality. He didn't. Ever.

You can't possibly know that , Were you there?, all mention of Jesus is wrote many years after.

Yes, but we can only go on what we have. You can't accuse Christ of being a homophobe based on things he may have said that we don't know about.
Voldermortsballsack · 14/12/2021 20:36

many people believe that Jesus himself was gay!

Grin they were talking about this at our local C of E church recently. (Open minded Bible reading)

Anyhoo, I’m sure your sister is fine @Southtrainer Smile

youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/12/2021 18:16

I think this is a huge issue when engaging with Christians about Jesus' teachings. We only know what other people say he said.

So when 'his words' are used as supposed evidence of something, it's nonsensical to us as non believers because all it 'proves' is that at some point someone said that Jesus said / did something.

This nonsensical logic (to us as non believers) is then exacerbated when people say oh well I believe x, y and z bits of the Bible are accurate but not a, b or c.

Conveniently usually the bits that are less palatable (thoughts on gay people and women) are the bits people claim not to believe or, more often, say are misquoted / twisted and not 'what Jesus meant'.

It so often feels like Cherry picking the bits that are palatable and least likely to offend. As I said upthread, it would almost be refreshing if someone on here said 'yes as a Christian I believe it's wrong to be gay' because we have all met plenty of Christians who feel that way and surely part of them being true to their beliefs is sharing them if they are sure of them? I find it all fascinating but these reasons and more make it really hard to have a meaningful discussion about.

Zilla1 · 14/12/2021 18:13

For the avoidance of doubt, the bold typeface of the quote in my post failed. I completely disagree that Christianity of Homophobic. Some Christians are, as are some people of other faiths and many with no faith.

Zilla1 · 14/12/2021 18:12

Christianity is fundamentally homophobic. Please feel free to post the words in the (few) Verses that some people interpret as discussing homosexuality so the uninformed can see how many there are and how clear of ambiguity they are. While you're at it, please feel free to post the New Testament's view of the Old Testament and for context, what the Old Testaments says about mixing textiles or planting fields. It is always interesting to set out the Scriptural basis that homophobes with hate in their heart use to justify their views and focus on Homosexuality and also what some Christianity-haters use to state that Christianity is fundamentally homophobic.

Againstmachine · 14/12/2021 18:07

Christianity is fundamentally homophobic For this to be true, Christ himself would have needed to say something condemning homosexuality. He didn't. Ever.

You can't possibly know that , Were you there?, all mention of Jesus is wrote many years after.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/12/2021 18:05

@hivemindneeded

Christianity is fundamentally homophobic For this to be true, Christ himself would have needed to say something condemning homosexuality. He didn't. Ever. Paul has a problem with it. But I have a problem with Paul. Christ himself didn't mention it. Not something he thought worth objecting to. And he was very opinionated on tax collectors and the rich being stingy and children being silenced and women being shunned. He was very clear on what he judged and homosexuality played no part in his judgements.
You say he wasn't keen on women being shunned... He was keen on them submitting to their husbands and their husbands being the absolute leader of the household and family. Sexism like that is rife in the church's teachings and it's disingenuous to say otherwise, especially to those of us who grew up in church and attended religious schools.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/12/2021 18:02

@hivemindneeded

Christianity is fundamentally homophobic For this to be true, Christ himself would have needed to say something condemning homosexuality. He didn't. Ever. Paul has a problem with it. But I have a problem with Paul. Christ himself didn't mention it. Not something he thought worth objecting to. And he was very opinionated on tax collectors and the rich being stingy and children being silenced and women being shunned. He was very clear on what he judged and homosexuality played no part in his judgements.
Do you genuinely believe that the majority of Christian churches across the globe preach that being gay, having gay relationships and being in a same sex marriage is absolutely no different to being straight and doing those things?
hivemindneeded · 14/12/2021 17:54

Christianity is fundamentally homophobic For this to be true, Christ himself would have needed to say something condemning homosexuality. He didn't. Ever.
Paul has a problem with it. But I have a problem with Paul. Christ himself didn't mention it. Not something he thought worth objecting to. And he was very opinionated on tax collectors and the rich being stingy and children being silenced and women being shunned. He was very clear on what he judged and homosexuality played no part in his judgements.

Practicebeingpatient · 14/12/2021 16:59

I'm a Christian and I have done some of the Alpha course. Imo didn't like it. If I hadn't already been a Christian I think it would have put me off.

Voldermortsballsack · 14/12/2021 14:25

I’ve done Alpha! I don’t think you have anything to worry about.

She can pray and believe in God and not be a church goer / full on religious.

She might be doing Alpha just to understand a bit more about her partners religion (that’s why I did it!)

Also, I made life long amazing friends from opening my mind and my heart to religion and I’m still not religious myself.

But I am happy. My marriage is great and I love knowing more about Christianity to support my husbands beliefs.

Plus, it’s a great topic! Chill out Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread