Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
paws17 · 19/12/2021 22:57

@amoosee - Homophobia encompasses a range of negative attitudes and feelings toward homosexuality or people who are identified or perceived as being lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (LGBT). It has been defined as contempt, prejudice, aversion, hatred or antipathy, may be based on irrational fear and ignorance, and is also related to religious beliefs.

Since you've turned to Wikipedia for your definition, perhaps you'll like this related word definition that I've just put together:

Christophobia encompasses a range of negative attitudes and feelings toward Christianity or people who are identified or perceived as being Christians or "religious". It has been defined as contempt, prejudice, aversion, hatred or antipathy, may be based on irrational fear and ignorance, and is also related to atheist beliefs.

Looks like we might both equally be guilty as charged Smile

amoosee · 19/12/2021 14:59

[quote paws17]@allyouvegottenminuteslynn

You believe, I assume, that if someone gay has same sex sexual partners, they go to hell? Even if they are great people who are kind and loving, but just happen to be gay and have a same sex sexual partner?

I wouldn't dare to suggest such a thing but I would recommend that anyone who is considering the possibility of becoming a Christian is ready & willing for the Holy Spirit (I know, another unsubstantiated entity) to challenge their conscience on ALL of their current behaviours & attitudes in the light of what God desires for their lives going forward.

It's baffling to me if you believe that (correct me if I'm wrong) that you're offended when people call you homophobic.

In honesty, I'd need to be provided with a universally agreed definition of the word in order to decide if I'm offended by being called it. I'd be surprised if sharing some of the contents of an ancient book which, apparently, very few people recognise as having any relevance or validity in shaping their life paths would come under such a definition.

Do I hate gay people? No. Do I discriminate against gay people? No. Am I fearful of gay people? No. Do I want gay people to be a part of God's family? Absolutely, YES![/quote]
Homophobia encompasses a range of negative attitudes and feelings toward homosexuality or people who are identified or perceived as being lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (LGBT).[1][2][3] It has been defined as contempt, prejudice, aversion, hatred or antipathy, may be based on irrational fear and ignorance, and is also related to religious beliefs.[4][5]

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homophobia

I'd say that describes you.

Do I want gay people to be a part of God's family? Absolutely, YES!

So long as they remain single and celibate.

Knittinglibby · 19/12/2021 13:39

I'm left wing and Christian. But I also understand your concerns. I think for me if it was a C fo E or mainstream Church running it I'd not worry so much. I have had a few friends get caught up in very divisive & right wing groups, but they aren't likely the type to run Alpha and more likely to do their own thing fundamentally b/c many don't believe C of E and anything done by/with it, is Christian enough!

youvegottenminuteslynn · 19/12/2021 13:29

@paws17

Your tone comes across as ever so disingenuous because however many ways you essentially say 'I'm not judging', your posts are dripping in both judgement and oddly a hesitation when it comes to committing to your beliefs.

I would bet my house that you believe gay people who have gay sex will go to hell unless they repent. I don't get why people won't own the fact they believe that, if they believe in god so strongly and are so sure that he believes sex with a same sex partner is wrong and a sin.

paws17 · 19/12/2021 12:41

@allyouvegottenminuteslynn

You believe, I assume, that if someone gay has same sex sexual partners, they go to hell? Even if they are great people who are kind and loving, but just happen to be gay and have a same sex sexual partner?

I wouldn't dare to suggest such a thing but I would recommend that anyone who is considering the possibility of becoming a Christian is ready & willing for the Holy Spirit (I know, another unsubstantiated entity) to challenge their conscience on ALL of their current behaviours & attitudes in the light of what God desires for their lives going forward.

It's baffling to me if you believe that (correct me if I'm wrong) that you're offended when people call you homophobic.

In honesty, I'd need to be provided with a universally agreed definition of the word in order to decide if I'm offended by being called it. I'd be surprised if sharing some of the contents of an ancient book which, apparently, very few people recognise as having any relevance or validity in shaping their life paths would come under such a definition.

Do I hate gay people? No. Do I discriminate against gay people? No. Am I fearful of gay people? No. Do I want gay people to be a part of God's family? Absolutely, YES!

donquixotedelamancha · 19/12/2021 11:04

I personally don't believe in evolution either grin But the Alpha course isn't to blame for that!

As this thread is already derailed I'll bite here:

I don't understand 'Christians' who don't 'believe' in evolution. It's completely outside mainstream Christianity to reject Science. Many of these people are Anglican or similar but holding views which are heretical to the mainstream protestant communions.

Why has that particular bit of Science denial got such a hold but these people still (usually) accept that electricity is not magic and will be treated by modern medicine?

If they want to accept the old testament (which Christians do not) why don't they go into the wilderness and burn two pigeons when on their period?

beastlyslumber · 19/12/2021 11:02

I'm sorry, I just need to clarify - when you say you don't believe in evolution - you are aware that evolution is not an idea to believe/not believe in? It's like saying you don't believe in the earth, or you don't believe in water. We know that evolution is how life on earth came to be. There is really no doubt at all about it.

Obviously you are entitled to your belief, but I just can't quite understand it. If you said you believed in aliens, then okay. That's something for which there is some evidence, however flimsy it may be, and certainly can be a matter of belief. But you're saying you don't believe in a material fact. Or are you just trying to wind people up?

amoosee · 19/12/2021 10:58

[quote paws17]**@amoosee* @allyouvegottenminuteslynn* @allAgainstmachine

Yes how dare people call you, who just compared homosexuality to paedophilia

To be fair to myself, if you re-read my earlier comments, you'll see that I wasn't comparing homosexuality to paedophilia. I listed a few issues that, like homosexuality, are not mentioned in the bible by Jesus in response to an argument put forward by some that if Jesus didn't mention it, it must mean that He didn't have a view on the matter.

Of course there are lots of other issues that Jesus did mention in his ministry which those of us who do believe need to be equally challenged by. (Unkindness, hatred, jealousy, divorce, gluttony, lies, stealing, adultery, cheating, ignoring the plight of the poor & widows, etc, etc.)[/quote]
Oh come on, it's very clean that you were comparing them don't act like we're idiots.

and now you're quite clearly comparing it with things like hatred and adultery.

The difference being those things are harmful. Homosexuality is not. Telling gay people especially children and teenagers, that because of who they are they can never have a relationship is harmful, however.

Flutterflybutterby · 19/12/2021 10:52

(I am a Christian, full disclosure, and have done the Alpha course twice. I personally don't believe in evolution either Grin But the Alpha course isn't to blame for that!)

Flutterflybutterby · 19/12/2021 10:41

The Alpha course is a very open way to explore Christianity and discuss your own thoughts and feelings. You are put under no pressure whatsoever. It's a wonderful, welcoming, lovely environment and experience. Just because your family holds certain beliefs doesn't mean that your sister isn't allowed to explore Christianity. It will be a wonderful experience for her.

MrsSkylerWhite · 19/12/2021 10:38

We’re atheists. Would think it was not my business.

CasperGutman · 19/12/2021 10:36

@FourTeaFallOut

Rearranging your beliefs to better mirror your partner doesn't scream healthy relationship though.
It's not as if she's going from being a fundamentalist Muslim or observant Jew to joining some weird sect though, is it? She's previously been "agnostic" and not a convinced atheist, so has always been open to the idea there's a God.

She's in love with a partner to whom God and the church are important, and I wouldn't find it concerning that she's exploring whether she wants to get more involved with that aspect of his life.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 19/12/2021 09:59

@paws17

I read your comments just fine.

You believe, I assume, that if someone gay has same sex sexual partners, they go to hell? Even if they are great people who are kind and loving, but just happen to be gay and have a same sex sexual partner?

It's baffling to me if you believe that (correct me if I'm wrong) that you're offended when people call you homophobic.

paws17 · 19/12/2021 09:53

@amoosee @allyouvegottenminuteslynn @allAgainstmachine

Yes how dare people call you, who just compared homosexuality to paedophilia

To be fair to myself, if you re-read my earlier comments, you'll see that I wasn't comparing homosexuality to paedophilia. I listed a few issues that, like homosexuality, are not mentioned in the bible by Jesus in response to an argument put forward by some that if Jesus didn't mention it, it must mean that He didn't have a view on the matter.

Of course there are lots of other issues that Jesus did mention in his ministry which those of us who do believe need to be equally challenged by. (Unkindness, hatred, jealousy, divorce, gluttony, lies, stealing, adultery, cheating, ignoring the plight of the poor & widows, etc, etc.)

paws17 · 19/12/2021 09:36

@allyouvegottenminuteslynn @allGoodPrincessWenceslas

Again, for future discussions you may have with atheists - citing the Bible as proof when speaking to a non believer is entirely nonsensical.

I understand people's irritation about the way that Christians seem to put so much faith in the contents of some ancient document scrolls - but if you take away the bible you take away the only physical artifact that gives any credence & validity to the framework of beliefs and practices that is Christianity. As soon as people start embellishing the message of the bible with their own modern nuances or ignoring bits that don't suit them, you may get more "peace on earth" but you can't call it genuine Christianity anymore.

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 19/12/2021 08:05

The only message I would share is my own belief that if anyone wants to do business with God at any time in their life, they'll need to do so on the basis of His revealed plans & purposes for the human race, as recorded in the bible, and avail themselves of the simple means He has already provided for obtaining forgiveness and coming into a restored relationship with Him i.e. repentance & putting their trust in the redeeming & cleansing work of His son, Jesus, on that famous cross.

The problem is that what is in the bible is not the revealed plan of any deity, but what a very disparate group of people who are products of the societies they lived in thought should be the plan. If Jesus turned up now and his followers started writing down his life and teachings without benefit of transcripts, you can bet that what they chose to record would be coloured by their own perceptions and values.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 19/12/2021 07:03

@paws17

Stephen Fry may be the cleverest man in the world but confronting God with his "bone-cancer in children" challenge is likely to be wasted effort if he's not already read & digested Genesis 1 to 3, which explains fully why there is currently so much misery and distress in the world - and Revelation 21 to 22, which assures those who do believe & trust in Him that it won't always be that way.

You keep citing words / passages from the Bible as if they are objective proof. They are not proof, they are an entirely biased source that requires faith to be believed.

'Well god explains this' doesn't mean anything to people who don't believe in god.

And you really don't get it - you say you don't understand how people can be angry with god if they don't believe in him. They aren't. They're angry with people who preach hate under the umbrella of 'god said xyz' and with the premise / concept that an all powerful, loving deity would allow such cruelty to occur in the world.

Again, for future discussions you may have with atheists - citing the Bible as proof when speaking to a non believer is entirely nonsensical.

amoosee · 19/12/2021 03:55

[quote paws17]**@amoosee* - I think I have been very clear throughout that it is same-sex sexual acts which are criticised in the Bible, not people who have same-sex "attraction & desires" - and also, that "Living Out"* was actually founded by a group of gay Christians, for gay Christians. Are you suggesting that gay people can be homophobic? Perhaps that explains why detransitioners get such a bad press, if they get any press at all.[/quote]
Of course gay people can be homophobic

The organisation you linked to tells gay people that they should either remain single and never have a romantic or sexual relationship their entire lives or should marry a member of the opposite sex.

paws17 · 19/12/2021 03:20

@amoosee - I think I have been very clear throughout that it is same-sex sexual acts which are criticised in the Bible, not people who have same-sex "attraction & desires" - and also, that "Living Out" was actually founded by a group of gay Christians, for gay Christians. Are you suggesting that gay people can be homophobic? Perhaps that explains why detransitioners get such a bad press, if they get any press at all.

amoosee · 19/12/2021 02:57

@paws17
In doing so, I have attracted the predictable name-calling that stems from the tendency to criticise & blame the messenger rather than the message. This problem seems to rear its head whenever sensitive issues are up for discussion - be it Trans issues, Brexit, the desirability of Covid mass vaccinations, etc. So, anyone who says something that we disagree with must be accused of "hate-speech" and "XXXX-phobia or YYYY-ism. Surely an enlightened society can cope with the concept of hearing alternative viewpoints, even if they are unpalatable for some/many?

Yes how dare people call you, who just compared homosexuality to paedophilia and promoted a homophobic group, a homophobe?

paws17 · 19/12/2021 02:50

It does intrigue me that some people seem to get so upset about someone/some being that they emphatically believe is just an unfortunate figment of the warped and unsound minds of deceivers and fantasists and an ancient book which they believe to be completely devoid of historical merit, accuracy or relevance.

I've only contributed to this thread because the OP invited us all to do so - and since the Alpha course is about promotion of bible-based Christianity, I did what few others appear to have been willing to do - provide a glimpse of what the bible - not me personally - has to say about certain issues of topical interest.

In doing so, I have attracted the predictable name-calling that stems from the tendency to criticise & blame the messenger rather than the message. This problem seems to rear its head whenever sensitive issues are up for discussion - be it Trans issues, Brexit, the desirability of Covid mass vaccinations, etc. So, anyone who says something that we disagree with must be accused of "hate-speech" and "XXXX-phobia or YYYY-ism. Surely an enlightened society can cope with the concept of hearing alternative viewpoints, even if they are unpalatable for some/many?

I can't apologise to you all for the fact that God (if He does exist) seems to be critical of a wide range of typical human behaviours in the publication which has been held to be His inspired work for the last 2000 years - and the basis of the Christian faith. I didn't write the bible - and it's definitely not my right to judge anyone - including my own children - about what God may be saying or not saying about human behaviour.

The only message I would share is my own belief that if anyone wants to do business with God at any time in their life, they'll need to do so on the basis of His revealed plans & purposes for the human race, as recorded in the bible, and avail themselves of the simple means He has already provided for obtaining forgiveness and coming into a restored relationship with Him i.e. repentance & putting their trust in the redeeming & cleansing work of His son, Jesus, on that famous cross.

Stephen Fry may be the cleverest man in the world but confronting God with his "bone-cancer in children" challenge is likely to be wasted effort if he's not already read & digested Genesis 1 to 3, which explains fully why there is currently so much misery and distress in the world - and Revelation 21 to 22, which assures those who do believe & trust in Him that it won't always be that way.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 18/12/2021 22:27

Same @GoodPrincessWenceslas

Stephen Fry put it perfectly IMO when asked what he would say if it turned out god was real and he was faced with him. He answered:

“I’ll say: bone cancer in children, what’s that about? How dare you how dare you create a world where there is such misery that’s not our fault? It’s utterly, utterly evil.

Why should I respect a capricious, mean-minded, stupid god who creates a world which is so full of injustice and pain?

The god who created this universe, if he created this universe, is quite clearly a maniac, an utter maniac, totally selfish. We have to spend our lives on our knees thanking him. What kind of god would do that?

Yes the world is very splendid, but it also has in it insects whose whole life cycle is to burrow into the eyes of children and make them blind.”

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 18/12/2021 22:23

It's a truly bizarre and quixotic god who, in his omnipotence, apparently chooses to create people who are only attracted to those of the same sex only to tell them it would be wicked to express those attractions - whilst allowing even the most evil of heterosexuals free rein in that regard. It really baffles me how people manage to construct that sort of being in their minds, let alone choose to worship him.

Againstmachine · 18/12/2021 19:43

Did you really just fucking compare homosexuality - which harms absolutely no one by the way, unlike the homophobic bile you're spewing - to incest kidnap and paedophilia?

Wow they did, and it's vile that this person is comparing homosexuality to the above, I thought we had left this thinking a while ago.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 18/12/2021 19:19

@paws17

At least you're (relatively) open about being homophobic I guess. Extra hate points for comparing gay people to paedophiles and incest.

How sad you'd want a child of yours never to have a romantic partner, a love of their life, a loving co-parent to kids if they were gay. FYI if you do have kids, they may well be gay but never tell you. I know I wouldn't.

As evidenced in your response to me, you preach hate, not love. But as I said, at least you're open about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread