Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 16:08

@EducatingArti

See I think you are shifting arguments there. Up thread you said specifically that all Christian churches pretty much were anti-gay. This is actually not true as I have shown. Many many Methodist churches will also have a very inclusive attitude for example.

I don't agree that Christianity is inherently homophobic. I am a Christian and not homophobic ( I hope!) . If I thought that my belief system was inherently homophobic I'd have to live with an irreconcilable conflict of belief within myself... I question, struggle and grow in my understanding of and relationship with God, I don't have all the answers for sure and I don't even know all the questions, but I do believe that true Christian faith is a dynamic, growing developing and redeeming thing. I can see this in the Bible when I look at how people shifted and changed ( either towards or away from) as a result of relating to Jesus. Our faith is not a static thing.
I don't think the homophobia within the church ( and there, I do agree with you that there is lots of it) is actually inherent to Christianity as a faith. I do think that many Christians misinterpret the Bible and I don't claim to have a monopoly on correct interpretation myself. However I do believe there is an undercurrent of evangelical ( maybe post-evangelical?) thinking that is coming to very different and more radical conclusions on biblical interpretation.

But all Christian churches pretty much are anti gay. You linking to literally two examples doesn't disprove my statement. There are millions of Christian churches of all denominations all over the world. The vast, vast majority are homophobic. You know this as well as I do. Just because your church supposedly isn't homophobic (though apparently it was sufficiently rabidly homophobic up to four years ago to cause one of your congregation to kill themselves, so...) doesn't mean the wider religion isn't. I'm afraid it is. If it weren't, churches who adhere to the central tenets of the Christian faith wouldn't be allowed to preach that homophobia is a sin. And yet they are and many do.

That's great that you're not homophobic. And I agree that Christianity as a faith at its heart is supposed to be about loving and accepting everyone no matter what as Jesus supposedly did when he was alive. That's a beautiful message. But the Bible doesn't actually say that, most Christians don't practice that, and the reality is that all religions are a way for humans to wield power over others.

I have never been so judged as I have been inside Christian communities.

It also amazes me that so many Christians think they have the monopoly on kindness and good works. The vast majority of charitable organisations in the world are not affiliated to any religion. Being religious doesn't make you a better person than anyone else. In fact, often, I think it makes people worse, because Christianity encourages you to view yourself as part of an 'elect' that has been 'chosen' to be 'saved'. You have come to 'see the light' and know 'the truth' - and therefore will go to heaven while the rest of us will die screaming in agony because we didn't spend our lives either self flagellating over our numerous sins or judging other people for theirs.

I don't have a problem with people going to church if it makes them happy. My problem is that a lot of churches - particularly evangelical ones - don't. They make people miserable by trying to make them change everything about themselves so that they conform to a narrow set of reactionary beliefs that coincidentally revolve around men getting to do whatever the fuck they want while women do the washing up and look after the kids.

kmblark · 11/12/2021 16:07

[quote Southtrainer]@PerfectPrepPrincess
I suppose initially their very different views that she suddenly stopped talking about in front of him, she stopped seeing her gay friends, he comes into zoom family chats and she goes quiet. She gave up a good job and life to
Move across the country to be with him (which I suppose is normal but he didn’t offer to move there).

Im still not sold on her not being converted. As another rooster said- that is part of what evangelical Christians believe is it not?[/quote]
This is a gigantic red flag, and my advice would be to be to let your sister k ow you're there fr her in case she ever needs help to leave this bastard.

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:07

I actually remember Nicky Gumble comparing homosexuality to paedophilia thinking about it, as one poster has recalled. This didn't sit well with me, but the thing about being a true believer isn't following what others say, but what God says. God says love all, not what Nicky Gumble says or suggests. You have to interpret the Bible with the social and historical context of when it was written, if you don't you're fooling yourself.

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:01

@Southtrainer

isn't that what evangelicalism is all about

Evangelicalism is about spreading Christianity and hopefully converting yes. BUT only if it's the choice of the one considering converting. Think of them like enablers.

Unfortunately there are many 'wrong' churches who give 'good' churches a bad name. Similar situation to the those who think all Muslims are jihadusts and terrorists, obviously they're not 😂

The Bible actually advises people to be wise to the 'wrong' churches /preachers and to seek the truth, not their spin on it.

Your sister dropping her gay friends is definitely not Christian and if her BFs branch of evangelical Church believes it is, they are definitely part of the 'wrong' church as God's instruction is to love all.

I've recently read a part of the bible that even does away with the need for a gender, taking me a long time to digest but it's there... The problem with the bible is that that the authors are no longer around to explain, its been translated from translations of translations, there are several books and chapters missing and it requires a certain amount of cognitive ability to interpret sensibly.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 11/12/2021 16:00

To me being a Christian is showing love and kindness not doing a hard sell on conversion.

Faith is not a problem but many non-believers sadly disagree with it.

Many non-believers are kind and loving without faith. That's not sad, it means they're being kind and loving for altruistic reasons rather than for reward or fear of punishment. I think that's pretty brilliant actually.

speakout · 11/12/2021 15:56

Faith is not a problem but many non-believers sadly disagree with it.

I don;t see what is sad about that.

Lunificent · 11/12/2021 15:52

I’d be concerned about the red flags you mention. I don’t know what you could do about it though.

ALightThatNeverGoesOut · 11/12/2021 15:49

Faith is not a problem but many non-believers sadly disagree with it.

V few people see themselves as the bad guy, despite how they appear to others.

ricepolo · 11/12/2021 15:47

Christianity as a religion instituted and perpetuated by men in order to ensure their own power and strength may well be anti women.

But Christianity as a lived belief isn’t anti women. Jesus loved and respected women! He treated them as equals to men in a society which institutionally and culturally saw them as second class citizens. This was truly revolutionary. Women were in no way inferior: it’s human distortion for their own ends of what Jesus said and who he was which has led to a false understanding and caused so much damage.

Lifeisaminestrone · 11/12/2021 15:45

All Christians are different!

I’m really quite upset reading Christians are anti-gay and anti-women.

I go to church to help me see a different perspective (from when I used to work in the city and people were so financially driven).

I also use my faith to pray for those in need and in the past support the more vulnerable children in society. In that role (and other church members) we never tried to convert, was just there for support.

I have done the Alpha course for an evangelical church and did not stay as found it as other posters have suggested. If my CofE church did it, I wouldn’t attend due to past experiences but I wouldn’t be anti it either.

To me being a Christian is showing love and kindness not doing a hard sell on conversion.

Faith is not a problem but many non-believers sadly disagree with it.

EducatingArti · 11/12/2021 15:40

See I think you are shifting arguments there.
Up thread you said specifically that all Christian churches pretty much were anti-gay. This is actually not true as I have shown.
Many many Methodist churches will also have a very inclusive attitude for example.

I don't agree that Christianity is inherently homophobic. I am a Christian and not homophobic ( I hope!) . If I thought that my belief system was inherently homophobic I'd have to live with an irreconcilable conflict of belief within myself... I question, struggle and grow in my understanding of and relationship with God, I don't have all the answers for sure and I don't even know all the questions, but I do believe that true Christian faith is a dynamic, growing developing and redeeming thing. I can see this in the Bible when I look at how people shifted and changed ( either towards or away from) as a result of relating to Jesus. Our faith is not a static thing.
I don't think the homophobia within the church ( and there, I do agree with you that there is lots of it) is actually inherent to Christianity as a faith. I do think that many Christians misinterpret the Bible and I don't claim to have a monopoly on correct interpretation myself. However I do believe there is an undercurrent of evangelical ( maybe post-evangelical?) thinking that is coming to very different and more radical conclusions on biblical interpretation.

ALightThatNeverGoesOut · 11/12/2021 15:33

I mean the entire point of Alpha is to convert people into evangelical christianity. If you'd be concerned about that wrt your sister then yeah I think you should be concerned wrt alpha.

I'm sure there are lots of nice people who are evangelical christians. But what they preach doesn't cohere with a pluralistic liberal society imo. And that's what - under the guise of "discussion" and "exploration" - alpha does to non believers in the hope that they will become believers. And they do have a v good success rate, conversion wise.

BritWifeInUSA · 11/12/2021 15:33

Maybe it’s the other way round and through exploring Christianity she met her new partner and not that the partner forced Christianity on her.

CactusLemonSpice · 11/12/2021 15:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 15:18

@EducatingArti, I agree, there are some churches that are accepting of LGBTQ.

But as a religion, the overwhelming belief system across all denominations is homophobic.

You can't deny that isn't true. Linking to a couple of churches that do gay pride doesn't erase the reality that Christianity is inherently homophobic.

EducatingArti · 11/12/2021 15:15

lizzielowe.org/shaping-an-inclusive-loving-and-faithful-church/
@EnidSpyton
The church describes itself as both evangelical and fully inclusive.
It is a tricky and difficult area, I agree but there is movement within the evangelical church for change and I just don't think it is true to describe all Christian churches as anti-gay.

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 15:15

[quote EducatingArti]@EnidSpyton
The church I linked to does welcome,accept and affirm those in gay and lesbian relationships. They hold annual gay pride events in their grounds. My same sex relationship friends and their children have been made very welcome there.
You can read a bit of the church story here about how tragedy transformed their approach. They have more women than men on their leadership team I think and women are certainly as much of a driving force as men in developing the focus and direction of that church.
stjamesandemmanuel.org/didsbury-pride-and-the-church-that-changed/
and there are Christians at the evangelical end of the spectrum who are engaging deeply with these things.
My personal view is that Christians need to check out what the Bible actually says about women, homosexuality etc in the context and culture in which things were were originally given. Many Christians are doing this and coming to surprising conclusions.[/quote]
But how fucking awful that a 14 year old girl had to commit suicide before your church realised that their attitude towards homosexuality was so damaging it was driving people to want to kill themselves. If she hadn't have committed suicide, would they have changed their tune, I wonder?

Don't get me wrong, it's great your church has done this soul searching and has realised they need to change.

But no church should need a child to kill themselves out of utter despair at the way they've been made to feel by their church community for a church to realise that they're preaching hatred.

Should they?

DreamingofTimbuktu · 11/12/2021 15:15

I’d be a little concerned. I know 2 friends who separately did the alpha course. They both then chose to move to different cities miles from home to “plant” a church and largely cut themselves off from previous friends.

CactusLemonSpice · 11/12/2021 15:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CactusLemonSpice · 11/12/2021 15:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

EducatingArti · 11/12/2021 15:01

@EnidSpyton
The church I linked to does welcome,accept and affirm those in gay and lesbian relationships. They hold annual gay pride events in their grounds. My same sex relationship friends and their children have been made very welcome there.
You can read a bit of the church story here about how tragedy transformed their approach. They have more women than men on their leadership team I think and women are certainly as much of a driving force as men in developing the focus and direction of that church.
stjamesandemmanuel.org/didsbury-pride-and-the-church-that-changed/
and there are Christians at the evangelical end of the spectrum who are engaging deeply with these things.
My personal view is that Christians need to check out what the Bible actually says about women, homosexuality etc in the context and culture in which things were were originally given. Many Christians are doing this and coming to surprising conclusions.

Deathraystare · 11/12/2021 15:01

Well I am not at all religious but my ex flat mate was doing the Alpha course and was an absolute sweetheart. She left the flat to get married (I attended!). She came from a religious background as her father was a vicar/pastor/whatever you call 'em.

We still keep in touch. Apart from inviting me to a church (for carols), there was no pressure to join. She knew how I felt!!!

TowandaForever · 11/12/2021 14:57

@EnidSpyton

OP have since seen your other posts about your sister's behaviour changing since she's been with this guy.

A lot of evangelical Christian men are very controlling. They're attracted to the church because it gives them legitimised power over women.

Evangelical Christians believe men are superior to women, that they have the role of the head of the household, that they are the authority over the household, etc etc etc. They believe that a woman's job is to 'submit' to her husband.

Evangelical Christian readings of the Bible are built around perpetuating a narrative of rightful male dominance over women. There's also a HUGE and incredibly unhealthy focus on sexual purity and homophobia.

Evangelical Christianity IS a cult. It's led by a small group of men who enjoy the power it gives them over others. Honestly, unless you've been in that world, you will never truly understand how toxic it is.

I would be doing whatever I could to get her out of this relationship before you lose her altogether.

I agree. With everything you said.
ManicPixie · 11/12/2021 14:56

I’d be more disappointed she’s dating (what you’ve made sound like) a religious fundamentalist than the course itself. But she’s an adult, what can you do?

Swipe left for the next trending thread