Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 11/12/2021 17:12

@WOTW

YABU! I am a Christian and would offer a similar course to folks in our area. The Alpha course (and the one we do) is used simply to provide information about the Christian faith. There's absolutely no pressure to convert, in fact, most Christian's (including myself) don't believe you can force someone to convert. Either they believe or they don't. We don't push.

It's funny, so many people will decide they are agnostic, or atheist without actually exploring what Christianity is all about. Your sister is showing an interest and "hearing them out" I guess you could say. I don't think this is a reason for concern, but actually, it's refreshing to see someone with an open mind. She may do the course and decide she still doesn't believe, and that's absolutely fine. It's only short videos and a discussion. Leave her be.

In this specific case though, OP is concerned about the relationship due to a number of red flags. She says her sisters partner and family don't believe in dinosaurs and that her sister has stopped seeing her gay friends since being with him - these things indicate he is relatively extreme in his views so I can understand OP being concerned.
EducatingArti · 11/12/2021 17:10

@enidspyton
I totally agree that it is horrendous that it took a teenager's death for that church to change and grow. It isn't actually my church but one I know of in my area.
I think everyone within that church would also agree with you that it was horrendous.
I am also extremely sorry about your experiences of spiritual abuse. That must have been an awful thing for you to go through. I know it happens. I have experienced (maybe a more minor version ?) it myself within the church and I have also experienced unconditional love and people who have stuck by me and supported me in an extremely sacrificial way.
I don't have easy answers, but I do know that the whole church is not homophobic or sexist and I am very sorry that you have been hurt.

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 11/12/2021 17:07

@ALightThatNeverGoesOut

It isn't.

ALightThatNeverGoesOut · 11/12/2021 17:02

If they're not after converting people then why is Alpha exclusively for non believers?

Lulu1919 · 11/12/2021 16:58

I'm not religious ...I did the alpha course ..it was interesting..lots of different views lots of chat ...no pressure to 'join' the church etc
I'm still in the same place regarding beliefs etc

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 16:56

@WOTW

YABU! I am a Christian and would offer a similar course to folks in our area. The Alpha course (and the one we do) is used simply to provide information about the Christian faith. There's absolutely no pressure to convert, in fact, most Christian's (including myself) don't believe you can force someone to convert. Either they believe or they don't. We don't push.

It's funny, so many people will decide they are agnostic, or atheist without actually exploring what Christianity is all about. Your sister is showing an interest and "hearing them out" I guess you could say. I don't think this is a reason for concern, but actually, it's refreshing to see someone with an open mind. She may do the course and decide she still doesn't believe, and that's absolutely fine. It's only short videos and a discussion. Leave her be.

Did you not read the part where her sister's boyfriend is homophobic, doesn't believe in dinosaurs, and her sister has changed since meeting him in order to fit in with his fundamentalist Christian views?

Under those circumstances, the OP has every reason to be concerned about her sister attending an Alpha course run by his church, which is preaching anti evolution and homophobic views.

And pretending the Alpha course is just about 'information' and not about conversion is ridiculous. Honestly. There's a reason why they provide free food, too. Draws in the most vulnerable and keeps them there.

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 16:52

@Tanith

Your experience is your experience, EnidSpyton. Nothing more, nothing less. It proves nothing.

My experience of the number of churches I have attended over the years is different from yours. My experience is not your description of Christian churches.

Your experience is your experience, @Tanith. It also proves nothing.

Not sure what your point is here.

WOTW · 11/12/2021 16:50

YABU! I am a Christian and would offer a similar course to folks in our area. The Alpha course (and the one we do) is used simply to provide information about the Christian faith. There's absolutely no pressure to convert, in fact, most Christian's (including myself) don't believe you can force someone to convert. Either they believe or they don't. We don't push.

It's funny, so many people will decide they are agnostic, or atheist without actually exploring what Christianity is all about. Your sister is showing an interest and "hearing them out" I guess you could say. I don't think this is a reason for concern, but actually, it's refreshing to see someone with an open mind. She may do the course and decide she still doesn't believe, and that's absolutely fine. It's only short videos and a discussion. Leave her be.

Tanith · 11/12/2021 16:49

Your experience is your experience, EnidSpyton. Nothing more, nothing less. It proves nothing.

My experience of the number of churches I have attended over the years is different from yours. My experience is not your description of Christian churches.

IAAP · 11/12/2021 16:47

@SpanielsAreMyLife

My sister did an Alpha course, though none of us knew about it at the time. It also co-incided with what I personally feel was a mental health crisis, and the person that I knew disappeared into the ether.

We're no longer in contact because I just don't know who she is anymore - and she's dropped everyone of her old friends. She's also dropped my DC, who were a massive part of her life beforehand.

I appreciate that for some people, religion can be a great comfort but I think it can also be a very big cry for help too.

This any religion when you are low, vulnerable or undergoing any stress or emotional or mental problems can provide a crutch that can reel you in.

I know as I’ve done it - my family is so abusive and I needed a family an evangelical church provided it - the anti women anti gay anti single mums etc was all hidden

hivemindneeded · 11/12/2021 16:45

I can categorically promise OP that the Alpha course is as far from a cult as any religious experience I've ever had.

What they don't do:
Call you all the time and badger you to spend every waking minute with them
Encourage you to stay away from family and friends who might be critical of Alpha
Ask for your worldly goods
Remove you from daily life
Have a guru figure you shoudl obey
Get angry if you disagree

What they do do:
Talk about the bible and Christianity
Ask you if you have any questions
Ask if you'd like to stay for food
Not mind if you can't

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 16:42

[quote PerfectPrepPrincess]@EnidSpyton I'm sorry to hear you've had bad experiences with Christianity but it doesn't mean you're right, only that your experience is your experience. The only way to prove you are right, if that's really what you're driven to do, is to cite evidence but when 2 billion out of 8 consider themselves Christian (obviously the majority not devout) you have to ask yourself why?[/quote]
My experience proves that I am right.

My experience wouldn't have happened, in multiple mainstream evangelical churches registered as charities and under the umbrella of the evangelical alliance, if the kind of misogynistic and homophobic teaching I was exposed to for years weren't supported and encouraged by the governing bodies of the Christian church.

So much damage has been done to people in the name of Christianity for many hundreds of years. If I started to 'cite the evidence' I'd be here until kingdom come, love.

Look, I respect everyone's right to faith and if you're happy in your beliefs, that's great. But as someone who has suffered hugely from psychological abuse at the hands of church leaders for years, and who has seen many other people go through the same experience, I see it as my duty to speak out about it. So many people have no idea because they've never been inside these churches. They're on every high street. They're full of white, middle class, well educated people. And they preach hatred. People need to know about them. Behind the glossy white smiles and the carefully posed photos of people from all colours of the rainbow on their websites, they're not inclusive, they're not accepting, and they're not kind. They want to convert you, they want your money, and they want you to mould your life to fit their narrow view of what makes a good Christian. And the minute you voice any doubts, or make any lifestyle choices they don't agree with, and they can't manage to pray your deviance out of you, you're out the door without a backward glance.

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:38

1.9 billion Muslims share the same God as Christians and however many Jews also.
I know why people believe in other religions, I know why people choose not to believe in anything. I do wonder these things and I do theorise as to why do you what's you're point?

Are we all just Christian bashing now?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 11/12/2021 16:35

but when 2 billion out of 8 consider themselves Christian (obviously the majority not devout) you have to ask yourself why?

I don't understand your point. I would bet my life that vastly more than 2 billion people in the world are misogynists, sexists, homophobic etc. It doesn't mean that their values are superior or justified just because lots of other people think it too.

And in any case, 1.9 billion follow Islam and 1.1 billion follow Hinduism. Do you ask yourself why and believe that somehow lessens the validity of your own religion?

By your own logic, 6 billion people don't consider themselves Christian, so surely you 'have to ask yourself why'?

BlackMamba99 · 11/12/2021 16:32

Don't worry about Alpha. It's nothing to fret about. It's just explaining about what Christianity is to those who are curious or thinking of becoming Christian. You don't have to go every week, it's all quite laid back an optional. I went a few times as I am a Christian but had a crisis in faith. A few visits it wasn't really for me but not in a bad way, i just preferred in the end to sort my beliefs out in my own way. Nice you're looking out for her though.

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:31

In how is that fact me eschewing superiority? I can say exactly the same thing about how you're writing 😂

ftw163532 · 11/12/2021 16:29

but when 2 billion out of 8 consider themselves Christian (obviously the majority not devout) you have to ask yourself why?

The answer to that is not what you are inferring. What a silly thing to say.

But well done on oozing the sense of superiority you claim to eschew.

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:27

@ftw163532. That's a really weak argument as that can mean ANY group is a cult 😂

ftw163532 · 11/12/2021 16:25

And cults are not about "bad people". People who lead cults don't act like monsters, and people who get sucked in are not monsters.

Saying "I know people who've done Alpha and they're lovely" is not an argument for or against it being a cult. It's entirely irrelevant but very revealing about the thought process of those saying it.

If you walk around looking for "monsters" you will miss the regular people behaving in monstrous ways. That's pretty much the recurring theme in safeguarding failures - "oh but he seemed like a nice guy so I took his word...".

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:24

I can’t imagine why anyone would decide to be in any form of any religious group these days!

Hope

withlotsoflove · 11/12/2021 16:23

I can’t imagine why anyone would decide to be in ^any* form of any religious group these days !

ftw163532 · 11/12/2021 16:19

I have never been so judged as I have been inside Christian communities.

This is my experience and that of generations of my family. I agree with the rest of the post too.

The usual air of superiority is coming across from those posters claiming Christians don't judge.

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:18

@EnidSpyton I definitely don't consider myself saved and part of the elect. I'm coming to the realisation that very very very few are. You can aliken being redeemed /saved to reaching enlightenment.

RB68 · 11/12/2021 16:16

I did alpha about 30 yrs ago - for me it was just about meeting like minded folk a bit of socialising when i was not in a great place. It deepened a number of friendships as we discussed issues around the videos or readings they had (not religious per se but about matters religion has views on) . I can see how it might lead more vulnerable people to cowtow a bit and think oh this is how I must do something. Am I a Christian - I don't think so even though brought up catholic. I found catholic school more indoctrinating than Alpha

PerfectPrepPrincess · 11/12/2021 16:15

@EnidSpyton I'm sorry to hear you've had bad experiences with Christianity but it doesn't mean you're right, only that your experience is your experience. The only way to prove you are right, if that's really what you're driven to do, is to cite evidence but when 2 billion out of 8 consider themselves Christian (obviously the majority not devout) you have to ask yourself why?