Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
KC934 · 12/12/2021 17:50

Oh god, I know ppl who've done the alpha course and it is mental. They preach decidedly unchristian values like homophobia, and think a woman's place is in the kitchen and breeding kids 🤢

THEDEACON · 12/12/2021 17:48

Minister of religion here not a massive fan of the Alpha course myself but I'm more liberal wing than evangelical wing of mainstream Christianity You needn't be overly worried though

Northernparent68 · 12/12/2021 17:45

@Rachand23

Have you thought she might be worried about you?
This. The sister might start a thread my sister is trying to convert me to atheism
bustersword · 12/12/2021 17:44

@Rachand23

Have you thought she might be worried about you?
Why? OP is not the one with the controlling boyfriend here.
Heruka · 12/12/2021 17:43

I’d be worried op. My mum is an evangelical Christian and helps run alpha courses. It’s very much about recruitment, not a ‘take it or leave it’ intention. Ultimately she/they believe that all of us who do not have an active relationship with god (being a good person is NOT enough), are going to hell. So there is a strong desire to recruit people, of course if you believed that I guess, and very little tolerance for other peoples views. I hope your sister is ok.

godmum56 · 12/12/2021 17:38

@Properjob

This happened to my brother. To be fair there are plenty of other factors that meant he has changed his views, not just because of the Alpha course, but he chose to marry an ex Catholic who was on her ownjourney, and they are now both right wing fundamentalist Christian antivaxxers nd were at one time in a cult. Its caused a huge rift between us although we continue to see and care for each other and they are both lovely people if you don't peek under the bonnet as it were. Also I had a friend brought up a Muslim who feel on hard times and then converted to Christianity after an Alpha course despite being very anti religion for her whole adult life. She did seem a bit happier for a while. I think it really depends upon what else is going on in their lives whether the brainwashing course sticks or not.
good point....sometimes people taking these courses bring their own baggage with them.....if it wasn't the alpha, it would be something else to fill the need.
Properjob · 12/12/2021 17:35

This happened to my brother. To be fair there are plenty of other factors that meant he has changed his views, not just because of the Alpha course, but he chose to marry an ex Catholic who was on her ownjourney, and they are now both right wing fundamentalist Christian antivaxxers nd were at one time in a cult. Its caused a huge rift between us although we continue to see and care for each other and they are both lovely people if you don't peek under the bonnet as it were. Also I had a friend brought up a Muslim who feel on hard times and then converted to Christianity after an Alpha course despite being very anti religion for her whole adult life. She did seem a bit happier for a while. I think it really depends upon what else is going on in their lives whether the brainwashing course sticks or not.

Rachand23 · 12/12/2021 17:30

Have you thought she might be worried about you?

Negligee · 12/12/2021 15:49

@CaptSkippy

So, to all the commenters who say that this course is simply an introduction/information course and not intended to convert anyone.

What would you do if you were tying to convert someone? How would you go about it?

It’s the equivalent of those ‘free personality tests’ the Scientologists are always offering on the street.
CaptSkippy · 12/12/2021 15:18

So, to all the commenters who say that this course is simply an introduction/information course and not intended to convert anyone.

What would you do if you were tying to convert someone? How would you go about it?

Negligee · 12/12/2021 12:10

@kmblark

It's worth pointing out that Nicky Gumble, who help start the alpha course, is deeply homophobic.
He is. He believes homosexuality can be ‘healed’. He’s also an astute political mover, a prolifically successful writer of simplistic books which are essentially worryingly influential assertions of pre-Enlightenment thinking (speaking in tongues, faith healing etc), and a lot of Christians, even within the C of E find Alpha profoundly problematic for its conservatism and evangelicalism, and obsession with the charismatic. He is the poster boy for a bewilderingly stupid, worryingly mainstream cult within modern Christianity.
kmblark · 12/12/2021 11:28

It's worth pointing out that Nicky Gumble, who help start the alpha course, is deeply homophobic.

StoneofDestiny · 11/12/2021 22:12

Sounds more worrying her partner is 'a fundamentalist Christian' that her doing the Alpha Course.

Cherryana · 11/12/2021 22:07

I think that Christianity attracts a certain rule following low on the openness scale type of person.

As someone high on the openness scale I find that I find the narrow mindedness and continual regurgitation of things without proper thought very difficult.

BUT I also know many intelligent and thoughtful and genuinely the most kind people, I know, are Christians. |I try to avoid the former type and spend more time with the latter.

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 21:34

@youvegottenminuteslynn

It would be fair to say that the rules and institutions of the formalised C of E and Roman Catholic church demonstrate homophobia in respect of marriage.

A less wordy, more accurate assessment: "It would be fair to say that the rules and institutions of the formalised C of E and Roman Catholic church are homophobic."

I wish that more religious people would say they know the rules of their church are homophobic and struggle with that knowledge greatly, but ultimately still choose to follow that faith and believe what the religion tells them to even if it's homophobic and unpalatable to us non religious people.

Rather than always say the bits that 'sound' homophobic / misogynist / sexist etc happen to not apply to their specific church. Or admit they agree that gay people shouldn't be allowed to marry. Nobody ever seems to admit that, yet we know many people believe it.

While I think it's an inherently wrong thing to believe, I would at least expect someone with real conviction to be open about believing it. After all, faith is supposed to empower people to speak their truth rather than say what causes the least kickback or makes them unpopular.

Absolutely.

So many Christians tie themselves into knots trying to get out of having to admit they're homophobic. 'Oh we accept everyone, but...'

Have the courage of your convictions. You either believe it all, or surely you can't actually believe any of it.

Once you start picking and choosing what bits you like and what you don't, you make a mockery of the whole thing.

Christianity is not just about loving other people and doing good works. By claiming a Christian identity you bring all this other baggage along with you. The baggage that excludes, that marginalises, that diminishes. You can't just ignore it or pretend it's not there. It's written into the text that you say is the foundation of your religion. The text that you believe is God breathed. So if God really does think women exist to serve men and that gay people are the scum of the earth, then you need to actually confront that and decide if you really want to align yourself with that. And if you do, then fine, but admit it. Don't try and pretend that you 'don't believe that bit' or 'that bit of the Bible is outdated'. Like I say, you can't pick and choose. It's all or nothing. It's all woven into the same cloth.

EnidSpyton · 11/12/2021 21:25

@PerfectPrepPrincess

They're on every high street. They're full of white, middle class, well educated people.

Seriously Hmm not in a city. Ever been to one in London? Ever watched any documentaries based in the USA? What about Africa? China?

I'm a born and bred Londoner.

Lived here all my life apart from a brief sojourn in the US.

All my church experience has been in London and a very big US city.

The type of evangelism I'm talking about is a largely white and middle class one. And it's all over London, by the way. Trinity Brompton, home of Alpha, is in Kensington, for goodness' sake!

Churches in Africa and China are a different kettle of fish altogether. Some of the stories from Africa about those spreading the prosperity gospel, persuading desperate people with barely anything to live on to give all they have to the church, are truly awful.

satci · 11/12/2021 20:57

@LadyMary50

The other thing to note,if anyone goes on to convert and be baptised they have to agree to subscribe a third of their salary a month to the church…
Really?
Campfirewood · 11/12/2021 20:53

YABU! I am a Christian and would offer a similar course to folks in our area. The Alpha course (and the one we do) is used simply to provide information about the Christian faith. There's absolutely no pressure to convert, in fact, mYABU! I am a Christian and would offer a similar course to folks in our area. The Alpha course (and the one we do) is used simply to provide information about the Christian faith. There's absolutely no pressure to convert, in fact, most Christian's (including myself) don't believe you can force someone to convert. Either they believe or they don't. We don't push. ost Christian's (including myself) don't believe you can force someone to convert. Either they believe or they don't. We don't push.

Yes, this. I have been involved with numerous churches. We've never tried to convert anyone. Gay people attended the churches and most did a lot to support the community... food banks, pamper sessions for DA victims, presents for kids in prison, supported an African children's charity, people from the church moved to Indian and sent money to support a children's charity there, helped people out of debt...

youvegottenminuteslynn · 11/12/2021 20:51

It would be fair to say that the rules and institutions of the formalised C of E and Roman Catholic church demonstrate homophobia in respect of marriage.

A less wordy, more accurate assessment: "It would be fair to say that the rules and institutions of the formalised C of E and Roman Catholic church are homophobic."

I wish that more religious people would say they know the rules of their church are homophobic and struggle with that knowledge greatly, but ultimately still choose to follow that faith and believe what the religion tells them to even if it's homophobic and unpalatable to us non religious people.

Rather than always say the bits that 'sound' homophobic / misogynist / sexist etc happen to not apply to their specific church. Or admit they agree that gay people shouldn't be allowed to marry. Nobody ever seems to admit that, yet we know many people believe it.

While I think it's an inherently wrong thing to believe, I would at least expect someone with real conviction to be open about believing it. After all, faith is supposed to empower people to speak their truth rather than say what causes the least kickback or makes them unpopular.

hivemindneeded · 11/12/2021 20:50

@ALightThatNeverGoesOut

If they're not after converting people then why is Alpha exclusively for non believers?
It's not. It is widely advertised in church services for existing Christians who might want to explore the faith more. When I did it everyone already went to church. When my very agnostic friend did it on all five occasions she was the only non-church goer.
EducatingArti · 11/12/2021 20:48

@ALightThatNeverGoesOut

To me "the church" is not an institution but the body of believers who call Christ "Lord" and seek to live, being transformed into his likeness.

Handy.

I guess you could say every institution in the world is hunky dory if you get to define it yourself and pick out the bits you like.

I don't define it like this because I feel like it and because it is "handy" . It is how I understand that Jesus and the early church described in the Bible thought about the church . I'm also far from claiming the church is hunky dory as I think can be seen from the rest of my post. I don't even think that I am that hunky dory to be fair!!
ALightThatNeverGoesOut · 11/12/2021 20:48

Ive done the alpha course 3-4 times. I'm still an agnostic.

Not sure what statements like this are meant to prove. It quite clearly is a useful tool in terms of conversion just by looking at the numbers it's generated. Obviously it doesn't work on everyone because nothing does including torture. But it's purpose is to create convert. You really think any religion organises events talking about itself in the expectation that no one will join up?

TatianaBis · 11/12/2021 20:43

[quote Midlifemusings]@TatianaBis

Did you read the thread? There are dozens of different descriptions from people sure about what Alpha is or isn't, what it includes or doesn't, what its purpose is or isn't.... and similar about Christianity / evangelicals. I don't think it is specific to this thread or religions.[/quote]
Of course I’ve read the thread. You didn’t answer my question which related to this statement of yours:

The either intentional or unintentional misinformation on here about Alpha, Christianity, and evangelicals is pretty mind boggling!

Negligee · 11/12/2021 20:43

@HobgoblinGold

Ive done the alpha course 3-4 times. I'm still an agnostic.
Why did you do it so often? Was someone ferociously attractive delivering it or something?
ALightThatNeverGoesOut · 11/12/2021 20:42

To me "the church" is not an institution but the body of believers who call Christ "Lord" and seek to live, being transformed into his likeness.

Handy.

I guess you could say every institution in the world is hunky dory if you get to define it yourself and pick out the bits you like.