Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried my sister is doing the Alpha course?

510 replies

Southtrainer · 11/12/2021 11:30

Just for a bit of context. My family is and always has been agnostic and left wing. My sister (early thirties) recently met a new partner who comes from a very religious evangelical Christian family. Their relationship surprised us all thinking there was be such a gulf that they wouldn’t stay together long but recently my brother told me my sister is doing the Alpha course and he was concerned she might have some pressure on her to convert to their religion. I’d this right? I’ve never had any experience of this course or religion. I’m worried. Thanks for any info or experiences x

OP posts:
HareHare · 12/12/2021 18:38

I wonder if you are interested in perpetuating your family views and find your sisters exploration of Christianity a threat? Christians come with many different political views. Perhaps she respects her partners views and does not want him to be put on the spot by your families views. The other red flags you speak of together with her interest in Christianity may be a concern as there are some controlling men to be found in churches just as there are outside of them. It is good you are concerned for her welfare. Would it bother you if she did become a Christian?

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 12/12/2021 18:37

DSis had a phase of being quite religious and went to part of an Alpha course. She said it was all a bit daft. They went in for throwing their arms in the air whenever Jesus was mentioned in Church, which was the bit that struck her as a bit cultish. I remember her talking about a discussion on the power of prayer and people were asked in turn about their experience of praying for something and their prayers being answered. Apparently everyone was coming up with stuff like "I prayed my foot would be better in time for me to play in the football match, and it was" or "I prayed that I'd get to work on time, and I did". No-one seemed prepared to say something like "Hang on, God has better things to do than make your train run on time" or "Your foot was almost certainly going to get better whether you prayed about it or not", and it was all uncritically accepted as evidence of the power of prayer.

DSis decided pretty quickly that it definitely wasn't for her, and for what it's worth they didn't put particular pressure on her to go back. However, it might have been different if the pressure was coming from a boyfriend or similar.

Landlubber2019 · 12/12/2021 18:31

I did the alpha course years ago. It wasn't brainwashing just looked at the bible and had discussions afterwards.

Funnily enough though as a life long Christian, I had to had some stuff explained very simply to me and there were bits I found very uncomfortable, I haven't been back to the church since completing the course.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 12/12/2021 18:31

@Southtrainer

I’m worried that she has had pressure to do the course and convert to something I know previously she would never have considered. I suppose I’m thinking it’s sort of coercive in this instance (within the context of their relationship which has a few other red flags).

Yes re the left wing thing, I suppose I was highlighting the fact that my family is very liberal and not conservative with a little c, whereas his family, via their religion I believe, have very different views on LGBTQ+ rights, Women’s rights etc. They (the family) are fundamentalist Christians and interpret the bible in that way. I’m not sure denying evolution would be considered mainstream nowadays @knittingaddict or maybe I’m wrong 🤷‍♀️

Convert to something?! Are you having a laugh?! It's just people attending a church and asking questions and the course leaders answer them. Followed by a few videos explaining a few myths. Mine was about 4 sessions. I was never once ushered into anything!!! I think you need to educate yourself a little more. Not all Christianity is a bloody cult! How ridiculous. Biggest eye-roll ever
Vynalbob · 12/12/2021 18:29

I'm dubious about it but as long as you make sure she is choosing freely then that's all you can do really.
CofE might not be a cult but.....
What would you call a group of people who meet as a group to discuss religion as perceived by a single individual (N Gumbel) and the latter part of the course many people 'speak in tongues'... cult-ish?
If it walks like a dog and sounds like a dog it's almost certainly going to be a dog.

MarvellousMonsters · 12/12/2021 18:27

@FourTeaFallOut

Rearranging your beliefs to better mirror your partner doesn't scream healthy relationship though.
This is the red flag for me.
ODFOgrinch · 12/12/2021 18:26

If your DSis is an averagely intelligent person she will get a discursive view of Christianity from the alpha course.
FWIW I was practising CofE for most of my life and I had a crisis when my son first came out as lesbian and then trans at the same time as the church was discussing the marriage of gay people.
Our local rector was quite vocal and provided petitions and other information (biased at best, bigoted at worst). I had a crisis of faith and stepped away.
The alpha course helped me dig down into scripture, make my own interpretation and move on. I am still a Christian, but not through my local parish).
I would hope that the course helps your DSis to make her own determination, rather then converting her to something she wouldn't otherwise condone.

Hadjab · 12/12/2021 18:25

@Southtrainer

I’m worried that she has had pressure to do the course and convert to something I know previously she would never have considered. I suppose I’m thinking it’s sort of coercive in this instance (within the context of their relationship which has a few other red flags).

Yes re the left wing thing, I suppose I was highlighting the fact that my family is very liberal and not conservative with a little c, whereas his family, via their religion I believe, have very different views on LGBTQ+ rights, Women’s rights etc. They (the family) are fundamentalist Christians and interpret the bible in that way. I’m not sure denying evolution would be considered mainstream nowadays @knittingaddict or maybe I’m wrong 🤷‍♀️

If he and his family Are Christian Fundamentalists, I seriously doubt they’d be recommending she do the Alpha Course…
ChubbyMoomin · 12/12/2021 18:23

My only personal experience of this is that a very close friend of mine did the Alpha course, out of the blue as far as I could tell. It really changed him & after that you couldn’t have a conversation with him without Jesus coming into it, he was just so different. It changed his views & we drifted apart significantly. He was once my best friend now and I haven’t seen him in person for years.
That said, he has always appeared very happy, he met his wife through religion & they have what looks like a very strong marriage with 3 lovely children. So maybe it was right for him (just not for our friendship).

keffie12 · 12/12/2021 18:18

The church foes not ask you for a third of your money.

The Mormon denomination does and that is a tenth not a third.

The others do not. You are asked to contribute what you can afford if you can. Any organisation needs funds to survive

angela99999 · 12/12/2021 18:16

Don't worry, as others have said it isn't a cult, just mainstream Christianity. I'm not religious but see nothing wrong with living your life this way, many people find it gives their lives structure and that it gives them comfort when times are hard.

Lilymossflower · 12/12/2021 18:16

If there are other red flags in the relationship, like the ones you mentioned (they are definitely red flags !)
Then I would see this as an additional reg flag in the whole picture.

Ellie474747 · 12/12/2021 18:15

Maybe she has decided she wants to follow religion herself, you will find the Church of England is not cultish at all, like other religions you will have some that use it as extremism but I have never had this experience with going to an Christianity church in the U.K the alpha course was lovely and quite inspiring. Like others have said it is quite light in terms of teachings.

pollymere · 12/12/2021 18:12

My friend created the Alpha Course. It is very much about exploring Christianity rather than trying to convert people. My only concern would be that sometimes people get swept up with a desire to belong to evangelical churches. Just as it wouldn't be right for your sister to be pressured into baptism, neither is it right for her to do it to be part of the community.

keffie12 · 12/12/2021 18:10

Forgot to add the Alpha course has been updated in the last 10 years as it was very much a 70s/80s type base before. I did the old one and very much told them I didn't agree with the week on sexuality and why. It didn't stop me doing the course nor having my own beliefs. If it was a cult people wouldnt be allowed to leave and would be coerced which doesn't happen

Mamajeet112 · 12/12/2021 18:08

I did the Alpha course a few years ago. You get a meal, get to know some people, discuss Christianity and try to figure out if it's for you. As some other people on this chat have said, there is no pressure at all. You can check it out on www.htb.org

Alex31op · 12/12/2021 18:06

Please don’t worry, I’ve been on Alpha. There is no pressure, no one is trying to convert anyone, it is just a place where you can ask questions freely and openly. You can walk away or explore it further if you wish. It’s very safe, nothing sinister at all.

keffie12 · 12/12/2021 18:05

YABU - Do you know how much the Christian Church in this country does for people for example?

The Trussel group (Foodbanks)
CAP (Christians Against Poverty) debt support
Reflect (Crisis pregnancy supporr)
Dayspring (CBT therapy)
Working with rhe homeless, soup kitchens etc

Those 5 above are the main 5. There are alot more run by each churches who have there own ministries. They all work together under one umbrella.

Yes I'm a Christian who belongs to an unconventional independent Church. My beliefs are mine and not main stream.

Your going on all the negativity around it when there is so much good done at home and abroad.

My faith comes through mysticism of St Frances. My churches teaches its a personal relationship with a power greater than you.

I can understand some caution however you really have to know far more than untrue prejudices about the Christian faith. Its not a microwavable meal. This below sums it up.

If you start going on at your sister you will push her away from you. Yes there are fundamentalists in the church however the majority aren't like that.

This sums it up for me, below

There is a principle which is a bar against all information, which is proof against all arguments and which cannot fail to keep a man in everlasting ignorance—that principle is contempt prior to investigation.”—Herbert Spencer

SnackQueen · 12/12/2021 18:00

Sounds like your sister is changing her ways, her beliefs and her personality to please a guy and to keep him. You should speak to her and ask her if she realises it. If she does and she actually prefers the newer version of herself then that’s her choice. Religion itself is NOT a red flag. Alpha/HTB is also a very watered down version of CoE. There is nothing to worry about and tbh it’s pretty rude and judgmental to suggest otherwise.

whataboutbob · 12/12/2021 17:56

Negligee says it best. Alpha is not mainstream C of E, it’s the evangelical branch of Christianity. I lived with an evangelical family for a while, lovely people, but I had no doubt that their church was quite a hothouse, mutually self reinforcing slightly cultish organisation where prestige would have been garnered by those who brought new persons into the fold. On a wider level, it’s quite allied to US style muscular Christianity, with all its ramifications including meddling in Middle Eastern politics to bring about the end of days “ rapture” where the righteous go to heaven and everyone else goes to hell. I guess how much a particular Alpha course subscribes to all this will depend on the personalities at that particular church.

Oreo78 · 12/12/2021 17:56

The Alpha course is fine. It just allows people to ask questions and find out more about the religion of Christianity. Teachers have to be very careful how they teach Christianity in schools so they don't come across as trying to evangelise. Therefore, children don't really learn what Christians actually believe when it comes to the person of Jesus Christ and how he saved humanity. I think this is a pity because there is such a huge misconception in the populace about Christianity in a nation that has been predominately Christian for centuries.

The Alpha course just shares the very basic concepts of Christianity so that your sister can have a better understanding of what her new partner believes.

Btw, many churches of different denominations use the Alpha course. Trust me, it is not a dodgy cult thing.

hivemindneeded · 12/12/2021 17:55

I do appreciate that Nicky Gumble and HTC Brompton are a bit this way inclined. Personally, I find Gumble unspeakably creepy and slithery and suspect him of being duplicitous. It doesn't surprise me that he is homophobic. And I didn't know he started alpha. But I just want to counter the massive criticism of it from people who haven't done it and point out that in most churches across the country it really is just bible chat, coffee and a bit of food once a week. Nothing more sinister.

Mary54 · 12/12/2021 17:52

Really don't need to be worried. This is not a "do the course and be converted" situation. Have been involved in several Alpha courses (my DH has lead them) here and in the UK. As stated, they usually involve a video, a discussion and in the original form, a bring and share meal at each meeting. Their purpose is to provide an informal (outside church) setting in which people can find out more about Christianity. There is no pressure put on the course members to attend church or accept Christ.

hivemindneeded · 12/12/2021 17:52

@CaptSkippy

So, to all the commenters who say that this course is simply an introduction/information course and not intended to convert anyone.

What would you do if you were tying to convert someone? How would you go about it?

Well if I were of a mind to run a cult and co-erce people into believing what I believed, I'd keep them around for a lot longer than a couple of hours a week. I'd bombard them with 'love' and 'friends' who thought they were 'brilliant' and steer them away from family, old friendships and activities that i would claim were rooted in the devil's work. I'd argue that the root of their insecurity/unhappiness/life failure/loneliness/relationship breakdown/depression (I'd home in on hat prompted them to seek spiritual exploration) was all the things that stabilised their life before. I'd avidly draw them into an exhausting round of praying and chanting and bible study in which they had little chance to speak or ask questions, but bombard them with my 'beliefs' while getting their coterie of new friends to enthusiastically agree and create false physical highs from all the healing and talking in tongues and nonsense like that. then I;d expect a hefty tithe of their income and for them to show their devotion to the Lord (and Me0 by doing lots of volunteering and recruiting of new members to our Holy Family.

But as I'm just a boring old Christian who has done the Alpha course, I might occasionally invite them for a coffee after class if they seem like they don't want to go home yet. And if they turned up at church of their own volition I'd smile and say hi.

Bertiebiscuit · 12/12/2021 17:51

I'd be troubled - I've heard that the Alpha course is homophobic apart from anything else, and I don't know why someone who isn't a Christian would go on it, as obviously anyone who grew up in an English school knows already what Christianity is about.