Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he shouldn’t sort of make her feel guilty for not hugging him?

66 replies

HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 20:59

Dp adores Dd, 3, is a great dad, but be annoys me with this thing he does asking Dd for a hug (mainly before bed or going to work) then if she says no or doesn’t bother to he acts all upset and says ‘Aww’ and acts upset, then she hugs him. It sounds like a silly thing and she really loves hugging him, I just don’t like it, for her to feel if someone looks upset she’s upset them by not hugging them/showing affection, does that make sense? 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
billy1966 · 11/12/2021 10:21

@trulyconfuseddotcom

Great posts👏

Snowmanuel · 11/12/2021 08:24

@Austen33

How very sad that a 3 year old does not want to be hugged good night and her father has to ask permission to hug his daughter. It should just happen. Is her father allowed to bath her or does he have to ask permission for that too? Consent is very important but so is being warm hearted and affectionate. Are you sure you are not just raising a rather self-centered little lady who is learning to be capricious and who sometimes takes pleasure in upsetting the people who love her?
What a load of gobshite.
OfMinceAndMen · 11/12/2021 07:50

I used to be forced to kiss my uncles as a child and I found it totally embarrassing and humiliating. There would be a huge scene every time one of them left the house.
I think forced physical affection is really wrong.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 11/12/2021 00:36

YANBU

Of course there is no malice in it, but the message of 'do something a man wants you to do, that you're not comfortable with, so his feelings don't get hurt' is a real issue, and engrained for many people, and it starts somewhere. How would your husband feel if she learnt to put other peoples feelings above her own, when she is a teenager and getting the 'I'll be so upset if you don't sleep with me because I'll feel like you don't love me' shit from a boy?

trulyconfuseddotcom · 11/12/2021 00:35

Also this piece of writing by Lisa Norgren is so powerful, about a 3-year-old girl and consent: https://motherwellmag.com/2018/11/21/fighting-the-patriarchy-one-grandpa-at-a-time

HibernatinguntilApril · 11/12/2021 00:34

@trulyconfuseddotcom ?

OP posts:
trulyconfuseddotcom · 11/12/2021 00:21

I love this Lunarbaboon comic, it really should be this simple.

To think he shouldn’t sort of make her feel guilty for not hugging him?
pigsDOfly · 11/12/2021 00:05

HibernatinguntilApril

I think it's very important to let children decide these thing for themselves.

My mother, who lived further away, always held back from asking for hugs and kisses when she did see the children and funnily enough the children would always want to give her hugs and kisses.

She was a firm believer that children might not want to kiss old people - both she and my in laws were pretty old when my children were born - so would let the children come to her.

HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:57

@TheSmallClangerWhistlesAgain I know, horrible thing to think!

OP posts:
Thwackit · 10/12/2021 23:56

@Austen33

How very sad that a 3 year old does not want to be hugged good night and her father has to ask permission to hug his daughter. It should just happen. Is her father allowed to bath her or does he have to ask permission for that too? Consent is very important but so is being warm hearted and affectionate. Are you sure you are not just raising a rather self-centered little lady who is learning to be capricious and who sometimes takes pleasure in upsetting the people who love her?
She’s THREE YEARS OLD. Are you on here just to cause conflict and upset the OP?
TheSmallClangerWhistlesAgain · 10/12/2021 23:51

@HibernatinguntilApril that other poster suggested they were!

HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:47

@TheSmallClangerWhistlesAgain I don’t see how a little one can be being manipulative

OP posts:
HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:44

@pigsDOfly Eurgh, I wouldn’t like that either! They’re just so little, all this I won’t do this until you..it seems so disrespectful to them, they’re people in their own right. I think I would’ve found it hard not to say ‘it’s ok, she doesn’t have to’ and sort of scoop her away.
That’s what I love about my parents, we live abroad so can go months without seeing them, Dd adores them, but they’re always so careful to take it gently with her at first and not overwhelm her, she always ends up coming to them just naturally and gives lots of goodnight hugs and kisses, because she wants to of her own accord, and they love it obviously.

OP posts:
TheSmallClangerWhistlesAgain · 10/12/2021 23:43

My parents used to do this with DD and they do it with my niece still now. Pulling sad faces and talking in whiny voices. Even if you don't buy the "teaching consent" argument, it's really fucking annoying.
DD was never a physically demonstrative child and isn't an overly huggy adult now. She did have a special two-handed wave she used to say goodbye that she reserved for older family members, so she wasn't being capricious or manipulative.

I hated enforced kisses and hugs with people like my lechy step-grandad and I was never very good at finding their stupid Funny Uncle jokes amusing either. I remember being accused of being rude and snooty because I didn't laugh at someone suggesting I wanted "my two front teeth" for Christmas. I knew that you didn't get teeth for Christmas, we'd drawn diagrams of teeth at school and that song is still stupid.

CovidMakesThingsHarder · 10/12/2021 23:41

Adding my voice to the WTAF @Austen33

HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:39

@Alltheblue Yes exactly, and we are all so tactile, Dd included, we get a lot of hugs, so it really shouldn’t bother him

OP posts:
pigsDOfly · 10/12/2021 23:37

I fell out with my, then, BIL over something similar when one of my daughters was a similar age.

We'd been to visit my, then, husband's family. When we were leaving BIL told DD to kiss her grandmother goodbye. DD said she didn't want to.

DD then went to kiss BIL goodbye but he refused saying that he wouldn't kiss her goodbye until she'd kissed her grandmother goodbye.

We left in a somewhat frosty atmosphere after I voiced my opinion about people attempting to coerce small children into kissing people they didn't want to kiss. And no one kissed anyone goodbye.

No child should ever be made to feel bad or mean for not hugging or kissing an adult, or another child come to that.

NoSquirrels · 10/12/2021 23:35

For instance, if DH asks for a hug and they’re not in the mood they feel free to say “I don’t want to” and if he appears put out/pretends to be hurt they’ll say “Daddy, that’s not fair you’re trying to make me feel guilty.”

Which is true! So he’ll snap out of it.

Alltheblue · 10/12/2021 23:33

HibernatinguntilApril

It's really hard being a parent isn't it. You think you're going to get all this love and then you find no, you're just as likely to have to hold your own feelings and remember this child owes you nothing.

There are lots of valid ways to teach kindness and empathy but insisting on physical contact is just not right. Children need to know and feel completely confident that physical contact is not an obligation and refusing it is never wrong.

NoSquirrels · 10/12/2021 23:31

[quote HibernatinguntilApril]@NoSquirrels Yes that’s exactly it, I don’t want her to feel that guilt it for him to be whiny for affection, that she has to deliver. Need to talk to him about it again as it just doesn’t sit right with me, it is manipulating, but I know not deliberate, he'd be really upset if I said that to him though,

What does your dh do/say about it?[/quote]
My DH accepts what I say but fundamentally he doesn’t see it how I see it - because he’s a man? - so has thought it’s a bit of a fuss about nothing. He’s in general a bit more “because I am your parent and I say so” than I am.

As they’ve got older they express themselves more and specifically how it makes them feel if they don’t want to. So I take that as a win that I have always fought that they understand -Are no matter who it is^ they can say no and be supported.

That makes it sound like they regularly withhold/refuse affection - that’s not the case, we are pretty huggy in general, cuddle on sofa etc. But I’ll always back them if they don’t want to, for any reason at all.

billy1966 · 10/12/2021 23:27

Agree with posters, I hate this shit.

I also never played pass the parcel with my babies.

They are not things to be mauled by anyone who fancies it, even if it is well meaning.

Give them bloody space.

We never asked this of our children for ourselves or for family.

Funnily enough as young adults they are all very demonstrative towards us on the kissing/hugging front, even my cranky eldest!

Certainly a lot more than I ever was.

Children like space IMO.

HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:27

@Alltheblue That’s it, it is about his needs and again, I know he doesn’t realise that just basically wants to cuddle her, I often feel the same, I could hug her all day. It isn’t about me though and if she needs/wants a hug she’ll come to us etc. She generally says no at the times she’s running around or wants to play not hug and that’s her perogative.

OP posts:
HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:24

@Itsalmostanaccessory Awful comment, wasn’t it

OP posts:
HibernatinguntilApril · 10/12/2021 23:23

@NoSquirrels Yes that’s exactly it, I don’t want her to feel that guilt it for him to be whiny for affection, that she has to deliver. Need to talk to him about it again as it just doesn’t sit right with me, it is manipulating, but I know not deliberate, he'd be really upset if I said that to him though,

What does your dh do/say about it?

OP posts:
lynntheyresexpeople · 10/12/2021 23:21

@Austen33

How very sad that a 3 year old does not want to be hugged good night and her father has to ask permission to hug his daughter. It should just happen. Is her father allowed to bath her or does he have to ask permission for that too? Consent is very important but so is being warm hearted and affectionate. Are you sure you are not just raising a rather self-centered little lady who is learning to be capricious and who sometimes takes pleasure in upsetting the people who love her?
Self centred and enjoys hurting people by not wanting a hug? She's fucking 3 years old, you utter lunatic.
Swipe left for the next trending thread