Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be very frustrated in A and E just now.

206 replies

changeitatanytime · 10/12/2021 18:50

I'm in Scotland, was advised by my doctor to go directly to A and E as have been having shortness of breath for few weeks and today I had an episode of chest pain.

Arrived at A and E at 4 pm. Was told to stand outside as shortness of breath was Covid symptom. Then brought into own room so I'm isolated (negative LFT). Was seen by doctor fairly quickly and was told would get bloods done, an ecg and a chest X-ray.

Had my bloods taken at 5 pm and chest X-ray at 5.10.

I have now been sat in this room alone for 1.5 hours without anyone even popping their head in to let me know what is happening. And no one has done an ecg.

I understand that they are very busy but someone presenting with shortness of breath and heart pain not being checked on for an hour and a half? Surely that's not right.

I'm not the most patient person and can feel my heart rate going up and blood starting to boil.

Am I allowed to just walk out the hospital without saying a thing? Do you think I'm being unreasonable? What time should I give them to until leaving?

OP posts:
SmellyOldOwls · 11/12/2021 10:27

'The thing is, the nurses were not working themselves 'to death'. They were standing around the nurses station chatting and laughing. Now that is fine - they can chat and laugh of course and have a break - absolutely fine but to not pop a head in for over 1.5 hours to even see if I needed a glass of water. I legitimately could have been on the floor dead lying there for 1.5 hours and no one would have known. I think if they have time to chat they have time to stick their head in? Aren't nurses supposed to care? '

Nurses don't run around getting glasses of water for people in A&E. you were waiting for results and for the doctor to see you, what exactly did you want the nurses to do? That's like complaining the psychiatrist didn't come in to check you were alright while you were there. There's a big nurse call button in every room, the nurses usually presume if you need them you'll have the gumption to use it.

Lachimolala · 11/12/2021 10:25

@ClintBartonsWife

Posters ought to remember that OP was experiencing chest pain and was probably frightened. Frightened people don't generally think rationally in the moment and OP's reaction is understandable.

However, it is unreasonable to leave a person with chest pain alone in a private room for 1.5 hours. How would staff had known if OP had suddenly deteriorated? Put it this way, it OP was an elderly or vulnerable person, and had deteriorated in the room, my team would be considering a Section 42 Safeguarding Adults enquiry.

Yes I agree, she sounded very frightened and with good reason! I think I’d be terrified if I had heart/chest issues.
Lachimolala · 11/12/2021 10:23

Wait times are very long right now, I broke my leg on the 26th November and it took 5 hours of me stuck in the corner of my kitchen on a freezing cold slate floor in shock and excruciating pain unable to move from said pain just for an ambulance to turn up. Then it was a further 2 hours queuing outside A&E, then a further 12 hours once inside before I’d had X-rays etc and a whole 24 hours before a cast was placed.

You just have to wait, they won’t be annoyed if you ask for an update on waiting times though.

MarieVanGoethem · 11/12/2021 10:10

@changeitatanytime
Just to warn you, your last few posts have been under @hopeyouhaveabadday so people may well miss them…
I think if you’re not used to A&E it must be very hard to hold to the idea that actually, you don’t really want to be seen quickly. (Although paramedics ignoring all information given to them & deciding you’re a low priority leading to your having a tonic-tonic seizure in the middle of a packed waiting room due to combined effects of a burst ovarian cyst & appendicitis that were written off as being the bug going round… could have done with being seen rather more speedily that time, really. Every rule needs an exception to prove it though, doesn’t it?)
I thought it was good of you to acknowledge you were being “bratty” - a lot of people would just have abandoned thread or doubled down.
WRT checking on you - had your door a window in it at all? Nurses are used to doing quick checks on patients through gaps in cubicle curtains or windows in doors or sometimes propped-open doors. If not, that does seem like a long time to go without any checks at all, in that someone in a cubicle who was not actively being checked would still be visible if they were to deteriorate.

@Katyppp
It’s absurd - & inappropriate - your father’s having to have routine transfusions in A&E. Even if the hospital doesn’t have a dedicated haematology unit, a general infusion suite would be a more suitable location for a whole host of reasons. He’s probably also eligible for hospital transport - it can mean hanging around a while after you finish your appointment (& you need to be ready to go aeons before your appointment time) but they can keep your mother up to date if your father’s not able to text/call her himself.

ClintBartonsWife · 11/12/2021 10:04

Posters ought to remember that OP was experiencing chest pain and was probably frightened. Frightened people don't generally think rationally in the moment and OP's reaction is understandable.

However, it is unreasonable to leave a person with chest pain alone in a private room for 1.5 hours. How would staff had known if OP had suddenly deteriorated? Put it this way, it OP was an elderly or vulnerable person, and had deteriorated in the room, my team would be considering a Section 42 Safeguarding Adults enquiry.

doveduck · 11/12/2021 09:42

@C8H10N4O2

But the NHS is bad because of bad management is a mantra that has been around for decades, and it just doesn’t hold up

But it does hold up that is the problem. Yes its underfunded but even in periods of good funding huge sums of money are wasted and its not always government initiatives.

There is no other sector I work with where senior staff actually boast about never having any other experience even within their own sector, let alone in any other sector. And gods forbid you suggest that possibly, just possibly there are some processes and practices in other sectors they could learn from. Every little fiefdom is run like a petty fiefdom. And we should all be "grateful" because its free. Patients are treated as if they should be grateful rather than accessing the service they pay for.

During the pandemic for the first time ever in my working life the fiefdoms collaborated because they were forced to - suddenly they had to play catch up in areas where they had refused to modernise just a few of their costly and dated processes and really dreadful employment practices. As soon as the first wave passed it was back to fiefdom mentality. There is no excuse for this and they get away with it because of the sacred caste status and mentality of the NHS.

All my life I've voted to support public healthcare financially but I've reached the point where the need for structural change and probably a model change is the only way forward to challenge that fiefdom mentality and the treatment of patients as supplicants who must be grateful.

Are you an academic? I didn't understand half of that 🤣
C8H10N4O2 · 11/12/2021 09:37

But the NHS is bad because of bad management is a mantra that has been around for decades, and it just doesn’t hold up

But it does hold up that is the problem. Yes its underfunded but even in periods of good funding huge sums of money are wasted and its not always government initiatives.

There is no other sector I work with where senior staff actually boast about never having any other experience even within their own sector, let alone in any other sector. And gods forbid you suggest that possibly, just possibly there are some processes and practices in other sectors they could learn from. Every little fiefdom is run like a petty fiefdom. And we should all be "grateful" because its free. Patients are treated as if they should be grateful rather than accessing the service they pay for.

During the pandemic for the first time ever in my working life the fiefdoms collaborated because they were forced to - suddenly they had to play catch up in areas where they had refused to modernise just a few of their costly and dated processes and really dreadful employment practices. As soon as the first wave passed it was back to fiefdom mentality. There is no excuse for this and they get away with it because of the sacred caste status and mentality of the NHS.

All my life I've voted to support public healthcare financially but I've reached the point where the need for structural change and probably a model change is the only way forward to challenge that fiefdom mentality and the treatment of patients as supplicants who must be grateful.

dementedma · 11/12/2021 09:22

Similar with 86 year old mum two days ago. Paramedics were wonderful but they had to wait with mum in the ambulance for an hour outside the hospital before she could even go in! Went in at 2pm. Sent home at 11.30pm. Staff themselves were wonderful but a long day for an elderly lady.

hopeyouhaveabadday · 11/12/2021 08:48

@helpadvicewhateverneeded

Anyone who can go home from A&E and can relax with a huge glass of wine shouldn't be in A&E in the first place.
I had shortness of breath and chest pain and was told by my GP to go immediately to A and E. Are you suggesting I should have ignored my symptoms and my doctors advice?
Peaplant20 · 11/12/2021 08:48

I took my 4 month old baby to a and e recently as per 111 advice and was told it was an 8 hour wait to see a doctor and that I may aswell call my own gp in the morning. The state of the nhs is shocking and it won’t get better under a conservative government.

hopeyouhaveabadday · 11/12/2021 08:37

@Kyliealwayshadthebestdisco

Having worked in A and E I can tell you they will give not one crap if you flounce out and in fact will be delighted that there is one less patient to see. You should be worried about your own health though!! Why would you take away your opportunity for treatment of a potential clot in the lung etc?! I do agree it’s not good enough and yes you should expect better but as others have said, this is not the fault of the people working themselves to death trying to look after everyone while the NHS and the country falls to pieces with these clowns at the helm.
The thing is, the nurses were not working themselves 'to death'. They were standing around the nurses station chatting and laughing. Now that is fine - they can chat and laugh of course and have a break - absolutely fine but to not pop a head in for over 1.5 hours to even see if I needed a glass of water. I legitimately could have been on the floor dead lying there for 1.5 hours and no one would have known. I think if they have time to chat they have time to stick their head in? Aren't nurses supposed to care?

Also the man that took my blood I asked him if they're really busy just as general chat and he replied 'not today'.

I am grateful for the NHS and of course I understand that others take priority over me. The doctor and the nurse that did my bloods and ecg were lovely, couldn't fault them. My frustration was more so about being left in a room alone for over 1.5 hours whilst the nurses stood around.

lljkk · 11/12/2021 07:08

How are you, @changeitatanytime -- I hope you've been seen now!

SilverSandStorm · 11/12/2021 06:53

Funnily, when I've went in with straightforward medical things that can be sorted quickly like child with something shoved up his nose, or me needing a tetanus or a few stitches, I've always been seen really quickly. I wonder if the doctors think right I'll just take ten minutes here and get this person out of the way because they know you won't take long to sort

My understand is that they usually have different teams working in different areas ie minors/majors but if majors/resus gets very busy then the Dr from minors gets pulled across to help. Plus there are usually nurse practitioners treating patients with minor injury/illness.

SmellyOldOwls · 11/12/2021 03:32

@BashfulClam

When DH went in with similar symptoms years ago he waited 6 hours (we are also in Scotland) in the bay beside us 4 people with minor complaints were seen and sent home. One was a woman who ‘had a funny turn’ as she hadn’t eaten lunch and it was now 9pm another needed a tetanus and a wound dressed. We could hear everything due to it being just curtains between the treatment bays. Eventually a doctor listened to his heart and sent us home.

Funnily, when I've went in with straightforward medical things that can be sorted quickly like child with something shoved up his nose, or me needing a tetanus or a few stitches, I've always been seen really quickly. I wonder if the doctors think right I'll just take ten minutes here and get this person out of the way because they know you won't take long to sort.

It's the things like chest pains or child with viral infection you're worried you can't control that you end up waiting hours to see someone about. Maybe the wait is part of it, if you take some paracetamol and wait long enough you start to just get better anyway and don't need admitted then.

BashfulClam · 11/12/2021 02:19

When DH went in with similar symptoms years ago he waited 6 hours (we are also in Scotland) in the bay beside us 4 people with minor complaints were seen and sent home. One was a woman who ‘had a funny turn’ as she hadn’t eaten lunch and it was now 9pm another needed a tetanus and a wound dressed. We could hear everything due to it being just curtains between the treatment bays. Eventually a doctor listened to his heart and sent us home.

QuestionableMouse · 11/12/2021 01:27

I spent 9 hours sitting on a chair on Tue in A&E. They teared me very quickly but bloods and such take time to process. Also the consultant was absolutely flat out, trying to see as many patients as possible. It's just what it is now.

Happymum12345 · 11/12/2021 00:40

I imagine they’re not concerned about you. I’d take that as a good sign.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 11/12/2021 00:21

@CurlyhairedAssassin but it is the overall lack of funding over the years, combined with silly government initiatives like ‘save on cleaning - get the cheapest contractors’ which led to a rise in hospital acquired infections. And getting rid of good structures like Matron/managed wards. Also years of nursing being ground down and now having a hard job attracting staff, with lots of bank nurses etc.

I’m not saying that there aren’t bad management examples. There are. That naming thing in Liverpool? No idea but I know that often money is strictly ear marked, there isn’t a central fund. Treatment is one pot, and rebranding probably came form some odd fund that couldnt’ be used elsewhere. But the NHS is bad because of bad management is a mantra that has been around for decades, and it just doesn’t hold up. Management also doesn’t really have a lot of power, they juggle most of the time just trying to keep things from going under. Beds moved from one place to the other.

But I do agree it’s not just money. Quality training and good staff retention is absolutely key. Having systems that work also very key. The NHS is still one of the best healthcare systems free for all in the world, believe it or not. The standard of care is excellent in many areas. But the Cinderella ones are A&E, mental health and also some real weaknesses in different trusts.

Redsquirrel5 · 11/12/2021 00:10

@viques

I would pop out of your room, ask where you can go to buy a cup of tea and then ask if they have any update on your results/ waiting for the ecg. That way they are reminded you are still there and waiting (and with the best will in the world they could have forgotten you though unlikely), you will feel a bit more in charge of what is happening, and you will have some lovely hospital tea to calm yourself down!
I was in the hospital for an investigation( not A&E ) and I was unwell afterwards so when my son came to collect me he was told to return a couple hours later. I was checked on a couple of times then I fell asleep but blood pressure wasn’t good so not sure. Came around to find I was in total darkness. Son had returned and heard her saying I wasn’t there, turned the lights on and checked they nearly locked the ward and went home! They were apologetic completely forgot I was there. Son told not to leave me on my own for 24 hrs🤔

So it does happen.

OP I went in with chest pain worsening and previous heart attack and monitoring. Waited 4 1/2 hours to be triaged so I think you are doing quite well actually.

Mamanyt · 10/12/2021 23:51

@changeitatanytime

Sorry I've had a drink of water and see how bratish I've been. I've been seen by doctor. Everything is fine. Just waiting on pcr results which take around 20 mins at hospital.
Waiting is the worst, isn't it? Hope your pcr results are excellent!

Having worked in US emergency rooms, I can tell you that there is a LOT going on that you are never aware of at all, and that no one wants to make you wait. In fact, we'd love to clear everyone out in no time flat, but it just doesn't work that way. Kudos for keeping your cool with the staff, and venting here!

Dreamstate · 10/12/2021 23:45

@CurlyhairedAssassin

The NHS is highly inefficient in places, with money spent in the wrong places. For a number of years I’ve despaired at how OUR money is wasted on “initiatives” like the rebranding of the Liverpool Women’s Hospital to “Liverpool Women’s”. The reason this change was done? It apparently is because it is what the place is affectionately referred to by locals. I mean, Jesus Christ, why have we got idiotic people paid huge amounts of money to sit round a table in meetings wasting huge amounts of time and money for this type of bloody trivia. It makes my blood absolutely boil. I mean, properly LIVID.

You don’t fanny around wasting money on fucking trivial shit like that unless you have the luxury of basics like a fully resourced maternity service first, including enough training places for new midwives. Otherwise you may as well put “turd polisher” as your job title.

This type of thing must be going on all over the NHS. Other countries must laugh at the pen pushers we have here in our health service. We really need to stop and go back to basics and get the frontline staffing right first.

You can’t run a medical facility on the bare bones of staffing. There needs to be enough permanent staff in the first place. Too much money goes to paying staff huge amounts of overtime for things like extra weekend clinics to clear the backlog of appointments, caused by not having the right staffing levels in the first place. Completely false economy. Plus when departments aren’t adequately staffed it causes huge amounts of stress to the staff who ARE there holding the fort. They end up on sick leave or taking early retirement. Which means even fewer staff to support trainee positions for new entrants to make up the numbers to replace those who are leaving. and the problem just goes round and round and no-one ever deals with it properly, least it all this appalling government.

I’m glad you’re feeling better, OP, but honestly these threads are getting worse and worse, more and more shocking . Half my family work in the NHS and are on their knees. It’s the same for anyone who works in education. The country’s public services have been decimated, and that had already started happening BEFORE COVID so no excuses there.

It’s time for you to bugger off, Boris, and take your cronies with you.

Your wasting your time pointing out about how money is wasted in the NHS. There have been plenty of NHS staff say the same thing with lots of examples but people don't want to hear it. It'll be the usual tory are underfunding it and it needs more money. 🙄 you could throw trillions at it tomorrow and it still wouldn't be enough...yeh no shit sherlock its cos of the inefficiencies! But no it'll be give it more money brigade.
CurlyhairedAssassin · 10/12/2021 23:41

The NHS is highly inefficient in places, with money spent in the wrong places. For a number of years I’ve despaired at how OUR money is wasted on “initiatives” like the rebranding of the Liverpool Women’s Hospital to “Liverpool Women’s”. The reason this change was done? It apparently is because it is what the place is affectionately referred to by locals. I mean, Jesus Christ, why have we got idiotic people paid huge amounts of money to sit round a table in meetings wasting huge amounts of time and money for this type of bloody trivia. It makes my blood absolutely boil. I mean, properly LIVID.

You don’t fanny around wasting money on fucking trivial shit like that unless you have the luxury of basics like a fully resourced maternity service first, including enough training places for new midwives. Otherwise you may as well put “turd polisher” as your job title.

This type of thing must be going on all over the NHS. Other countries must laugh at the pen pushers we have here in our health service. We really need to stop and go back to basics and get the frontline staffing right first.

You can’t run a medical facility on the bare bones of staffing. There needs to be enough permanent staff in the first place. Too much money goes to paying staff huge amounts of overtime for things like extra weekend clinics to clear the backlog of appointments, caused by not having the right staffing levels in the first place. Completely false economy. Plus when departments aren’t adequately staffed it causes huge amounts of stress to the staff who ARE there holding the fort. They end up on sick leave or taking early retirement. Which means even fewer staff to support trainee positions for new entrants to make up the numbers to replace those who are leaving. and the problem just goes round and round and no-one ever deals with it properly, least it all this appalling government.

I’m glad you’re feeling better, OP, but honestly these threads are getting worse and worse, more and more shocking . Half my family work in the NHS and are on their knees. It’s the same for anyone who works in education. The country’s public services have been decimated, and that had already started happening BEFORE COVID so no excuses there.

It’s time for you to bugger off, Boris, and take your cronies with you.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 10/12/2021 23:21

@Lemonlady22

I went to A&E breathless, thought I would only be a couple of hours...one week later I went home. It was busy, and I didn't go to a ward until about 6 hours later, but I'm glad I stayed or else I would have died!
Glad that you are OK now, must have been quite a scare! Good advice for the OP now.

I do think that England is a little crazy right now though. There is a thread about someone wanting to have a picnic on a train, without masks, and everyone going ‘go for it’. And now this one on how bad A & E is. You would think we could join the dots, our health system is on it’s knees, so many things have been crushing it and now a sustained high rate of Covid is toppling it.

giggly · 10/12/2021 23:12

@viques

I would pop out of your room, ask where you can go to buy a cup of tea and then ask if they have any update on your results/ waiting for the ecg. That way they are reminded you are still there and waiting (and with the best will in the world they could have forgotten you though unlikely), you will feel a bit more in charge of what is happening, and you will have some lovely hospital tea to calm yourself down!
Seriously, pop for for a nice cuppaHmm clearly not been in a busy A&E this century. If your well enough to do that A&E is not for you
Lemonlady22 · 10/12/2021 23:09

I went to A&E breathless, thought I would only be a couple of hours...one week later I went home. It was busy, and I didn't go to a ward until about 6 hours later, but I'm glad I stayed or else I would have died!

Swipe left for the next trending thread