Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if do (or will) miss British English?

485 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/12/2021 18:05

License plate - Number plate
Driver's license - Driving licence
Windshield - Windscreen
Envision - Envisage
Bring (instead of take)

So much British English is being replaced with the US versions.

UK courtroom dramas now feature lawyers shouting "objection!" and judges saying "sustained" - something that never actually happens in UK courts but the writers have all grown up watching US dramas and films.

I know it's inevitable but I celebrated the little differences - they seem to become fewer and fewer each year.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 11/12/2021 19:23

*I hate all these Americanisms in the English language.

Gotten
Can I get
I have instead of I've got*

I was raised and taught in school “Can I have” growing up in the Midwest and only heard “Can I get” usually from my Southern relatives.

Americans don’t seem to like saying please or thank you. It’s very rude.

I was raised with please and thank you and I heard it a lot growing up. I could also say the same as you. I’ve seen those same behaviours living in England and in different areas on top of rudeness for daring to politely ask to get past a couple or group of people who are taking up the pavement (some blatantly ignoring me or giving me an eyeroll ) or helping someone and not getting an acknowledgment back. I doubt it is an American thing and more of a people thing.

Nemorth · 11/12/2021 19:16

To those questioning the use of British English it's probably not what you think.

IIRC it's a term used by those that study language to define a set of habits, phonemes, pronunciation models etc.

There is also:

RP = Received Pronunciation
SSE = Scottish Standard English
BE = British English
AE = American English
Gaelic
Irish Gaelic
Welsh

I think. That knowledge is from an English language course I did in 1996 and 1997!!!

DickMabutt73962 · 11/12/2021 19:11

😂😂😂 are you serious?

So much British English is being replaced with the US versions.

That's karma for the UK colonising so much of the world, those counties lost a lot of their native language to 'British English'

😂😂😂

XelaM · 11/12/2021 18:57

No such thing as "UK courts". You probably mean "courts of England & Wales"

phlaps · 11/12/2021 18:56

Haven't spotted it in the thread...

"Mother Tongue" by Bill Bryson is a fantastic book on this subject, can't recommend it highly enough if you're into this kind of thing.

LoveFall · 11/12/2021 18:45

The English language is constantly changing and adapting. I learned somewhere that the reason English is so widespread is its constant adaptation.

As a Canadian I love exploring the differences between our usage, American usage, and British. I tend to adopt the usage of the place I am in oddly enough.

As an example, Americans say restroom, Canadians say washroom and the British say loo. There are also all the standard British ones like pavement for sidewalk, boot, rubber for eraser etc.

Recently I have been reading a lot about the United Empire Loyalists who basically fled the US during their war of independence. The Loyalist were considered traitors as the maintained loyalty to the Crown.

Many were descended from the original settlers in America. Many ended up in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick. Many of my ancestors fled to New Brunswick. Many had Scottish ancestry as they formed a big group of America's early settlors. They were mostly "Episcopalians" and some of their beliefs led them to the Loyalist view.

I expect that Canadians retain many English terms and spellings because of our history. My ancestors sacrificed a great deal, even their lives, to remain loyal to the Crown.

If you are interested, goggle Fyler Diblee, a distant great grandfather of mine. There are some interesting but very sad stories about him and his experiences. It all provides some insight into how Canadians speak.

EmmaWoodhousestreehouse · 11/12/2021 18:45

@Mummyford

I hate the ‘can I get’ with no please or thank you, when ordering things in cafes/coffee shop. Americans don’t seem to like saying please or thank you. It’s very rude.

@EmmaWoodhousestreehouse

That's an interesting observation, because when we moved to the UK, I was gobsmacked by the shocking rudeness of Londoners. We've lived in several cities in several countries and I'd never experienced or seen anything quite like it. I do apologise if your experience of Americans is anything like that.

You’re absolutely right, there’s plenty of rudeness in London. It’s annoying. Don’t apologise, there’s nothing that would put me off America.
SenecaFallsRedux · 11/12/2021 18:45

But "please" and "thank-you" are not necessary to avoid being rude. It's a cultural convention, and I have often heard the words used very perfunctorily in the UK.

Where I live, it's the entirety of the interaction that determines whether people are treated with respect: body language, smiling or not, engaging with the server (which I know some people on MN hate, but that is somewhat expected in the US). I may not have said please to my server when I ordered my grilled salmon, but I will probably know where her children go to school and where her parents live by the end of the meal.

EmmaWoodhousestreehouse · 11/12/2021 18:36

[quote Anonymous48]@EmmaWoodhousestreehouse

Americans don’t seem to like saying please or thank you. It’s very rude.

I don't know where you get that impression. If anything, in my experience Americans tend to be more polite.

I happen to think you are very rude.[/quote]
I didn’t say they’d been directly rude to me. I’m talking about hearing them order things/ask for things in cafes/shops. I’ve done nearly a dozen trips to various parts of America and I’ve rarely heard people say thank you or please when they are ordering things, ie, can I get a flat white. I always want to say ‘what do you say’?

I don’t think it’s rude of me to state my opinion. That’s what we’re all here for. We can do that without calling each other rude 🤷🏻‍♀️

SenecaFallsRedux · 11/12/2021 18:23

I notice this in films when people are in pubs/bars. They never say please when asking for a drink.

So what? To an extent, this is generally true in some parts of the US. It's not considered rude to order in a restaurant or bar and not say "please." It's a cultural difference. It can actually sometimes be considered patronizing to use "please" when asking someone to do their job. Same thing with "thank-you." It's nuanced, but definitely a thing.

When I'm in the UK, I say both words often because I know it's a cultural difference and expected.

Tal45 · 11/12/2021 18:16

Everyone including my DH says 'gotten' now, I often hear it on TV too. Drives me mad.

LubaLuca · 11/12/2021 18:12

I work for a global company, and US English is what I hear and read all day. I don't think I use the Americanisms, but it's not something I'd actively avoid. I've picked up all sorts of colloquialisms from the various parts of Britain I've lived in, and so far nobody has had an issue with me using them out of region.

Cheeseplantboots · 11/12/2021 18:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SenecaFallsRedux · 11/12/2021 18:07

@RaraRachael

I live in an area of Scotland where we had our own words for things when I was little. Nowadays kids are more likely to use American words so it's going to die out. I shudder when asked about an eraser, recess or diapers.

Do Americans adopt our words into their language? I think not.

There are a few Scots or Scottish English words used frequently in American English: "pinkie," "wee," "blather," "caddy." But these are not so much adopted as organic from Scottish settlers and immigrants.

My favorite Scottish borrowing into American usage is "high school." That comes directly from the first school to call itself a high school, the Royal High School in Edinburgh.

SenecaFallsRedux · 11/12/2021 18:00

In my part of the US we call everything silverware, whatever it's made out of, unless it's super fancy and then it might be called 'the silver'

Same for my part of the country. It's all silverware, from plastic to stainless steel to Tiffany silver. We might say "the sterling silver" especially this time of year when people bring it out to use at Thanksgiving and Christmas.

dreamingbohemian · 11/12/2021 17:56

There is a huge difference between finding it jarring that British people in Britain are using American terms, and thinking that all the other countries are 'doing English wrong'

Quite a bit of the latter on this thread sadly

American or Irish or Australian or whatever English is not 'wrong' it's just different

SenecaFallsRedux · 11/12/2021 17:53

@DGRossetti

Didn't FDR use "Normalcy" ? So it's hardly new.

I like catching odd snippets in US TV shows that must have sneaked past the script editors from a British writer. Law & Order:Criminal Intent was a hotspot. In one episode an American character talked about needing to go to "the loo". In another a character was described as "nicking" stuff. Which I am pretty sure are not in everyday usage in New York.

The word actually appeared somewhat earlier, but it was President Warren G. Harding who gave it currency beginning in 1920.

I don't think FDR used it. He spoke a type of mid-Atlantic English, both in accent and substance.

dreamingbohemian · 11/12/2021 17:51

Mac and cheese... it's macaroni cheese ffs!

Says you

350 million Americans say differently

Maybe just let it go

SenecaFallsRedux · 11/12/2021 17:46

More worrying is American pronounciation - noos rather than news, etc

"Noos" is an American pronunciation, not the American pronunciation. We Southerners say "news."

DGRossetti · 11/12/2021 17:37

@EBearhug

I wish everyone would say "y'all" It's much better than "you guys" or that horrible "yous".

We should bring back "thou" - then "you" can just be plural. Wink

Only if we are also allowed to insult people by saying "thou" instead of "thee". Or is it the other way around ?
wtaf37 · 11/12/2021 17:34

Back again!
Mac and cheese... it's macaroni cheese ffs!
More worrying is American pronounciation - noos rather than news, etc

LizzieAnt · 11/12/2021 17:24

So much of what MN despairs at for being 'American' English is actually from Scotland and Ireland.

Are any of the examples I gave from Ireland/Scotland? I am English but have spent a lot of time in Ireland and Scotland and I think they would apply equally

The use of 'bring' and 'take' is a bit different in Ireland OP. Here's an extract from Wikipedia's article on Hiberno-English -

'Irish use of these words differs from that of British English because it follows the Irish grammar for beir and tóg. English usage is determined by direction; a person determines Irish usage. So, in English, one takes "from here to there", and brings it "to here from there". In Irish, a person takes only when accepting a transfer of possession of the object from someone else – and a person brings at all other times, irrespective of direction (to or from).'

I use the word gotten all the time EarringsAndLipstick, as in "the weather's gotten worse (again)" Smile

Bitofachinwag · 11/12/2021 17:20

@Bagamoyo1

I agree OP. And on all these threads you see the same thing - people saying “but language evolves”. This isn’t evolution though. Evolution is things like new phrases developing eg “girl power” when the Spice Girls started. What we have now is just people trying to be cool by adopting americanisms. I hate it.
So do I.
Bitofachinwag · 11/12/2021 17:14

@Peregrina

I don't like the now commonplace Stay Home - it should be Stay at Home.

Or Teach School, instead of teaching in School or Teach English, or Maths or whatever!

Or work a job! Although you mainly hear that phrase when people have more than one job, so "he works two jobs to make ends meet".
EBearhug · 11/12/2021 17:05

I wish everyone would say "y'all"
It's much better than "you guys" or that horrible "yous".

We should bring back "thou" - then "you" can just be plural. Wink