Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if do (or will) miss British English?

485 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/12/2021 18:05

License plate - Number plate
Driver's license - Driving licence
Windshield - Windscreen
Envision - Envisage
Bring (instead of take)

So much British English is being replaced with the US versions.

UK courtroom dramas now feature lawyers shouting "objection!" and judges saying "sustained" - something that never actually happens in UK courts but the writers have all grown up watching US dramas and films.

I know it's inevitable but I celebrated the little differences - they seem to become fewer and fewer each year.

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 11/12/2021 10:21

@MajorCarolDanvers

I can’t get a context for “outwith “ Can you put it in a sentence for me?

It is necessary to work outwith these hours.
She has lived outwith Scotland for 5 years.
It is outwith my area of responsibility.
Please use the other door outwith normal opening hours.
It is outwith the understanding of many on MN that there are different dialects across the UK.

These examples are not a good advertisement for "outwith", in every one one the more common "outside" would work equally well.

(I was also going to explain how outside made more sense when divided into component parts, but I realised as I wrote that I was wrong. If you think of outwith as the opposite of within it is exactly the same concept as outside. One can be inside/outside a set defined by some phrase, or within/outwith the set.)

Wbeezer · 11/12/2021 10:12

I particularly dislike "normalcy" replacing normality.

Jarbed · 11/12/2021 10:10

@MasterBeth

Welcome to the process of ageing.

As a young person, you will have incorporated the latest slang and modern usage into your vocabulary without thinking about it. Your parents would have found it irritating and “incorrect.”

Now, your lexicon is more established and you are irritated by the latest slang and modern usage of the next generation.

Your use is not correct. Their use is not correct. The English language isn’t policed and has no authorities judging it. It evolves and changes.

Exactly this.

I would suggest that instead of getting irritated by it, you try to relax and appreciate that language changes over time and it does nobody any harm.

sst1234 · 11/12/2021 10:09

@hotfroth

There's no such thing as 'British' English.

It's just English.

hth

English English then!
Hospedia · 11/12/2021 10:09

him and all his friends say pants instead of trousers

I say pants instead of trousers, I'm in NE England. So school pants, work pants, etc. Underwear is knickers (female) or undies/underpants/boxers (male).

In fact, I find Americans to be incredibly polite, "Sir, Ma'am etc" Also very hospitable and friendly

My bestie is American and is very polite, as are her American family. Please and thank you are very important, when we go out they'll do stuff like going over and saying a quick thanks to the bar staff or the waiting staff before we leave, always get a thank you card for gifts or events, they always have something positive to say - for example it's never just "hi, how are you?" It's "hi, how are you? You look great/I love your coat/that's a cute hat".

MasterBeth · 11/12/2021 09:58

Welcome to the process of ageing.

As a young person, you will have incorporated the latest slang and modern usage into your vocabulary without thinking about it. Your parents would have found it irritating and “incorrect.”

Now, your lexicon is more established and you are irritated by the latest slang and modern usage of the next generation.

Your use is not correct. Their use is not correct. The English language isn’t policed and has no authorities judging it. It evolves and changes.

liveforsummer · 11/12/2021 09:50

@GerbilCurse

To add as someone living in England I would never say "in the hospital". It would either be "in hospital" meaning an inpatient or "at the hospital" meaning visiting or working
In Scotland we add a lot of unnecessary 'the' we'd absolutely say in the hospital, I've got the flu etc it's just local dialect
DGRossetti · 11/12/2021 09:41

@GerbilCurse

To add as someone living in England I would never say "in the hospital". It would either be "in hospital" meaning an inpatient or "at the hospital" meaning visiting or working
Unless you had to be specific ? The hospital as opposed to a hospital ?

I'm fascinated by situations where you can clearly understand a sentence in "US English" although it's nothing like how I would have said it in "English".

Maybe a kindly USian could confirm it's mutual, and that they can understand British English, although if they had to say the same thing they'd never actually use that form of words ?

I love getting the little updates about NOOBs. Especially the forensic analysis to pinpoint origins. There was quite some research around an American actress telling a NY paper about "having builders in" that led back to a residence in London that may have rubbed off.

Ulelia · 11/12/2021 09:39

@Mummyford absolutely valid. In my defence, I was very hungover when I wrote that sentence. I'm embarrassed that I did so!

GerbilCurse · 11/12/2021 09:27

To add as someone living in England I would never say "in the hospital". It would either be "in hospital" meaning an inpatient or "at the hospital" meaning visiting or working

GerbilCurse · 11/12/2021 09:24

Would you use "at the hospital" for a visitor? (Genuinely curious, this fascinates me and my students are always asking me these things!)

@Geamhradh I'm not sure what most Americans would say, I'm English with a few years in the midwest. I just know if someone tells you someone else is in the hospital it's polite to send well wishes/enquire how they are :-)

I don't think it's Midwest specific though, I'm sure I've heard it on TV shows and in films.

Skyll · 11/12/2021 09:17

When you teach “British English” do you teach RP, Northern British English, Liverpudlian British English, Glasgow British English, Aberdeen British English, Belfast British English, Derry/Londonderry British English …..

Flutterflybutterby · 11/12/2021 09:15

@hotfroth

There's no such thing as 'British' English.

It's just English.

hth

Umm yes there is. I'm an teacher abroad and I teach in British English. American English is seperate and taught in different schools. There are entirely different text books and resources for those studying British English and those studying American English. If you're British, you might just call it 'English' but that's like how my Indian husband just calls Indian food 'food'. People in other countries are more specific about things from different cultures or it would be so confusing!
Geamhradh · 11/12/2021 09:15

@TrashyPanda

The grammatical difference between "in hospital" and "in the hospital" (in UK English) is that "in hospital" means you are in a bed being poked about by doctors. "in the hospital" means "in the building" so a visitor, at a specific time, could also be "in the hospital"

Not necessarily. In fact, it’s the reverse where I live. If you are a patient, then the definite article is used.

The main hospital in my town is The Royal Infirmary. If you are a patient there, you are “in the Infirmary”.
People would also say “I was at the hospital to see about my broken arm”.

If you are not a patent but are in the building, there is no definite article. A visitor would say “I visited my friend in hospital yesterday”

Yes, I understand that usage, but I'd imagine that's a different use of "the". Because the article is being used for the ONLY example of the thing being talked about. Your other example- the "in hospital" refers to your friend in that sentence though, not you. The grammatical difference is definitely what I said. The semantic difference is clearly more blurred. But I'm not (fortunately) a prescriptive linguist (God forbid!) so I'm happy to observe that others use the terms in a different way.
Geamhradh · 11/12/2021 09:09

@GerbilCurse

"In the hospital" in US English definitely means as a patient, you wouldn't say it about a visitor.
It's interesting isn't it? I found something about the possibility (but it's just a sociolinguistic hypothesis) that maybe Americans have such a different relationship with the healthcare system, that the "the" removes some of the "relationship" between subject>building>what happens in that building. Would you use "at the hospital" for a visitor? (Genuinely curious, this fascinates me and my students are always asking me these things!)
DGRossetti · 11/12/2021 09:07

I find it genuinely curious how British people

British or English ?

who live in a bungalow in a cul de sac can get on their bicycles to go into town to visit the cinema followed by having a nice casserole at a restaurant before deciding to have an early night rather than go on to the karaoke bar because the following day they need to take their kid to a gymkhana… can then bemoan the English language being beseeched and cultural traditions lost because the frightfully ignorant American barista making their lattes in the cafe earlier asked them if they wanted a cookie when she was clearly pointing at a biscuit.

Quite Grin

You could probably click your fingers, go back two millennia, and find the good folk of the 1st century whinging how their backwater dialect is becoming infected with that "latin" that's come over here.

Or go back 1,500 years and hear the complaints about that there "anglo-saxon" that's taking over.

Or 1,200 years and "them Vikings"

Or 1,000 years and "them Normans"

Although I think people are being far too harsh on those that wish to preserve English as it is now - this arbitrary point in time. After all there are plenty of other languages that have been preserved over the centuries. Sanskit. Ancient Greek. Latin ....

yourestandingonmyneck · 11/12/2021 09:00

@hotfroth

There's no such thing as 'British' English.

It's just English.

hth

Bloody hell, at least make sure you're right if you're going to be cheeky.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/12/2021 08:58

Which reminds me, the “thee” pronunciation of “the” as in the RAF is gradually going too.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/12/2021 08:56

@ComtesseDeSpair

I find it genuinely curious how British people who live in a bungalow in a cul de sac can get on their bicycles to go into town to visit the cinema followed by having a nice casserole at a restaurant before deciding to have an early night rather than go on to the karaoke bar because the following day they need to take their kid to a gymkhana… can then bemoan the English language being beseeched and cultural traditions lost because the frightfully ignorant American barista making their lattes in the cafe earlier asked them if they wanted a cookie when she was clearly pointing at a biscuit.
You aren’t comparing like with like. Of course English has always stolen words. That isn’t the same as adopting the usage and idioms of the USA pretty much wholesale.
OP posts:
TrashyPanda · 11/12/2021 08:53

The grammatical difference between "in hospital" and "in the hospital" (in UK English) is that "in hospital" means you are in a bed being poked about by doctors. "in the hospital" means "in the building" so a visitor, at a specific time, could also be "in the hospital"

Not necessarily. In fact, it’s the reverse where I live. If you are a patient, then the definite article is used.

The main hospital in my town is The Royal Infirmary. If you are a patient there, you are “in the Infirmary”.
People would also say “I was at the hospital to see about my broken arm”.

If you are not a patent but are in the building, there is no definite article. A visitor would say “I visited my friend in hospital yesterday”

JenniferWooley · 11/12/2021 08:40

@OldTinHat

I'm just here to snigger about a 'fanny pack'. Also 'pants' instead of trousers (what are pants called??), 'chips' being crisps and chips being 'fries'. 'Cookies' are biscuits but how do you distinguish actual cookies from biscuits?

Anyway, apologies if these have already been mentioned. I was too excited about posting these to read the whole thread.

But I agree, OP. So many Americanisms abound! I saw 'Clifford The Big Red Dog' yesterday and one of the characters was attempting to sound British by saying 'bollocks', 'collywobble' and what have you (deliberate part of the script) and it sounded hilarious and so wrong in the midst of a US film.

In my part of Scotland pants are called knickers

liveforsummer · 11/12/2021 08:31

I use all the English version of the examples given (plus many Scottish ones) the only thing that's invaded most of our lives round here is trick or treating. I've given up correcting it to guising.

bubblicious3 · 11/12/2021 08:04

I've been working with some Scots recently, and discovered the word timeously which I love - so much more useful & concise than 'in a timely manner'

GerbilCurse · 11/12/2021 08:04

"In the hospital" in US English definitely means as a patient, you wouldn't say it about a visitor.

TrashyPanda · 11/12/2021 08:02

@EdithWeston

Father Christmas sounds very formal

No!!!!!

He's the jolly old pagan version, a version of the Green Man

Not the Christian saintly Nicholas version that is the root of Santa Claus

I said it sounds formal. I didn’t say anything about the history of the name. Santa is shorter and sounds friendlier. Just as “Ms Jennifer Brown” is more formal than “Jenny”.

The association of a Christian Saint with a Christian festival seems very appropriate.