Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

women experts get shit that men just don't

71 replies

BayesianBlues · 10/12/2021 15:05

is that your experience?
when I weigh in and (if relevant) mention I have PhD in the area, I have been told (by men) that I'm narcissistic, insecure, don't know what I'm talking about (in my area of expertise), an opinionated drone, full of myself etc
is there something so challenging to some men as a qualified woman? Men don't deal with this shit do they? Although the disparaging of 'experts' seems to be a trend regardless of gender.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
foxgoosefinch · 13/12/2021 09:52

That reminds me of the time I went to a conference in a particularly niche area of the history of analytic philosophy. It was two days, and there were no women panellists at all, and no discussion of women apart from a brief mention of Anscombe by one male panellist, and most of the discussion and questions was by senior men (though there were women in the audience). I asked a question about the omission of the history of women philosophers from the papers generally, and the all male panel looked at me as if I had just farted in public 🤣

This was in 2015. 🤷‍♀️

BobbinThreadbare123 · 13/12/2021 09:51

I don’t give way to men on the pavement
I won't either, or the walkways on the site I work on. Patriarchy chicken!
Had one guy absolutely smash into me on site; I was tucked right into the wall (V windy day) and he bee-lined. His mates had a massive go at him.

dreamingbohemian · 13/12/2021 09:44

I don't know why but this never really happens to me at work, and I work in a very male dominated field of academia. I'm another one who's always the only woman in the room. I'm sure it's mostly just luck.

I've mostly had this from family and friends with very dogmatic political views (on both sides) who like to rant at me about topics I've been working on for 20 years.

YourVagesty · 13/12/2021 09:07

I don’t give way to men on the pavement

I started doing a similar thing a couple of years ago. I now stare back at men who stare at me - in supermarkets, carparks, work, etc. It's amazing how many do not break their gaze and carry on staring even though you are meeting their eye and stating back unsmiling.

My partner told me to be careful because men will read my behaviour as a positive response. Ffs.

foxgoosefinch · 12/12/2021 23:00

@Namechangesagain

My boss (female) had the same as *@HoardingSamphireSaurus* She wrote a paper on a very complex issue which the company then used to run a seminar on the issue. She sat next to a guy who then explained how complicated the issue was and how not many people understood it but he did, he then explained the issue to her using the paper she had written. (He came across more condescending then im making this sound) She said she'll never forget his face when she was called up to speak as author of the paper
Rebecca Solnit in her original essay that coined “mansplaining” starts with a similar anecdote - a man who asked her what she was working on at a party, then proceeded to mansplain at her that she really must read a recent book that had just come out about that topic as she would get so much more from it than her own research…said book was written by her!
MushMonster · 12/12/2021 22:56

@VillanellesOrangeCoat to get a PhD you have to back up every sentence with facts, based on your own research, backed up by other publications. Or if the subject is not a practical one, with full reasonings, and reference to other authors.
You have to prove everything you write down.
I doubt any expert, with PhD or not, in a particular field would go around saying this is so, because I say so! They will be providing explanations, reasoning or experimental proof.
But to be ignored over and over, even when proven wrong is quite annoying!

bordermidgebite · 12/12/2021 17:04

We are all experiencing the same social pressures , ones that show men to be better , successful women are often portrayed as bitchy or neglectful of family or household.

Then to succeed those women need to show no softness , nothing that can be mistaken for female weakness

And also I think we might see sone behaviour, such as not joining in gossip , as fine from a man but stand offish from a woman

seethesuninwintertime · 12/12/2021 16:47

..... and what we can do about it!

seethesuninwintertime · 12/12/2021 16:47

“As a group we don't do ourselves any favours though. Studies have shown that we prefer male bosses, and vote even more strongly in favour of this than men do. We also collaborate better with men and are less likely to help a female colleague if she's senior to us at work”

I wonder why this is?

hotfroth · 12/12/2021 16:12

I once did freelance consultancy work for small businesses, and one of my clients had considerable trouble with me knowing more than he did, despite having specifically engaged me to do the work he couldn't. He would argue the toss at every turn. Stupid git.

That was the one really good thing about being self-employed. I could walk away without a backward glance if I felt like it.

EightWheelGirl · 12/12/2021 15:14

As a group we don't do ourselves any favours though. Studies have shown that we prefer male bosses, and vote even more strongly in favour of this than men do. We also collaborate better with men and are less likely to help a female colleague if she's senior to us at work.

DdraigGoch · 12/12/2021 14:56

@EBearhug

I don’t give way to men on the pavement

I once decided to do this in the cortidor at work, to see who would move. One of my colleagues stopped right in front of me, and said, "I thought you were going to hug me." Why? I mean it would be perfectly reasonable (and not without precedent) to think I'm walking along, deep in thought and not really aware of my surroundings, but why would you think if I'm not moving out of the way, the only possible reason would be because I’m about to give someone a hug, when I never do that at work?

The Guardian's former Comment Editor, Seamus Milne used to refuse to give way in corridors. It was some form of power play. One six-foot staffer eventually got fed up with it and kept walking:

order-order.com/2016/03/24/seumas-milne-floored-in-guardian-game-of-chicken/

DdraigGoch · 12/12/2021 14:21

@VillanellesOrangeCoat

I had a younger male boss once who had no clue about my area of expertise and definitely had an issue with middle aged women. He forced me to implement changes which I vociferously advised against and predicted the outcome if we proceeded. The only thing I was wrong about was the speed at which these changes caused everything to go pear shaped, costing the company a hell of a lot of money. He put me on a disciplinary and tried to blame me for his fuck up. Tosser.
This is why it's so important to get everything on the record, and to keep a copy yourself.
YourVagesty · 12/12/2021 12:28

I'm anti-experts. Nobody cares if you have a PHD, you still need to argue your case and explain your reasoning and your views and people will make their mind up on their merits. Some men take an argument less seriously if it is coming from a woman which is wrong but I wouldn't take self proclaimed experts seriously man or woman.

I despise this sort of reverse snobbery. It's idiotic.

PhDs are not 'self-proclaimed experts', their qualifications are peer reviewed and rigorously assessed.

You come across like you've a huge chip on your shoulder. Poorly educated by any chance?

sammylady37 · 12/12/2021 12:21

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

And expressing an opinion doesn't make you opinionated. It bloody well does when it's based on something read on social media, is based on urban myth, total misunderstanding, lack of information and flies in the face of all known science.

It does when the person doing the questioning sees the very fact that they are questioning a 'challenging', when the expert being 'challenged' expects to be questioned, sees it as a reasonable and essential part of diagnosis, procedure etc. and would be very cautious about continuing without ensuring the non-questioning client/patient had fully understood what had been said.

My dad is like that. Feels somehow vindicated if he asks a slew of questions about whatever. As if his questions, no matter how daft, have proven to whatever expert he is talking to, that he is a man of intellect, not to be trifled with. When what he actually displays is his belligerence and, quite often, fear of not knowing what is going on.

Excellent post.

As a hospital consultant, I want the patient asking questions. I want them to engage with me on the topic of diagnosis and treatment plan. I need to know I’ve communicated correctly, they’ve understood what I’ve said and that they know what their options are. I occasionally encounter patients who are quite deferential and ‘doctor knows best’ and tbh my heart sinks with them because it’s hard to establish that they’ve grasped everything and have realistic expectations. Someone asking about why I’m recommending a particular treatment and what the alternatives are is very welcome and not at all challenging.
It’s very clear to spot the ones who have a chip on their shoulders though, and who have done their own research Hmm

EBearhug · 12/12/2021 12:00

I don’t give way to men on the pavement

I once decided to do this in the cortidor at work, to see who would move. One of my colleagues stopped right in front of me, and said, "I thought you were going to hug me." Why? I mean it would be perfectly reasonable (and not without precedent) to think I'm walking along, deep in thought and not really aware of my surroundings, but why would you think if I'm not moving out of the way, the only possible reason would be because I’m about to give someone a hug, when I never do that at work?

sleepymum50 · 12/12/2021 11:32

I’m female, retired and don’t have a PhD or any expertise.

I don’t give way to men on the pavement, or let men queue jump in the supermarket. And try and remember to only use male gendered insults stead of female ones.

I shall now make a point of making sure I address all of my questions/comments only to any woman in a group - even if I know for a fact she is not the most senior.

I don’t get out much, so my contribution will be trivial. Congratulations and well done to all you fabulous women!

seethesuninwintertime · 12/12/2021 11:13

I’ve just accepted my first senior rôle/authority role.

Guess I’d better buy The Authority Gap!!!

RedToothBrush · 12/12/2021 11:01

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel

Mary Ann Sieghart has written a book about this called The Authority Gap. (I haven’t read it, am waiting to borrow dd’s copy).
Thanks for this.

Its a major problem im having generally in life. Would be nice to see it written down and in a form which i can pass around to friends...

BayesianBlues · 12/12/2021 10:57

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel

Thank you for the recommendation of 'The Authority Gap'. Just started reading. I haven't got alll that far in and it's validating EVERYTHING I already knew. The accounts of transgender people before and after transitioning is just depressing but so important.

OP posts:
aspirational · 11/12/2021 13:43

That's interesting @LuaDipa , my DD had the opposite at school, she's very strong in STEM subjects and her male teachers were the ones encouraging her and challenging her. While the female teachers even in science subjects were much more likely to put her down.

MushMonster · 11/12/2021 12:35

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

Ah yes! You may drive it dear, but that just means you took notes at the meetings and handed out the To Do lists.

I was told much the same after winning a very prestigious award. One that was awarded on merit, not as a yearly thing, just if something was unusal an innnovative.

It had my name on it as lead design/researcher. My male colleagues were thrilled to have been involved and received their own mentions in the award.

One of them had a male boss who had wanted to lay claim to having been the impetus for the work, but couldn't if I was always being mentioned as the project lead. My boss just laughed. The funding was all in my name. Nobody ever thought it was anything other than my project, my team Smile

This is a good one! LOL
FatherDickByrne · 11/12/2021 09:17

My friend’s book on marine conservation was published last year. When she was writing it, she went to a dinner party where she was asked to explain the idea behind the book. A man who considers himself very green said, ‘Oh, that’s ridiculous’. The host then said, ‘I think you should listen to [my friend], she knows a lot about the subject’, to which the man replied, ‘Well, I don’t know anything about it but I know she’s wrong.’

Twunt.

Werk · 11/12/2021 09:13

This annoys the hell out of me. I work in a team of 5, all the others are men. I pointed out a flaw in one of our processes - they all disagreed with me. I sent links to new guidance and even emailed the body concerned to clarify a few points - I passed all this information on. All shot down.

We had a review - why weren't we following X guidance? Angry

I am changing jobs now.

MushMonster · 11/12/2021 08:44

PP mentions younger people in the work place! Yes, I had issues with those. They are so focussed on climbing the ladder that ignored and undermined me constantly!

Anyway, well done to you all for being hard workers and doing your job well! And continue to use your expertise to move forward! No company can make money to pay all these angry people based on the wrong info and facts!