Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to speak to junior colleague about her use of CC?

160 replies

ContactTraced · 09/12/2021 22:55

I hold a senior management position at my workplace. Today in a meeting, I shared some documentation I’d been working on for consultation with middle management. I asked them to make comments and suggestions, which may or may not be implemented (but I promised I’d explain why if I chose not to implement a suggestion)

After the meeting a colleague who is 5 months into their first middle management role asked if they could send me their suggested edits on a copy of the document rather than making comments as they found this easier. I had no problem with this.

Tonight they have emailed me their version; attached to an email saying they have made this change and that change and have cc’d in my line manager.

AIBU to have a quiet and gentle word with them tomorrow and say something like “I know you didn’t mean it, but you’re email came across as if you think you know better and there was no need to CC in (line manager) as it gives an impression I don’t think you intended.”

If it’s worth anything, some of her changes I would be happy to implement; but some go against company policy and some I just, based on my experience in the industry, don’t agree with.

I don’t want to come across as not being able to take criticism; but at the same time her response had left me a bit “WTF”?

OP posts:
Elle8344 · 11/12/2021 20:27

@StepAwayFromGoogling

Yep, this would piss me right off. I HATE people copying in my manager to emails I've sent. Why the need? You're doing one of two things a) trying to highlight to my manager that you think I'm doing something wrong (in which case, how about just speaking to me?) or b) showing off to my manager that you believe you have contributed something astounding to a piece of work. Either way it's a passive aggressive dick move. And, yes, I'd call them on it.
This 👆
Caffeinefirst · 11/12/2021 18:59

I think you need to set out a document review process, with timescales even if you just put it in a covering email with the doc.
If it’s your document and your process you can define how/when you want to receive comments on the first draft and what the next steps will be

maddiemookins16mum · 11/12/2021 18:44

I’m a Team Leader, there’s a lady I work with that CC’s her Manager in on every email she sends to me. It drives me mad. I respond to her without copying her Manager in - it makes me feel better.
She really doesn’t need to copy her Manager in on an email responding to my sending out the normal weekly rota or me asking if anyone needs any stationery ordered.

Mumontour85 · 11/12/2021 18:27

As a director at my company company I am often copied into email like this, and have to say it winds up no end.
This is EXACTLY WHY WE HAVE A MANAGENENT HIERARCHY!!
If your LM is anything like most senior managers, they'll ignore it!
I definitely don't think it says anything about you, but does say a lot about her. And it's not great.

It wouldn't hurt to take her aside and call her out on it, I like the comments at beginning of thread that suggest outright asking what she was trying to achieve by doing it!

Bertiebiscuit · 11/12/2021 17:39

Mmmm I wonder why she felt it necessary or desirable to do this - I think I would watch my back, she sounds like a trouble maker - I would certainly have a quiet word with her to let her know that in future would she not go over your head, it's rude at best and she must not do it again

user1471604848 · 10/12/2021 09:04

I'd reply to her email saying thanks for the suggestions, but unfortunately many would not work since they're against company policy, or industry standards.
Maybe send her some company policy links, to help familiarize her.

Then a the end, a one-liner, saying no need to cc manager since the document is only in draft.

NoSquirrels · 10/12/2021 08:56

@Sausagedogsarethebest

If the colleague is fairly new to the company then I'd wonder if she's had bad experiences at other workplaces where senior people have 'stolen' her ideas and not given credit. Alternatively she may think by copying in your senior then it's a way of making herself shine to leadership.
Well, if she’d used the shared doc and left public comments then her ideas would be visible to all.
CovidCorvid · 10/12/2021 08:55

I pulled a more junior person up on this recently. They emailed me moaning about something I’d done which they didn’t like. Just work stuff. It was their first week in the job straight out of college and they cc’d my manager in.

I emailed them back thanking them for their thoughts. Politely explained why they were wrong and at the end just said if they ever have an issue again I always welcome feedback but please to initially at least keep it to those involved.

NoSquirrels · 10/12/2021 08:55

Honestly, I think your first mistake was to let her annotate a copy and send via email when there was an easily accessed and established protocol - shared comments.

It increases your workload - having to transfer from different sources, having to respond individually etc.

The cc is definitely not cool.

I’d have a word - Dear X, thanks for this. I’m not sure why you cc’ed Y, though? Do we need to discuss anything in particular?

fakereview · 10/12/2021 08:54

I recently read a book called "Why Men Win at Work" (well worth reading) and one of the things it said is that women tend to do their jobs "under an umbrella" and the people senior to them don't really know what they do. Whereas men naturally shout about it. Maybe this colleague has read that book and is poking her head out from underneath the umbrella! Though then it would make more sense to copy in her own boss, not the OP's.

I have to admit I find unnecessary cc-ing really annoying too and have often replied along the lines of "x I don't know why you were cc'd in on this, let me know if you need to stay on copy" and then delete them from the email chain. But only when I had the distinct feeling that the cc'ing was arse-protecting.

Sausagedogsarethebest · 10/12/2021 08:50

If the colleague is fairly new to the company then I'd wonder if she's had bad experiences at other workplaces where senior people have 'stolen' her ideas and not given credit. Alternatively she may think by copying in your senior then it's a way of making herself shine to leadership.

Shedmistress · 10/12/2021 08:47

In some workplaces it would not be unusual for certain senior staff to take good ideas from their junior staff and pass them off as their own

Hang on a minute. She copied in the OP's manager. She must be making some weird point and the OP is entitled to know just what that point is.

Hence pushing it back to her line manager to look at.

FreedomFaith · 10/12/2021 08:41

I'd probably just point out one by one which of her suggestions work, which ones don't and which ones go against company policy. And then also add a bit at the bottom to teach her how to do editing properly like everyone else.

Phrase it all in a polite, 'just helping you out' manner, as she's new and doesn't know company policy just yet.

If she wants to be noticed, help her out. Such a shame its in a bad way but oh well.

NCkitchen · 10/12/2021 08:30

Hi x,

Going forward please give your edits/comments to me as I need to finish editing the final doc before it goes to senior manager.

I'd imagine it's a bit annoying for senior manager to receive several drafts from various people rather than one final doc.

Thanks so much for your comments. I'll definitely include abc but xyz are not inline with brand policy.

Many thanks

NextChristmas · 10/12/2021 08:16

The only time someone puts someone's boss on a cc when it's not actually directly to do with the boss is to make a point. Odd (and brazen!) for someone junior to you to take that approach which makes me think it has to have been some sort of mistake or just inexperience.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/12/2021 08:12

I receive these kind of CCs, most of them are automatically diverted to a subfolder, others just make my eyes roll a bit.

However I see very different workplace practices on this within clients and between geographies.

If it bothers you just ask her. I'd also ask her why she can't provide comments in the standard format requested like everyone else.

tttigress · 10/12/2021 08:11

There is nothing I had more than "weaponised cc"!!

AvocadoTrees · 10/12/2021 08:08

Depends. In some workplaces it would not be unusual for certain senior staff to take good ideas from their junior staff and pass them off as their own.

Is your workplace like this or do you give credit where it is due?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 10/12/2021 08:01

Really couldn't get worked up about this. You're a senior manager so I don't understand why you can't say to her thanks for the feedback but we don't cc in others here. Or just say nothing because the cc doesn't affect you it affects your line manager so if they don't want to read it they can tell her, or just ignore it.

thedarkling · 10/12/2021 07:51

@Summerfun54321

I’d reply all and say, “Thanks for that Newbie. Manager I’ll forward to you when it’s done”. I wouldn’t tell her off for it.
This
FallingStar21 · 10/12/2021 07:50

The fact that she did not want to submit her comments like everyone else, but EDITED your document and CC-ED YOUR BOSS just feels like she wants to show your boss she can do your job better than you. I am reading it like she wants to take your job or make it look like you aren't good at it for other reasons (doesn't like you and wants to make it hard for you, for example).

LakieLady · 10/12/2021 07:43

I wouldn't bother myself with this tbh. I think it might make you look a bit petty, OP. And she's made herself look a bit pushy and crass, and not up to speed with what company policy is on some issues.

Most places where I've worked people would find this funny and her line manager would probably be telling her "we don't work like this here".

Rainartist · 10/12/2021 07:35

@ZenNudist

Why don't you reply all addressing line manager (let's call her jenny). "Jenny, not sure why you are ccd but you don't need to look at this [yet]. I told Newbie she could send me her edits on the document rather than separate comments. I will review and then if you need to see it will forward updated version "
This is sensible
Haus1234 · 10/12/2021 07:34

This is a cultural thing - in both my current and previous roles everyone would be cc’d. Just let her know clearly it’s not how you do it in your company “for next time”. If she does it again then that’s when you know she’s scheming!

Scrabblecrabapple · 10/12/2021 07:33

Surely your manager should be saying please don’t CC me in, if that’s what he/she wants.

Swipe left for the next trending thread