Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think everyone hates their MIL?

282 replies

Mercs · 09/12/2021 21:22

As a mum of boys I am honestly petrified people hate their mother in law and I am destined to become an old lady that never sees their kids or grandkids

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 10/12/2021 07:54

Mine is a nice women kind and sweet and I like her well enough. We aren't best friends though and she favours sil (her other dil) over me and her children so I keep her at arms length. I phone her a few time a week and see her once a week pre covid. I have a 3 month old baby and she has seen her a handful of times , sil has a 2 month old baby that lives with mil and she has said that she is too busy to visit. Her loss as my kids simply aren't as close to her despite her living a 10 minute drive away compared to my parents that live 4 hours away.

As long as you aren't overbearing, don't offer up your opinion all the time and treat your dil's equally or better yet any grandchildren equally I'm sure you will be fine. It is up to your sons to cultivate their (future) children's relationship with you, not their mothers so maybe remind your boys of that.

FlipFlops4Me · 10/12/2021 07:50

I loved mine and then I found out that for 30 years she's been faking it. She doesn't like me at all. She trusts me to manage her finances and to organise household repairs, but she doesn't like me.

My DH had a stroke almost exactly 6 months ago. It's affected him quite badly. She lives 10 minutes away and has visited once. The last time she phoned was 2 months ago about her gas bill. I think she's gone vlc with us but only since DH became unable to drive her round and run her errands. It hurts - even at my age.

DrunkenKoala · 10/12/2021 07:46

Mine is great. It’s my own mother who I have problems with.

LubaLuca · 10/12/2021 07:09

[quote SunscreenCentral]@LubaLuca the older my dear DF gets, the older the films we watch together ...
Classic movie nights are such a great way of relaxing and connecting, The Three Faces of Eve was a recent one[/quote]
It's not that she hasn't watched a film made since 1975, and prefers the oldies. She and FIL pride themselves on being 'out of the loop'. They have never wanted to watch a film, and she has never wanted to read a book. I'd watch anything with them if I thought it might give us something to talk about.

SparrowNest · 10/12/2021 06:33

I like mine!

DBI78 · 10/12/2021 06:18

@TheLovleyChebbyMcGee

I like mine, she's a bit irritating ag times and can drive both DH and I up the wall, but we get on.

However my own mum isn't great to my brothers wife, but nice to my DH. DH and I joke that we're glad he got thd MIL he has and not the one my SIL has!

Just curious do you defend sil to your mum? I am that sil and nobody acknowledges I'm getting a rough deal!!
DBI78 · 10/12/2021 06:14

My mil is a pain in arse. (As is fil) They favour their dd, hubby and child over us and our kids. She sometimes says mean things and generally they make little effort. I find it hard as I lost my mum n my dad needs support and my sister is other side of country. So would really benefit from the support (emotionally as well as practical) so it's hard to see how much they support sil who also has her in-laws plus her hubby has two siblings so they have a big network supporting them and their one child. And we have none for us and out 3 children. But we make it work. In terms of one day being a mil myself I will try to be a warm and open one and hope it's reciprocated. In my experience daughters tend to stay closers than sons.

Hothammock · 10/12/2021 06:00

My MIL is mostly sweet but as an imperfect human she has her oddities as we all do. The problem we have is very she tries to impose those oddities on us. She has done some really odd things which really common sense should have prevented. She has taken our children's things, toys and clothes, without permission and given them to her friends. She has treated our children differently to her daughters children who are showered with gifts, visits and money whereas our family get Biros and pound shop note pads. She makes unpleasant comments about their characters and habits, how dirty or untidy they are or how they will never be good at something. She insists on turning a blind eye to her filandering husband who has flaunted affair after affair to the world and expects us to join in with her doting on him and ignore the truth. This kind of stuff stacks up to become an irritation and makes it difficult to behave normally with her. As I said really common sense should have limited all this this but unfortunately MIL syndrome just seems to drag some women into the most peculiar and annoying behaviour.

EssexLioness · 10/12/2021 05:44

I have been married twice and got on well with both MIL. They have both made an effort to meet up with me 1:1 eg for coffee, lunch, go shopping, spa days etc. When I split up with my ex I truly mourned the loss of MIL as she was the closest thing to a loving mum I’ve ever had. I know she struggled with that too.
My sister also gets on well with her MIL, but doesn’t meet 1:1 in this way. However, you do hear a lot of women who don’t seem to like their MIL so I feel very lucky with mine

faithfulbird20 · 10/12/2021 05:13

Raise your sons well to be good partners and don't intrude on their lives when they're married and I'm sure you'll have no issues.

Chasingaftermidnight · 10/12/2021 05:04

I don’t like mine at all. She’s incredibly fussy, demanding and judgmental - not just of me but of everyone, including strangers on the street. I also don’t like my FIL for the same reasons.

But out of my group of friends the majority have great relationships with their MILs. I’m so envious of people who have that relationship in their lives. I think all you need to do is a) be nice; b) don’t come between your son and your DIL; c) don’t be judgmental of your DIL’s appearance, family, house, or parenting; and d) be as helpful as you can be without being intrusive. All fairly normal rules of social interaction tbh - the general principles aren’t confined to a MIL/DIL relationship. Normal people wouldn’t go to a neighbours’ house and pass comment on their parenting or housework, or cause a rift between the neighbour and his/her partner, so it should be perfectly straightforward not to do it with a son and DIL.

Flutterflybutterby · 10/12/2021 04:40

I love mine. Maybe even like her more than my husband 😂Grin Just kidding. But she is fab.

TheFairyCaravan · 10/12/2021 04:31

I love my MIL. She is the most kind, caring and considerate woman ever. She treats me as well as she treats her own daughters.

I’m the mum of 2 grown up sons, I don’t think mum DIL hates me. In fact I know she doesn’t. I adore her. She makes my son so very happy so that’s all I could ever want. When their relationship became serious she said that I was going with her, and her mum, to choose her wedding dress (she’s not been proposed to yet) because it would br something I’d miss out on by not having daughters. I thought that was a lovely gesture.

moni34 · 10/12/2021 04:17

Love mine

MyDogLovesBiscuits · 10/12/2021 04:13

I loved mine until my ex told her a pack of lies and she went cold and distant on me. We split and I never once heard from her again which really made me sad and wonder if she had ever really liked me at all.

Treat your children like adults and be nice to your DIL and if they are normal people you should be fine.

EdgeOfACoin · 10/12/2021 03:57

Mine is lovely!

OFFREDOFFSTUART · 10/12/2021 03:34

Also- don't do things which will put their relationship under pressure- be the flexible one!

OFFREDOFFSTUART · 10/12/2021 03:32

I have had 3 mother-in-laws [don't ask] and am now a MIL myself.
My experiences with MILs have ranged from lovely to downright hostile...
I try my best with my DIL to be understanding- but more importantly, never say anything to my son which I wouldn't want repeated to her; even if I don't agree with what she's [allegedly] done/said. Also, I have called my son out openly, if he's rude/disrespectful to his wife.

Bananarice · 10/12/2021 03:09

I never meet her as she died before me and dh got together.

I'm raising three sons, I hope to get along with all their partners in the future.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 10/12/2021 03:07

I loved my mother in law more than my own mother! She died when she was only 58 and I miss her.

My step-MIL and ex-step-MIL are both awful though. Can't wait until philandering FIL gets bored with the current one and dumps her.

Kanaloa · 10/12/2021 02:55

So yeah, I was a bit lucky with a lovely mil but I also think I work hard at maintaining a good relationship as well. Bit of both!

Kanaloa · 10/12/2021 02:54

Mine is lovely. She’s not a perfect person but who is?

I think one thing that’s key is give and take. Of course sometimes a mil might just be a horrible person in which case nothing you can do. But you see it all the time on mumsnet with people saying aibu to go mad at mil because the free childcare she provides 5 days a week isn’t up to scratch?

Unfortunately in cases like that you need to balance it. You either pay a professional, and have it all your way, or you get it for free and are grateful for the favour. You can’t have all the mil bits you want (free childcare/babysitting/helping financially and practically) with the mil then disappearing conveniently when you can’t be bothered, and never asking a favour in return.

Isitmeorthemm · 10/12/2021 02:53

Mine can be very irritating but can be equally amazing. I dont hate her at all. I'm lucky in some ways and in other ways she can be overbearing but overall I quite like her.

stayathomer · 10/12/2021 02:49

Sorry, that was in reply to this: "Don’t be overbearing - forcing son and DIL to spend time with you using guilt tactics

  • Don’t spend little interest in DIL or son for 10 years and then suddenly want to be their best friend when GC arrive
  • Don’t become hysterical when your 25 year old son says he’s going to spend Christmas with his gf of 6 years
  • Don’t hog the newborn baby, take the baby out of sight of DIL, press to do anything with the baby, handle the baby like a play thing for your amusement. Let DIL have this time and be invited in rather than pushing your way in
  • Don’t act in a way that you know will lead to arguments between your son and DIL. Make their relationship with each other easier, not harder"
stayathomer · 10/12/2021 02:47

See I think this is all very easy to say until you're in the position that you're on your own, people are off doing their own thing and you're tired and maybe stuff sore etc. My mum (and mil) were the easiest going most chilled people ever and then I noticed as things got harder health wise etc we got little 'oh were you not going to come over' comments that I'm guessing both would have been embarrassed about. We'd be unable to come over for some reason or I'd miss one phone call and I'd get a 'oh I missed you so much I wondered would you call again, I was telling Mrs x how I'm alone now (both live with sons)'. I think it's inevitable that we feel we're missing out and cling onto new life experiences such as a new baby. And I think 20 years in the future most people on MN who don't like their mil or dm will suddenly realise either they weren't so bad or will even find themselves doing the same!