Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who can I report this to?

163 replies

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 18:33

Hello everyone! 👋

Last year I bought my first car and took out a black box insurance (the type which is fitted to your engine). I had a couple of minor accidents as most new drivers do, however every month on my driving report I always had high scores and was rewarded with bonus miles for good driving.

This year my insurance was up for renewal and because of the accidents that I had, my insurance went up slightly, and I had a cheaper quote from another insurance company so I chose to go with them instead because it worked out about half the price (still a black box policy but one that sticks on the windshield instead and connects to your mobile phone).

A month or so into my new insurance policy, I noticed that my scores had dropped very low (I’m talking from 90’s range to under 10 points). I knew that this was not correct at all because I have always driven safely (the first accident was not my fault, I was hit at the back, and the second accident involved an ambulance and I completely panicked and couldn’t pull over in time but had only been on the road around a month or so) and on top of that, because I now have slight agoraphobia since the pandemic started, I rarely go out and only drive my car around once a week within a 2 mile radius of my home.

I complained to the insurance company straight away and they said that they would investigate and let me know the outcome, I waited their reply which never came, and I ended up being in hospital for a long time so I didn’t get round to chasing it up, but equally because I hadn’t been driving during that time I wasn’t exactly worried about having a low score for bad driving - because no driving was happening!

Today, I get a random email completely out of the blue saying that because of my low driving score (for bad driving) my policy is now being cancelled and I have 20 days to find a new one.

I rang them and disputed this based on the fact that 1; I had a good history with black boxes until I went with them. 2; I raised a concern about the low score weeks ago which they were supposed to investigate but evidently have not or it wouldn’t have reached this point and 3; they are supposed to give out warning emails before cancelling a policy and the last email I got from them was 3/4 months ago.

The manager is due to ring me back tomorrow to discuss it because I was EXTREMELY unhappy that I tried to resolve this with them weeks ago and now I’m going to be left uninsured and unable to drive my car IF I need to because there is no way I’m going to be able to afford an initial deposit on a new insurance on top of Christmas, and I have a physical disability so I can’t walk to places I need to get to either.

If I was driving stupid every single day I would suck it up and get on with it, but I barely drive and when I do it’s always normally and safely - and now I’ve had a policy cancelled through absolutely no fault of my own and have the financial impact of this happening too.

If I can’t resolve this with the manager, who else can I report this to?

They asked what kind of solution I am seeking and I am thinking to either set me up on another policy free of charge of initial deposit, or reimburse me some of the money I have paid to be able to afford a new policy with someone else - is this unreasonable?

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 09/12/2021 19:41

Does your phone automatically go into
Do Not Disturb mode and therefore not properly connect, perhaps?

I would suggest, though, that either your mileage is too low for them to take accurate recordings or you've become a worse driver than you realise since your accidents.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:37

@TakeYourFinalPosition that’s my point - my phone has been linked up and with me every single time - the tab isn’t working properly with my phone and I’ve contacted them ages ago to sort that out and they haven’t!

One accident was not my fault - as I have said before too.

I am getting defensive now because I keep repeating myself and then keep getting the same questions asked that I’ve already answered!

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:36

@margotsdevil and the fact that you keep focusing on the past events is getting extremely irritating too because that is not the reason why it’s been cancelled. They knew all about my history when they gave me a policy months ago, they’re cancelling it purely down to the fact of what’s being recorded on the tab in my car (which I’ve reported problems with already) and I’ve just checked over my policy document - it doesn’t mention anything about mileage, just if you go over it might affect your payments or when you try to claim.

OP posts:
TakeYourFinalPosition · 09/12/2021 19:36

Not having your phone with you and synced up to record your data is very likely to be against the T&Cs of the insurance - they need that data, live, to assess your driving. Between that sync failing and you not driving much, I’m not surprised that your policy has been cancelled - although it’s poor that you raised the sync issue and they haven’t got back to you. Have you chased that up, or did you just leave it until they cancelled your policy?

Although it’d be good customer service, they don’t have to warn you that you’re at risk of your insurance being cancelled - especially if it’s in the T&Cs.

But I’d agree that you seem quite defensive, and while both of the incidents you describe seem unlucky, you have had two - so you are a higher risk driver. Not driving much since you got your insurance will make that worse, not better, because it means you’re not getting much experience, and your skills will be declining.

margotsdevil · 09/12/2021 19:32

@justamumseekingadvice I think your responses just illustrate what I was trying to say. It doesn't feel like you're taking any responsibility here at all.

No-one is saying that it's your fault the insurance company didn't get back to you about the potential issue with the black box. What people are trying to suggest is that there is definitely an onus on you to make sure that it's followed up - getting insurance cancelled is a massive issue moving forward. You are going back to the recording of mileage historically - but have you (as you definitely should) contacted them to highlight you are doing reduced mileage? That is 100% your responsibility. I don't know that statistics for accidents in year 1 - but I do know that insurers now don't seem to care who was at fault - a no fault accident bumped my premium recently, and I know others have noticed the same, so I'm not sure the no-fault has had as little impact on your history as you think.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:31

@gwenneh first of all - they gave me an extremely cheap quote despite my accident so they didn’t exactly hold them over me or it would have been through the roof. And secondly if someone is not driving around so much because of mental health issues or physical health problems (not declarable to DVLA either before anyone asks) - an insurance company cannot drop you for that - I would like to see them try and discriminate against me like that because then I would kick up a fuss.

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:29

@crowsfeet57 that is honestly why I have kicked up such a fuss and got so annoyed over it - because I think there has been an issue between my phone and this new tab - the only thing I could do is ask them to investigate and potentially send me a new one but they didn’t (I doubt they’ve even bothered looking into it) and now it’s lead to this.

If I was even POTENTIALLY driving round a bit too fast etc, I would admit it and suck it up and move on. I have done nothing wrong or had no incidents since I got this new policy and it’s completely blown up in my face.

OP posts:
gwenneh · 09/12/2021 19:28

I have done nothing with my new insurance to class me as a high risk driver

Right, but you did with your old insurance, and that carries over.

The amount of accidents you have had TOTAL doesn't matter what insurer you had divided by the miles you drive goes into the calculation of your risk score. The insurance company aren't going to ignore the two accidents, even if they're with another insurer, when factoring whether or not to insure you. You don't drive a lot, and you were involved in two accidents in your first year. That is enough to drop you.

Everything is just speculation, though, and you need to speak to the insurer. Just be mindful that it may not be a mistake or an oversight, it's the result of the risk assessing algorithm.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:27

@funnelfanjo it picks up information from my phone via blue tooth, I always have my blue tooth on and it says it’s connected on my phone but the information is not reading onto the tab - hence why I rang the insurance company when it first started happening and asked them to sort it out - which they haven’t.

How is that my fault?

OP posts:
crowsfeet57 · 09/12/2021 19:26

The only solution that will work for you is for them to admit they have made a mistake and reinstate your insurance.

Money is not going to help you because every time you apply for car insurance, you will be asked the question "Have you ever had an insurance policy cancelled?"

A dishonest answer will invalidate your insurance. You need them to keep the insurance policy going until your renewal comes up.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:25

@margotsdevil plus I am not deflecting anything - I raised a concern with the insurance company because I suspected something wrong with their equipment (for example it doesn’t pick up my phones presence in the car and yet it’s meant to get my driving information from my phone?) and whilst I waited for the insurance company to try and sort this out with me, they have cancelled my insurance out of the blue with no warning - I’m pretty sure that’s broken some policy guidelines.

OP posts:
funnelfanjo · 09/12/2021 19:25

[quote justamumseekingadvice]@CorrBlimeyGG when I go onto ‘my driving’ section all it gives me is the journeys I have done and my overall score - a lot of these journeys are saying that my phone hasn’t been present to record the data even though it has been in the car with me - that’s why I raised the concern that it wasn’t working properly with them but they’ve done nothing about it - just cancelled my policy instead.[/quote]
There you are then - they think you're fiddling the system somehow. What are you doing to get your phone to talk to the box?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/12/2021 19:25

Are you in the USA op? I assume you are since you called the windscreen a windshield?

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:24

@margotsdevil only one accident was my fault - a lot of new drivers are most likely to have an accident in their first year of driving. I have not had anything happen since. A one off (considering the other one someone hit me) isn’t a high risk person. Plus if the insurance company was that concerned about me I’m sure that my monthly payments would be a lot higher when they first decided to give me a policy. Nothing has happened with this insurance company.

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:22

@Silvershroud only one accident was my fault and I have proof of being a good driver by always having high scores with my other insurance company (they were the ones I had my accident with). I have done nothing with my new insurance to class me as a high risk driver and my insurance with them is extremely cheap with a next to nothing excess to pay - that’s not exactly showing a high risk driver is it.

OP posts:
margotsdevil · 09/12/2021 19:18

I've got to be honest and say I'm beginning to think that the insurance company have got concerns for a valid reason. You seem to be unwilling to take on board valid comments here (that 2 accidents in year 1 isn't really average, for example) - and when it's being pointed out (again very validly) that you are probably driving so little that they can't accurately assess your safety, you again deflect to the insurance company staying they should have warned you you weren't driving enough. I'm pretty sure that it will say in your contract details that it is on you to ensure you update with any changes - which would include a drastic change in mileage.

On top of this, I suspect statistically that someone driving so little is actually an increased risk to an insurance company.

Silvershroud · 09/12/2021 19:15

Going on the information you give, you sound high risk. (Two bumps in your first year, anxious, panicky, denying you are a poor driver, etc). If I were you, I wouldn't be too demanding. Take what you are offered and count yourself lucky if you get insurance again.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:02

Regarding the lack of miles - I am not aware of a minimum amount as such - but if this was a reason why surely they have a responsibility to contact me and ask me why I’m not driving or inform me that I have to start driving more or they will cancel etc?

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:01

@CorrBlimeyGG when I go onto ‘my driving’ section all it gives me is the journeys I have done and my overall score - a lot of these journeys are saying that my phone hasn’t been present to record the data even though it has been in the car with me - that’s why I raised the concern that it wasn’t working properly with them but they’ve done nothing about it - just cancelled my policy instead.

OP posts:
Clymene · 09/12/2021 19:00

Are you sure your policy doesn't have a minimum number of miles driven to be valid? If you're getting a discount for having a black box then I'd guess you do actually have to drive the vehicle.

BeautifulBirds · 09/12/2021 19:00

Maybe, due to the lack of driving, they think you've interfered with the box?

If they cancel it you will struggle to find anyone to insure you.

funnelfanjo · 09/12/2021 18:57

Is it possible your current mileage is so low the insurance company thinks you're fiddling the system somehow - ie driving more but somehow disabling the black box so it doesn't record your data?

BurscoughBooths · 09/12/2021 18:57

If you only drive 2 miles a week, a taxi would be cheaper than running a car

CorrBlimeyGG · 09/12/2021 18:54

You can usually log in to your account and see how the insurer is assessing your driving. What does this tell you?

Onehotmess · 09/12/2021 18:52

To be fair she didn’t say she crashed into an ambulance 🙈 she was moving out of the way of an ambulance. You need to see the data for the period you have been insured with this company so you can go through it point by point with the manager on the phone.