Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who can I report this to?

163 replies

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 18:33

Hello everyone! 👋

Last year I bought my first car and took out a black box insurance (the type which is fitted to your engine). I had a couple of minor accidents as most new drivers do, however every month on my driving report I always had high scores and was rewarded with bonus miles for good driving.

This year my insurance was up for renewal and because of the accidents that I had, my insurance went up slightly, and I had a cheaper quote from another insurance company so I chose to go with them instead because it worked out about half the price (still a black box policy but one that sticks on the windshield instead and connects to your mobile phone).

A month or so into my new insurance policy, I noticed that my scores had dropped very low (I’m talking from 90’s range to under 10 points). I knew that this was not correct at all because I have always driven safely (the first accident was not my fault, I was hit at the back, and the second accident involved an ambulance and I completely panicked and couldn’t pull over in time but had only been on the road around a month or so) and on top of that, because I now have slight agoraphobia since the pandemic started, I rarely go out and only drive my car around once a week within a 2 mile radius of my home.

I complained to the insurance company straight away and they said that they would investigate and let me know the outcome, I waited their reply which never came, and I ended up being in hospital for a long time so I didn’t get round to chasing it up, but equally because I hadn’t been driving during that time I wasn’t exactly worried about having a low score for bad driving - because no driving was happening!

Today, I get a random email completely out of the blue saying that because of my low driving score (for bad driving) my policy is now being cancelled and I have 20 days to find a new one.

I rang them and disputed this based on the fact that 1; I had a good history with black boxes until I went with them. 2; I raised a concern about the low score weeks ago which they were supposed to investigate but evidently have not or it wouldn’t have reached this point and 3; they are supposed to give out warning emails before cancelling a policy and the last email I got from them was 3/4 months ago.

The manager is due to ring me back tomorrow to discuss it because I was EXTREMELY unhappy that I tried to resolve this with them weeks ago and now I’m going to be left uninsured and unable to drive my car IF I need to because there is no way I’m going to be able to afford an initial deposit on a new insurance on top of Christmas, and I have a physical disability so I can’t walk to places I need to get to either.

If I was driving stupid every single day I would suck it up and get on with it, but I barely drive and when I do it’s always normally and safely - and now I’ve had a policy cancelled through absolutely no fault of my own and have the financial impact of this happening too.

If I can’t resolve this with the manager, who else can I report this to?

They asked what kind of solution I am seeking and I am thinking to either set me up on another policy free of charge of initial deposit, or reimburse me some of the money I have paid to be able to afford a new policy with someone else - is this unreasonable?

OP posts:
MathsFiend · 09/12/2021 20:46

One thing to bear in mind is that under GDPR, you can get them to review a decision that has been made based on data alone. You must have the ability to have that decision reviewed by a person. It seems this decision has been made solely based on the low scores from your black box, which you has previously contacted them to query.

As PP said, raise an official complaint. The very minimum you want is for your policy to be reinstated as it will be difficult to get insurance elsewhere. I’d also suggest seeking compensation for your time involved in resolving this. If it reaches the stage where you are uninsured for a period, I’d also expect compensation for not being able to use your car.

If you are unsuccessful I’m the complaint, the next step is the Financial Ombudsman service.

madisonbridges · 09/12/2021 20:39

If you never drive further than two miles and you hardly go out, take a photo of your present mileage to show how few miles you've driven. I would think that you get a special deal for using a black box as they record you're driving safety. If you're not recording any mileage, whether your fault or not, they will automatically think you're avoiding recording your driving stats. They deal with all sorts of chancers - they have no way of knowing if you are one or not!
If you can demonstrate that you have been off the road through being ill that might help. I wouldn't state you've lost confidence in driving, rather say you're just doing local shopping because you need to stay close to home.

Lou98 · 09/12/2021 20:26

You're getting a very hard time on here OP - they won't have cancelled your policy over the accidents as they knew about them when you took out the policy (I used to work in motor claims).

It will be the data from your black box - if you're genuinely driving as you're saying here then it does sound faulty. Phone them again and put in a complaint, keep chasing it if they're not. If you're not happy with their resolution to your complaint then you can escalate it to the financial ombudsman.

It would be in your best interest to get them to continue on with your policy rather than reimburse you some costs and still cancel - if they void your insurance it will make it very difficult to get insurance with another company as they see you as more of a risk - especially as a new driver with two accidents (regardless of fault). Your premiums would also be through the roof.

They have given you notice of cancelling your insurance by giving you 20 days notice so technically they've done nothing wrong there. You'll need to keep chasing them before the policy is cancelled - escalating if need be

scarpa · 09/12/2021 20:25

@Aprilx

…and accidents do happen - you’re telling me you have never been involved with one?

I am 51 and I can tell you that I have never been in an accident. My husband can say the same, so can lots of people, in fact most people will not have been in an accident. Honestly you are over normalising accidents. New drivers do not have one or two accidents in the first year of driving. Your driving record is poor and you are also over focusing on whose fault it is. It wasn’t my fault that my fence blew over in the last storm but it still impacts my insurance.

People are trying to help you and you just aren’t listening. People have referred back to what happened a year ago because it is relevant for insurance. It is uncommon for insurers to cancel insurance and if you can at all avoid it you must try to do so. However, I suspect that the insurer has taken multiple factors into account before coming to this decision. Nevertheless see if there is anything you can do to prevent it.

So many people I know had a small bump or scrape in the first year of driving! Mostly gateposts etc while parking - I didn't think this was that unusual?

Obviously OP's involved another car so it's gone on insurance but it was hardly a ten car pile up - just a new driver trying to get out of the way and misjudging space.

Given the videos I've seen of people trying to get through this narrowed lane - 11 in a month!! - I don't think misjudging space is that unusual either.
www.deadlinenews.co.uk/2021/10/13/astonishing-video-shows-11-cars-crash-in-four-weeks-on-watford-road/amp/

And as OP has said, the other accident wasn't her fault.

scarpa · 09/12/2021 20:20

I think the accidents are a red herring - it's not that which is causing them to cancel OP's policy otherwise they wouldn't have offered her the policy in the first place... it's the supposed poor driving data with the new insurer (which her past driving data would suggest wasn't accurate).

Definitely keep pushing them to investigate and if not speak to the Ombudsman!

(Also, one small accident, clipping another car, in your first year of driving isn't that unusual! Not ideal obviously, but hardly a sign that OP is Mad Maxing it all over the show. And the other accident wasn't OP's fault so I'm not sure why everyone is at such pains to comment on how outrageous 2 accidents in a year is...)

Viviennemary · 09/12/2021 20:20

You had two accidents quite quickly but haven't built up very many accident free miles which probably flags up on their system. Sounds like your very cheap insurance could even have been a mistake on their part and the risks weren't calculated correctly.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 20:18

@Aprilx no I’m sorry but an insurance company cannot cancel your policy over past accidents that they knew about correctly and in full detail when you took the policy out. If they deemed me too high risk they shouldn’t have offered me the policy in the first place.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 09/12/2021 20:15

…and accidents do happen - you’re telling me you have never been involved with one?

I am 51 and I can tell you that I have never been in an accident. My husband can say the same, so can lots of people, in fact most people will not have been in an accident. Honestly you are over normalising accidents. New drivers do not have one or two accidents in the first year of driving. Your driving record is poor and you are also over focusing on whose fault it is. It wasn’t my fault that my fence blew over in the last storm but it still impacts my insurance.

People are trying to help you and you just aren’t listening. People have referred back to what happened a year ago because it is relevant for insurance. It is uncommon for insurers to cancel insurance and if you can at all avoid it you must try to do so. However, I suspect that the insurer has taken multiple factors into account before coming to this decision. Nevertheless see if there is anything you can do to prevent it.

girlmom21 · 09/12/2021 20:15

@christmaspombears

The problem with an accident even if no fault is that the insurance deem you a higher risk. 2 accidents in a year is high and therefore the insurance will see you as high risk.
This is a new policy taken out after the accidents
christmaspombears · 09/12/2021 20:14

The problem with an accident even if no fault is that the insurance deem you a higher risk. 2 accidents in a year is high and therefore the insurance will see you as high risk.

LIZS · 09/12/2021 20:13

There is an ombudsman www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/consumers/complaints-can-help/insurance but you would need to have followed the internal complaints process first. I wonder if your previous accidents were correctly recorded when you took out the policy. Were both claims resolved at that point?

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 09/12/2021 20:09

I think the only thing you can do when you speak to them is
a) Ask about the outcome of the original investigation.
b) Ask them to reinstate the policy with a new black box.
I think you need to be assertive about a (although it’s a shame you didn’t raise your concerns in writing) but swallow your pride over b. Because you need them not to cancel the policy more than they need you as a customer.
We can all speculate, but until you have that conversation you won’t know their reasons. I am sorry for your heart issues and hope you are back on your feet - and the road - very soon.

Q123R · 09/12/2021 20:08

FYI 21.6% of new drivers are involved in an accident in their first year here so definitely not 'most'. That being said, I sincerely hope you get this sorted to your benefit soon.

AnyOldPrion · 09/12/2021 20:03

@FranklySonImTheGaffer

It sounds like the person who took your call when you raised the issue hasn’t actually flagged it at all.

Make an official complaint to your insurer, ideally by email and ensure it is logged with them (you should receive an acknowledgment of your complaint within 5 working days).
In your email include the date and time of the call when you raised the issue, ask for the way they calculate driving scores, ask if they have a garage or somewhere local you can take the car and have the black box checked to make sure it’s working and connected correctly and specifically state that cancellation of your policy is going to effect you financially and physically as you have a disability.

Following this they are entitled to 8 weeks to investigate and respond but they often don’t take that long.
Your final response letter will contain your rights to go to the Financial Ombudsman Service if they haven’t rectified the issue for you (until you have this letter the ombudsman won’t investigate as they have to give the company the chance to deal with it via their own complaint process).

This.

Thank goodness there’s someone decent here to give you a useful response. They took you on, knowing about the accidents, so they are wholly irrelevant to what’s happening now.

What I will say is that very cheap insurance is very cheap for a reason. Sorry they sucked you in and I hope you can hang on with them till the year is up and can return to a better company.

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 20:03

@minionsrule thank you, that’s been really helpful, I’ll take all that on board! Flowers

OP posts:
minionsrule · 09/12/2021 20:02

So re reading your original post they haven't cancelled the policy yet, they have given you the required notice of intention to cancel, they are entitled to do this provided they give you the required notice.
I would have thought they would have explained the full reason for this and, if you have breached any conditions, they would point out to you which one.
It could be the data is wrong due to an issue with the box, it could be you need to fulfill minimum miles to qualify, its unlikely it will be your previous accidents.
See what reason they give when they call and I'd suggested you read your policy wording before then.
They won't take pity on your financial position sadly but, if the limited mileage is an issue, maybe ask if there is an alternative contract they can move you onto. It may cost more over the year but they may waive an initial deposit.
Finally, if you get no luck and have to go elsewhere try an Insurance Broker rather than online quotes as you will get declined for having previous insurance cancelled..... it might need a human rather than a computer.
Good luck

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 20:01

I honestly don’t know why people bother coming on here asking for advice - because there is a big difference between giving advice or having a different opinion and attacking someone about something - and I bet you lot are the same people who sit there and shout out ‘be kind’ all over your social media’s.

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:57

@starfishmummy plus, would an unsafe driver get 96-98/100 every single month for a whole year on their driving score?

Every new driver is panicky when they first get on the road and not confident and accidents do happen - you’re telling me you have never been involved with one?

Nothing has happened since, after the ONE mistake I made as a very new driver over a year ago - that has nothing to do with my current situation

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:55

@starfishmummy that happened when I first got my car over a year ago, I am now a confident driver I just have a specific phobia (not driving related) that prevents me from wanting to go out in general and this has only got to this point in the last few weeks or so. Before that, I was driving around a lot and I’m guessing as soon as I get this phobia under control I will drive around normally again to go out.

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:53

@EatYourVegetables my ONE accident that happened when I first got on the roads just over a year ago and nothing has happened since (apart from a young panicky driver hitting me up the arse which I couldn’t avoid) isn’t exactly a monthly occurrence is it?

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 19:52

@margotsdevil I raised the concern with them - they said they would investigate and let me know the outcome - I was then in and out of hospital pretty much constantly for several weeks very unwell with a feeding tube so my car insurance wasn’t exactly in the front of my mind especially because it was an open investigation and they never said there was a possibility of cancelling my policy or that it was at risk.

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 09/12/2021 19:52

I had a couple of minor accidents as most new drivers do no they don't.

I knew that this was not correct at all because I have always driven safely
If you are getting into a panic because you see an ambulance I would question just how safe you are. And if you are hardly using the car it's not going to be helping your confidence, plus do you really need it? Maybe driving is not for you

EatYourVegetables · 09/12/2021 19:51

Christ that’s a lot of accidents. I undestand you’re saying they were “minor” and “not your fault” and “panicky” but most people I know have had 1-2 minor accidents in their lifetime, not in 1 year!

I walk and cycle, as do my children, and stories like this make me scared. An overwhelmed, anxious, panicky new driver who thinks minor accidents are a regular monthly occurrence could kill a cyclist.

margotsdevil · 09/12/2021 19:49

@justamumseekingadvice feel free to focus on the bits you want. You don't seem to be seeing the link between your current extremely low mileage and a decision to cancel your policy, nor do you seem to think that you maybe should have pursued the issue logging miles. A number of other posters have also raised these as possible contributors to the situation 🤷🏻‍♀️

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 09/12/2021 19:41

It sounds like the person who took your call when you raised the issue hasn’t actually flagged it at all.

Make an official complaint to your insurer, ideally by email and ensure it is logged with them (you should receive an acknowledgment of your complaint within 5 working days).
In your email include the date and time of the call when you raised the issue, ask for the way they calculate driving scores, ask if they have a garage or somewhere local you can take the car and have the black box checked to make sure it’s working and connected correctly and specifically state that cancellation of your policy is going to effect you financially and physically as you have a disability.

Following this they are entitled to 8 weeks to investigate and respond but they often don’t take that long.
Your final response letter will contain your rights to go to the Financial Ombudsman Service if they haven’t rectified the issue for you (until you have this letter the ombudsman won’t investigate as they have to give the company the chance to deal with it via their own complaint process).