Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who can I report this to?

163 replies

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 18:33

Hello everyone! 👋

Last year I bought my first car and took out a black box insurance (the type which is fitted to your engine). I had a couple of minor accidents as most new drivers do, however every month on my driving report I always had high scores and was rewarded with bonus miles for good driving.

This year my insurance was up for renewal and because of the accidents that I had, my insurance went up slightly, and I had a cheaper quote from another insurance company so I chose to go with them instead because it worked out about half the price (still a black box policy but one that sticks on the windshield instead and connects to your mobile phone).

A month or so into my new insurance policy, I noticed that my scores had dropped very low (I’m talking from 90’s range to under 10 points). I knew that this was not correct at all because I have always driven safely (the first accident was not my fault, I was hit at the back, and the second accident involved an ambulance and I completely panicked and couldn’t pull over in time but had only been on the road around a month or so) and on top of that, because I now have slight agoraphobia since the pandemic started, I rarely go out and only drive my car around once a week within a 2 mile radius of my home.

I complained to the insurance company straight away and they said that they would investigate and let me know the outcome, I waited their reply which never came, and I ended up being in hospital for a long time so I didn’t get round to chasing it up, but equally because I hadn’t been driving during that time I wasn’t exactly worried about having a low score for bad driving - because no driving was happening!

Today, I get a random email completely out of the blue saying that because of my low driving score (for bad driving) my policy is now being cancelled and I have 20 days to find a new one.

I rang them and disputed this based on the fact that 1; I had a good history with black boxes until I went with them. 2; I raised a concern about the low score weeks ago which they were supposed to investigate but evidently have not or it wouldn’t have reached this point and 3; they are supposed to give out warning emails before cancelling a policy and the last email I got from them was 3/4 months ago.

The manager is due to ring me back tomorrow to discuss it because I was EXTREMELY unhappy that I tried to resolve this with them weeks ago and now I’m going to be left uninsured and unable to drive my car IF I need to because there is no way I’m going to be able to afford an initial deposit on a new insurance on top of Christmas, and I have a physical disability so I can’t walk to places I need to get to either.

If I was driving stupid every single day I would suck it up and get on with it, but I barely drive and when I do it’s always normally and safely - and now I’ve had a policy cancelled through absolutely no fault of my own and have the financial impact of this happening too.

If I can’t resolve this with the manager, who else can I report this to?

They asked what kind of solution I am seeking and I am thinking to either set me up on another policy free of charge of initial deposit, or reimburse me some of the money I have paid to be able to afford a new policy with someone else - is this unreasonable?

OP posts:
Lou98 · 09/12/2021 23:20

even one accident is one too many and you’re lucky you got insurance after that.

That was meant to be highlighted

Lou98 · 09/12/2021 23:20
  • even one accident is one too many and you’re lucky you got insurance after that.

What a ridiculous comment - what do you think insurance is for? If people couldn't get insurance after one accident there would be a lot less drivers on the road.

@BritWifeInUSA that's not true - the insurance company can see whether the accident was logged as "fault" or "non-fault" but when taking out insurance you need to declare all accidents, regardless of fault. Unfortunately even once you've been in an accident that's not your fault, it's likely that your premiums will go up as statistically you're more likely to be in another accident. I used to work in motor claims and it was crazy the amount of people that wouldn't declare non fault accidents when taking out a policy because they thought the same as you and didn't think they needed to declare it

WouldIBeATwat · 09/12/2021 22:43

Are we 100% clear that both accidents were correctly recorded on the new policy?

user1471447863 · 09/12/2021 22:35

Can people please forget about the accidents (for the issue at hand anyway)? They are irrelevant being under a previous policy & the current insurer being entirely aware of them at the time then new policy was purchased.

Whatever happens OP you need to not get your policy cancelled as this will cost you forevermore.
Anything connecting to your phone is going to be pot luck over time - software up dates change the way phones behave with certain apps, simply state of charge, or not charging etc. So their supplied equipment being faulty/defective/not appropriate for the task should be a focus, after all your phone works fine, you make and receive calls with it don't you, maybe even brows mumsnet and send an email.

Herecomesthesun70 · 09/12/2021 22:26

Going back to your original question. Speak to a manager first and get all the information as to why are threatening to cancel the policy.
If you are not satisfied then ask to raise a complaint. Their complaints department will review the issue and decide if they've acted correctly. If they reject your complaint and you're still not happy you can go to the financial ombudsman service who will investigate for you.
It might well be down to not enough driving.
It will NOT be down to your medical issues.

CrimeJunkie01 · 09/12/2021 22:18

I had an issue with house insurance where they insured me following an online check sheet then decided that they didn't like the fact there was a tree in the garden and decided to give me 21 days notice or something like that before they cancelled it. The only way not to have an insurance cancellation on my record was to take out a new policy and cancel the original one myself thereby stopping the insurer from cancelling it which would have to be declared.

I then argued the toss with the old insirer afterwards. I recommend you take out a new policy and cancel this one yourself before they cancel it and you are stuck declaring it forever.

Weegiewtf · 09/12/2021 22:13

OP you’ve been given a bit of a hard time here.

Your previous accidents are irrelevant in this instance - you were awarded a new insurance policy, I presume having declared both accidents and whether at fault or not. You can leave the issue of prior accidents behind. You’re arguing something that is pointless. Your points in your previous insurance are not indicative of driving behaviours under this one.

What your issues are now is the present insurance and why they are cancelling it. You have two things you need to do urgently. You need to get an explanation as to why they are cancelling your insurance and you need to get a response to your initial contact regarding the potentially broken black box. The answer to one may negate the other.

One thing I’m wondering about, that I only ask you to consider & you have no need to answer here, is whether you have declared your anxiety and other disability to both DVLA and the insurer. You’d be surprised at the kinds of conditions that require reporting to dvla and not informing them or your insurer of having a reportable Condition can invalidate your insurance immediately. You also need to consider whether you’ve been driving upon release from hospital when perhaps you shouldn’t have been. It is your responsibility to find out whether you have to refrain from driving and if you do not do so & it is required, you will have insurance cancelled even if you’ve been driving safely. The issue I raise here may be totally irrelevant but it’s something that has jumped out at me in your posts as unaddressed and is a common reason for insurance cancellation for sick and disabled people.

Instead of fighting people on here on irrelevant points take the advice people have offered on what to do next.

DicklessWonder · 09/12/2021 21:58

[quote justamumseekingadvice]@VodselForDinner One accident someone hit me at the back so that wasn’t my fault, the one that was my fault was trying to get out of the way for an ambulance and clipped another car slightly - you couldn’t even see the damage to their car. Plus that wasn’t with this insurance company so it has nothing to do with their quote or data etc.[/quote]
Insurers share claims data.

You’re not a good insurance risk, I’m afraid. 2 accidents, at least 1 due to inexperience, and how you’re barely driving thus not gaining any experience.

minionsrule · 09/12/2021 21:57

Interestingly OP I just googled about BB insurance, I can't mind anything about minimum mileage, most have a max mileage or you pay more if you drive a lot of miles (makes sense) so it is unlikely to be that you are not driving much.
Most likely reasons for the insurer cancelling are speeding, poor cornering and hard braking and excessive mileage... that or discovery of a non disclosure of information or non payment of premium.
When you speak to them, in case you want to escalate it, tell them up front that you would like them to follow up the call with an email confirming the reasons for cancellation, that way you don't need to be scribbling notes and trying to remember stuff

mm40 · 09/12/2021 21:54

There have been articles on TV regarding this. Adrian Flux we’re apparently one of the worst as they had a record of a girl who’d apparently driven into a shop and driven the wrong way down a dual carriageway - none of which actually happened. It’s down to the quality of the equipment that they provide.

www.lynnnews.co.uk/news/insurance-companys-black-box-hailed-as-life-saving-9213638/

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-7678069/Complaints-soar-black-box-gadgets-hep-young-drivers-insured.html

cherrypie66 · 09/12/2021 21:45

@justamumseekingadvice

I honestly don’t know why people bother coming on here asking for advice - because there is a big difference between giving advice or having a different opinion and attacking someone about something - and I bet you lot are the same people who sit there and shout out ‘be kind’ all over your social media’s.
Honestly take no notice they really are being twats. Having a couple of knocks In the first year is perfectly normal. My daughter has done it and all of her friends have had a least one knock within a few months. Take it up with the manager and try and get to the bottom of of. Good luck
godmum56 · 09/12/2021 21:43

I hate to say "I read somewhere" but I did read somewhere of drivers having problems with this kind of insurance because the setup wasn't working properly and the app wasn't picking up the data...Sorry but because it didn't affect me I didn't take much notice....might be worth doing a general google or looking on the Martin lewis website.

cherrypie66 · 09/12/2021 21:38

@gwenneh

I had a couple of minor accidents as most new drivers do

In the one year since you got your car? No, that's not actually normal driving at all, and I suspect there's more going on in the data that led to the cancellation.

Yes a few minor incidents is very normal in the first year it's when you actually learn to drive !
Tee20x · 09/12/2021 21:35

@BritWifeInUSA she would still have to declare that type of accident even if she was not at fault. Most insurers ask whether you have been in an accident in the last 5 years whether you are at fault or not. Unfortunately even if you are not at fault for an accident but have been involved in one your premiums can be affected as you are still deemed more risky.

BritWifeInUSA · 09/12/2021 21:30

@Tee20x

Accidents are sheer luck or lack there of. I've seen people pull some risky moves and got away with it because there has been no one there or the other driver has reacted quickly. A new driver won't have had the time to build up those skills so may become flustered or not know what to do. Like OP said one of the accidents wasn't even her fault - how can you stop someone driving into the back of you? You can't.
If she was rear-ended through no fault of her own (there are cases where it can be your fault such as being in a queue at traffic lights and rolling when you set off due to poor clutch control) then it wouldn’t be listed as an accident or claim on her insurance as the whole matter will have been dealt with by the other person’s insurance. If the rear-ending is affecting her insurance quotes then she must have been found at fault in some way.
Porfre · 09/12/2021 21:29

Yeah check on trust pilot if they're a dodgy company.

This is the exact reason why I would never get a black box. Luckily I dont need one now.
But my niece had similar. The black box kept flagging up poor driving when the driving was fine. In the end her mum cancelled the policy.

scarpa · 09/12/2021 21:27

@Lokdok

Sorry to say, I agree with basically everyone else. It definitely isn’t common for new drivers to have accidents. And there’s no point being defensive saying one wasn’t your fault - even one accident is one too many and you’re lucky you got insurance after that. They might think you have been turning off Bluetooth so your driving isn’t recorded, I expect that’s why it’s been cancelled. If you told them you were going to do 10000 miles a year and have only done 50 in a month then this will be why. Or, if you were speeding for those two miles you drove, even slightly, that would throw you over the risk threshold and you were already high risk. I’d play it very nicely with them and not be asking for discounts etc, just see if you can get insurance reinstated, even for an increased cost because if you can’t get that with them I’m afraid you’re probably uninsurable.
"You're lucky you got insurance after that"?

What world do you live in where nobody ever gets reinsured after one accident? 🤣

BritWifeInUSA · 09/12/2021 21:26

I’ve been driving over 30 years and had one accident.

I’m not sure how it works there but over here those boxes that monitor your driving for insurance purposes (and record his hard you use your brakes, etc) also score you negatively if you drive very little as this means you are inexperienced. From what I was told by my insurance company here when they tried to get me to have one to supposedly lower my insurance cost, they work best for people who drive medium distances and often - such as a 10-mile commute twice a day - rather than people who only drive 2 miles a few times a week or people who drive 500 miles once a month.

Skyll · 09/12/2021 21:20

It’ll be to do with them not having your phone synced with the app. You need to get to the bottom of that.

Lokdok · 09/12/2021 21:20

Sorry to say, I agree with basically everyone else. It definitely isn’t common for new drivers to have accidents. And there’s no point being defensive saying one wasn’t your fault - even one accident is one too many and you’re lucky you got insurance after that. They might think you have been turning off Bluetooth so your driving isn’t recorded, I expect that’s why it’s been cancelled. If you told them you were going to do 10000 miles a year and have only done 50 in a month then this will be why. Or, if you were speeding for those two miles you drove, even slightly, that would throw you over the risk threshold and you were already high risk. I’d play it very nicely with them and not be asking for discounts etc, just see if you can get insurance reinstated, even for an increased cost because if you can’t get that with them I’m afraid you’re probably uninsurable.

Tee20x · 09/12/2021 21:18

Accidents are sheer luck or lack there of. I've seen people pull some risky moves and got away with it because there has been no one there or the other driver has reacted quickly. A new driver won't have had the time to build up those skills so may become flustered or not know what to do. Like OP said one of the accidents wasn't even her fault - how can you stop someone driving into the back of you? You can't.

Tee20x · 09/12/2021 21:14

Not sure why people are acting like accidents never happen. Of course new drivers have accidents and get into minor bumps and scrapes - even if it's a post, gate etc. That's the reason new driver insurance is so high in the first place - clearly they're more risky and that will be based on some algorithm or another.

I can see why you're annoyed. You've been taken on with them knowing about the accidents - no new accidents have occurred and you say you have been driving safely so shouldn't have anything flagged up and are now being told your insurance is being cancelled. Doesn't really make sense tbh. Do they have a flag system? I knew someone with a black box who would get warnings if they had been speeding etc. I think 3 flags led to the policy being voided. But with that obviously there was prior warning etc.

I think other posters may be right in that they may think you've tampered with the box. Contact them and find out what's going on. Surely they would have given a reason as to why they are voiding the policy?

Bedtimeforever · 09/12/2021 21:12

Check this insurance policy on Trustpilot, chances are you’re not the only one this has happened to, and they are probably notorious for this sort of thing.

I took out a policy with a similar sounding company. 90% of reviews were like this, I quickly cancelled it.
Good luck getting it sorted.

SeasonFinale · 09/12/2021 20:58

Did you also declare the accident that wasn't your fault as you need to have declared that too?

Their policy presumably states that you need to be connected and the low mileage suggests to them that you are driving with it turned off.

girlmom21 · 09/12/2021 20:47

It might be that data is only logged for journeys over a certain number of miles. If that's the case it might look like you're trying to play the system by getting a years no claims and 'experience' without actually using the car.

Or it might look like you're really hesitant and stop/start on the data because there's no long, steady bouts of driving.