Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who can I report this to?

163 replies

justamumseekingadvice · 09/12/2021 18:33

Hello everyone! 👋

Last year I bought my first car and took out a black box insurance (the type which is fitted to your engine). I had a couple of minor accidents as most new drivers do, however every month on my driving report I always had high scores and was rewarded with bonus miles for good driving.

This year my insurance was up for renewal and because of the accidents that I had, my insurance went up slightly, and I had a cheaper quote from another insurance company so I chose to go with them instead because it worked out about half the price (still a black box policy but one that sticks on the windshield instead and connects to your mobile phone).

A month or so into my new insurance policy, I noticed that my scores had dropped very low (I’m talking from 90’s range to under 10 points). I knew that this was not correct at all because I have always driven safely (the first accident was not my fault, I was hit at the back, and the second accident involved an ambulance and I completely panicked and couldn’t pull over in time but had only been on the road around a month or so) and on top of that, because I now have slight agoraphobia since the pandemic started, I rarely go out and only drive my car around once a week within a 2 mile radius of my home.

I complained to the insurance company straight away and they said that they would investigate and let me know the outcome, I waited their reply which never came, and I ended up being in hospital for a long time so I didn’t get round to chasing it up, but equally because I hadn’t been driving during that time I wasn’t exactly worried about having a low score for bad driving - because no driving was happening!

Today, I get a random email completely out of the blue saying that because of my low driving score (for bad driving) my policy is now being cancelled and I have 20 days to find a new one.

I rang them and disputed this based on the fact that 1; I had a good history with black boxes until I went with them. 2; I raised a concern about the low score weeks ago which they were supposed to investigate but evidently have not or it wouldn’t have reached this point and 3; they are supposed to give out warning emails before cancelling a policy and the last email I got from them was 3/4 months ago.

The manager is due to ring me back tomorrow to discuss it because I was EXTREMELY unhappy that I tried to resolve this with them weeks ago and now I’m going to be left uninsured and unable to drive my car IF I need to because there is no way I’m going to be able to afford an initial deposit on a new insurance on top of Christmas, and I have a physical disability so I can’t walk to places I need to get to either.

If I was driving stupid every single day I would suck it up and get on with it, but I barely drive and when I do it’s always normally and safely - and now I’ve had a policy cancelled through absolutely no fault of my own and have the financial impact of this happening too.

If I can’t resolve this with the manager, who else can I report this to?

They asked what kind of solution I am seeking and I am thinking to either set me up on another policy free of charge of initial deposit, or reimburse me some of the money I have paid to be able to afford a new policy with someone else - is this unreasonable?

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 10/12/2021 08:43

Thank you for all of the good advice that has been posted by a few people on here - I’m going to get back onto them today and start looking at other policies!

@Skyll - my daughter used my phone once to keep her calm going home after spending hours in a&e - hardly the worst crime of the century and definitely not a reason to cancel my policy.

Gosh, if policies got cancelled for some of the reasons people have said on here no-one would ever be insured!

OP posts:
Skyll · 10/12/2021 08:40

I don’t think it sounds like a faulty black box.

It sounds like the op hasn’t read her terms and conditions of her policy and is letting her child play with her phone which makes the app think she’s using her phone while driving.

Qwertykeys · 10/12/2021 08:31

Hi op how very frustrating, what company are you with. The only thing I can say is screen shot your scores , email them over and ask for a full explanation. It sounds a little like faulty black box

missy111 · 10/12/2021 08:23

Does someone else use your phone whilst you are driving? This could affect your scores as your phone thinks you are on it whilst driving.

reasysteady · 10/12/2021 08:16

Please take the good advice on this thread.

When you have new insurance make sure you use your car - drive even if you don't need to.

In your position I would even carry on lessons / advanced lessons in your car (no emergency stops!) to increase your mileage and confidence.
I wasn't a great driver when I first had a car, the learning continues after your pass your test and it's only miles under your belt which increases your skill and confidence

Skyll · 10/12/2021 08:09

Exactly @MrsLarry. No. They don’t op. You have an obligation to read your policy documents properly and abide by any terms and conditions.

MrsLarry · 10/12/2021 08:06

@justamumseekingadvice

Regarding the lack of miles - I am not aware of a minimum amount as such - but if this was a reason why surely they have a responsibility to contact me and ask me why I’m not driving or inform me that I have to start driving more or they will cancel etc?
😂 No. No they don't.
wombat1a · 10/12/2021 07:45

If they cancel your policy you will find it virtually impossible to get another one at a reasonable price. THey gave you 20 day so you can move yourself to another company before they cancel,, they are helping you out here.

CrimeJunkie01 · 10/12/2021 07:39

@CrimeJunkie01

I had an issue with house insurance where they insured me following an online check sheet then decided that they didn't like the fact there was a tree in the garden and decided to give me 21 days notice or something like that before they cancelled it. The only way not to have an insurance cancellation on my record was to take out a new policy and cancel the original one myself thereby stopping the insurer from cancelling it which would have to be declared.

I then argued the toss with the old insirer afterwards. I recommend you take out a new policy and cancel this one yourself before they cancel it and you are stuck declaring it forever.

At OP, I get that you are stressed and pissed off but you are wasting time getting into arguments with people about things that don't matter. please read my comment and act quickly to get another insurance policy in place
Skyll · 10/12/2021 07:25

Have you read your terms and conditions of your insurance?

justamumseekingadvice · 10/12/2021 07:23

@mum11970 I even double checked the meaning of how many bars and what the score is etc, apart from those 3 journeys the rest are either unrecorded or 5/5 bars which means top marks or ‘gold’ - it even congratulates me on my driving underneath!

OP posts:
justamumseekingadvice · 10/12/2021 07:22

@mum11970 I’m sure I’m staying in the green and gold and I now have the screenshots from the trips to prove it.

OP posts:
mum11970 · 10/12/2021 07:10

First I’ve heard about a black box connected to phone so googled it and come up with something called a ‘Ticker’. If it’s that, it says all journeys will still be recorded on the windscreen box even if your phone doesn’t connect and it will download the next time you connect, so the connection problems you are having shouldn’t make any difference. It also says you have to be seriously high risk to be asked to leave. Are you sure you are staying in the gold and green areas, rather than the red? Something very strange is going on if you aren’t driving often and staying in the safe driving zones, because insurance companies do not cancel policies unless they think there is a very strong risk that you will make multiple claims.

eurochick · 10/12/2021 06:23

The issue is almost certainly they think you are fiddling the black box because it is not connecting properly with your phone. You need to keep pushing them on that.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 10/12/2021 04:56

I think the OP is being given a very hard time.

Virtually everyone I know has had accidents. I live in London. Maybe that has something to do with it, and maybe the OP also lives in a busy city.

Accidents are a combination of skill and luck. As a PP said, you can be lucky and drive appallingly or be an advanced driver with hundreds of thousands of miles of experience and some idiot drive into you.

Accidents are also what insurance is for. There would be hardly anyone on the road if those who had had an accident got their insurance cancelled.

Definitely complain and get someone senior to investigate. A GDPR request sounds very sensible.

Skyll · 10/12/2021 04:31

You need to read the terms and conditions of your insurance too.

steff13 · 10/12/2021 01:54

Totally irrelevant, as OP was not insured with this insurer when she had the accidents. If they thought the accidents made her such a terrible risk, they would never have taken her on in the first place.

These things are cumulative, though. They may have accepted the risk with the two small accidents but now from their point of view she's not a good driver per whatever the black box is. They're adding that all together and saying that she is no longer a good insurance risk.

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 10/12/2021 01:18

You’re not a good insurance risk, I’m afraid. 2 accidents, at least 1 due to inexperience, and how you’re barely driving thus not gaining any experience.

Totally irrelevant, as OP was not insured with this insurer when she had the accidents. If they thought the accidents made her such a terrible risk, they would never have taken her on in the first place.

steff13 · 10/12/2021 01:09

Is it worth trying to get them to change their minds, or would you be better off just to get a new policy in place before this one terminates? Do they have an obligation to keep it open?

And, it's possible the original black box was faulty. Maybe not, since it didn't record that your phone was with you. But people never seen to consider that the thing in their favor was wrong.

Yes a few minor incidents is very normal in the first year it's when you actually learn to drive !

Not really.

Twolostsoulsswimminginafishbow · 10/12/2021 00:28

I HRTFT but you’ll get nowhere if they want to cancel the policy. What I recommend is you cancel it before they do because you have to declare if you’ve ever had a policy cancelled and with your two accidents you’ll find it really hard to get insurance.

justamumseekingadvice · 10/12/2021 00:10

This thread isn’t about PAST accidents that have zero affect on my CURRENT insurance - stick to the issue I’ve asked about and actually offer advice if you have any please - if you’re going to keep going on about something else and just making a comment for the sake of it - please find something better to do with your night - in the politest way possible it’s getting boring now.

OP posts:
EIIa · 10/12/2021 00:07

Hmmm

Your breezy attitude towards accidents is kind of a red flag tbh

I suspect we’re not getting the full story!

BoredZelda · 10/12/2021 00:03

Doesn’t the black box record more than just accidents?

justamumseekingadvice · 10/12/2021 00:01

Just a quick update - I found the information from the black box on the app and now I’m even more confused and pissed off!

You get scored on 5 different elements of driving and get scored out of 5 bars (5/5 being top marks etc). There was 3 journeys that I made 1; I had 4/5 bars on phone use which I know is when my daughter was playing on my phone on the way back from A&E and 4/5 bars for corners. 2; I had 3/5 for braking and 4/5 corners. 3; 4/5 for corners.

The rest of the journeys were fine. However, over half of the journeys weren’t recorded because it was saying my phone wasn’t present when it’s always with me and Bluetooth is on too - so I’m guessing it’s more of a fault with the tab.

Surely they cannot flipping cancel my policy based on 3 journeys which were only missing 1/2 bars?!

If they were 1 or 2 out of 5 bars on those occasions than I would be a bit more understanding but come on?!

OP posts:
AdobeWanKenobi · 09/12/2021 23:21

The problem you might have is having to declare on your new insurance that you have had a policy cancelled. Most will automatically refuse you on that basis alone if doing it online so really you need to fight the cancellation.

Do they know you've been in hospital? Explaining that may help if they are thinking you've blocked the box perhaps. I agree with others that this is most likely a telemetry issue. Ask if they can replace the box or even if you can pay a little more and not have one. It will still be cheaper than declaring cancelled insurance.