Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Idling cars

157 replies

VegMam · 09/12/2021 17:30

AIBU to ask people with engines idling to switch them off (primary culprits are workmen and parents at schools)?

It’s terribly polluting and totally unnecessary. Drives me mad and I don’t know why so many people do it (and seem miffed when you ask them to switch their engines off)?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itsnotover · 13/12/2021 09:29

@MarshasMincePies

Very easy to take issue with it when you’re not the one working outside in the cold all day with only a van for any proper warmth I think…..

I hear the sound of a tiny violin 🎻

Nemorth · 10/12/2021 19:53

@Fidgetty

Could they pack a spare set of dry clothes and take blankets with them?

You've never been closely aquainted with workmen have you? The absolute nonsense on this thread 🙄

I have been extremely well acquainted with workmen (ooer missus).

I also used to be the only female officer in my Regiment. My soldiers were always prepared in the field with dry clothes. Basic fieldcraft admin.

Dry socks stop you getting blisters. It's so easy to be comfortable in hard living conditions. Choosing not to is stupid.

Running an engine over a break or lunch time isn't going to dry clothes.

Nemorth · 10/12/2021 19:50

@Fidgetty

I don't have a fancy stop-start engine but I turn my engine off even at traffic lights.

That's daft and extreme. Hope you don't hold up the people behind you as that really would be a pain in the arse!

I've never, ever held anyone up!! I pay attention to the queue of cars in front of me, if anything I'm normally ready to go before the two or three cars in front of me!
Nemorth · 10/12/2021 19:49

@Shade17

I don't have a fancy stop-start engine but I turn my engine off even at traffic lights. I can see from my trip counter and average mile petrol counter that it makes a difference.

That’s not the best idea, you’re putting a lot more strain on battery/starter motor than they were designed for. Any fuel savings you make are likely to be wiped out by premature failure of one or the other.

Very reliable car. I only do it in queues of traffic, when I know I'm going to be sitting for a while. Car is 10 years old now.

It has a problem that will be the end of it one day...but it's neither of those things. We're probably on borrowed time at the moment so I'm happy to continue in this vein.

Shade17 · 10/12/2021 19:34

Utter bollocks.

Maybe you should approach the manufacturers? You could save them a fortune by not fitting upgraded batteries and starter motors to stop/start equipped vehicles!

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/12/2021 17:55

@Shade17

I don't have a fancy stop-start engine but I turn my engine off even at traffic lights. I can see from my trip counter and average mile petrol counter that it makes a difference.

That’s not the best idea, you’re putting a lot more strain on battery/starter motor than they were designed for. Any fuel savings you make are likely to be wiped out by premature failure of one or the other.

Utter bollocks.
Fidgetty · 10/12/2021 17:53

Could they pack a spare set of dry clothes and take blankets with them?

You've never been closely aquainted with workmen have you? The absolute nonsense on this thread 🙄

Fidgetty · 10/12/2021 17:51

I don't have a fancy stop-start engine but I turn my engine off even at traffic lights.

That's daft and extreme. Hope you don't hold up the people behind you as that really would be a pain in the arse!

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 10/12/2021 14:55

Why not address that properly with the employer instead of poisoning the air by idling?

Stellaris22 · 10/12/2021 14:40

Being in traffic is very different to idling whilst sat outside a primary school, with adults and pre schoolers queuing and having no choice to breathe in the fumes.

Thecurliestwurly · 10/12/2021 14:27

I've had to idle my car when waiting in traffic a few times just after leaving my house as I haven't driven my car for a while and was worried it wouldn't start again. Normally wouldn't, but a car with a dead battery in front of a huge queue of traffic would be a much bigger problem to everyone. I actually have to drive it for no particular reason sometimes to keep the battery going, as I barely use my car and only for short journeys where I can't carry things home.

Just wanted you to know that sometimes there is an alternative explanation OP.

MarshasMincePies · 10/12/2021 14:17

Very easy to take issue with it when you’re not the one working outside in the cold all day with only a van for any proper warmth I think…..

Shade17 · 10/12/2021 13:20

I don't have a fancy stop-start engine but I turn my engine off even at traffic lights. I can see from my trip counter and average mile petrol counter that it makes a difference.

That’s not the best idea, you’re putting a lot more strain on battery/starter motor than they were designed for. Any fuel savings you make are likely to be wiped out by premature failure of one or the other.

RedToothBrush · 10/12/2021 12:28

@Pigsears

Every morning dad drives mum and two primary age children 1.5 miles to the school- on a school street- and dad idles car whilst mum pops out and deposits children at each classroom door.

No disabilities (hidden or otherwise) Many families walk from the area they live in- some with younger (and more) children.

You wont be surprised to know that he drives a SUV.

Its the family in the mini van that live next door but one to me who take the biscuit.

It is a 5 minute walk to school, and because of the road lay out its quicker to walk. I know because if we leave at the same time I usually get their first.

In the afternoon she leaves at 2pm for a 3.10pm pick up to make sure she gets the best space. Then sits there with the engine on.

Strangely enough she's been complaining about how she's put on weight and has developed a heart problem in the last 12 months.

I struggle with sympathy tbh.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/12/2021 11:56

@Sirzy

Hgvs have night heaters which will run to keep it warm overnight without needing engines on or anything so I am sure similar could be used for workmen!
Watch out! those night heaters burn diesel and they don't have any of the emissions devices like the diesel engines now have to. Their exhaust (yes they have one) is much dirtier than any current engine - but obviously use a lot less fuel.
Pigsears · 10/12/2021 11:48

Every morning dad drives mum and two primary age children 1.5 miles to the school- on a school street- and dad idles car whilst mum pops out and deposits children at each classroom door.

No disabilities (hidden or otherwise) Many families walk from the area they live in- some with younger (and more) children.

You wont be surprised to know that he drives a SUV.

Sirzy · 10/12/2021 11:42

Hgvs have night heaters which will run to keep it warm overnight without needing engines on or anything so I am sure similar could be used for workmen!

Nemorth · 10/12/2021 11:34

@2pinkginsplease

I have sympathy with workmen, my dh works outside and has his van idling during the winter months at lunch time to give them a heat and to dry off their clothes on a wet day.
Could they pack a spare set of dry clothes and take blankets with them?

If they have the van there's space to store and change.

He could also look into other heating options to keep them warm. Maybe a tent heater (designed to be used off grid) could be used safely in the van?

You may have spotted a gap in the market! Someone needs to invent a safe, energy efficient heater for people who work outdoors but have a van to shelter in.

Nemorth · 10/12/2021 11:31

I used to take my DD to football. In effort to cut down on unnecessary journeys I'd wait in the car park for her.

In the winter I'd sit under the blanket we keep in the car (winter prep) with my coat, hat and fingerless gloves on.

If I was super organised I'd have taken a flask of tea and a hot water bottle!

Scotland, windy coastal area so definitely cold outside. Sometimes I ended up too warm without the need to run my engine for heat.

No need to sit with engine idling. So many other cars used to though.

With a few exceptions there is no good reason to sit with an engine idling. Think of all the money (fuel costs) that's just idling away...and the wear and tear on the car...and the air pollution.

With the price of fuel nowadays I'm surprised anyone can afford to let their car idle.

I don't have a fancy stop-start engine but I turn my engine off even at traffic lights. I can see from my trip counter and average mile petrol counter that it makes a difference.

2pinkginsplease · 10/12/2021 10:41

I have sympathy with workmen, my dh works outside and has his van idling during the winter months at lunch time to give them a heat and to dry off their clothes on a wet day.

Daftasabroom · 10/12/2021 10:38

@Evergreenblue apologies, I missed that bit, my bad.

The government could have required all vehicles sold in the UK to be auto stop start enabled ten years ago. This could massively improve urban air quality.

Itsnotover · 10/12/2021 10:00

YANBU - the selfish bastard workmen do this on our road - why should we have to breathe that in?

Evergreenblue · 10/12/2021 09:59

[quote Daftasabroom]@Evergreenblue you only need to idle a hybrid if you are not using it for an extended period of time. You absolutely do not need to idle it if you are using the vehicle on a daily or even weekly basis.[/quote]
Did you not read where I said "if you do not use them a lot" .

No obviously not, go back to your pearl clutching.

Felix125 · 10/12/2021 09:48

@Burnt0utMum

Probably to keep warm or to leave the radio on without risking draining the battery
There's loads of other equipment on the vans/cars which need a charge. Lap-tops, mobile devices, body cams, ANPR cameras, defibs (sometimes).

We can of course sit in a police station to do this, but I think we need to be more visible in the public areas.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 10/12/2021 09:37

So much aggression over this... it's an eye opener for sure!

Frustration. The idler gets to drive off and I have to walk through the stinking poisonous cloud of exhaust he leaves behind. Cold days are often still, so the gases linger for the pedestrians to breathe in for longer.