Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that there is a huge amount of anti vax threads allowed on mumsnet?

310 replies

visitingagain · 09/12/2021 16:07

I fully expect this to be taken down but I am getting completely fed up with the number of anti vax and anti mask threads on mumsnet at the moment. People should be allowed to express views but some of the misinformation is shocking.

OP posts:
visitingagain · 10/12/2021 09:28

@tigger1001 Biscuit for saying I am scared of debate!! After starting this thread!!!
We are past debating. What is there to debate? Whether we like it or not covid is here to stay and the best thing we can do is try to mitigate against it with the tools we have - vaccines, masks etc. because that's ALL WE HAVE.
It would be great to see everyone getting ffp2 masks free from the government but that's incredibly unlikely. However even a nasty old rag is still more effective than not wearing anything at all.
Also, the Scotland/ England comparison is useless as there are so many variables.
But what can be said is Scotland and Wales have not had to faff about persuading people to put masks back on at a crucial moment when we are seeing pressures on out health services.
"Debate"on this topic is so unhealthy and can become downright dangerous, as someone said there are other topics that get pounced on by MNHQ but why is this one allowed?

OP posts:
FestiveMelts · 10/12/2021 09:27

@Caggietambellblack

YABU. God forbid you should see opinions that are different to your own!

People are allowed to express views that may differ from yours. As the poster above said, intolerant censorious people like you frighten me far more than ‘anti vaxxers’ or ‘anti maskers’.

Learn to cope with differences of opinion rather than demanding anyone who thinks differently to you is silenced.

Exactly.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/12/2021 09:26

I didn't make that very clear, the OP there wasn't anti vax but could easily be misinterpreted because there is so much of that on here.

You made it very clear what you thought. Your posts on that thread were ridiculous. It was a thread about maximising vaccine efficacy, but you had to ride your odd hobby horse in.

HereComesSpringAgain · 10/12/2021 09:25

@Whatwouldscullydo

Those of us working closely with the public witness this poor behaviour every time

Ha I work in retail. Just there days ago a customer entered with theor mask across ther forehead. Fiddled with throught theor vist Pulled up pulled down etc

We also have a toilet. I can tell you now that none of the customers are ever in in long enough to have peed and washed their hands. The hand dryer gets used one in 5 visits maybe ( we can hear it) I then have to take money from dry hands...

Even if their mask was sterile ut won't be for long.

Yes retail here too

The public are not doing any good at all. This is why the mask drama is pointless. The public are FILTHY and just play the game to get in and get what they want

SusieBob · 10/12/2021 09:25

The issue is that for people to become educated about matters like this, it requires subtle, often difficult conversations.

Wheras on the internet the discussion invariable descends into bitching and slagging and all that happens is that existing positions are intrenched and nobody ever, ever changes their mind.

That said, I do think MN moderation is pretty poor and while they are happy to jump on anyone challenging anti-vaxxers the far more dangerous av posts full of information get left up. It's like the laughable attempts the BBC make at "balance".

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 09:25

@HereComesSpringAgain

Exactly!!

Those of us working closely with the public witness this poor behaviour every time

Can't admit to being a saint about masks myself though. ... do we all honestly thoroughly wash our hands before putting one on/off? Sanitise? Not touch our mask/face at all whilst wearing one?

Bet we don't but someone will come along in a minute and say they do I'm sure...

Agree.

I know I constantly fiddle with mine as I can't see. My glasses steam up, especially now weather is colder.

thepeopleversuswork · 10/12/2021 09:24

@Whatwouldscullydo

What's to understand. Everyone has the right to decide what they do with their bodies.

But only as long as it doesn't have a damaging impact on other people's bodies. This is the central point that the "my body my choice" lobby fails to grasp.

This would be fine if it was just your body. But its not. It's the health of the broader community and the impact on society and the healthcare system.

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 09:24

@QueenofKattegat

I see this sort of comment a lot. It’s bizarre. No one is recommending that sort of mask. No one at all. It’s not difficult to have a decent mask on your person to use when needed. Why pretend that’s the case?

Because it is the case.

Don't you go out? Have you ever witnessed somebody remove a sterile mask from a ziplocked bag and put it on with hands that have been sanitised up to the elbow, and then not touch or adjust that mask again once it is on their face? I haven't. Not once. The vast majority of people whip out the mask they have had in their coat pocket/glove box for days/weeks and stick it on because they have to. It gapes at the side, they fiddle with it because it steams up their glasses, it's taken off at the supermarket door and worn the next time they nip in. Which study has found that this makes masks effective?

I would agree.

My kids have to wear masks all day at school. There isn't an endless supply of masks and I can guarantee almost all will wear the same one all day, taking it off at lunch and putting it back on.

I also see it at work. People put it on to move around the office, then take it off and put it on their desk, until next time they need to move around.

HereComesSpringAgain · 10/12/2021 09:22

@Sparklingbrook

I do wonder about people standing observing people and their mask wearing. Long enough to notice it’s ‘damp’ and ‘grubby’, and that the masks always live in the bottom of pockets and handbags. Plus the wearer never washes their hands. That’s quite the study Grin

I take stuff posted on the CV Topic with a huge pinch of salt on the whole. There are posters with agendas and some love a bit of scaremongering.

I wonder if it’s time for some sub sections? A Coronavirus AIBU maybe?

Bit of 'door marshalling' comes with the job

Standing at the door welcoming customers, offering ( new clean ) masks, reminding them of new rules etc..... you know, being a responsible company

So why wonder about people stood observing when it's part of the job.

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/12/2021 09:21

Those of us working closely with the public witness this poor behaviour every time

Ha I work in retail. Just there days ago a customer entered with theor mask across ther forehead. Fiddled with throught theor vist Pulled up pulled down etc

We also have a toilet. I can tell you now that none of the customers are ever in in long enough to have peed and washed their hands. The hand dryer gets used one in 5 visits maybe ( we can hear it) I then have to take money from dry hands...

Even if their mask was sterile ut won't be for long.

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 09:20

@FOJN

So it censorship you are after. That's far more dangerous than people discussing different views on covid.

I'd go further and describe it as rabid authoritarianism and it's more terrifying than misinformed or poorly informed opinions on vaccines or masks could ever be.

I agree.

I really worry about the damage covid has caused - and I'm not only talking about the physical aspect of getting the virus. Society has been damaged. People now think it's perfectly acceptable to openly judge others. Whether it was meeting friends, or going out for longer than an hour, buying "non essential" things, or getting vaccinated or wearing masks etc. and they think their judgement means something.

HereComesSpringAgain · 10/12/2021 09:17

Exactly!!

Those of us working closely with the public witness this poor behaviour every time

Can't admit to being a saint about masks myself though. ... do we all honestly thoroughly wash our hands before putting one on/off? Sanitise? Not touch our mask/face at all whilst wearing one?

Bet we don't but someone will come along in a minute and say they do I'm sure...

Sparklingbrook · 10/12/2021 09:17

I do wonder about people standing observing people and their mask wearing. Long enough to notice it’s ‘damp’ and ‘grubby’, and that the masks always live in the bottom of pockets and handbags. Plus the wearer never washes their hands. That’s quite the study Grin

I take stuff posted on the CV Topic with a huge pinch of salt on the whole. There are posters with agendas and some love a bit of scaremongering.

I wonder if it’s time for some sub sections? A Coronavirus AIBU maybe?

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 09:17

@visitingagain

Hi *@tigger1001* masks do work though, so why do you think your opinion that they don't needs to be expressed? What purpose does that serve?
Where did I express my opinion?

I'm in Scotland so no break in mask wearing here. But question for you. How come until now, (haven't checked for a couple of weeks) englands rate per 100k was the lowest in the uk, despite no mask mandate at the time? Certainly here masks have been required since they were introduced, and we also have since October covid passports for some events. Yet we had a higher level of covid.

People have different opinions. Many shaped by their own experiences. You don't get to say that their opinions are invalid.

Why are you scared of debate?

QueenofKattegat · 10/12/2021 09:09

I see this sort of comment a lot. It’s bizarre. No one is recommending that sort of mask. No one at all. It’s not difficult to have a decent mask on your person to use when needed.
Why pretend that’s the case?

Because it is the case.

Don't you go out? Have you ever witnessed somebody remove a sterile mask from a ziplocked bag and put it on with hands that have been sanitised up to the elbow, and then not touch or adjust that mask again once it is on their face? I haven't. Not once. The vast majority of people whip out the mask they have had in their coat pocket/glove box for days/weeks and stick it on because they have to. It gapes at the side, they fiddle with it because it steams up their glasses, it's taken off at the supermarket door and worn the next time they nip in. Which study has found that this makes masks effective?

Mouseonmychair · 10/12/2021 09:08

@ErrolTheDragon

I think MNHQs view is generally that misinformation usually gets robustly rebutted, which may be preferable to 'censorship' both in terms of getting correct info out there and also not pandering to antivax/conspiracy theorists persecution complexes.
It's the inconsistency that is the problem. You never hear that argument allowed to stand with posts that touch a Mumsnet sensitive area that they obviously focus on moderating. You can make a sweeping generalisations about men no issues, same comment about women "not in the spirit" likewise on race. I would just like consistency.
FOJN · 10/12/2021 09:07

So it censorship you are after. That's far more dangerous than people discussing different views on covid.

I'd go further and describe it as rabid authoritarianism and it's more terrifying than misinformed or poorly informed opinions on vaccines or masks could ever be.

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/12/2021 09:06

I don’t think your statement makes you stupid or a rabid antivaxxer but it is worryingly factually incorrect. If people like you don’t understand these basic principles then we have a problem

What's to understand. Everyone has the right to decide what they do with their bodies. That applies to People you dont like doing things you disagree With. See that's the trade off. Your right to a secind opinion or choosing between treatments comes with the price that someone else has the same choices.

Same with opinions.

You can tie yourself up in knots trying to prove everyone right or wrong but ultimately it's their choice to make.

daisydoh · 10/12/2021 09:03

I agree OP. And then any thread about for instance race can go up like a puff of smoke.

It's wrong.

inloveagain2022 · 10/12/2021 09:03

@MrsBerthaRochester

Im not having the vaccine. (Blows huge raspberry and runs away)
🤣
visitingagain · 10/12/2021 09:02

Hi @tigger1001 masks do work though, so why do you think your opinion that they don't needs to be expressed? What purpose does that serve?

OP posts:
MrsBerthaRochester · 10/12/2021 09:01

Im not having the vaccine. (Blows huge raspberry and runs away)

visitingagain · 10/12/2021 09:01

I'm sorry you don't like being called anti vax @Whatwouldscullydo but vaccine hesitancy is just a posh word for it, you either get a vaccine or you don't. No one was ever promised by medics that we wouldn't need boosters ( as we do for flu) unless you got all your information from the Fail and believed in freedom day.
Everyone is entitled to an opinion, yes - that's an opinion about your own feelings. Do you think everyone should be entitled to express those opinions as if they were facts?

OP posts:
tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 08:59

@visitingagain

I don't have a problem with different opinions but I do have a problem with misinformation. The only different opinion you can have on vaccines and masks is " I don't like them" and anything else you want to say about them is misinformation. Funnily enough a whole lot of posters now turn up to censor me for being censorious
The only different opinion on vaccines is "you dont like them"? Really?? There are lots of different, valid, opinions on vaccines. And mask wearing can be so much more complex than " don't like them".

So it censorship you are after. That's far more dangerous than people discussing different views on covid.

Maybe there would be far less threads if people accepted that other opinions are allowed.

Derbee · 10/12/2021 08:59

Totally agree. I was told the other day by some nutter that the vaccine isn’t even a vaccine, and we’re all sheep.

Reported to mumsnet, and they’ve allowed the comment to remain. So everyone can see that said idiot has “done their research” and “the so called vaccine isn’t even a vaccine”

It’s shocking on here a lot of the time