Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that there is a huge amount of anti vax threads allowed on mumsnet?

310 replies

visitingagain · 09/12/2021 16:07

I fully expect this to be taken down but I am getting completely fed up with the number of anti vax and anti mask threads on mumsnet at the moment. People should be allowed to express views but some of the misinformation is shocking.

OP posts:
CaliforniaDrumming · 10/12/2021 17:00

A thing I have seen posted again and again is vaxxed people are the same as unvaxxed, and just as likely to transmit. No. Yet it is posted on every thread.

It frustrates me that because the vaccine is not 100% effective, people think it is as good as ineffective.

samyeagar · 10/12/2021 16:51

@LakieLady

Anti-vaxxers drive me mad. If they'd been around in 1800, we'd still have people dying of smallpox. Not to mention disabled by polio, dead from measles and damaged by rubella during pregnancy.
They were. In spades.
LethargicActress · 10/12/2021 16:26

@visitingagain

I'm sorry you don't like being called anti vax *@Whatwouldscullydo* but vaccine hesitancy is just a posh word for it, you either get a vaccine or you don't. No one was ever promised by medics that we wouldn't need boosters ( as we do for flu) unless you got all your information from the Fail and believed in freedom day. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, yes - that's an opinion about your own feelings. Do you think everyone should be entitled to express those opinions as if they were facts?
Actually, we were told that two vaccines would mean we are fully vaccinated and have as much protection as possible. I’ve barely listened to any news about it (including in the ‘fail’) because I have actively avoided it, but I did watch most of the Downing Street press conferences and we were very much given the impression that two vaccines would give us all the protection we need.

True that the possibility of boosters was never ruled out, but this isn’t a different vaccine with a different target like the flu vaccine that changes every year. It’s the same one that were being expected to take, for the third time in the same year. It is not at all comparable to the flu vaccine for that reason.

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 16:14

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

It’s terrifying how many people on this post think their opinion is right, that censorship is ok, that statistics and information can’t differ from different sources (and be legitimate and verified yet still opposing).

I’m vaccinated and I think that’s the right thing to do but key word being “THINK”. It’s fine for people to think otherwise. It’s fine for people to quote things which are discredited or not verified - someone else can come and explain why it’s not correct: that’s the point of a discussion forum ffs.

Agreed.

I listened to Nicola sturgeons announcement today and she was using statistics in a less than fully disclosed way to back up what she was saying. I can't stand it.

I can read the numbers, and while she wasn't incorrect in what she said, she didn't go on to explain other aspects of the numbers which were important to understand the whole picture rather than using them to make her point.

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 16:10

The problem you have op with the stance of "we are past debating" is that the advise changes on a regular basis. The science is ever evolving. That's why it's important to allow discussion on covid measures including vaccination.

The changes on timescales on vaccines for the under 18's for example didn't come with a big fanfare. I read it on here. If there wasn't conversations surrounding whether people felt comfortable vaccinating their teens and if people felt it was necessary if their teen had covid then than vital information may have gone unnoticed.

Vaccinations in particular should be informed consent. That can only be achieved if both pros and cons are discussed, without one side telling the other that they are stupid.

People should be able to discuss their fears and concerns without being shut down.

The minute you say that the conversation shouldn't happen you lose the argument.

visitingagain · 10/12/2021 15:44

@TheScenicWay I would quite like my life expectancy back, before you suggest this disease has a low death rate

OP posts:
visitingagain · 10/12/2021 15:42

@Justheretoaskaquestion91 people don't just come on innocently to ask though, unless they've been living in caves there's plenty of information out there so why come on mumsnet to ask " does anyone find masks make their eyes turn stripy ? " or " I'm not an anti vaxxer but does anyone find that the site where they microchipped me attracts metal objects?"

OP posts:
TheScenicWay · 10/12/2021 15:41

“I can't think this would be the same for smallpox, Ebola or any kind of horrible fever. Its such a weird phenomenon.”

Isn’t this the point though? If it was a disease with a high death rate then people would take more measures.
We can see this mild for the majority of people so people think of it differently.
We have the freedom (or should have) to make a personal risk assessment. Especially if already recovered from Covid.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 10/12/2021 15:34

It’s terrifying how many people on this post think their opinion is right, that censorship is ok, that statistics and information can’t differ from different sources (and be legitimate and verified yet still opposing).

I’m vaccinated and I think that’s the right thing to do but key word being “THINK”. It’s fine for people to think otherwise. It’s fine for people to quote things which are discredited or not verified - someone else can come and explain why it’s not correct: that’s the point of a discussion forum ffs.

visitingagain · 10/12/2021 15:22

There are at least three topics and terms on Mumsnet that aren't allowed.
And if I mention them here @Sparklingbrook then the thread will get removed.
That's apparently not dictatorship @BrightYellowDaffodil but obviously anyone who thinks there's no debate to be had over vaccines and masks is censorious, blinkered and hard of thinking. Probably would be better off in Korea or China.
It totally amazes me that there are so many people who hate the precautions taken for this particular disease so much that they would argue for all kinds of misinformation, whataboutery and red herrings. On this thread we have already had what about " deaf people" "people with disabilities " and " real side effects".
These are legitimate problems but they don't mean that we should all stop with the mitigations and vaccines now and " have a debate".
I can't think this would be the same for smallpox, Ebola or any kind of horrible fever. Its such a weird phenomenon.

OP posts:
TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 10/12/2021 14:22

There’s misinformation on both sides. Someone posted the other day that if you have the booster you can’t catch or spread covid.

If you’re getting your covid info from mumsnet then you’ve got bigger problems though. 😬

Sparklingbrook · 10/12/2021 14:11

I started off thinking Dr John Campbell was really interesting and informative, I remember him talking about aspirating the needles months ago. Now, I'm not too sure about him.

TheScenicWay · 10/12/2021 14:06

“It's jarring for me to find myself defending the rights of anti vaxxers because I'm very pro vaccine but I think it's more a defence of liberal democratic values. I'm sure China and North Korea have very high rates of vaccine compliance but I wouldn't want to live in either of those places and I think we should avoid emulating them.”

I agree with this too. People have genuine fears that they want to voice.
I listen to Dr John Campbell and he’s been saying for a while that often, poorly delivered vaccines are causing adverse effects and the vaccinators should be aspirating the needles. Isn’t this worth listening to?
If people are anxious, can we not share this advice and get them some reassurance instead of labelling them anti vaxxers?
When we question, listen and discuss we progress.

The only thing in my opinion that should be moderated is hateful speech and incitement to harm or cause physical damage.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 10/12/2021 13:42

It's jarring for me to find myself defending the rights of anti vaxxers because I'm very pro vaccine but I think it's more a defence of liberal democratic values. I'm sure China and North Korea have very high rates of vaccine compliance but I wouldn't want to live in either of those places and I think we should avoid emulating them.

I agree with this entirely. It sometimes sticks in my craw to defend that with which I don't agree , but I defend vociferously someone's right to have that opinion. That, to me, is the more important thing.

FOJN · 10/12/2021 13:36

Frankly their lack of tolerance makes me side more with the anti-vaxxers/vaccine-refusers/vaccine-hesitant and feel even more strongly about defending their right not to be bullied by sanctimonious arseholes.

It's jarring for me to find myself defending the rights of anti vaxxers because I'm very pro vaccine but I think it's more a defence of liberal democratic values. I'm sure China and North Korea have very high rates of vaccine compliance but I wouldn't want to live in either of those places and I think we should avoid emulating them.

110APiccadilly · 10/12/2021 13:27

@visitingagain

I don't have a problem with different opinions but I do have a problem with misinformation. The only different opinion you can have on vaccines and masks is " I don't like them" and anything else you want to say about them is misinformation. Funnily enough a whole lot of posters now turn up to censor me for being censorious
So would it be misinformation, in your view, if someone were to point out masks make it harder for deaf people to communicate? As that's not, "I don't like them?" Am I allowed to point out my personal experience that my very young child doesn't interact normally with people who are wearing a mask?

I'm inclined to say someone is certainly spreading misinformation here...

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/12/2021 13:25

@Tootsey11

Well I'm sick of the threads were if someone is unsure or just doesn't want the vaccines, other posters pile on calling them thick stupid selfish anti vaxxers. Everyone is entitled to an opinion.
Of course they’re entitled to an opinion. But to many people, what they’re not automatically entitled to do, is to endanger other people, not to mention taking up NHS beds when they’re sorely needed for patients awaiting ops for cancer, etc.

Three male neighbours (siblings) of ours, ‘weren’t sure’ about the jabs.
All three ended up in hospital for 2-3 weeks each, and came out very weak, needing sticks to walk very slowly and cautiously,
They’re all ‘sure’ now.

tigger1001 · 10/12/2021 13:25

@BrightYellowDaffodil

I certainly don't think people have a right to have an opinion about whether masks or vaccines are effective.

I too find this a disturbing comment, along with "We are past debating. What is there to debate?"

I'm very pro-vaccine (much as I don't like having them or the side-effects, which people should also be able to talk about without being decried) but I absolutely support anyone's right to a) choose and b) question. I know a few people who are full-on It's Bill Gates Coming To Get Us, which I don't have any respect for (other than it usually coming from quite vulnerable people, so there's no point arguing) and another few who have decided, based on risks and practicalities, that vaccines aren't for them, and I DO respect that. It's not my viewpoint or choice but I respect theirs.

People like the OP cause the very problem they complain of, as their black-and-white thinking, lack of nuance or respect for any view other than their own and their haste to denigrate and mock anyone who opines differently, for whatever reason, just drives people away. Frankly their lack of tolerance makes me side more with the anti-vaxxers/vaccine-refusers/vaccine-hesitant and feel even more strongly about defending their right not to be bullied by sanctimonious arseholes.

Well said
Sparklingbrook · 10/12/2021 13:21

I think the never ending debating of the same old subjects surrounding CV (masks/vaccines/lockdowns and guessing the possibility of one being the ones that spring to mind) drives people away.

Lilifer · 10/12/2021 13:18

@BrightYellowDaffodil

I certainly don't think people have a right to have an opinion about whether masks or vaccines are effective.

I too find this a disturbing comment, along with "We are past debating. What is there to debate?"

I'm very pro-vaccine (much as I don't like having them or the side-effects, which people should also be able to talk about without being decried) but I absolutely support anyone's right to a) choose and b) question. I know a few people who are full-on It's Bill Gates Coming To Get Us, which I don't have any respect for (other than it usually coming from quite vulnerable people, so there's no point arguing) and another few who have decided, based on risks and practicalities, that vaccines aren't for them, and I DO respect that. It's not my viewpoint or choice but I respect theirs.

People like the OP cause the very problem they complain of, as their black-and-white thinking, lack of nuance or respect for any view other than their own and their haste to denigrate and mock anyone who opines differently, for whatever reason, just drives people away. Frankly their lack of tolerance makes me side more with the anti-vaxxers/vaccine-refusers/vaccine-hesitant and feel even more strongly about defending their right not to be bullied by sanctimonious arseholes.

Hear hear 👏🏻👏🏻
BrightYellowDaffodil · 10/12/2021 13:13

I certainly don't think people have a right to have an opinion about whether masks or vaccines are effective.

I too find this a disturbing comment, along with "We are past debating. What is there to debate?"

I'm very pro-vaccine (much as I don't like having them or the side-effects, which people should also be able to talk about without being decried) but I absolutely support anyone's right to a) choose and b) question. I know a few people who are full-on It's Bill Gates Coming To Get Us, which I don't have any respect for (other than it usually coming from quite vulnerable people, so there's no point arguing) and another few who have decided, based on risks and practicalities, that vaccines aren't for them, and I DO respect that. It's not my viewpoint or choice but I respect theirs.

People like the OP cause the very problem they complain of, as their black-and-white thinking, lack of nuance or respect for any view other than their own and their haste to denigrate and mock anyone who opines differently, for whatever reason, just drives people away. Frankly their lack of tolerance makes me side more with the anti-vaxxers/vaccine-refusers/vaccine-hesitant and feel even more strongly about defending their right not to be bullied by sanctimonious arseholes.

Sparklingbrook · 10/12/2021 12:47

That's what confused me, that there's a good few topics that are 'heavily moderated', but assume that meant that when things are posted they get deleted swiftly after they are reported maybe?

I assume that on the CV board where people are stating things as fact, if it's reported MNHQ have to establish exactly how factual it actually is which takes time.

HereComesSpringAgain · 10/12/2021 12:40

Mumsnet have never really moderated the site anyway. Back when it first started out HQ used to post with us

They rely on reports. It's not like other forums where they are over run with 'moderators'

Sparklingbrook · 10/12/2021 12:15

no one complains about them being heavily moderated

I'm not sure which topics they are, are they moderated in a different way in that they are constantly monitored rather than MNHQ have to have it reported?
I do have a lot of topics hidden, but also hide threads as I go from Active without opening them if needs be.

visitingagain · 10/12/2021 12:10

@Sparklingbrook I have tried to avoid but it comes up in my active tab... and the cv topic is absolutely full of misinformation. @TheScenicWay and many others on here suggest we should have a healthy debate about covid and anything else is censorship/ dictatorship etc. There are a good few topics on Mumsnet which are absolute no go areas and no one complains about them being heavily moderated. Why is covid different?

OP posts: