Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that there is a huge amount of anti vax threads allowed on mumsnet?

310 replies

visitingagain · 09/12/2021 16:07

I fully expect this to be taken down but I am getting completely fed up with the number of anti vax and anti mask threads on mumsnet at the moment. People should be allowed to express views but some of the misinformation is shocking.

OP posts:
visitingagain · 11/12/2021 16:33

And also @Notthemessiah I don't support people being physically forced to have vaccines. However as I think I have said before, if you actively choose not to be vaccinated for no medical reason ( including actual mental health) then I see absolutely nothing wrong with your lifestyle being more restricted - having to do more pcr tests, to access certain events or self isolate for longer if you get a positive etc. I'm so pissed off at the amount of doubt spread around vaccines and masks on here, we need to have everyone working together to get out of this situation.

OP posts:
visitingagain · 11/12/2021 16:26

Oh @Notthemessiah I am fed up with being told I am sinister or authoritarian, as @Saucery says if people went round saying that mmr was a terrible thing their comments would be taken down. And a number of other topics are also banned.
@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan you've been on these threads before I think and you have a very tenuous argument against vaccines which even PETA don't support. ( apologies if you are a different extreme vegan) Your point of view is probably not going to change and I think you need to be really upfront about that, not say "sadly I live very quietly" because it's a choice you've made, from a point of view that makes you willing to accept the benefits of my vaccination, your family's vaccination and the wider community's commitment to social cohesion, without contributing. I have a serious problem with this point of view being discussed as a possibility on boards where it might influence more people, because the fewer people who get vaccinated the more possibility there is of even more variants arising.
But also because it's just a bit anti social, and disappointing that someone who feels that ethical living is really important should be so silly.
And this is why I think we need more moderation of the covid topics.

OP posts:
Notthemessiah · 11/12/2021 16:05

[quote visitingagain]@thepeopleversuswork it would be nice to think the anti vax people are poorly educated but sadly that's not my experience. It cuts straight across all levels of society and seems to be connected to personal influences- people they know or admire either in real life or online. Look at Eric Clapton and Van Morrison.
There needs to be a huge bonfire of the covid threads to keep it in check before mumsnet turns into a notorious anti vax haven.[/quote]
I imagine for some it's the association with the sinister and obviously authoritarian point of view you appear to be espousing here OP, telling people what they are and aren't allowed to think or say.

Did it not occur to you that you that you and others like you are having a counter-productive effect on vaccine take-up? That the more you belittle and 'other' anyone with an opinion you don't like, the more they'll resist the message you are supposedly advocating?

Or maybe that's your endgame here. Push more people away from vaccination by being so intolerant about it, so that the only option is then to make it mandatory and you get the proper authoritarian, 'everyone do as they're told' state that you presumably want.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 14:54

Saucery

Unfortunately there’s lots of people who class all unvaccinated people as anti vax as in ‘they’re all people spreading lies, conspiracies and generally talking nonsense.’

I’d rather not be put in the same category as those people, but what can I do? I’m not vaccinated but I live a very quiet life, have worn a mask throughout, limit my contact with people as much as possible, social distance where possible and definitely don’t spread misinformation it try to influence others decisions. The people talking nonsense, denying science and harassing others piss people like me off too.

Saucery · 11/12/2021 14:42

Tis to me, antivaxxers are the ones who try to persuade others they shouldn’t be vaccinated. Or wear masks or social distance either, in the vast majority of cases.
I’m sure your reason is valid. In fact “because I don’t want to” is valid, because as much as I would love to see a population vaccination rate in the 97% + range, I can’t get behind mandatory vaccinations. I think “I don’t want to” is the wrong decision but it’s not my decision. Just don’t try and back it up with utter nonsense some quack off the Internet has come up with.

I’m pretty sure that anyone who went round MN posting that Wakefield was right and the MMR gives children autism would be deleted quick sharp and rightly so. Well, this is a huge public health crisis we’re in right now and we can’t afford to let fake science get a hold of the people who might still be undecided about Covid vaccination.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 14:19

It made an otherwise boring wait entertaining and this is how I will now picture all anti vax posters

The thing is, all unvaccinated people seem to be called anti vaxers. But the unvaccinated people I know, including me, wouldn’t act like that. They wouldn’t spread misinformation or harass others about their decisions. They don’t think the vaccine doesn’t work, they just don’t want or can’t have the vaccine for a variety of reasons.

thepeopleversuswork · 11/12/2021 14:12

@visitingagain

There is a small but genuinely scary minority of clever but paranoid people who actually have done frightening amounts of research (always the wrong kind, like reading the rantings of Michael Yeadon etc). I slightly know someone who works in the pharmaceutical industry and posts really scary shit online, which I find staggering, not least because I'm amazed he hasn't lost his job. I think nine times out of ten these people are either a) congenital show-offs who like to be contrary and "counterculture" or b) paranoid or with mental health problems and pour all their attention into this stuff.

But the vast majority of the posts on here are from people who are genuinely worried but clearly not very well educated. They're either "I've done my research" (on the internet) or "my body my choice" (also from the internet) or "my second cousin twice removed had an adverse reaction" (paranoid anecdata). They are all people with a poor grasp of science and risk.

visitingagain · 11/12/2021 14:05

@thepeopleversuswork it would be nice to think the anti vax people are poorly educated but sadly that's not my experience. It cuts straight across all levels of society and seems to be connected to personal influences- people they know or admire either in real life or online. Look at Eric Clapton and Van Morrison.
There needs to be a huge bonfire of the covid threads to keep it in check before mumsnet turns into a notorious anti vax haven.

OP posts:
Sugarplumfairy65 · 11/12/2021 14:04

@Tootsey11

Well I'm sick of the threads were if someone is unsure or just doesn't want the vaccines, other posters pile on calling them thick stupid selfish anti vaxxers. Everyone is entitled to an opinion.
Until they start spouting untrue information
thepeopleversuswork · 11/12/2021 13:54

I'm also surprised so many threads are left up. Before covid, many anti vaxx threads were swiftly deleted for misinformation (eg the classic mmr causes autism argument). I can only imagine that MN is receiving massive amounts of traffic and need the ad revenue with pre-xmas high CPMs.

The problem with this approach during COVID is that antivaxx/vaccine hesitant people tend to be a) poorly-educated and b) with paranoid or anxious tendencies anyway. If MN took to deleting threads and comments or flagging them as inaccurate it would just fuel the general suspicion that they are trying to stifle us, keep us quiet, treat us like sheep etc. It didn't go well for Facebook when they started flagging posts as inaccurate.

I actually think MN largely has the right approach to this: it allows people ranging from the vaccine-anxious out to the full tin-foil hat brigade to put their views out there and by and large the more sensible views prevail.

Given that reaching vaccine-hesitant people is such a huge priority at the moment I don't think deleting threads expressing concern about vaccinations is the right way to go.

GoldenOldBoy · 11/12/2021 13:44

The right to chat shit is in the English Bill of Rights. Mumsnet is not an academic website with a responsibility to only post factual information. There's even a disclaimer at the top of each thread.

If someone is going to make a big life decision, such as getting vaccinated, from reading a post on mumsnet then they are just as likely to be swayed by Facebook, Tiktok or twitter. Censoring websites to only repeat information that the government/law makers deem to be true is not a road we want to go down. I enjoy hearing all the different opinions and theories, but that doesn't mean I'm going to believe every one of them.

FestiveMelts · 11/12/2021 13:38

@User20393442

The weird thing is in real life I barely know any anti-vaxxers, maybe 5 out of 60+ friends & acquaintances (and those are friends of friends who I don't have any direct contact to). However MN is crawling with tin-foil hat types who think they know "the truth" and are "horrified" at totally banal things that are logical measures in a pandemic. If you read any covid thread you'd assume 30-40% of the population are anti-vaxx, anti-mask etc.

I'm also surprised so many threads are left up. Before covid, many anti vaxx threads were swiftly deleted for misinformation (eg the classic mmr causes autism argument). I can only imagine that MN is receiving massive amounts of traffic and need the ad revenue with pre-xmas high CPMs.

Either that, or people DO have concerns/objections but daren't speak up in RL.

Saucery · 11/12/2021 13:29

In her mind, the vaccine is still worse. She’s otherwise a lovely person, but total blind spot about the way vaccines work and how any side effects are much more manageable and treatable than Covid side effects. Her GP told her she’d be better off with the vaccination but still some nut job on the Internet knows better as far as she’s concerned and her family nearly lost her because of it Sad

Derbee · 11/12/2021 13:25

*doesn’t get through to these people

Derbee · 11/12/2021 13:24

@Saucery

Weirdly, I know 3 at work. All have ‘done their own research’ Hmm. One has just spent 2 months off and a couple of weeks in hospital. That’s where misinformation and bad research gets you, I suppose. They are also very mask averse and of the Let It Rip persuasion. There might be others, I don’t know, because they don’t wang on about it constantly.
It’s so disturbing that even hospitalisation doors to get through to these people. I know a doctor working in the US who has patients in ICU who don’t believe him when he tells them they have Covid. How the hell he and his colleagues keep on treating those patients with respect is beyond me.
WeAllHaveWings · 11/12/2021 13:21

It’s basically what the anti-vaxx posters on here do anyway grin I almost admire the dedication of someone doing it in rl and risking a punch in the face.

They reminded me of the 'end of the world is nigh' highstreet preachers, I havent seen one of them for years. Think they were more at risk of a pity overdose than a punch.

Saucery · 11/12/2021 13:15

Weirdly, I know 3 at work. All have ‘done their own research’ Hmm. One has just spent 2 months off and a couple of weeks in hospital. That’s where misinformation and bad research gets you, I suppose. They are also very mask averse and of the Let It Rip persuasion.
There might be others, I don’t know, because they don’t wang on about it constantly.

User20393442 · 11/12/2021 13:08

The weird thing is in real life I barely know any anti-vaxxers, maybe 5 out of 60+ friends & acquaintances (and those are friends of friends who I don't have any direct contact to). However MN is crawling with tin-foil hat types who think they know "the truth" and are "horrified" at totally banal things that are logical measures in a pandemic. If you read any covid thread you'd assume 30-40% of the population are anti-vaxx, anti-mask etc.

I'm also surprised so many threads are left up. Before covid, many anti vaxx threads were swiftly deleted for misinformation (eg the classic mmr causes autism argument). I can only imagine that MN is receiving massive amounts of traffic and need the ad revenue with pre-xmas high CPMs.

Saucery · 11/12/2021 12:56

@WeAllHaveWings

Met my first real life anti vaxer this morning.

They were walking up and down the queue while I was waiting for my booster jab pointing and swearing at everyone and telling us we were all sheep and why vaccines didnt work 🤦🏻‍♀️

It made an otherwise boring wait entertaining and this is how I will now picture all anti vax posters 🤣

It’s basically what the anti-vaxx posters on here do anyway Grin I almost admire the dedication of someone doing it in rl and risking a punch in the face.
WeAllHaveWings · 11/12/2021 12:50

Met my first real life anti vaxer this morning.

They were walking up and down the queue while I was waiting for my booster jab pointing and swearing at everyone and telling us we were all sheep and why vaccines didnt work 🤦🏻‍♀️

It made an otherwise boring wait entertaining and this is how I will now picture all anti vax posters 🤣

samyeagar · 10/12/2021 20:20

Well, given that words have no meaning any more as evidenced by a bunch of people not wearing masks is "horrifying", then what would an emaciated third world village be considered?

Sure, go ahead and throw all the hyperbole at me, call me what ever names you want. I fully embrace them...and will carry on about my own business.

PAFMO · 10/12/2021 17:58

@CaliforniaDrumming

A thing I have seen posted again and again is vaxxed people are the same as unvaxxed, and just as likely to transmit. No. Yet it is posted on every thread.

It frustrates me that because the vaccine is not 100% effective, people think it is as good as ineffective.

Oh they love that one. It's the gold standard cherry pick. Yes, the vaccinated can of course pass on Covid as much as the unvaccinated. BUT ONLY IF THEY'VE GOT THE FUCKING THING TO PASS ON IN THE FIRST PLACE which is between 65 and 95% less likely.
visitingagain · 10/12/2021 17:19

That's great news @FOJN but don't worry someone will be along I'm a minute to tell you it's not the full picture!

OP posts:
FOJN · 10/12/2021 17:13

These are legitimate problems but they don't mean that we should all stop with the mitigations and vaccines now and " have a debate".

Its a good job then that most people are taking vaccines and wearing masks.
As of today 89% of people have had their first vaccine, 81.2% have had a second vaccine and already 38.6% of people have had a booster. The majority of people where I live are wearing masks, many continued to do so in the supermarket even when the mask mandate was lifted. In my local area I have noticed an increasing number of people wearing masks outdoors.

Whatever you think about people who can't or won't get the vaccine or are undecided it's fairly evident that antivaxx views are not having a huge impact on vaccine uptake. Why are you so bothered when all evidence suggests people are capable of making up their own minds and taking action to protect themselves and others.

samyeagar · 10/12/2021 17:08

@CaliforniaDrumming

A thing I have seen posted again and again is vaxxed people are the same as unvaxxed, and just as likely to transmit. No. Yet it is posted on every thread.

It frustrates me that because the vaccine is not 100% effective, people think it is as good as ineffective.

The "just as likely to transmit" is one that gets me as well. However, things are just too socially and politically polarized black and white.

The accurate way of presenting it would be...Vaccinated are less likely to transmit, but less likely does not mean unlikely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread