Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that there is a huge amount of anti vax threads allowed on mumsnet?

310 replies

visitingagain · 09/12/2021 16:07

I fully expect this to be taken down but I am getting completely fed up with the number of anti vax and anti mask threads on mumsnet at the moment. People should be allowed to express views but some of the misinformation is shocking.

OP posts:
Notthemessiah · 11/12/2021 23:52

Are you ten? It is perfectly reasonable to ask someone who is pushing an agenda or repeating misinformation or clearly hostile to vaccines and actual data that displeases them (whether that hostility is overt or veiled) if they have been vaccinated. It is interesting to me that most such posters angrily refuse to answer this question.

Why is it reasonable? Of course most people who are likely to be critical of the pressure put on the unvaccinated are themselves likely to be unvaccinated. Why do you need to know that and how exactly do you think it invalidates their argument?

'You would say that, you're unvaccinated' - well duh.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 23:44

milkyaqua

I haven’t seen anything from that poster that was pushing an anti vax agenda or any misinformation from them. Yet they were asked why they weren’t vaccinated. Their answer was apparently not good enough so a response of ‘so not a medical’ with a smily face was given. It was clearly sarcastic.

I just don’t know why people think they can ask people medical info. It’s weird.

Notthemessiah · 11/12/2021 23:42

So what was the reason for your post with the smiley face then? It was clear already that the poster wasn't vaccinated for any medical reason, so why did you feel the need to state it yourself for everyone to see unless as a, not so subtle, dig? Maybe we have indeed misinterpreted you though, so please set us straight.

Also implying thatTistheseason is posting with 'radically escalated hostility' is just silly. No-one here is posting with any hostility, just the usual forthright discussion you get on this kind of topic on mumsnet or most chat forums.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 23:34

You’re going to keep on insisting that your emoji and comment were perfectly innocent. Based on your comments here and other threads, o choose not to believe you. Using emojis to be sarcastic is also a well established behaviour.

I don’t like to see people questioned about their medical information. It’s rude. If the posted wanted you to know the reason, they would have told you. They said something like personal choice but this wasn’t good enough for you. So you continued. That’s unpleasant so I will point that out as that is what I don’t like to see.

I’ve already said I encourage my children to be vaccinated and my partner has had 2 vaccinations and I will he will be having his booster this week. I will be driving him as he felt unwell within 30 minutes of his last vaccine. But yes, I’m anti vax and have issues with vaccinated people. 🙄

I have no interest in talking about the ethics of the vaccine, why would I. It works, there’s not much else to say except people must be free to make the decision whether to have it or not.

My only hostility is to those who don’t respect people’s boundaries and choices on this matter, both vaccinated and unvaccinated.

milkyaqua · 11/12/2021 23:33

You asked, you had no right to. Why do you feel you have that right.

Are you ten? It is perfectly reasonable to ask someone who is pushing an agenda or repeating misinformation or clearly hostile to vaccines and actual data that displeases them (whether that hostility is overt or veiled) if they have been vaccinated. It is interesting to me that most such posters angrily refuse to answer this question. It is not an offensive question, really. I think your aggression, baiting, and snideness on this thread is very offensive, however.

Innocenta · 11/12/2021 23:21

Obviously you're allowed to think any given post is rude, TisTheSeason, it's not something anyone can stop you from thinking!

But the fact remains that using an emoji to signal tone is a normative, well-established online behaviour. It is not considered objectively rude or offensive. I didn't use any slurs, insulting language, allcaps, or similar verbal or formatting choices that would have unavoidably conveyed negativity - the reason for that is that I was, at that time, doubtful and curious, but not feeling negatively towards the poster! So it just seems a bit silly for you to keep insisting you know what was in my mind better than I do.

The impression it gives, however, is that you cannot stand to see anyone challenged if they express a viewpoint that accords with your own (i.e. they are not vaccinated). There are some good reasons not to get vaccinated! They are rare, but they exist. I'm also always happy to talk about the ethics of a situation like this. But time and again it is those coming from an anti-vaxxer standpoint who meet quite calm and civil questions with radically escalated hostility.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 23:15

Innocenta

I don’t care if you use emojis or not. But I don’t believe for a second that your ‘so it’s not for a medical reason’ followed by a Smile was anything other than rude and sarcastic.

If you feel it’s aggressive for me to point out you have boundary issues when you keep asking people’s vaccination status and reasons, not just on this thread, then that’s your issue. It is overstepping boundaries. It is none of your business. You should learn boundaries or people will point this out to you.

Saying that I need to be moderated for anti vax views? What anti vax views? I’m unvaccinated but have given no reason and have spread zero information at all. I have encouraged my kids to be vaccinated and although they don’t want to be, I continue to encourage them to change their mind. My partner has his booster this week.

lightisnotwhite · 11/12/2021 23:11

I think it needs an actual statistic. Someone should count the pro and anti posts.

I don’t see any evidence of anti vaccine in mumsnet. If anything it appears to be a panic in the other direction. The few anti vaccine posts appear to be from people doing it for their own reasons ( had Covid already, don’t want side effects from the jab) rather than conspiracy theories.
You see what you want to see.

Innocenta · 11/12/2021 23:05

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

You decided I am aggressive for saying you had issues with boundaries. I’m just stating what is clear to see. And you continue to pretend that your smily face wasn’t sarcasm after what you had written. 🤯

I’m not vaccinated, no, but I couldn’t care less what others do. You will find no misinformation in my posts so there is literally nothing to challenge me on.
And now you’re playing some sort of victim. 🙄

Your responses, overall, have been bizarrely disproportionate - and, yes, aggressive.

I'm perfectly happy not to use emojis to you if it's what you prefer (or I'll at least do my best to remember). But by definition, you can't possibly know my intent when writing earlier messages: it seems absolutely strange to insist that an emoji which I appended to a post for a normal reason must actually be there for some secret, hidden one...

DroopyClematis · 11/12/2021 23:00

Yes, people should be allowed their views.
The problem is that anti-vaxxers are kicking off spectacularly, not just here but on other media platforms.

The fact that nearly everyone was vaccinated against smallpox meant that the disease has been eradicated and no one needs the vaccine for it.

The six million who have refused / not had the vaccine for Covid ( excluding non-eligible) means that the virus will continue and continue to mutate.

This debate will rage forever.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 22:58

You decided I am aggressive for saying you had issues with boundaries. I’m just stating what is clear to see. And you continue to pretend that your smily face wasn’t sarcasm after what you had written. 🤯

I’m not vaccinated, no, but I couldn’t care less what others do. You will find no misinformation in my posts so there is literally nothing to challenge me on.
And now you’re playing some sort of victim. 🙄

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 22:53

👍

SmileSmileSmileSmileSmile

tigger1001 · 11/12/2021 22:53

[quote Innocenta]@tigger1001 I think that telling somebody she is judgmental and censorious constitutes a personal attack. Posts by pro-vaccine contributors have been deleted by MNHQ for far less inflammatory wordings. [/quote]
How is it?

She has been judgemental. She has made judgements on me - by reading things in my posts that weren't there. And when questioned on it ignores it.

She has tried to stop discussion - that's the point of the thread. She thinks there isn't a debate needed.

Not a personal attack.

Innocenta · 11/12/2021 22:52

@visitingagain This exchange is a rather good example, actually - notice how brief and civil my messages are, containing nothing unusual or notably offensive... And then the degree of aggression that I'm receiving from TisTheSeason, completely mismatched to the actual situation. If I had, in fact, been harassing the person to whom that question was originally put, it might at least make sense... But the posts are right there. A simple question and a one-line follow-up. Nothing negative to the poster, no insult, no name-calling.

Yet MNHQ is not moderating effectively to limit the constant, escalating aggression that anti-vaxxers display towards anyone who challenges them.

tigger1001 · 11/12/2021 22:49

@visitingagain

I don't think I need to say anything more on this thread, but why don't you head over here *@Notthemessiah* *@tigger1001* If you dare to question science you are labelled uneducated? www.mumsnet.com/Talk/coronavirus/4423877-If-you-dare-to-question-science-you-are-labelled-uneducated And have a look at the kind of thing I mean. Fortunately the OP is getting absolutely slated by actual scientists, a bit unkind but she did start the thread. Why don't some of the posters here start telling the scientists they are being censorious and authoritarian.
Can you not see that you are deliberately trying to censor people?

You are the one who asked what is there to debate.

You are the one who wanted a separate area to post queries re reactions and side effects to the vaccine. Which is pretty ironic as there is a separate area to post about covid topics which you ignored.

You seem to be suggesting you know my views on this subject - you have made assumptions when quoting me a few times. You do not. I just disagree with your attempts to stop people 1) expressing their views and 2) discussing side effects and worries about them.

Scientists won't want that discussion stopped. The nature of science is continual questions. A scientist doesn't stop researching just because they think they found a solution. They carry on to see if it can be bettered. Other scientists challenge their work.

The reason some of the side effects are known about is as a result of discussion. No one should be seeking to stop that. It just makes them look foolish to suggest it.

Open discussion is what leads to informed consent. Which is, and should always be the gold standard of medical care.

Innocenta · 11/12/2021 22:48

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

But I am not "pressing". The poster has no obligation to reply to me (and indeed had not done so). I am following up with you because of your unreasonable hostility and aggressive tone.

You asked, you had no right to. Why do you feel you have that right. You have issues with boundaries. They answered, it wasn’t a good enough answer for you so you made a sarcastic/rude/dismissive comment back with a smily face. You’re now trying to justify it as friendly. It wasn’t friendly at all. You’ve done this before to people also.

‘Follow up’ with me all you like. I’m not easily intimidated. SmileSmileSmileSmileSmileSmile

If you struggle with boundaries, try to learn. Asking people for their medical information, vaccination status and reasons is overstepping. Smily faces don’t help. SmileSmileSmileSmileSmile

I'm not trying to intimidate you. You're reading in something that isn't there, and you are the only one attacking, here.

Again, it is normal online behaviour to use an emoji to signal tone.

Asking someone a question about the topic of the thread is a reasonable thing to do. People in all the Covid vaccine threads are routinely talking about their vaccine choices. Nobody has to answer (which I fully support).

changeyourname11111 · 11/12/2021 22:43

@GabriellaMontez

The vaccine carries a mortality risk.

There remains plenty of unknowns, dissenting experts and the 'science' continues to evolve.

To me, anyone who says 'There aren't two sides' is just as much of a fanatic as some of the people you criticise.

^ this
TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 22:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Innocenta · 11/12/2021 22:35

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

Do you think it's polite to tell someone in an aggressive tone that they have "issues with boundaries"? I don't find that to be polite, personally.

And you don’t get to have people’s medical information no matter how much you keep pressing for it, pretending it’s all friendly with a smily face.

You clearly do struggle with boundaries and I’m politely pointing that out. SmileSmileSmileSmile

But I am not "pressing". The poster has no obligation to reply to me (and indeed had not done so). I am following up with you because of your unreasonable hostility and aggressive tone.
visitingagain · 11/12/2021 22:34

I don't think I need to say anything more on this thread, but why don't you head over here @Notthemessiah @tigger1001
If you dare to question science you are labelled uneducated? www.mumsnet.com/Talk/coronavirus/4423877-If-you-dare-to-question-science-you-are-labelled-uneducated
And have a look at the kind of thing I mean. Fortunately the OP is getting absolutely slated by actual scientists, a bit unkind but she did start the thread. Why don't some of the posters here start telling the scientists they are being censorious and authoritarian.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 11/12/2021 22:34

@Notthemessiah

This is a message board. I asked another poster a question; they answered; I asked a follow-up question. Since the topic is a heated one, I used a smiling emoji to indicate tone, i.e. to signal that I intended my message to be taken in a discursive way, rather than as an attack.

You do realise that putting a smiley after making a rude or dismissive comment doesn't make the comment any less rude or dismissive?

Using emojis is a normal way to signal tone online. If you prefer I don't use them to you, I won't - that's fine by me.
TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 11/12/2021 22:30

Do you think it's polite to tell someone in an aggressive tone that they have "issues with boundaries"? I don't find that to be polite, personally.

And you don’t get to have people’s medical information no matter how much you keep pressing for it, pretending it’s all friendly with a smily face.

You clearly do struggle with boundaries and I’m politely pointing that out. SmileSmileSmileSmile

Notthemessiah · 11/12/2021 22:28

This is a message board. I asked another poster a question; they answered; I asked a follow-up question. Since the topic is a heated one, I used a smiling emoji to indicate tone, i.e. to signal that I intended my message to be taken in a discursive way, rather than as an attack.

You do realise that putting a smiley after making a rude or dismissive comment doesn't make the comment any less rude or dismissive?

Lovenahla · 11/12/2021 22:22
Swipe left for the next trending thread