Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that there is a huge amount of anti vax threads allowed on mumsnet?

310 replies

visitingagain · 09/12/2021 16:07

I fully expect this to be taken down but I am getting completely fed up with the number of anti vax and anti mask threads on mumsnet at the moment. People should be allowed to express views but some of the misinformation is shocking.

OP posts:
LookslovelyinSpringtime · 12/12/2021 08:26

@ShinyHappyPoster

You seem poorly read and ill informed. MN isn't about censoring opinions or debate. It's a discussion and advice forum. If there's no discussion or debate, it wouldn't exist. I wonder if trying to rile people up against particular sections of society counts as a hate incident. I guess it could if the targeting correlates against a protected characteristic eg disability, pregnancy or belief. It's frightening to see such blatant anti-intellectualism.
Totally agree.
lightisnotwhite · 12/12/2021 08:24

The problem with this approach during COVID is that antivaxx/vaccine hesitant people tend to be a) poorly-educated and b) with paranoid or anxious tendencies anyway.

Well that’s a theory but unfortunately it’s bollocks. The unvaccinated I know have chosen not to get the jab as they’ve a) had Covid or b) worried about side effects ( ie self employed and don’t take days off).

They are the opposite of paranoid and anxious. They are optimist and laid back and assume the worst won’t happen to them.

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 08:23

@Saucery

MNHQ is not doing enough to support a pro-science perspective in this respect.

According to MNHQ in a Report reply to me, they are not epidemiologists and will therefore not delete posts stating that the vaccine kills an unspecified number of people. So, I’ve sort of given up now tbh. If they want the fact that unsubstantiated claims like that could lead to someone not having the vaccine, putting themselves and others in danger, then so be it 🤷‍♀️
Their circus, their antivaxx monkeys.

Truly disturbing that they are intentionally platforming anti-vaxxers and targeting pro-vaccine posters for post deletion.
Saucery · 12/12/2021 08:16

MNHQ is not doing enough to support a pro-science perspective in this respect.

According to MNHQ in a Report reply to me, they are not epidemiologists and will therefore not delete posts stating that the vaccine kills an unspecified number of people. So, I’ve sort of given up now tbh. If they want the fact that unsubstantiated claims like that could lead to someone not having the vaccine, putting themselves and others in danger, then so be it 🤷‍♀️
Their circus, their antivaxx monkeys.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 07:55

Can someone point me to the posts that still remain that are anti vax please. And have you reported them?

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 07:51

It was not sarcastic. You are not psychic.

It was sarcastic and rude imo. You say it wasn’t. There’s nothing else to say on this.

Newrumpus · 12/12/2021 07:44

@visitingagain

But *@Powerpotpie*, there aren't two reasonable sides to the anti vax debate. There is the side that presents all the scientific facts eg. Get a vaccine because it's our best and only way to try and reduce deaths from covid and other excess deaths and overwhelming health systems. And there is the other side which includes " it's not fair" "they don't mean me though" " everyone knows only old/ fat/ stupid people will die " and then all the " I'm not against vaccines BUT " threads.
This comment reminds me of the attitudes on here to Brexit: Let’s debate how there is only one valid opinion and how stupid those people who I am unable to convince of that fact are.
Innocenta · 12/12/2021 07:23

I don't know how people can claim there isn't a right or wrong answer in a general sense. There are absolutely people who cannot have the vaccine (but this is extremely rare), and there are - far more often - cases of anxiety and hesitancy which are, in themselves, valid and deserving of sympathy and support. I doubt there is anyone, no matter how staunchly pro-vaccine, who would claim that literally every single person in the UK should have it.

But that still doesn't make it two equally justified and justifiable sides of an argument. It is wrong to engage in Covid denialism and to misinform people about the vaccines. Misleading people about vaccine efficacy and safety leads to avoidable deaths.

MNHQ is not doing enough to support a pro-science perspective in this respect.

RancidOldHag · 12/12/2021 06:46

There isn't a wrong or right answer to being vaccinated

Yet 'lockdown lovers' are routinely mocked on here.

If enough people choose not to vaccinate (and idc the top ups against new variants) then it's going to mean more extensive and long-lasting restrictions. Though I suppose preferring lockdowns as means of control to vaccination, everyone else in society get to carry the consequences of that choice.

That is why I think they are far from evenly weighted issues

ShinyHappyPoster · 12/12/2021 04:42

You seem poorly read and ill informed. MN isn't about censoring opinions or debate. It's a discussion and advice forum. If there's no discussion or debate, it wouldn't exist.
I wonder if trying to rile people up against particular sections of society counts as a hate incident. I guess it could if the targeting correlates against a protected characteristic eg disability, pregnancy or belief.
It's frightening to see such blatant anti-intellectualism.

Tayegete · 12/12/2021 04:21

It’s only on MN that I have heard so many anti-vax opinions expressed. Everyone I know is vaccinated and happy to wear a mask to protect others. I’ve been really shocked by how misinformed people are on here and how little they are willing to put themselves out (let’s face it getting vaccinated and wearing a mask are pretty minor) to help others and get us out of this mess.

Nextlevelnonsense · 12/12/2021 04:04

I listened to an excellent podcast on this topic.
It's on YouTube

Well worth a listen/view because it's a very thorough scientific, but accessible discussion WITHOUT name calling and smugness.
An actual discussion.
Not a person repeatedly stating facts that cannot be disputed.
It actually provides a lot of interesting subject matter.

Search for:
A cautionary message from vaccine advocates (Dr Arditi Bhargava).
I actually watched the whole thing, and it's very interesting.

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 03:12

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

milkyaqua

I haven’t seen anything from that poster that was pushing an anti vax agenda or any misinformation from them. Yet they were asked why they weren’t vaccinated. Their answer was apparently not good enough so a response of ‘so not a medical’ with a smily face was given. It was clearly sarcastic.

I just don’t know why people think they can ask people medical info. It’s weird.

It was not sarcastic. You are not psychic.
Innocenta · 12/12/2021 03:11

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

I'm talking in general

I’m not. This was a specific example of someone overstepping, being rude asking and then being sarcastic at their response to feel what...superior?

But in general, I don’t really think anyone should ask anyone’s vaccination status on here. In real life if someone is vulnerable, I can understand. And I think people should take an LFT before mixing, wear masks and social distance where possible, especially if they’re unvaccinated.

I was not being sarcastic, though.
Innocenta · 12/12/2021 03:10

*posting

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 03:10

@milkyaqua The very fact that MNHQ deleted my innocuous and civil post only illustrates their bias against people who are post from a pro-vaccine perspective. Believe me, I have sent a further informal complaint about the lack of even-handed moderation, and will be following it up with a formal one ASAP.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 01:31

As the posts in question were deleted, it is a little hard to understand the full story. But you have been going off like a frog in a sock ever since.

All the posts are still there apart from one but even that one still exists in my quote.

It seems that when people don’t want to listen, because they’ve been called out for being rude and not respecting boundaries, they accuse posters of being hostile and now you are accusing me of going on too much because I won’t be shut down. 🤷🏻‍♀️

milkyaqua · 12/12/2021 01:24

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

I'm talking in general

I’m not. This was a specific example of someone overstepping, being rude asking and then being sarcastic at their response to feel what...superior?

But in general, I don’t really think anyone should ask anyone’s vaccination status on here. In real life if someone is vulnerable, I can understand. And I think people should take an LFT before mixing, wear masks and social distance where possible, especially if they’re unvaccinated.

As the posts in question were deleted, it is a little hard to understand the full story. But you have been going off like a frog in a sock ever since.
TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 00:43

I’m pissed off as I got told to change my name but all the anti vax stuff is allowed to stand

Who told you to change your name? 😬

Also, which anti vax stuff is allowed to stand, can you link? I’ve seen the ‘face nappy’ 🙄 type posts get deleted.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 00:40

I'm talking in general

I’m not. This was a specific example of someone overstepping, being rude asking and then being sarcastic at their response to feel what...superior?

But in general, I don’t really think anyone should ask anyone’s vaccination status on here. In real life if someone is vulnerable, I can understand. And I think people should take an LFT before mixing, wear masks and social distance where possible, especially if they’re unvaccinated.

AntiMaskersAreTwats · 12/12/2021 00:38

I’m pissed off as I got told to change my name but all the anti vax stuff is allowed to stand Hmm

milkyaqua · 12/12/2021 00:34

I'm talking in general.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 00:33

milkyaqua

But that particular poster only posted twice on the whole thread, nothing to make you think they had an anti vax agenda.

Booklover3 · 12/12/2021 00:10

Yes YABU

milkyaqua · 12/12/2021 00:04

I think it is a reasonable question, after a certain point of reading someone's posts. Often, I would assume from their tone of discourse that someone has not been vaccinated and/or is an anti-vaxxer, but it turns out they are just anti-masks/restrictions/mitigation measures of every sort and in fact have gone out and got themselves double-vaxxed. Or posters up in arms and all 'we weren't told we'd have to have boosters!' etc, turn out to be double-vaxxed but against boosters. I would prefer to know, rather than just receive a false impression that they deem themselves immune to all harm and have 'done their own risk assessment, thanks'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread