Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that there is a huge amount of anti vax threads allowed on mumsnet?

310 replies

visitingagain · 09/12/2021 16:07

I fully expect this to be taken down but I am getting completely fed up with the number of anti vax and anti mask threads on mumsnet at the moment. People should be allowed to express views but some of the misinformation is shocking.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PlanktonsComputerWife · 12/12/2021 12:51

I am vaxxed and boosted to the eyeballs, and have to wear a mask for my job and commute, but I still find the finger-wagging threads like this easily the most tiresome.

wasthataburp · 12/12/2021 12:44

Get a life OP. This is a chat forum and everyone's opinions are valid. I wish there was a way to stop any Covid thread on here showing up on my active threads page

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 12:11

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

Innocenta

If I agreed with a part of someones post but thought another part was ‘inappropriate and rude’ as you claim to feel calling someone thick is, I wouldn’t quote that part. Strange that you would quote it when you apparently feel such comments are rude and inappropriate. Hmm

Still not engaging with my points, then.
TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 12:00

Innocenta

If I agreed with a part of someones post but thought another part was ‘inappropriate and rude’ as you claim to feel calling someone thick is, I wouldn’t quote that part. Strange that you would quote it when you apparently feel such comments are rude and inappropriate. Hmm

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 11:49

@TisTheSeasonToBeVegan

I actually agree that blanket statements using rude language (such as calling people 'thick') are inappropriate

And yet within the last few days you have quoted someone who called people thick and said you agreed with them.

I can broadly agree with someone's opinions on an issue, and not concur with the mode of expression. This is hardly groundbreaking.

Obviously, I largely agree with the people on the pro-vaccine 'side'. In no way is this going to surprise you or anyone. But at the level of granular detail, there will also be much disagreement (within the pro-vaccine side) between me and others, re: the best and most appropriate language to use, and what public policy is appropriate, and how exemptions should be handled... and so forth.

For example, I: (1) support mandates; (2) support psychiatric exemptions in rare cases; (3) do not support withholding care from the unvaccinated. These are all major differences of opinion within the pro-vaccine side - but I am still likely to say I largely agree with others on that side, even where we disagree on such (important) specifics.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 11:43

I actually agree that blanket statements using rude language (such as calling people 'thick') are inappropriate

And yet within the last few days you have quoted someone who called people thick and said you agreed with them.

InexperiencedDogOwner · 12/12/2021 11:38

I personally thought it was the opposite and if anyone dares to question the vaccine they are labelled as "stupid", "uneducated", "idiots" 🙄

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 10:54

I don't see the unvaccinated expressing the same sentiments or level of hostility

You are clearly not reading the threads in full, @Grenlei - the hostility and inappropriate comments from anti-vaxxers and 'the unvaccinated' are floridly apparent. The most egregious ones (generally comparing current vaccination programmes and pro-vaccine people to the Holocaust / Nazis) are sometimes deleted.

I am not denying your intelligence. Do you think such comments are defensible?

Innocenta · 12/12/2021 10:52

@Grenlei I haven't called you 'thick'. I'm the person who asked about your reasons - which, obviously, is a question you're free to choose not to reply to; the choice you have in fact made - but I don't think there's anything wrong with asking. This is a Covid discussion board; vaccines are a hot topic. Nobody is forced to go online and say "I am not vaccinated".

I actually agree that blanket statements using rude language (such as calling people 'thick') are inappropriate, and I don't particularly mind if MNHQ deletes them - even if the poster is on my 'side' in the argument. But again and again I see accusations like this levelled against pro-vaccine posters who have not said that another poster is thick!

LookslovelyinSpringtime · 12/12/2021 10:50

GrinGrin

Mojoj · 12/12/2021 10:47

It's called having a difference of opinion.

Grenlei · 12/12/2021 10:39

To clarify, I have no anti vax agenda to push here. I've taken a decision not to be vaccinated, but that's my decision made for my own reasons. I'm not trying to convince people of my views, to dissuade others from getting vaccinated or to decry the decisions of those who have been. Please point to any post from me on this thread or others where I've expressed any such sentiment.

I'm Oxbridge educated so please don't try to label me as thick which is the stick usually used to beat the unvaccinated. I have had some vaccinations in the past as have my children. I have chosen not to have this one, as has my partner (albeit for slightly different reasons to me).

As a discussion forum we should be able to express differing views. I've not seen posts by the unvaccinated full of misinformation but I have seen a lot of dogmatic comments by the vaccinated trying to close down any discussions or dissenting views with 'if you're not vaccinated you're thick/ selfish/ ignorant/ condemning others to death.

I don't see the unvaccinated expressing the same sentiments or level of hostility, more just objecting to those comments.

Florianus · 12/12/2021 09:57

The yellow card scheme largely reflects coincidence when it comes to deaths. Around 1400 people a day die in England and Wales, and with nearly half a million people a day being vaccinated, it is inevitable that quite a few will die soon after being jabbed.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 09:23

Florianus

I saw a much higher figure, apparently from the yellow card scheme. I imagine there are various figures out there that people will use to justify their stance. I think mumsnet should go with the ONS, but maybe they just can’t be bothered to check. I suppose it brings in posters that debate, which from MN point of view, wanting more traffic, is a good thing. I agree that forums like this should take some responsibility for what’s posted, but they don’t have to.

Florianus · 12/12/2021 09:09

Is there clear information for deaths resulting from the vaccine?

According to the Office for National Statistics, there have been 4 deaths in England (up to August this year) in which the vaccine initiated a chain of events directly leading to death. These could, of course, been cases of people who had, for instance, an existing condition that proved fatal due to an immune response triggered by the vaccine (and that might equally well have been triggered by the virus itself had they become infected).

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/12/2021 09:09

Also saw that you are an "extreme vegan" who believes the vaccine is morally wrong just because you have the word vegan in your username Hmm

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/12/2021 09:07

I responded very similarly to you. Be prepared to be told not to derail the thread, even though you’re just responding to someone else who tried to sneak this shit in.

Yes I've just seen Confused

Newrunner29 · 12/12/2021 08:59

@Saucery

MNHQ is not doing enough to support a pro-science perspective in this respect.

According to MNHQ in a Report reply to me, they are not epidemiologists and will therefore not delete posts stating that the vaccine kills an unspecified number of people. So, I’ve sort of given up now tbh. If they want the fact that unsubstantiated claims like that could lead to someone not having the vaccine, putting themselves and others in danger, then so be it 🤷‍♀️
Their circus, their antivaxx monkeys.

This is shocking to me. The major problem i have is when someone who has deicded not to have vaccine is quoted incluidng own family memebers they have done own research and not having it. As they are not scientists they r not on same level. Its this weird thing where someones opinion is somehow on a level with a doctor who has spent carer on this specific subject. Like the arrogance. I think the internet is to blame. Just because information is out there doesnt mean anyone knows everything. Like i wouldnt go on a flight and assume i can fly the plane because ive 'done my research ' Anyone can say anything on here so we dont even know if these opnions of people are actual thoughts and not something bit different to suit their point of view. Misinformation is very dangerous
TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 08:57

Ereshkigalangcleg

I responded very similarly to you. Be prepared to be told not to derail the thread, even though you’re just responding to someone else who tried to sneak this shit in.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/12/2021 08:53

MN has a reputation for allowing discussion on certain topics that aren't considered "woke" or correct in the liberal mainstream media. The trans debate is just one of them, and all those nitpicking "women should be called women" discussions. There have also been plenty of racist threads against China (in the context of covid) or Dubai/UAE (human rights) that were not deleted despite extensive reporting.

What a ridiculous comment. Women are female, not male, and need clear health messages. Biology matters. It's completely hypocritical to cite "science!" on the efficacy of covid measures and then throw it out of the window to virtue signal about peoples gender identity issues. Women's rights conversations on MN have zero to do with racism, such a lazy, uninformed comparison.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 08:46

I think most people are sensible enough to realise that and know that the vaccine is NOT killing loads of people.

What a typo! The vaccine is definitely NOT killing lots of people.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 08:44

It is. This wasn’t a case of a wrong percentage etc. It was a statement that the vaccine kills people. An unspecified amount of people. You don’t have to be an epidemiologist to know that’s false.
But hey, if that’s what they want then I won’t waste my time drawing such posts to their attention.

So that post still stands? Can you tell me which thread and when so I could read it.

Is there a definite figure for vaccine deaths? When I just googled, it all was very vague so I suppose those posters could use that vagueness to justify what they’re saying. People do twist statistics all the time to suit the argument. I think most people are sensible enough to realise that and know that the vaccine is killing loads of people.
I think mumsnet have banned people’s accounts for less though so I can see the frustration. They can do what they like though as they run it, as unfair as that seems at times.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 08:38

*hear

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 12/12/2021 08:37

According to MNHQ in a Report reply to me, they are not epidemiologists and will therefore not delete posts stating that the vaccine kills an unspecified number of people.

Is there clear information for deaths resulting from the vaccine? I would presume it’s difficult to know the number as there could be other factors. Ive just googled and seen a figure but it was all very vague and said full investigations hadn’t been done yet and the number given was likely to be higher than the actual deaths when they were looked into more. The number does seem high as a figure but obviously when looked at in comparison to the amount having the vaccine, it will be a very small percent.

I can understand mumsnet not wanting to get involved if the figures are not all that clear, if that is the case, I’ve only googled quickly. I just presume the figure are low as we’d here more about it in the news, lots of us would know people it had happened to and we don’t. I know people who have had side effects from the vaccine but nothing more than sickness, headache, sore arm and a bit of tiredness.

Saucery · 12/12/2021 08:28

Truly disturbing that they are intentionally platforming anti-vaxxers and targeting pro-vaccine posters for post deletion.

It is. This wasn’t a case of a wrong percentage etc. It was a statement that the vaccine kills people. An unspecified amount of people. You don’t have to be an epidemiologist to know that’s false.
But hey, if that’s what they want then I won’t waste my time drawing such posts to their attention.