Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Under 14s in NZ to be banned from ever buying cigarettes in their lifetime

234 replies

Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail · 09/12/2021 15:42

metro.co.uk/2021/12/09/new-zealand-bans-people-14-and-under-from-ever-buying-cigarettes-15743607/

Thoughts?

OP posts:
applepearorangebear · 09/12/2021 16:48

@AlternativePerspective

I assume anyone against this move is also in favour of legalising (and taxing) all drugs? it’s not about being against it, it’s about being realistic.

IMO smoking is a vile habit and I would love for it to not exist.

But it’s a fact that we make a huge amount of tax from smoking, far more than costs the country in treating smoking-related illness. Where is that shortfall going to be made up from? Are people prepared to pay higher income taxes to make up the shortfall?

Also, this law proposes that it will be banned for under 14’s. Given many people live into their 80’s and 90’s smoking won’t be banned altogether until the 22nd century. Banning under 14’s isn’t going to make smoking less of a scourge, the smokers, most of who are over the age of 50 or so, are going to continue to be around for the next 50 years or so.

So in truth this is just a statement, “let’s ban cigarettes being sold to under 14’s, and eventually no-one will be able to buy them ever.” Except that by the time that “one day” arrives Arden and all her followers will be long dead.

The tax revenue is actually more than off-set by the overall economic costs of tobacco use to society (reckoned to be £10bn v £13.7bn in the UK as at 2016). The tobacco industry is wholly parasitic: there won't be a need for higher taxation.

I don't know if banning sales to under 14s will work, but I applaud the attempt...

fuckyeahdannybrooks · 09/12/2021 16:48

I'm surprised that so far, no one has mentioned the race aspect of this. 25% of indigenous Maori are smokers who will be accusing the governmant of racism. Just a thought.

Thatsplentyjack · 09/12/2021 16:47

@CheesyFootballsAreEvil

Seems a good idea to me stop people starting
It really won't. I started smoking when I was 14. I wasn't legally allowed to buy cigarettes, but I still got them.
TheFrendo · 09/12/2021 16:47

They will be after alcohol next.

Jobseeker19 · 09/12/2021 16:47

Cigarettes don't get you high though. So its nothing like comparing it to drugs and alcohol.
It will become a chore to get illegal tobacco.

SecretKeeper1 · 09/12/2021 16:47

Our friends moved there 10 years ago when their children were tiny. They have a lovely lifestyle - very sporty and wholesome - and a great house and garden with a swimming pool. However, they want to move somewhere else when the kids leave home, they say it’s rapidly changing from the country they fell in love with.

I do think smoking bans are a good thing, but it’ll just mean a black market for cigarettes. Kids will think it’s cool to go and score cigs from some shady dealer, and there’ll be fake ones with god knows what in.

Thatsplentyjack · 09/12/2021 16:45

@Enb76

I think the level of control that governments think they can have over people is quite scary.

And then you look at some of the answers on this thread and realise that people are very happy to be controlled - or rather, to have other people controlled for things that they don't personally like.

Yes, that part is even scarier.
Ponoka7 · 09/12/2021 16:45

"I think they should introduce an NHS surcharge for anyone who smokes."
Not unless we start charging whole groups of people, including a woman who knows that she'll need a C Section on her next pregnancy, yet goes ahead.

"Also passports for smokers that keeps them out of certain venues unless they can prove they haven't smoked for at least a week."
You don't shed nicotine. A stranger isn't going to pose any risk to you because they've smoked, unlike a drinker. Although I love a drink and have never smoked. Stupid suggestion.

JuicySatsuma85 · 09/12/2021 16:45

@ThreeFeetTall

I assume anyone against this move is also in favour of legalising (and taxing) all drugs?
Yep. I certainly am. Prohibition has never, ever in history worked. Literally ever. Cultural change is what’s needed.

In Scotland the SNP have been begging Westminster to allow us to treat drug use as a mental health issue here rather than a legal one. We have the worst heroin problem in the world and heroin being illegal isn’t magically making that go away. Time to switch tactics.

jgw1 · 09/12/2021 16:45

@Thatsplentyjack

Smoking damages other people who do not smoke, especially children.

So ban smoking around children.

I wonder if so many people on here would be advocating this if the ban was purchasing alcohol. Probably not.

I really hope that is the next step. Think how much better the world would be. Boris wouldn't be having to defend his mates stupid parties without alcohol and would be a much nicer person to be around.
SickAndTiredAgain · 09/12/2021 16:44

Seems like a good idea to me.

And to worry that it will spread to junk food, which doesn’t even have an age limit on it is a stretch I think.
Even alcohol is talked about in very different terms, health messages are to stop smoking, but reduce drinking. There aren’t massive campaigns for the average drinker to stop completely.

MapleMay11 · 09/12/2021 16:43

@AlternativePerspective

Someone thinking about the health of the nation rather than tax dollars. bollocks. The health of the nation isn’t going to be impacted by this. Not for decades.

She’s thinking “what can I do that keeps me in the headlines.” It’s a platitude. That’s all.

NZ has some appalling health inequalities. If Jacinda Ardern was truly thinking about the health of the nation, she would have done so much more to address these issues long ago.
MapleMay11 · 09/12/2021 16:41

@LarryTheLurker

Ardern is a fanatic who wants to impose her own values on the people of NZ regardless of what they want.

She has been a disaster and will be gone soon.

Completely agree.
Thatsplentyjack · 09/12/2021 16:41

Smoking damages other people who do not smoke, especially children.

So ban smoking around children.

I wonder if so many people on here would be advocating this if the ban was purchasing alcohol. Probably not.

Gwenhwyfar · 09/12/2021 16:40

@allmywhat

What about schizophrenics? About 90% of schizophrenics smoke, something in the schizophrenic brain seems to need nicotine. It's not actually true that smoking doesn't benefit anyone. It quite clearly has beneficial neurological effects for a minority of the population and I think they should be allowed to make that cost-benefit calculation for themselves.
There are other ways to take nicotine if this is really true.
Allsorts1 · 09/12/2021 16:39

People can still have nicotine - just not smoke cigarettes.

I don’t believe in criminalising drugs though - however would be happy for positive mind altering drugs to be legal and cigarettes to be illegal as cigarettes don’t get you high and are just massively addictive and harmful vs MDMA or weed.

However I disagree with banning cigarettes as think it is too much control, and rates of smoking among teenagers have already plummeted - why bother banning it? Just educate, as that’s working well.

Gwenhwyfar · 09/12/2021 16:38

@Enb76

Because banning stuff works so well.

Prohibition works
War on drugs etc...

This is a terrible thing - the only thing that banning stuff does is lead to criminality. Banning something gives it a power it would not otherwise have.

Banning smoking from public places worked very well actually.
AlternativePerspective · 09/12/2021 16:38

I find it rather interesting that people seem to think that JA is such an inspiration for having curtailed the freedom of an entire country for the past almost two years and yet those same people seem to be up in arms when the government here suggest they should wear a mask in shops.

It’s easy to applaud the rules someone else makes when you’re not the ones being forced to follow them.

Thatsplentyjack · 09/12/2021 16:38

Also passports for smokers that keeps them out of certain venues unless they can prove they haven't smoked for at least a week.

Jesus, we will need passports for breathing soon.

ClowningAround21 · 09/12/2021 16:37

@Thatsplentyjack

I think banning smoking for teenagers is great idea, alcohol is banned in this country for u18's

It's notnjust banning smoking for teenagers though, it's banning smoking, or being able to buy cigarettes for anyone born after a certain date, so those born after that date will never be able to buy cigarettes.

I think the level of control that governments think they can have over people is quite scary.

I'm not allowed to buy Cannabis, Drink Drive, Drive over 70 mph, i can't even have a smoke with my meal in a pub.

Do you think that is a level of control over my life that Governments shouldn't have?

Smoking damages other people who do not smoke, especially children.

Allsorts1 · 09/12/2021 16:36

@AlternativePerspective In terms of vaping they said that the strategy is that vaping replaces cigarettes so I don’t think they’ll ban vaping

Sofuckingsad · 09/12/2021 16:36

I stopped smoking years ago but for some reason just reading this story makes me crave a fag.

Enb76 · 09/12/2021 16:35

I think the level of control that governments think they can have over people is quite scary.

And then you look at some of the answers on this thread and realise that people are very happy to be controlled - or rather, to have other people controlled for things that they don't personally like.

ClowningAround21 · 09/12/2021 16:33

@Clymene

To be fair its also 1 in 3 in the UK and men can self ID as women here too.

allmywhat · 09/12/2021 16:32

What about schizophrenics? About 90% of schizophrenics smoke, something in the schizophrenic brain seems to need nicotine. It's not actually true that smoking doesn't benefit anyone. It quite clearly has beneficial neurological effects for a minority of the population and I think they should be allowed to make that cost-benefit calculation for themselves.