Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Under 14s in NZ to be banned from ever buying cigarettes in their lifetime

234 replies

Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail · 09/12/2021 15:42

metro.co.uk/2021/12/09/new-zealand-bans-people-14-and-under-from-ever-buying-cigarettes-15743607/

Thoughts?

OP posts:
Briony123 · 09/12/2021 17:16

@Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail

I agree it certainly does, but then I think, what’s next? Alcohol, fast food ?
The state of the health of many kiwis, fast food should definitely be next to go!
GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 09/12/2021 17:16

It's not a bad idea. Banning it for those who are not yet addicted as still children but allowing current smokers to carry on sounds an better approach than banning across the board. I'd suggest very few people start smoking after the age of 20 anyway.

mam0918 · 09/12/2021 17:16

@Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail

I agree it certainly does, but then I think, what’s next? Alcohol, fast food ?
Not remotely the same.

If Im in Pizza Hut having a greesy Pizza and vodka cocktail it doesn't magically defuse through the air into a child on the next table eating Salad and drinking cordial and get her drunk and fat - smoke would/does effect others.

olaroller · 09/12/2021 17:14

What I think is strange, is that the moves to make the smoking of tobacco illegal continue at a fast pace, whilst at the same time the calls to decriminalise drugs grow ever louder. I can see a situation developing where people are going to get done for smoking cigarettes but be allowed to take drugs, safe in the knowledge they will not face prosecution.

user1745 · 09/12/2021 17:13

I don't like this idea. I think if something is legally available to buy, any adult (or anyone over a pre-determined age of reason) should be able to buy it. Saying that (in 10 years time) a 30-year-old can buy cigarettes but a 23-year-old cannot makes no sense to me.

I would actually be more supportive of a law banning under 21s or even under 25s from buying cigarettes because a) it is known that people under those ages don't have the same ability to assess risk vs short term benefit, so there's a scientific justification and b) I think most people who smoke probably started before their early twenties.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/12/2021 17:13

Theoretically fine. But totally discriminatory and nanny state. Presumes couples of different ages never get together. Vaping will likely be seen as the new smoking in 20 years time and according to a pp (struggling to find the post), vaping in NZ is rife. Plus ça change.

TomPinch · 09/12/2021 17:09

Smoking is uncool here. It's for old people.

The ban is just the end of a long road.

iloveeverykindofcat · 09/12/2021 17:09

I once saw a Tweet reflecting on the US opiate crisis that said 'I would like to congratulate drugs for winning the war on drugs'. Which makes you think!

WhereYouLeftIt · 09/12/2021 17:07

I think this will backfire on NZ. Banning things that people decide they want pushes the supply of that item into the hands of criminals.

Prohibition in the USA made the Mafia (and other gangs) very powerful, because lots of people still saw nothing wrong with drinking alcohol. And if the only place they could get it from was criminals, they dealt with criminals. It normalised dealing with criminals, gave the criminals a veneer of 'respectability'. And that has made it impossible to eradicate such gangs.

It's all very well saying you're banning cigarettes for the under 14s, but a 13 year old will be 18 in five years time. Are they still going to accept this when a 19 year old can legally buy them? What about when they're 25? 30? Will the law really look reasonable banning a 30-year-old from buying something a 31-year-old can legally buy? Really?

Are NZ banking on 'if they don't start at 14 they won't ever start'? It strikes me they really don't understand human nature. And show a bit of a totalitarian streak we should be wary of, because if they pass such a law, which product is next on their (potentially long) list?

SammyScrounge · 09/12/2021 17:07

@Enb76

Because banning stuff works so well.

Prohibition works
War on drugs etc...

This is a terrible thing - the only thing that banning stuff does is lead to criminality. Banning something gives it a power it would not otherwise have.

Absolutely right. Banning can't be enforced and will cause criminals to step in to provide the missing . goods. They will make millions out of the ban. Then you have to wonder what else will be banned. It is wise to distrust the authorities when they talk about doing things for your own good.
ConfusedParticle · 09/12/2021 17:02

Cars cause cancer too, but nobody is in a rush to cancel them.

I can get away from a smoker but i cant get away from traffic, sadly.

Our world is simply fucked up and fairly random. Yet governments make a serious shitshow of exhibiting any true concern about climate change or the environment.

ConfusedParticle · 09/12/2021 17:00

I really dont like smoking or recommend it, but I really dont like this level of meddling. It's state control at it's worst.

ClowningAround21 · 09/12/2021 17:00

@LoveB

I don't know what's wrong with people who agree with this. What happened to freedom? We'll soon be banned from anything remotely dangerous.
Yes having the freedom to cause cancer in other people is a right i will lay down my life for.
godmum56 · 09/12/2021 16:59

I would be happy to see tobacco use vanish but I can't see this working.

Nevertime · 09/12/2021 16:59

So eventually the selling of cigarettes will be banned and before that there'll be fewer and fewer people able to buy them so it might make stocking them unviable for shops/manufacturers?

PleasantBirthday · 09/12/2021 16:58

@Bagamoyo1

Wow have in read this correctly? That the legal age at which someone can buy cigarettes will go up every year? So if they start with the age being 18 now, in 20 years time you’d have to be 38 to be able to buy cigarettes? I hate smoking but I can’t see that working.
So I think it's going to be like this:

Year 1: You are 14. You can't buy them, nor can anyone younger than you
Year 2: You are 15. You can't buy them, nor can anyone younger than you
Year 3: You are 16. You can't buy them, nor can anyone younger than you

And so on.

LoveB · 09/12/2021 16:57

I don't know what's wrong with people who agree with this. What happened to freedom? We'll soon be banned from anything remotely dangerous.

Bagamoyo1 · 09/12/2021 16:56

Wow have in read this correctly? That the legal age at which someone can buy cigarettes will go up every year? So if they start with the age being 18 now, in 20 years time you’d have to be 38 to be able to buy cigarettes?
I hate smoking but I can’t see that working.

FourteenSixteenTwentyTwo · 09/12/2021 16:54

"I think they should introduce an NHS surcharge for anyone who smokes”

Seeing as approx 80% of a packet of cigarettes is taxed I would say they already do pay that surcharge.

fromdownwest · 09/12/2021 16:53

If the governement has set the precedent that their primary driver is the health and wellbing of it's residents I assume that mandatory exercise for people with BMI outside of the acceptable range.

TomPinch · 09/12/2021 16:52

I'm in NZ. This will work. It's very, very rare to see a young person smoking. Only old people do it.

The reason is that the young people are all vaping like crazy and vape shops seem to be everywhere. The government isn't doing anything I know about this. My DD's school has a big vape problem and it's the best state school in the city.

Sportsnight · 09/12/2021 16:52

It will sort of happen anyway won’t it? I don’t know anyone who smokes under the age of 40 any more - and among younger people it’s even rarer. I also think making it a banned substance is probably a bit heavy handed - adults should have some personal choice, even if what they choose is bad for them.

jgw1 · 09/12/2021 16:50

@Ponoka7

"I think they should introduce an NHS surcharge for anyone who smokes." Not unless we start charging whole groups of people, including a woman who knows that she'll need a C Section on her next pregnancy, yet goes ahead.

"Also passports for smokers that keeps them out of certain venues unless they can prove they haven't smoked for at least a week."
You don't shed nicotine. A stranger isn't going to pose any risk to you because they've smoked, unlike a drinker. Although I love a drink and have never smoked. Stupid suggestion.

Yes indeed we should indeed charge whole groups of people. For example an alcoholic smoker would be charged double.
fromdownwest · 09/12/2021 16:50

Social posturing at it's finest.

Banning a product does not negate desire of people to use it, as has been proven throughout history with drugs and alchohol.

All you do is move it from a regulated and taxable entity, towards an unregualted product sold by criminal factions. Of which, will also most likely be involved in the sex trade, people trafficking and drug trafficking.

Education is key, banning smoking in pubs and bars, made a huge dent in smoking numbers.

Don't ban the product, educate.

CSJobseeker · 09/12/2021 16:48

Someone thinking about the health of the nation rather than tax dollars.

bollocks. The health of the nation isn’t going to be impacted by this. Not for decades.

So it is going to be impacted then, in the long term? Which makes this an example of a government doing something for the long-term health of its people, even though it won't still be in power when the benefits come.

Swipe left for the next trending thread